10 ms·
> This appeal to employment is disconcerting, as ride sharing apps are doing their workers no favors by paying them so poorly (including the lack of benefits).
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> This appeal to employment is disconcerting, as ride sharing apps are doing their workers no favors by paying them so poorly (including the lack of benefits).
Except that they do, because they provide a level of flexibility not available at most other jobs.
If you're a college student and you have two hours and fifteen minutes between classes, you can drive for two hours and fifteen minutes. If you're a school bus driver who drives kids to school in the morning and drives them back in the afternoon but has nothing to do in the meantime, you can get in your own car and drive passengers at that time and make some extra money. If you have a part time job working three days a week with an inconsistent schedule set by your employer, you can drive another two days a week, even if it's a different two days every week.
There is value in that, or why is anybody doing it rather than working at Walmart or Starbucks where that isn't available?
But if you make the drivers employees then the company has no reason not to schedule their hours inflexibly, because the flexibility was only needed to attract workers at the lower level of compensation.
In practice what you're doing is disallowing employers from offering employees terms of employment that provide the employee with working conditions of greater non-monetary value than ordinary jobs in exchange for less money. There is no reason to think that this is never advantageous for the employee, and the workers who don't find those terms advantageous remain free to work for any other employer.
> When talking about jobs, especially in the US where so many benefits are tied to employment, a job with pay so low and no benefits should not be considered a good thing.
Then do something about all the benefits tied to employment. All of that exists only as a direct result of government policy.
- carlob 6y agoThen again a few taxi drivers I have talked to in the US admitted starting to drive for ride sharing companies after finishing their maximum allowed shift of 12 hours... Also I've heard multiple reports that in most of the gig economy markets casual workers are de-prioritized, so that only those who put in at least 40 hours a week stay in the game...
- vsareto 6y agoSeattle has the authority to change the conditions of employment - how much less Uber pays in exchange for the flexibility. Uber/Lyft has a right to stop operating there if they don't like it. Why would Uber/Lyft fight so hard to stay with unfavorable conditions?
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoSome amount of ride sharing works under arbitrarily unreasonable conditions. Making $1 is better than making $0. But it's not as good, for multiple parties, as the alternative where they make a million dollars, more drivers have work, more passengers can afford rides and the existing passengers (many of which are also lower income people) pay less for them.
- formercoder 6y agoExactly. The only question here is can Uber/Lyft operate in an npv positive manner under these new regulations? If so, then they will and the regs hurt their margins in order to serve workers and that’s fine. If not, they’ll leave, and these people won’t have driving as a source of income.
- JamesBarney 6y agoThey could continue to operate but with less drivers, fewer hours worked, and fewer total dollars being paid out to their employees. Thus hurting the employees, anyone who relies on ubers, and the companies while benefiting a subset of drivers who will make more money per hour.
- formercoder 6y agoPrecisely. They could do that, they only will do that if the returns from doing so exceed their cost of capital.
- Pet_Ant 6y ago> In practice what you're doing is disallowing employers from offering employees terms of employment that provide the employee with working conditions of greater non-monetary value than ordinary jobs in exchange for less money. There is no reason to think that this is never advantageous for the employee, and the workers who don't find those terms advantageous remain free to work for any other employer. That is true, but it's an ecosystem thing. Sure, it might be of benefit of some... but to others it's the only game in town. When people describe fast food jobs as for students saving for their first car so they don't have to provide a living wage... that doesn't help single parents who are using it as their sole income. It's better to inconvenience the students seeking a car, to help the single parents. Those at the bottom have nothing but the flex jobs available to them.
- baggy_trough 6y agoWhy do you think that every job has to be suitable for single parent breadwinners? Couldn't our society function better if there were different kinds of jobs available, including for low skilled teenagers?
- Pet_Ant 6y agoBecause there is nothing that a low-skill teenager can't do that a low-skill breadwinner can. That's the point. We need to lift the floor so that even low-skill people can support themselves and their families. Otherwise people with supports having their living subsidized will outcompete people without those supports. Just look at the controversy about having to be well-born to be able to afford zero-income internships that are the gateway into some industries.
- jimbokun 6y ago> Otherwise people with supports having their living subsidized will outcompete people without those supports. And this sounds like some form of UBI. If everyone had some income floor as a starting point, the government could be far less involved in micromanaging employment relationships, and low income people would be in a better position to turn down jobs offering very low wages.
