14 ms·
The author of the article says that a network of regular security cameras is a better solution. He must not be married. There's no way my wife would allow all
by reaperducer 6y ago
The author of the article says that a network of regular security cameras is a better solution. He must not be married.
There's no way my wife would allow all those wires everywhere. And the wireless security cameras are a pain because you have to remember to recharge them.
Now, before the wannabe This Old House crowd starts up with "You just put the wires in the walls," consider that 43% of Americans rent their homes, and the number is even higher in other countries. The vast majority of landlords won't allow you to run wires in the walls.
That said, there's NFW I would have one of these in my house because I don't trust any tech company to have a camera in my house.
It's marketed as a security device, but it's not like a toy quadcopter is going to stop an intruder any better than a non-flying camera. Which means "not at all."
If you want home security that can reach all parts of your home, and provide alerts when someone breaks in, get a dog.
No, the dog can't alert you when you're not home, but again, it's not like you can do anything about a break-in when you're not home either way.
Then again, iOS has the built-in ability to detect dogs barking and react to that. Perhaps in the not-too-distant future, your Homepod can detect the dog barking and hit you with a text message.
- gjulianm 6y agoI mean, who actually does need an array of security cameras? Traditional alarms work well without the need for cameras, specially when cameras are simply defeated by a face covering. At that point, the camera is just a glorified motion sensor. In the case of the drone, it's just a geeky toy that will be inevitably marketed via fear-mongering, so they can collect even more data on you.
- the-pigeon 6y agoMy only thought for practical use would be to checkup on a pet while you are away from home. Since if the pet has feel roam of the house you can't necessarily see if from a stationary camera.
- reaperducer 6y agoPoint the camera at the food dish. When I go away, I put my old launch-day iPhone on a dock and aim it at the food dish. I has an app that polls that camera and checks for movement. If movement is detected, it sends a series of stills to me by e-mail. The app is no longer available on the App Store, but it keeps working because the iPhone is too old to connect to the App Store and be told that the app no longer exists. But I should think that there's a modern equivalent out there somewhere.
- jjav 6y ago> The app is no longer available on the App Store, but it keeps working because the iPhone is too old to connect to the App Store and be told that the app no longer exists. Nice! But also sad that this is the only way one can keep running a desired app in this day where an external corporation controls what one is allowed to use.
- tshaddox 6y agoI don’t think that apps on iPhones stop working just because the app was removed from from the store. You wouldn’t be able to get the app on a new phone, of course, but the old installed app should keep working. The comment might have been thinking of remotely-triggered app removal, which I believe is a rarely used function.
- ThePowerOfFuet 6y agoApps aren't removed from devices in the event they're removed from the store.
- leetcrew 6y agogood luck finding your cat after spinning up the beehive.
- leetcrew 6y agoyou get most of the benefit out of a security camera before you even turn it on. past that, probably only useful to document the actions you take if someone breaks in while you're actually home.
- reaperducer 6y agoyou get most of the benefit out of a security camera before you even turn it on Reminds me of how in the 80's, Radio Shack used to sell fake car alarm stickers.
- nobody9999 6y ago>Reminds me of how in the 80's, Radio Shack used to sell fake car alarm stickers. Those aren't as useful as you might think. I grew up in NYC, and in the late '70s/early '80s, people put all sorts of stickers and signs on their cars. One time, I even saw a car with a broken window and a sign (presumably from the window that was broken) reading "No radio. Nothing of value." The person who broke the window (at least I assume it was them) helpfully jotted "Just checking" on the sign.
- kebman 6y agoAside from general documentation of damage, cameras can also be used to measure the body and movement (for instance gait) of the criminal, which is actually useful for an investigator. It shows where the criminal walked, which is also useful for securing tracks, prints or even DNA samples. Means you can save a ton of time looking. Many criminals aren't smart enough to discard or burn their clothes after use either, so this would also positively ID the perp if found. So yeah, I'd say that cameras are pretty useful for investigating crimes outside of mere facial recognition. ^^
- reaperducer 6y agocameras can also be used to measure the body and movement (for instance gait) of the criminal, which is actually useful for an investigator For a theoretical investigator. Police departments don't have the money, manpower, or time to do gait analysis on a burglary suspect. And outside of China, is that even considered evidence in a real court of law?
