5 ms·
How about we go back to a place we can install whatever we want on our computers? (The phone is a computer, not a "device" or "appliance".) If you want to use
by echelon 6y ago
How about we go back to a place we can install whatever we want on our computers? (The phone is a computer, not a "device" or "appliance".)
If you want to use Apple's discovery and distribution system, you pay a cut.
If you want to train your customers how to install on their own, you pay nothing, but have to distribute the app yourself.
The DOJ needs to force Apple to allow this, because they've unfairly strong armed their way into being middle-man for over 40% of Americans for all of the computing they do.
- jbob2000 6y agoNo they don't. If you want that, you can use Android. You can develop Android apps and buy devices that use it. There is no reason to force Apple to change when there is an equal competitor in the market that allows what you want.
- nvr219 6y agoWhy would you tell somebody to use Android? Super rude.
- suprfnk 6y agoHow is it rude to suggest buying another brand of the product?
- hu3 6y agoHave your tried telling an iPhone user to use Android? Outside our bubble, most don't even know what are the implications of switching.
- imtringued 6y agoApparently I'm rude to myself
- bobthepanda 6y ago> unfairly strong armed their way into being middle-man for over 40% of Americans What about the actual selling of iPhones counts as "unfair strong-arming"? No one's getting their arms twisted to buy a phone they don't want.
- echelon 6y agoConsumers often aren't aware of the impact of their choices. Apple is disrupting our industry. Consumers shouldn't have to change their behavior or learn about a complicated issue in order to restore balance and fairness. The forces at play are so great that the DOJ needs to pull the levers to fix this broken and unfair system.
- savolai 6y agoWho is the ”us” Apple is disrupting? There are arguments why consumers should be able to not have to think about this, and to have what Apple is doing as the default choice. I.e. everything available verified by default as mostly secure. There’s no a priori reason to assume consumers should be aware / educated which places to download from are safe and which ones are not. What should imho perhaps be changed if is the size of the cut, which indeed seems a lot.
- kelnos 6y agoWhen the only mainstream choices are iPhone or Android, and both of those options have significant, non-overlapping pros and cons, it's not like there's much choice. The other option, "don't have a smartphone", is becoming less and less tenable for most people who want to interact in society in a common way. And sure, you could buy something that runs PostmarketOS or whatever, but then you lose access to banking apps and mobile payments and a whole host of other things that are becoming table stakes for a mobile platform.
- bobthepanda 6y agoThe reason there isn't a third OS is because building a good OS and app ecosystem is hard. MS flunked, Blackberry flunked, to name a few heavyweights. Companies winning with good consumer solutions to complex problems isn't arm-twisting in any sense of the word.
- Ericson2314 6y agoIt doesn't actual matter if it's unfair or not. We're the citizens, the economy should work for us. If we think the tech industry needs less vertical integration to be healthier (imagine if Samsung made cheaper iOS phones), we simply can do it, passing laws as needed.
- alkonaut 6y agoI have no interest in smartphone form factor “PC”. I want an AppStore with humans that gatekeep what I can do. That part I have no problem with. It’s better than the situation is on my PC anyway. I only think the payment terms for developers and customers are bad.
- asdf333 6y agowell then you can just use the app store. some others of us would like the option of installing apps that aren’t sanctioned by apple.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alkonaut 6y agoYes. Again, I want the AppStore and find it better than the “open” platform model. I’m only annoyed with their 30% cut for unrelated purchases.
- mFixman 6y agoThe Apple app store has a ton of shit and scams that are approved by Apple. It doesn't have Fortnite however, since the developed correctly told people that Apple took a 30% cut of their payments.
- imtringued 6y agoFortnite was kicked because Epic willingly broke the rules by selling a premium currency without using Apple's payment infrastructure. If you want to stay on the App Store then stop breaking rules intentionally.
- ksec 6y agoThis. I have been saying exactly the same thing since the start of iPhone Vs Android. ( Remember there used to be a War between the two? ) Apple is trying to create its ideal computer, which is actually an Appliance. iPhone was that, with added custom and App ability on top. Google ( And Microsoft ) was trying to shrink the PC into Phone form factor. Arguably the two meet somewhere in the middle. But they differs in fundamental principles and values. To be point I believe if there were no profits and vested interest in App Store, Apple will be happy to shut it down and only offers default apps. I also agree the payment terms and how the handle developers were extremely poor. Did I mention Discovery and Search on App Store sucks?