3 ms·
Iceland's response to Covid-19 has been among the very best in the world. But the threat very much persists. The selfishness and criminal negligence of two Fr
by dredmorbius 6y ago
Iceland's response to Covid-19 has been among the very best in the world. But the threat very much persists. The selfishness and criminal negligence of two French tourists has resulted in 400 new infections and counting, likely to result in 2-16 deaths given case fatality rates in Iceland (0.5%) and globally (4%).
I found myself recently attempting to explain to someone who seems strongly motivated not to understand the principle that a crisis can be both enduring and critical, in answer to the false assertion that “ongoing crises are not emergencies.”
Iceland proves my point. As has New Zealand recently: "Covid 19 coronavirus: 5 new cases as Jacinda Ardern reveals alert level call" (https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=12362251 https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&object...)
This thing is with us until it isn’t. Covid operates on its own schedule, not ours. People not being selfish idiots would help one hell of a lot to speed the process and lower risks, deaths, and costs, however.
- vertis 6y agoI crossed the border (by Ferry) into Estonia the other day, and was informed by the border guard that I would need to isolate for 14 days[1], and asked to sign a document saying that I understood the isolation. The way the border guard approached the subject, made it seem like he was worried that I would flip out at having my movements restricted. I'm guessing, but I think this was because I travel on an Australian passport, and the assumption becomes that I'm a tourist and that it will ruin my holiday. As soon as I started talking about my isolation plans (I even went to the supermarket in Sweden before the ferry[2]), he relaxed a lot. It became "very good then, carry on". I do wonder how many people are becoming unreasonable in situations like this. [1] You can take tests to shorten it. [2] It is allowed to go to the supermarket here while in isolation, but I didn't know that before arriving.
- bredren 6y ago> I do wonder how many people are becoming unreasonable in situations like this. Pushback on masks or any type of covid-altered behavior is not limited to "walmart meltdown" youtube social shame videos. While it has been walked back, poll workers in a Missouri county were told: "You may act surprised that you don’t have a face mask on properly and then apologize as you put the mask on,” “Wear your mask correctly until the voter leaves the polling place. Please do this every time a voter says something to you.” [1] https://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/516943-st-louis-poll-workers-told-to-act-surprised-and-put-on-mask-if https://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/516943-st-...
- qwerty1234599 6y agoThe people traveling abroad currently are mostly absolute idiots. Exactly the kind that will break mandatory isolation and are way more likely to have an ongoing covid infection than a random person from the general population, due to overall careless behaviour. The sensible people are all waiting in their homes. So yes, I guess the border guard you spoke to has had to endure tantrums from these people on a daily basis
- vertis 6y agoIt's my impression that Europe has been a little bit more relaxed than "only idiots are traveling". It's only now that the numbers are rising again that they're again putting increased measures in place.
- dgellow 6y agoYes, it's correct, it was possible to travel between EU countries during the whole summer without that much restrictions (some places required a quarantine of 14 days, but others didn't). The number of identified cases only started to rise again in central Europe around mid August.
- BrandoElFollito 6y agoWhy do you think there is a magical virus barrier at the border? It does not matter if you travel to the next city or to the country nearby. Yes, there are clusters but at least in Europe we do not have vast empty areas between populated places. It is pretty much a continuum.
- user_501238901 6y agoTravel creates new unidentified clusters, the tourists also tend to leave the area rather quickly => very hard to find and trace who originally caused the cluster, and who were in contact. Tourists also tend to have much different riskier behaviour compared to the average native inhabitant of a city (eg nightclub hopping many days in a row)
- 6y ago
- masklinn 6y ago> I do wonder how many people are becoming unreasonable in situations like this. Would be an interesting stat. I would hope not that many but expect a large population given they'd be people who have elected to take short-term vacations in foreign country during a pandemic, they'd either be very self-centered or not very bright.
- leptons 6y agoMy wife worked with fashion models before covid, and as one would expect - they aren't the brightest people out there, and sure enough, cheap plane tickets! woohoo! - they go off to mexico, europe, wherever and post photos to instagram of them partying it up without masks, and sure enough, they got covid. And this is why my wife had to quit in March, because she knows how idiotic, selfish and reckless those people can be.
- aunty_helen 6y ago>Covid operates on its own schedule, not ours. It reminds me of the Christmas Day truces, we were able to put aside our differences for a day. But it seems we're incapable of understanding this doesn't apply to virology. Covid doesn't care if it's your wedding, sisters birthday or that your fathers dying. We seem to assume that it has some kind of humanity or that the just lowering my mask to say something once won't have any affect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christmas_truce https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christmas_truce
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI think you're misunderstanding the psychology. It's not a matter of people literally believing virology doesn't apply to them; it's just a values tradeoff. The virus might not care if my father were dying, but I would, and I wouldn't allow a virus to stop me from being there for him.