- mountainb 6y agoYes. This is absolutely done when assessing and comparing security footage. Burglars are often serial burglars (it's their job or hobby to steal stuff), and many of them show up on camera multiple times from different angles. Crime goes by some skewed power law distributions and a relatively small number of people do most of the crime in any given area. As an aside, security camera footage of a crime in your house is also great for your criminal defense (if you are going to use violence against the intruder) and for pressing a claim to an insurance company. If the intruder pulls a gun on you and you shoot him in response on camera, you can use that piece of evidence to get charges dropped against you or to prevent the police from even recommending charges in the first place.
- anjel 6y agoDoes Palantir accept citizen's uploads?
- owenmarshall 6y agoThis strikes me as laughably naive. I once had my residence burglarized. The police came hours after they were called and stayed long enough (10 minutes) to write a report that took me weeks to get which essentially said "door kicked in, owner said these things gone." That was it: no attempts to follow up with my neighbor that had security cameras, no attempt to run fingerprints on the metal pipe that was found outside that was almost certainly used to break the window, nothing. If your surveillance drone doesn't get a crystal clear picture of the face of the person who broke into your house, absolutely no one is going to attempt to pull prints or tracks or DNA samples from what it captured. And even if it did get a crystal clear picture, you'll be lucky to get someone to look at it.
- kube-system 6y agoI've never been interested in using cameras for security concerns. By the time you need to use camera footage for a security concern, it's usually too late. I think they're really handy for monitoring the status of routine household tasks, though. "Did I get a package today? What time does the mail normally arrive? How is the dog doing? Did the garbage truck come by yet? Did the storm do any damage while I was away?"
- reaperducer 6y ago"Did I get a package today? What time does the mail normally arrive? How is the dog doing? Did the garbage truck come by yet? Did the storm do any damage while I was away?" Most of that sounds like the side-effects of FOMO. Did I get a package today? Unless you live in a neighborhood or building where packages get stolen, who cares? You'll find it when you get home. If it's important, you have a tracking number and know if it was delivered. What time does the mail normally arrive? Who cares? My office window overlooks the mailboxes, and it comes at a different time every day. As long as it comes. How is the dog doing? He's fine. And if he's not, you'll find out when you get home. Did the garbage truck come by yet? Who cares? Even when I had an HMO, we had eight hours to get the trash cans off the curb. Did the storm do any damage while I was away? Nice to know, if it's a tornado. But again, there's nothing you can do, so why do you need to know? It's not like you're not going to push a button on your phone and magically lift your patio set out of the neighbor's pool. If you come home and see flashing emergency lights, then yes, there is damage.
- dylan604 6y ago> Who cares? Even when I had an HMO, we had eight hours to get the trash cans off the curb. What does your health care plan have to with getting talked to by the home owners association?
- triceratops 6y agoThey might've meant "HOA". Lol
- 6y ago
- Tiktaalik 6y agoUseful perhaps for diagnosing how the criminal gained access, but not really useful at all beyond that.
- iratewizard 6y agoYeah, the arguments the author made against it aren't that strong, either. I like the idea of being able to check on my older but self sufficient pet (via a loud drone that will scare her unfortunately). I like knowing that if an intruder gets into the house, they will have to look directly at the camera and get close to swat it down. Quite a bit more difficult than defeating a static camera in the corner of a room.
- reaperducer 6y agoif the quality of the images is anything like the Ring videos I used to see when I was on Nextdoor, the burglars have nothing to fear.
- ghaff 6y agoThis was actually one of the first things along these lines that looked sorta interesting. In normal times, I travel quite a bit. I do have one camera (RPi) looking outside along with a couple other sensors. And I don't really care enough to put cameras all over the house so I can look over things when I'm traveling. (Or, given where I live, enough to subscribe to a security service.) But, for general peace of mind, to have a single device that lets me look in on things now and then? It actually seems reasonable.
