8 ms·
no no no. this is bad advice. 1) "Some Samsung TVs already try and connect to open WiFi networks if you don't connect them yourself." https://news.ycombinato
by m463 6y ago
no no no. this is bad advice.
1) "Some Samsung TVs already try and connect to open WiFi networks if you don't connect them yourself."
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24629155 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24629155
2) there is ethernet over hdmi - I would image this is another source of inadvertent connection.
3) samsung tvs require an ethernet cable to "update firmware" so HDMI works.
4) ACR - which will look at ALL the inputs.
and wait for the next few iterations
- smart devices talk to each other and exfiltrate data
- smart device manufacturers collaborate with ISPs who have put wifi gateways in your house and your neighbor's house.
- coryrc 6y agoSolder the wifi antenna to ground (so long as the remote is IR and not radio!)
- jjoonathan 6y agoMy TCL starts to bootloop if it goes more than a month without connecting to the internet so it can download screensaver ads. The warranty people force me into the support gauntlet. The support gauntlet's first demand: connect it to the internet.
- echelon 6y agoThis is disgusting. Ads are ruining everything. And if you think it stops here, I've got bad news. This is only going to get worse without strict regulation.
- antman 6y agoEdit: Didn't know TCL is a brand, not available in my part of the world... - What brand is your TV?
- LeoPanthera 6y agoHe already said - TCL.
- andrewflnr 6y agoTCL is the brand. (I hadn't heard of it either)
- kaetemi 6y agoI see that around in supermarkets here. Cheap garbage from you-know-where.
- ezconnect 6y agoTCL is a big Chinese company, they even have their own tv streaming service golive tv.
- bloody-crow 6y agoHold up. What if you don't have internet? Are they legitimately prepared to say "well, in this case your TV is not gonna work"?
- em-bee 6y agosoon, not having internet will be like not having a phone, and wanting a tv that works without internet will be like using a computer without internet. in any case, i'd get any claim that the tv works without internet in writing. then it becomes a warranty issue if the tv stops working
- ObsoleteNerd 6y agoYes. I lived on a farm for a couple years recently and you had to extensively research any tech you bought even if logic said there’s no reason that particular tech should need internet. The TV we took with us no longer worked (Samsung) so we had to buy a Sony (and have never looked back), among other things. Also, software. Half the software on our computers stopped working despite not being internet related. It was incredibly frustrating and really soured me on the direction tech is headed.
- volfied 6y agoYes and they’re legitimately paid to ignore the fact that internet access is a base need for everyone and should be cheaply available.
- Scoundreller 6y agoHow does it know the time? Can't you set it to 1971?
- tornato7 6y agoYou should try running it through a pihole. Even better, maybe you can manage to MITM it and replace the ads with something funny.
- lostlogin 6y agoSome devices bypass the Pihole, and while you can catch them at the firewall, it’s a tedious game.
- panpanna 6y agoSo what we need is a jailbreak and custom firmware?
- lostlogin 6y agoVery very much so.
- 867-5309 6y agohow is it possible to bypass? if it is the only thing available then it is impossible to use an alternative
- girvo 6y agoThey use their own DNS rather than PiHole’s.
- mateuszf 6y agoIf they use own DNS then maybe it can be disabled by IP rule in firewall?
- Spare_account 6y agoIf they can't get to their preferred DNS servers directly then they use DNS-over-HTTPS which you can't block.
- sgrove 6y ago#2 sounded intriguing, but it seems likely to not be the case [0]. I was curious because I have a Vizio that I deliberately keep disconnected from the internet, and rely on an Apple TV. Seems like that's not an attack vector in this case, though #1 is (and #3) seem worth looking into. What's ACR in point #4? [0] https://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/325215/appletv-ethernet-over-hdmi https://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/325215/appletv-eth...
- jasonjayr 6y agoACR == Automatic Content Recognition. Basically it periodically screenshots what the panel is showing and sends it to their servers to see if it matches the programs they know about to figure out what it is you're watching.
- nitrogen 6y agoI don't see why people aren't rioting in the streets about this, apart from the fact that there are currently bigger issues already occupying rioters. It's seriously beyond the pale.
- klyrs 6y agoThey're glued to their TVs.
- ajmurmann 6y agoBecause most people don't know and/or understand. Look how many (often smart) people are bringing Alexa devices to their homes
- jonnytran 6y agoI know smart people who have Alexa devices. Some of these people are software engineers who know there's someone on the other end listening to everything. One could argue that they must not be smart to buy these things. But I think that a more helpful way of thinking about it is that (1) people are great at rationalizing, especially when it makes their lives easier. And (2) the open source alternative isn't good enough or easy enough. For a long time, pirating music was the easiest way to listen to music that you wanted. Then things like iTunes and the iPod came along. Until there's an easy, open alternative, even smart people will continue paying money to put surveillance devices in their living rooms and bedrooms.