- namdnay 6y agoI thought the French tourist thing was debunked? I remember seeing an article saying they hadn’t infected anyone
- oflocet 6y agoIt was indeed. https://pledgetimes.com/covid-19-iceland-denies-the-responsibility-of-two-french-tourists-in-a-wave-of-new-contaminations/ https://pledgetimes.com/covid-19-iceland-denies-the-responsi...
- djsumdog 6y agoBoth this article and the original post talk about the different "strains" of CoV2. I thought there were no real strains; and that the L/S strain reports from earlier weren't correct?
- cratermoon 6y agoCOVID-19 re-infection by a phylogenetically distinct SARS-coronavirus-2 strain confirmed by whole genome sequencing (https://academic.oup.com/cid/advance-article/doi/10.1093/cid/ciaa1275/5897019?fbclid=IwAR1NFpQYLomC3ZR2WzeJ0eaw5oUmKGiJGR69v827uXjbgyd5gB3VDoIKK-c https://academic.oup.com/cid/advance-article/doi/10.1093/cid...) Current studies suggest there are up to six distinct strains.
- m0llusk 6y agoThere are minor genetic variations that can be used to trace whether infections came directly from Wuhan or through Italy or wherever. These variations do not vary the function of the virus or its infectiousness or reproduction in any known way, but do enable some methods for tracing the spread. California has an aggressive ongoing effort to sequence the genes of all COVID-19 cases which has contributed to this.
- cratermoon 6y agoThat story quotes one guy, who is not a government official, and provides no other evidence to back up its claims. Sketchy news rehosting site run by two people is sketchy.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> People not being selfish idiots would help one hell of a lot to speed the process and lower risks, deaths, and costs, however. The only endgame is herd immunity. Whether that's delayed or not doesn't really matter to corona.
- jMyles 6y ago> Covid operates on its own schedule, not ours. We do have some tuning knobs though, including vertical risk-stratification, which has collected dust around the world. It is possible to have a much more acute and accelerated course among the least vulnerable populations while isolating the more vulnerable populations. Whether Iceland and New Zealand will be viewed as successes depends in part on how much misery is inflicted during the long period it will take to finally reach herd immunity in those places, and how many people in vulnerable sub-populations are infected along the way.
- vvanders 6y agoPopulation x Fatality Rate will tell you how much it "costs" to achieve herd immunity. That also doesn't take into account long term impacts that are not fatal.
- jMyles 6y ago> Population x Fatality Rate will tell you how much it "costs" to achieve herd immunity. ...what? My comment was about risk-stratification. "Population x Fatality Rate" is the formula we are resigned to use because we're not doing risk-stratification. This is what Katz, Ioannidis, Gupta, Osterholm, etc. (it, many of the most trusted experts on this topic) have been saying all along, and being ignored not only in the hugely ignorant US response, but also in the more sophisticated ones. > That also doesn't take into account long term impacts that are not fatal. Yes, there are rare complications from all viruses that can cause long-term disease. But we're fighting a pandemic right now, so it's probably not time to focus on phenomena of rounding-error incidence and which are not unique to this virus.
- djsumdog 6y ago> That also doesn't take into account long term impacts that are not fatal This is the new narrative and it makes no sense. The largest impact of this virus are the elderly and they can get long term effects from any infection, bacterial or viral. I read the 60+ person UK case study on long term effects published out of Charlottesville and almost all the major conditions were in the elderly or high risk workers (possibly medial workers; the paper didn't say for privacy reasons). It's way too early to talk about "long term effects," when this hasn't even been around that long. Remember that 96% of fatalities in the US are people 55 and over, most of those in long-term care and retirement facilities. The areas that were hit the worst (Michigan, California, Kirkland/Seattle) were all cases of bad policy in regards to nursing homes.
- arcticbull 6y ago> ... likely to result in 2-16 deaths given case fatality rates in Iceland (0.5%) and globally (4%). I can't believe people continue to use CFR for evaluating risk. It's a totally worthless metric, and now that we have serological studies, an approximation of the IFR is available. The IFR is somewhere around 0.5% plus or minus. The disease is effectively the same the whole world over and is equally fatal the whole world over. The reason for an order of magnitude spread in CFR is because Iceland is testing everyone (hence approximating the actual fatality rate, IFR) whereas every other country is testing different groups. Yes the fatality rate is 4% for people who walk into hospital hugely ill. This is a sampling bias. It's like saying skydiving is 99% fatal based on counting only people whose parachutes failed to deploy. Then presenting the risk as "anywhere between 0.001% and 99%." It's about 0.5% across the whole population. Much lower for children (lower than the flu). About the same as the flu for 20s and 30s people, particularly healthy ones. It's much, much higher for old sick people (20-30% in a nursing home, for instance). There's no way to say 2-16 deaths based on the 400 infected by multiplying 400 by 0.5%; it could be zero if the 400 infected were kids, and it could be 150 if the French folks did a tour of nursing homes. [edit] 'just-juan-post' provided a link to a study indicating my figures are overstated and the fatality rates are probably half that. [1] [1] https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M20-5352 https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M20-5352
- anoncake 6y agoOf course people continue believing in a death rate of 4-5%. Having panicked over a disease with a death rate below 0.5% must be quite embarrassing.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoHaving a preferred stat to wave around is certainly one advantage of front-loading Covid death stats with the negligibly infected.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago(Not singling you out here) It's a bit unsettling to limit the risk discussions to death rates. It feels like no one is compiling stats on people who are exiting Covid with new, life altering disabilities.
