4 ms·
>My explanation for this? In general, men are simply more interested in computers than women. to a degree possibly but the extreme skew in engineering discipli
by Barrin92 6y ago
>My explanation for this? In general, men are simply more interested in computers than women.
to a degree possibly but the extreme skew in engineering disciplines makes that hard to believe. In almost all other fields with a gender bias that could be put down to preference there's usually still a sizeable amount of the opposite sex. In psychology where women outnumber men it's like 30-70, even women in the national guard on active duty are more common than in CS departments. Even other adjacent STEM fields like maths usually look more diverse than CS.
And in the workplace compared to academia it arguably gets worse. Just from personal experience in software development jobs, I put a lot of it on culture. Just look at how 'boys summer camp' like startups are run, with frequent stories of drinking at the workplace and stories that sound more like out of a fraternity than an actual job. Emily Chang wrote a good book about, 'Brotopia'
https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2018/01/brotopia-silicon-valley-secretive-orgiastic-inner-sanctum https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2018/01/brotopia-silicon-val...
- look_lookatme 6y agoAren't nursing and teaching essentially 90% female?
- Barrin92 6y agoteaching is 60-75% female depending on what country you're looking at. For nursing you can make a pretty strong cultural case. One of the founders of modern nursing, Florence Nightingale, insisted that men's hands are too "hard and horny" to be a nurse, in the UK male nurses were not even admitted to schools until the 1960s. In character the job of a proffesional nurse these days is not much different from that of a physician so gender differences are probably less of an issue than class. Nursing for a long time was simply a 'women's only' job, by cultural norm rather than free choice. Male nurse rates are actually rising pretty fast.
- look_lookatme 6y agoI'm talking about the united states, but if we are talking global shares: Early childhood education is over 90% female teachers. Primary school education is 70%-95 female teaechers. Secondary education is 60-75% female teachers. Source: https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=EAG_PERS_SHARE_AGE https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=EAG_PERS_SHARE... I don't know Florence Nightengale has to do with this discussion. As a percentage of new nurses it is true that more males are going into nursing, but many of the traditionally male working class jobs have disappeared in the United States. This alone could account for the increase in male nurses over the last 10 years, though I do think it is also cultural to some degree. The numbers we are talking about are like 15% of new nurses being male instead of 5%. I would be surprised if this growth doesn't level off in the next decade and hold steady for decades to come.
- rednerrus 6y agoI had a CS Prof who ran a bunch of Women Who Code type meetups. His observation was that the idea that in order to be a software engineer, you have to devote your entire life to it was the biggest turnoff to many of the women. You have to always be working on a side project, always going to meetups, engross yourself in the geek culture in order to feel like you can do the job. For many women it was just too much of a hassle. He advocated for tearing down some of these cultural norms as the best way to be more inclusive.
- llampx 6y agoInteresting. Where do these cultural norms come from? I think it is true that to be truly great at something you have to dedicate your life to it, whether you are a man or a woman. How do doctors and lawyers get by, without spending most of their waking hours learning?
- nradov 6y agoLaw and medicine are professions which require a certain number of continuing education hours per year. For example lawyers in California have to complete 25 hours every three years. Everyone knows that going in. Most do little more than the minimum.
- Pet_Ant 6y ago> He advocated for tearing down some of these cultural norms as the best way to be more inclusive. But what about those for whom that is the draw? I mean is there any gain if women join but a lot of geeks leave?
- rednerrus 6y agoCan’t we have both? Do you have to be singularly focused on writing software to work in this field? I think we can have people who think of this as a career and people who are obsessed and they can work did by side.
- 6y ago