- mkhpalm 6y agoI have a 65 inch samsung tv that kept popping up on my network. I put it on an isolated wifi network once to get the firmware updates. After I did that I turned it back off. But it keeps trying to come back for just a moment every couple of days. I had to ban its mac address since there was no way to get it to stop in the settings or after factory resets.
- ziftface 6y agoIt's crazy how user hostile TV manufacturers have become.
- heresie-dabord 6y agoProfiteering using the personal information of consumers. It is maddening how incompatible with Democracy the commercial surveillance system has become.
- aiisjustanif 6y agoJust wait till you’ve been to the country it’s made in.
- christoph 6y agoForcibly banning the MAC address of a TV on your own home network, that you've paid money for, really does sum up the state of consumer electronics atm.
- chasd00 6y agothat's pretty funny, it's like fighting a rogue employee in a corporate network.
- gruez 6y ago>1) "Some Samsung TVs already try and connect to open WiFi networks if you don't connect them yourself." This claim doesn't seem to be well sourced. It's essentially going on the word of an anonymous redditor.
- bjelkeman-again 6y agoSee user mkhpalm’s comment
- Godel_unicode 6y agoThat's unrelated to open Wi-Fi networks.
- zxcb1 6y agoOne needs to mentally prepare for the coming 5G era; ubiquitous tracking and data harvesting combined with artificial intelligence and social credit. Where is the opt out from this hellish corporate revolution?
- kllrnohj 6y ago5G doesn't change the economics of having cell radios nor paying for cell data. Why would notoriously low margin products like a TV ever pay for such a lavish addition when most people voluntary connect it to wifi or ethernet anyway?
- zxcb1 6y agoA TV is no longer a TV when it is part of a lucrative network of sensors; this not only represents a risk for the buyer, it fundamentally alters what a product is, while reducing language to newspeak.
- ViViDboarder 6y agoBut still, 5G changes nothing. Why have they not had this since 3G radios could be found in a Kindle?
- m463 6y agosearch for "comcast lpwan" or machineq or "comcast iot" just make an agreement with one company, done.
- 3np 6y agoThis is the only reason why I'm concerned about an overly optimistic 5G rollout. It's frustrating that all the nutso conspiratists have made it practically impossible to problematize this without coming off as either uneducated or a lunatic.
- gjm11 6y agoMeta-conspiracy-theory: the 5G conspiracy theories were spread deliberately with the precise intention of making the truth look like just another crazy conspiracy theory. (I don't think that's very likely in this case, but I bet there are actual examples out there of conspiracy theories being deliberately seeded as a way to discredit potential real criticisms.)
- ornornor 6y agoSamsung TVs are an extreme example though. They’re the most obnoxious and the most disrespectful of your privacy by implementing all these dark patterns. Not to mention their QLED bullshit, it’s just LED but it’s meant to make you think it’s OLED and pay extra. I despise Samsung and their junk.
- conradfr 6y agoIt's sad because I have multiple (ageing) Samsung appliances (amongst them a dumb TV) and they're all great so Samsung would have naturally be a contender for my next TV.
- ornornor 6y agoIf all you’ve read in this thread doesn’t put you off Samsung... then nothing will.
- tigershark 6y agoHow can you even think to not buy an OLED instead of their scammy QLED full of advertisements is beyond my comprehension...
- radley 6y agoOld Samsung HDTVs were awesome, but that's changed in the last few years. They added features like in-menu ads to the low end models that seem to be trickling up their top end as well. I also have a buggy 1.5 year old Samsung stove that has to be reset when I lean a pot lid against the back It causes the touch panel to trigger a random button and lock up.
- lostlogin 6y agoTo add to this, various things try to bypass the Pihole by doing their own DNS. Google devices skip the Pihole, and I’ll bet others do too. You can catch at least some of the bad behaviour by blocking all outbound port 53 traffic that isn’t from the Pihole, or redirect it back to the Pihole. I’m sure this will be beaten though.
- m_eiman 6y agoThis is why they invented DNS-over-HTTPS, to work around your ”foul play”.
- TheSmiddy 6y agoIt's funny because at home apps bypassing my dns annoys the hell out of me but in China which is where I currently am DNS-over-HTTPS is necessary just to get online some days. I just wish there was a manual captive portal check button built into browsers that forces a standard port 53 check because if I'm behind a captive portal I have to reset my dns settings to sign in before then switching it back to get my VPN to connect.