- Taylor_OD 6y ago> If you're a college student and you have two hours and fifteen minutes between classes, you can drive for two hours and fifteen minutes. Can you though? You wait for 10 minutes to get your first ride which takes
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoAnd then you also have to stop in time to make sure you are on time for your next class.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ksk 6y ago>There is no reason to think that this is never advantageous for the employee, and the workers who don't find those terms advantageous remain free to work for any other employer. Your use of "never" is a red-herring. You have to quantify what it means. If 100% of uber drivers prefer higher pay over flexibility, what would be your argument? In other words, your argument completely hinges on a significant chunk of employees feeling like they are not being exploited. Without data, it won't stand on its own. >There is value in that, or why is anybody doing it rather than working at Walmart or Starbucks where that isn't available? Because those jobs are soul crushing, if you've ever worked at one of those. Just because Uber is offering "better" working conditions doesn't mean the drivers are happy about the pay. Also, if your standard of ethics is "whatever the employee voluntarily accepts" then why have a minimum wage at all?
- sokoloff 6y agoOne of the strongest appeals to me of a sustenance level of UBI is that we could then abolish the destructive minimum wage laws that shut some people out of the workforce, preventing them from the pride that is inherent in a solid effort at a job and bettering their lives on their own. Right now, if you can only create $7/hr of economic value, no employer can legally employ you for a regular job in a way that's profitable for them.
- ksk 6y ago>Right now, if you can only create $7/hr of economic value, no employer can legally employ you for a regular job in a way that's profitable for them. Sure, but its just a shifting of costs. Either the employer pays them the extra $ or the government taxes everyone and makes up the difference. It comes out of the economy in either case. I think UBI is a great idea, but so is minimum wage, and so is welfare, etc, etc. They're are all great ideas intended to help people in tough conditions.
- canb3 6y agoThis is one of those “you can eat or starve” kind of arguments made to back up how “free” we are. No pesky people demanding you live. And your family can watch you struggle, because they’re broke from a medical bill, but at least you got schedule flexibility in a nation where rent is outpacing inflation. Abstract nonsense. Reductionist garbage. Celebrating the percent of people on poverty going down 2% emotionally ignores the raw number of people in poverty and creates an emotionally distorted psychology of motivation. It’s no different in waving away the effects of such a crap wage for given the extent of financial inequality when we also know there are empty rooms everywhere. Unfortunately, the landlords can’t rent them for obscene profit so whatever but there’s flexibility in this like you can’t imagine! What? Other real externalities? Have I mentioned to scheduling flexibility!?!
- quercusgrisea 6y ago>[Being paid less is actually better for workers] I don't think people find this argument very convincing
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoDo you think that your own comment is a convincing or useful addition to the discussion?
- quercusgrisea 6y agoI find it useful to point out the faulty core of a person's argument when they're making a bad point that will hurt people, so that others who come across it don't give it undue deference.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pjmorris 6y ago> But if you make the drivers employees then the company has no reason not to schedule their hours inflexibly, because the flexibility was only needed to attract workers at the lower level of compensation. What if there were another purpose to the flexibility, to apply that 'two hours and fifteen minutes' of time the college student had to capturing the market value of shuttling people around campus and nearby, rather than stationing some 40-hour/week employee near campus, hoping to have them utilized all 40 hours?
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoWhat if you can have actual employees and offer flexible times? That can be done. That college student can sign up for short shifts, after all. You can allow folks to self-schedule. I*m pretty sure Uber already rates folks, in part, by their availability to drive.
- twblalock 6y ago> What if you can have actual employees and offer flexible times? Sort of. If you have actual employees you need to pay for benefits. Someone who only works a few hours a day may not bring in enough revenue to cover the cost of their benefits, so the employer may need to require longer, less flexible hours in order to make it worth hiring someone in the first place.
- pjmorris 6y agoSo, that's an optimization problem around cost of benefits versus amount of revenue, right? The company can view it from the aggregate perspective; they might lose money on some low-hour employees, but still capture the revenue, enhance their market share and convenience, and make it up on revenue versus cost aggregated over all employees.
- rmrfstar 6y agoThat makes a lot of sense: allow the market to do its thing and efficiently allocate scarce resources. But it raises the question: why doesn't Uber operate like a normal marketplace where buyers/sellers submit bids/offers at prices of their own choosing? By preventing buyers/sellers from participating in price discovery, Uber makes itself look a lot more like a classic employer/vendor than an online marketplace.
- clairity 6y ago> "In practice what you're doing is disallowing employers from offering employees terms of employment that provide the employee with working conditions of greater non-monetary value than ordinary jobs in exchange for less money." the other side of that problem is that the wages are dictated by one party (with basically no external price signals impinging on them) rather than being free to respond to demand. it has the same anti-competitive issues that any price-fixing scheme has. plus, there are other sociopolitical forces depressing wages in a decidedly tilted labor market. fix those imbalances and then we'd have much more support for a freely self-adjusting labor market for driving.