7 ms·
Acorn Woodpeckers Have Multi-Day Wars, and Birds Come from All Around to Watch
- spodek 6y agoNot a gamer, but sounds like the makings of a game that might teach some biology too. I wonder how they'd render the fighting.
- ycombinete 6y agoAt first I didn’t understand what the motivation for such complex social behaviour, and risk taking. But then they explained the acorn larders. Large static depositories of food wealth. This makes me think of humanity and the organisation of large societies, and war, that appears to be associated with the development of agriculture.
- thimkerbell 6y agoNative Americans, did the nomadic tribes fight more or less than the ag ones? Before they got horses, which would have changed things.
- ycombinete 6y agoSo I suppose that fighting over a scarce resource is the natural state of almost every form of life. War, then, is a logical result of complex social structures. The more static and wealthy the resource the more pitched the battles. I would imagine nomadic cultures to have less cause for war. At least until they clash over a resource. Or, their mode of resource gathering incorporates piracy of other groups wealth. I’m thinking of peoples like the Vikings, the Spartans [0], or IIRC the Comanche. Usually becuase there is pressure to do so. As in Sparta where their arable land was insufficient to support their population. [0] https://sites.google.com/site/megaraathenssparta/spartan-econo https://sites.google.com/site/megaraathenssparta/spartan-eco...
- herodotus 6y agoI have a bird feeder in my small back garden. Sometimes there is a lot of activity - mainly chickadees, finches and goldfinches competing for the feeder perches. When this happens, a hummingbird often shows up and seems to just be watching the activity. (I don't have a hummingbird feeder). I have no idea why it does this.
- dalbasal 6y agoPossibly for the same reason you watch it. It's interesting.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoIf you attract enough hummingbirds they will go after each other, trying to spear their competition.
- mikorym 6y agoFrom what I can tell, this is intraspecies competition. In Southern Africa, we have a situation whereby not all woodpecker species can peck the holes from start to end. The ones who start the holes look similar to the ones in the article, but they are black, white and yellow with red flecks [1]. Then there is a smaller orange, white and black one that either steals the former's nest or uses an old hole, after which it proceeds to do some interior decoration and expansion. This rather fashionable bird is also the emblem of the University of Johannesburg. [2] [3] There are some other woodpecker species, but these two are quite common in places where I have lived and although I am not an ethologist, I believe the comment about their interaction is accurate. The Crested Barbet is somewhat bigger than the Hoopoe, so it would be interesting to know the full picture behind their symbiosis. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crested_barbet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crested_barbet [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/African_hoopoe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/African_hoopoe [3] https://www.uj.ac.za/ https://www.uj.ac.za/
- ycombinete 6y agoI’ve always love seeing both of those birds in my garden. The barbet, with his squat sturdy frame and bright colours, especially. I’ve never read about their interaction though, and neither of links that you’ve provided appear to explicitly connect the two species. All I know, and can find, is that they both like to nest in holes in trees. Do you have any info to backup this story? Also neither of those birds are woodpeckers.
- tempytempy1 6y agoI could find that the Bennet's Woodpecker does have the behaviour of re-using or stealing holes. On Wikipedia it's only very briefly mentioned, but the large Robertson's book may have something on it. [1] Still looking for more information on what kind of holes the Hoopoe uses or makes; perhaps I was rather thinking of the Bennet's. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bennett%27s_woodpecker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bennett%27s_woodpecker
- ycombinete 6y ago
- dalbasal 6y agoI find these animal behavioural studies fascinating. There is always the risk of personification clouding our understanding, when we observe similarities to human behaviour. But another angle is de-personification of our own behaviour. That seems insightful in all sorts of way. Certain behaviours, like "war," almost certainly predate cognitive modernity... modern human consciousness. Gwynne Dyer, a historian of war, had some interesting comparisons of humans and chimps. Many interesting similarities. In any case, the ways that we rationalize our warfare, tribalism and such cannot actually be the reason for war. The warfare predates even our ability to formulate such rationalizations. This has a lot of applicability in our personal lives. Is the reason I did X really Y, or is Y a post fact rationalization?
- HenryKissinger 6y agoAre you saying that humans are partially automatons pre-programmed to behave in certain specific ways in certain situations? What are the implications of a theory like that for free will?
- vczf 6y agoNot GP, but my understanding is that free will is weak, not strong. You can suppress a desire to eat a donut (requires willpower) but can't prevent the thought/desire from arising on its own when presented with the stimulus. Similarly, we can suppress the desire to go to war after a provocation. However, we can't choose to not feel furious, at least for an instant. Thoughts and feeling tend to arise on their own, and free will is about whether we accept or reject them.
- lalos 6y agoReminds me of this comic https://goneintorapture.com/post/183584817776 https://goneintorapture.com/post/183584817776 and other variations I've seen of it.
- comeonseriously 6y agoSerious trypophobia from that one image on the linked article.