- lbeltrame 6y ago> People not being selfish idiots would help one hell of a lot to speed the process and lower risks In my opinion, not quite. What it highlights is that non-pharmaceutical interventions like quarantines and lockdowns are at best tools (very blunt tools) to slow down the virus. But you can't win against it with them alone. In this case, negligence, but you can imagine that errors can and will be made simply because we aren't perfect. And the spread will start again. It is a completely unsustainable strategy on the long run, and that's why countries (at least the ones which can afford that) should look more into pharmaceutical development and therapeutic options.
- dredmorbius 6y agoTo quote six-months-ago-me, yes, curtailing spread through quarantine and hygiene is our principle tool, "for the duration of the epidemic, or until such time as any control is utterly futile" and recognises "Epidemiological response is about reducing vectors, contacts, reservoirs, and susceptibility, as well as second-order risks. Limiting movement, enhanced disease monitoring, contacts-tracing, quarantine, free treatment, mandatory vaccination (if available), financial aid and intervention to individuals, businesses, and the financial sector (in that order)". https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22528060 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22528060 It's possible for diseases to drop below the noise floor or sustaining transmissiion (plague, hantavirus), or for mutual evolution to reduce severity (rhinoviruses, influenza). Vaccines will likely be the long-term resolution, but this likely remains 2+ years off by optimistic estimates (WHO, Bill Gates). I consider a fair probability that an eendemic state will be the new normal.
- lbeltrame 6y agoThis response is not sustainable when applied to entire populations for extended periods of time. Not only for the economy, but also for the mental well being of people: you can't build a society without contact (if you think this is too much, I've seen already people distancing from the elderly that might require aid for getting into a bus, for example, as if they were plagued). Secondly, vaccines work, but people forget pharmacological treatments, which can make a terrible disease manageable. As someone with a background in pharmacology, it baffles me when these options are never considered (like a post, probably trolling, which I saw on HN once, "The drugs don't work. Enjoy your 24 months quarantine"). Secondly, the "2+ years off" depends on the estimates. These are estimates made with previous experience, where one could afford waiting, if need be. This is not the case. "We can't wait 18-24 months", said at one point CanSino's CEO. I agree with him. Drugs or vaccines should, if the tests allow it (and despite the popular thinking, the current vaccines aren't rushed, the speed is mainly done because a lot of money has been poured into recruitment and monitoring) make sure that the situation is it at least lessened before that. Because if not, people will start blatantly ignoring any recommendations from authorities (and that would also mean governments becoming even more heavy-handed than today, which is already worrying).
- just-juan-post 6y ago> The selfishness and criminal negligence of two French tourists Your grandstanding is a complete turn off and I stopped reading as soon as I saw it.
- anoncake 6y agoPeople being "selfish" speeds up the process. The quicker people get infected, the faster this nonsense is over.
- barumi 6y ago> The selfishness and criminal negligence of two French tourists has resulted in 400 new infections and counting, likely to result in 2-16 deaths given case fatality rates in Iceland (0.5%) and globally (4%). Interesting. Do you have any source that corroborates that story?
- dredmorbius 6y agoWorldometers provides case history (total, current active, daily new) and calculated CFR. Calculated likely mortaality is based on this data. Global: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/ Iceland: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/iceland/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/iceland/
- mr_woozy 6y agoPlease use Covid.is for Iceland, there's a section in english.
- dredmorbius 6y agoWorldometers is one-stop shopping for the entire planet. There are reasons aggregators are useful.
- barumi 6y ago> Worldometers provides case history (...) It seems you didn't understood my question. I asked for any source that substantiates your claim that a pair of French tourists were responsible for 400 infections. You said, and I quote, "The selfishness and criminal negligence of two French tourists has resulted in 400 new infections and counting". I asked for a source that substantiates that specific claim. Do you have any source for that assertion?
- mr_woozy 6y agoAs someone currently living here in Iceland this entire incident boils my blood. As most likely those two tourists will never be fined as it would 'send the wrong message' to tourists thinking of visiting the country. At the moment we have an entire school shut down and increased restrictions and nothing has actually changed the dynamic so that miscreants won't ruin the progress after this 3rd wave passes. Due to this latest outbreak we're now at a daily infection risk rate of 87 or so, well above the 50 mark other countries use to determine risky countries. The tourists should be named, shamed, fined and put back on a plane immediately.