- andrewprock 6y agoThis sounds like the opposite of peace of mind. Instead my mind will be cluttered with decisions about whether or not to do a "look in" right now.
- dpiers 6y agoI have a lot of IoT devices in and around my home, including some cameras. I don't trust any of the smart devices, which is why they all have offline/locally controlled operation modes and are segmented off from the rest of the network with their own manufacturer/purpose specific VLANs and firewall rules. I don't think most people comprehend what their devices are doing, or how their data could be used against them. My robovac has a LIDAR sensor that maps the house - that's cool - what isn't cool is that by default it uploads those maps to Xiaomi and they can connect it via GeoIP (or GPS if I ever use their app) and have the location and floorplan of my home. I'm not special enough for that information to be very valuable, but it's still super creepy and I would prefer they not have it.
- georgeburdell 6y agoAre you doing any hand-rolled home automation? I just finished building a house and I had power over ethernet (PoE) put throughout before I discovered that security items using this command a hefty price premium over simple wireless / battery operated. I've toyed with the idea of just buying a Raspberry Pi with a PoE module and a decent camera module and seeing if I can replicate the functionality for half the price or less (and obviously not valuing my time at anything).
- ghaff 6y agoCan't speak to PoE but Raspberry Pi works fine as a camera. I just have it shoot a still every hour that I can see on a web page. Also have a temperature sensor. Obviously I could password protect, add a motion sensor, save video, email, etc. if I wanted to get fancier.
- pinkythepig 6y agoYou can buy splitters that convert the PoE into standard network + barrel power plug. Cost 20ish dollars and a roughly raspberry pi sized device in physical space. One such example (Though I haven't used it personally): https://www.amazon.com/Amcrest-Splitter-Adapter-802-3af-compliant/dp/B00CDT7KPO https://www.amazon.com/Amcrest-Splitter-Adapter-802-3af-comp...
- chaostheory 6y agoContrary to the promotional ads, I feel the main use case is to have a closer look at small things where your main cameras are unable to have a good enough look eg, is the stove or toaster still on? Did my kid leave his school project in his room? Did I drop my wallet in this spot? What is my cat or dog doing right now?
- alistairSH 6y agoI have a few cameras and the cables are all hidden. The camera doesn't have to be mounted on a wall to be useful - mine sit on existing furniture and the cables hang down behind, out of sight. As for their utility, meh, dubious utility. Yeah, I get a notice on my phone when they detect movement. That just means I know when my maid is moving between the basement and the living room. But, I know this going in - bought them more as a nerd gadget thing that actual security.
- krstffr 6y agoA friend of a friend had a break in in his house last week and could see the burglars in his kids room via his cameras on his phone. He also had the hopeless feeling of there being nothing to do, but had some sort of Eureka-moment and started playing “Fuck the police” on max volume on the floor above (all via his phone), and that apparently sent the burglars running! (When he later talked to the cops they did call him a genius but questioned the song choice.)
- drchopchop 6y agoThe theme song from Cops ("Bad Boys" by Inner Circle) would have been brilliant, actually
- mLuby 6y agoEvery breath you take Every move you make Every bond you break Every step you take I'll be watching you or One way, or another, I'm gonna find ya I'm gonna get ya get ya get ya get ya!
- HenryBemis 6y agoJust thought of "Body count is in the house" by Body count. It starts with police sirens, and it is "loud" enough.
- Balgair 6y agoThe intro to 50 Cent's Massacre may also be a good chice: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vNBbQV_rCzQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vNBbQV_rCzQ
- Zenst 6y agoThe distinctive sound of a walkie talkie chirp is also a good sound to play, had it as my message alert on my phone - the number of people who suddenly think your a cop and get spooked. Though any music works best as shows somebody in and most burglars don't want anybody there as then it becomes a robbery and those sentences are higher. So playing music good and your choice is pretty excellent in the psychological factor upon the burglars.
- Eugr 6y agoEven without visible wires I don't think many people would put security cameras in every room. This drone looks like a good solution to check on the house while you are away without compromising everyday privacy (you can always turn it off when not in use). Also good tool for those of us being paranoid if they turned off the stove/water/etc.