- genericone 6y agoWhen I imagine the occupants of said holes as downy/fuzzy birds, rather than squirming things, my mild trypophobia went away a great deal.
- qwertygnu 6y agoI enjoy being reminded that we don't know everything. This isn't like dark matter/gravitational waves/relativity level stuff but it shows me that there are still many many layers of things happening that no one notices. It just takes careful observation.
- ceedan 6y agoAuthor has broken the first rule of Woodpecker Fight Club
- lallysingh 6y agoI think one motivation for the onlookers is to learn tactics for future fights.
- 082349872349872 6y ago> "... when a bird’s death creates a vacancy in prime territory, the battle to fill it breaks out within minutes, and faraway onlookers can arrive in less than an hour." makes it seem to me that they wish to be the close onlookers. but > "Acorn woodpeckers are known to recognize relationships outside their own groups" agrees with the idea that they're learning, if not actual tactics, at least what the potential oppositional coalitions may be, and likely gauging their strengths. I wonder if they're sophisticated enough to manage the Stanleys' deferred approach to ensuring one is a member of the winning coalition? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Bosworth_Field https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Bosworth_Field > "Lord Thomas Stanley and Sir William Stanley also brought a force to the battlefield, but held back while they decided which side it would be most advantageous to support."
- Indirector 6y agoTrypophobia Trigger warning!
- ManBlanket 6y agoTwo days ago I heard a loud, "SQUEE! Bock bock bock bock." from our back yard. Two (Flicker) woodpeckers were fighting in the branches of a maple, our chickens standing around foot of the tree seemingly captivated by the spectacle. I assume the cause of the commotion was the tussle finding its way to the ground, startling the chickens. When I realized what was going on my daughter and I crept outside to watch. The woodpeckers and chickens ignored us as we sat down at the tree. The contenders hopping from branch to branch, diving at each other, dodging, and trying to get an angle on the other. They landed together on the roof of the nearby coop jumped up in the air and locked together in a flurry of feathers. Again the loud, "SQUEEE!" right before they hit the ground, both of them alighting on their feet, one with two of the other's breast feathers in its beak. The apparent victor of the clash exaggeratedly held the feathers above its head and gently placed them on the ground before the two of them zipped away to a power line where they remained for a while, seemingly calm. My daughter recovered the two feathers, both a downy orange quill extending up to a stark black dot, and shared her experience the next morning with her class mates. Funny I came across this article now, I'll have to share it with her when she returns from school.
- gkolli 6y agolove this story! you also have a very nice and descriptive writing style.
- soupfordummies 6y agoNice writing! That was fun to read.
- bsanr2 6y agoOne has to wonder if they were fighting over the Rose Bird. You didn't hear any rock music, did you?
- dnautics 6y agoI was hoping the parent article would talk about other species of bird as onlookers, but that wasn't the case. Got my fix from your story. Thank you!
- 6y ago
- hirundo 6y agoAround twenty years ago my dearly departed father had a multi-year war with an acorn woodpecker. The little pecker liked to hide its nuts under my dad's roof shingles. Those birds are outstandingly persistent and after a while and enough nuts they would pry up the shingles. Maybe a quarter of the shingles on one side were affected at most. About once a year my dad would go out on the steep roof and repair it. After a few years of that he got fed up and shot the bird with a bb gun. He didn't find a corpse but didn't see it again. And that shot apparently solved the problem. It must've been just that one bird. He may have broken state or federal law though.
- dmoy 6y ago> He may have broken state or federal law though. Federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act, yes It was probably federally illegal
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- s1artibartfast 6y agoUnlikely. AS I understand it, most woodpeckers are not migratory.
- dmoy 6y agoRight but the federal migratory bird act covers a ton of birds that aren't what you or I would consider migratory For whatever reason, basically every species of woodpecker in the US is classified as migratory non-game, and thus it's federally illegal to hunt them The only way you can legally shoot a woodpecker is with a depredation permit by the USFWS
- MisterTea 6y ago> "dearly departed father" ... "shot the bird with a bb gun" ... "He didn't find a corpse" Somewhere, a stash of acorns rests upon on a grave.
- petemir 6y agoFor those of us curious about the range of animal behavior (and possibly cognition), I recommend “Are We Smart Enough to Know How Smart Animals Are?” from Frans de Waal. Beautiful read.
- hyperpallium2 6y agoWhere there's fight, there's food.
- pfdietz 6y agoWoody Woodpecker, the cartoon character, was inspired by an Acorn Woodpecker.
- SusAnnie 6y agoThese birds are so much fun to watch! We have oaks in our yard, and there’s a telephone pole out back that seems to be their primary base of operations. There is always a group of them sitting on the top of the pole. They will fly off to the trees and then regroup at the pole to “chat” for a bit before flying off again. This will keep happening all day.
- ngcc_hk 6y agoWar and fighting, like competition, is part of us. Suppressing them it will appear somewhere else. There is no stop.