- kohtatsu 6y agoSettings > Accessibility > Sound Recognition https://www.theverge.com/21300261/ios-14-update-smoke-alarm-sound-detection-accessbility https://www.theverge.com/21300261/ios-14-update-smoke-alarm-...
- spiffytech 6y agoPreventing break-ins isn't the point of security cameras. Their purpose is reacting to break-ins. Maybe you can give the police a picture of the burglar's face. Or their license plate or car make/model/color. You can see what they took, so you don't leave something off your insurance claim because you hadn't yet noticed it was missing. Your dog can't do any of these things, and a camera is a much smaller commitment than a pet.
- marcinzm 6y agoIs there a jurisdiction where the cops actually care to track down burglars? The clearance rate is something like <20% in the US and I suspect many of those were luck based (ie: the caught the burglar for something else and found stolen property).
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoIf you're a cop or government official high up enough that being on your good side is useful to the cops it will get solved.
- potatochup 6y agoI've had cops show up the next day, take fingerprints, footprints, give me a call a few weeks later when they tracked down the perp. I don't live in the USA though...
- Tiktaalik 6y ago> If you want home security that can reach all parts of your home, and provide alerts when someone breaks in, get a dog. Also don't get a Lab because he'll just lick the hands of the burgler.
- pdonis 6y ago> wireless security cameras are a pain because you have to remember to recharge them Wouldn't you just have them located near an outlet so they could be plugged in all the time? > Perhaps in the not-too-distant future, your Homepod can detect the dog barking and hit you with a text message. Considering that our dogs bark at things way across the street, we'd be bombarded with false alarm text messages with a system like this. :-)
- somehnguy 6y agoI don't know what your situation looks like but nearly every spot I can think of where a camera would work well there is no outlet. Not too many people have outlets just hanging out up near the ceiling in corners or on the outside of their homes on the roof.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- UncleOxidant 6y ago> It's marketed as a security device, but it's not like a toy quadcopter is going to stop an intruder any better than a non-flying camera. Which means "not at all." Maybe version 2.0 will have lasers?
- cameldrv 6y agoI believe this is version 2: https://youtube.com/watch?v=9CO6M2HsoIA https://youtube.com/watch?v=9CO6M2HsoIA
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoClaymore Roomba was ahead of it's time.
- biztos 6y ago> the dog can't alert you when you're not home That's a business model right there!
- triceratops 6y ago> iOS has the built-in ability to detect dogs barking Say what? Seriously?
- SamBam 6y agoIt's actually at the hardware level. The 64-bit Apple K9 chip.
- everdrive 6y agoI’m sorry that your wife won’t allow you to make your own decisions.
- reaperducer 6y agoI’m sorry that your wife won’t allow you to make your own decisions. I'm not. It's a marriage. We make decisions together.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoI'm not married but not all wives are the same. My gf wouldn't care :)
- outsomnia 6y ago/remindme after this guy finds out how it is
- stbtrax 6y agoWhat are you talking about? Is your marriage living out some outdated trope of totally changing after your wedding?
- outsomnia 6y ago/remindme after this guy finds out how it is
- reaperducer 6y agoIs your marriage living out some outdated trope If your worldview some stereotype of calling everything you haven't experienced "outdated?" That's borderline ageism right there. Celebrate diversity.
- JshWright 6y agoI've been married >15 years and agree with the comment you're replying to. Are you going to drop the same low-effort reply on me?
- novok 6y agoTBH I think the best use case for this device is anxious pet owners who want to check up on how their pets are doing. Often pets sit somewhere where the cameras are not pointing. But this also might not be good for the pet's mental health either as a loud ass drone buzzes around them.
- chakalakasp 6y agoMy dogs would make it their mission to knock the drone out of the sky and manually dissect it with their teeth to learn its secrets.
- chakalakasp 6y ago> Then again, iOS has the built-in ability to detect dogs barking and react to that. Perhaps in the not-too-distant future, your Homepod can detect the dog barking and hit you with a text message. Oh cool. I always wanted to get texts all day alerting me to people walking dogs across the street and that the squirrel that lives in the tree in the front yard has descended again.
- kortex 6y agoDearest human, I would like to politely inform you that the neighbor has gone out to get the mail. This is an urgent matter, you must attend to it at once. Sincerely, Doggo
- salawat 6y agoI've actually started classifying my dog's barking since starting to work at home. There's the "neighbor let the dog out" barking, unexpected car door, terrible music, that creepy neighbor guy, battlestations: generally unfamiliar dog or delivery person pulled up. They can actually communicate quite a lot.
- kortex 6y agoYES! My poodle has all the above. You can definitly tell the difference between "I see something" and "I hear something but idk what". Snowplows are DEFCON1. Also, "there's something I want but I can't get it", very similar to "I want to be somewhere but I'm stuck" (usually she trapped herself in the bathroom). Even though both are a shrill YARP, the former is insistent, the latter is uncertain. Then there's "throw the damn ball already", "cat, get away from my food", and the ultra rare yet adorable ambulance howl.
- joshvm 6y ago>There's no way my wife would allow all those wires everywhere. And the wireless security cameras are a pain because you have to remember to recharge them. Several manufacturers sell battery powered cameras that last up to two years without charging. Or you can get solar powered ones for outdoors. They have very low power consumption as they're normally off, until PIR triggered. That's a reasonable trade off, I think. The downside is triggering is potentially unreliable and they're not good for continuous monitoring/recording. But for detecting someone at the door, or in your garden, they're not a bad choice.
- lumost 6y agoTBH My main use for home "security" cameras has just been to check-in on my cats while away, and make sure that the people who're coming by to take care of them have given them food etc. A flying security drone solves a few big problems for me A) sometimes a cat decides not to come downstairs for a while, being able to see them is great. B) Stuff gets wrecked while we're gone, its nice to know what we're walking in to and figure out how to have less stuff wrecked in the future. I'd imagine other folks have various "peace of mind" concerns while away such as the classic "did I leave the oven on?". A patrolling camera is the perfect solution to this problem and is only tangentially related to true home security.
- freddie_mercury 6y ago> Now, before the wannabe This Old House crowd starts up with "You just put the wires in the walls," consider that 43% of Americans rent their homes, and the number is even higher in other countries. The vast majority of landlords won't allow you to run wires in the walls. It also assumes typical American construction styles. In my country all houses are made of brick. Opening up the walls to run some cables is often borderline impossible.
- tibyat 6y agoi mean in ios14 settings > accessibility > sound recognition you can do just that: get a notification when dog barking is identified.
- aurelwu 6y agoso what you are saying is that there is a market for a drone which recharges wireless security cameras?
- giancarlostoro 6y agoI have Wyze cams in the front and back of the house and when I am away I leave one pointed at where everything intersects downstairs on the inside. It just needs wire for power unless you get the outside one, those you only need to mount somewhere no wires just recharge. They let you only store things on an SD card. Really cheap anr awesome company.
- redblugreen 6y ago> There's no way my wife would allow all those wires everywhere. And the wireless security cameras are a pain because you have to remember to recharge them. This is some misogynistic bull because you’re implying that only women would care about unsightly wires strung around the place. Educate yourself.
- reaperducer 6y agoThis is some misogynistic bull because you’re implying that only women would care about unsightly wires strung around the place. I am implying nothing. I am stating a fact. My wife hates visible wires. Every time we move, it's a pain in the ass to hide all the wires for the TV. When Bluetooth became a thing, she was first on board with a wireless mouse and keyboard. It's been an ongoing theme in our relationship for decades. Educate yourself. I don't need to educate myself about my wife. You might want to educate yourself about projection, and making false assumptions to fit other people into your stereotypes.
- rewq4321 6y ago> If you want home security that can reach all parts of your home, and provide alerts when someone breaks in, get a dog. Agree with everything you said except this. This is terrible advice for most people. Don't get a dog unless you really want a dog. And if you do get one, adopt, because there are people who do think like this^ about animals, and a significant number of those animals will end up at a shelter at some point.