8 ms·
I feel like the powers that be have decided to make this extradition happen. Most people don't care because they don't pay attention. Of those that do, the noi
by LatteLazy 6y ago
I feel like the powers that be have decided to make this extradition happen.
Most people don't care because they don't pay attention. Of those that do, the noisy attention payers like us, a sizeable group have decided Assange isn't likeable and so should suffer for upsetting people more powerful than him.
Now we have to go through all this theatrics simply so those people can say things like "he got a fair hearing" and "the magistrate ruled against him so that must be the law".
It's very disappointing, because the whole point of laws is that it shouldn't matter whether you're pretty or funny or sympathetic. And after thousands of years of civilisation, people still rely on their gut feelings.
- luckylion 6y ago> Most people don't care because they don't pay attention. Are you sure it's not the other way round? Additionally, I don't think it matters whether they care or pay attention. Unless the media pays attention and publishes information, they won't get anywhere. > It's very disappointing, because the whole point of laws is that it shouldn't matter whether you're pretty or funny or sympathetic. A cynic might say that the whole point of laws is to give the impression of justice, not to provide it.
- anm89 6y ago> A cynic might say that the whole point of laws is to give the impression of justice, not to provide it. Is there one singular "point" to laws? I feel like justifying this statement inevitably ends up at some kind of secret cabal conspiracy theory. Otherwise you have to admit that there are many groups who have many competing points and goals for legal systems.
- cassepipe 6y agoThis is what Chibber calls the "pluralist theory" which he argues is not entirely false but rather incomplete. I hope this will be of interest to you : https://youtu.be/R5R-9X_BtP4 https://youtu.be/R5R-9X_BtP4
- anm89 6y agoI'd be more interested to hear what a local bartender might have to say about any of this than a marxist scholar. Hard pass. Also, naming a theory does not give it credence. So simply saying that a person said a thing and gave it a name tells me nothing if you don't tell me what they said. Linking to a hour long video is not a good substitution for defining your terms.
- anm89 6y agoI'll take all the downvotes in the world on this one. Marxist's don't get a seat at the adults table. Same way neo nazis don't get a seat at the adults table. Makes sense anyway. The communists have a higher death toll.
- cassepipe 6y agoThat explains the bartending bit above : I thought you were being provocative but you were just being simplistic. Counting the number of dead people does not explain anything. Did people die because of poor politics/administration that ended in a famine? Because they were in the middle of a conflict? Because somebody wanted to exploit their workforce? Were they sent to death directly? I think it actually matters. No nation or ideology has a monopoly on colonialism, slavery, child labor, massacres and other monstrosities. You seem to have very clear cut categories : The communists, The nazis, The adults. Although they must be quite comforting, I don't think they work very well.
- claudiawerner 6y agoA Marxist is not necessarily a Maoist, Stalinist, or even Leninist. Marxism is a philosophical, sociological, historical, and economic framework for analyzing reality. And much as one can make a great or terrible web application with a web framework, one can do the same with philosophical frameworks. Your comment is unnecessarily dismissive and only harbors guilt by association. Can you attribute support for, say, gulags to Prof. Chibber? If not, then your comment is irrelevant. If you can, you have further to prove that this opinion is a defect in this particular theory of law.
- luckylion 6y ago> Is there one singular "point" to laws? On a high level view probably "to make it work", but that just shifts the problem to what "it" is and what "work" means. It's easier to look for a priority, I think. When two interests clash (e.g. a fundamental interest of the state and the law), which one is given priority? Since it's the state that enforces the law, I believe the answer is obvious.
- rayiner 6y ago> Are you sure it's not the other way round? I agree it's the other way around. People trust the government (conceptually, they may or may not trust any given administration). I can't even get most of my friends worked up about the TSA. My wife is one of the most libertarian people I know IRL (to be fair, I live in DC and not SV) and she hates Assange and thinks he's a Russian puppet.
- anm89 6y agoIt's little events like these that expose the inner workings of the system. For all of our lip service to due process and blind justice, governments are still made up of people and the people at the top have the ability to do whatever they want with the system when they are motivated. The sad part is that recently everyone seems to be ok with this, as long as it's working in their favor in whatever particular instance.
- ta1234567890 6y ago> The sad part is that recently everyone seems to be ok with this Or they feel like they can't do anything about it, because if they even try, they'll end up getting their lives either ruined or completely turned around, like Assange or Snowden.
- abiogenesis 6y agoIsn't that the whole point of ruining someone's life? To intimidate others.
- krageon 6y agoYes, and it's working.
- wegs 6y agoI mean, this sort of shit happens in our court systems all the time. This just raises the visibility to where we all see it.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoI can’t help but feel the media doesn’t seem to pay attention because Assange doesn’t have anything damaging against “persona non grata”. It’s a shame really. Assange and Wikileaks has done a lot for government transparency and paid for it. Way more than the martyrs who go to rallies and complain that they’re called fake news. Who cares? Do something that gets you exiled into indefinite solitary confinement then you can have my sympathy. In the meantime, his defenders really are motley crew. You have people from all sides, from the WWG1WGA people to amnesty internal and reporters without borders. We'll see if that's enough to pierce the walled garden of coastal and mainstream media.
- rayiner 6y agoI’m not sure I parse things the way you do. Assange is accused of going beyond leaking into assisting Chelsea Manning get pass security systems. If he was not only the distributor of classified material, but actively participated in expropriating it, he’s on the wrong side of the law. Folks had been willing to overlook that, because they viewed him as sympathetic. But he’s undermined that with his connections to Russia. Moreover, Russian attempts to manipulate the 2016 election showed a lot of people that radical transparency isn’t cost free—hostile governments can use this information to jeopardize American national security, including by manipulating otherwise well meaning leakers. If you’re neither sympathetic nor on the right side of the law, you’ve got a problem.
- agd 6y agoI believe that is incorrect. Assange is accused of helping Manning cover her tracks rather than extract the information in the first place. I.e. he was trying to protect his source. In addition, multiple journalists have spoken out to the effect that encouraging sources to leak is standard journalistic practice.
- rayiner 6y ago“Protecting your source” means that you don’t disclose your source. It doesn’t mean you help your source cover up a crime. This is not a difficult line drawing exercise. Lawyers do it all the time: you’re protected from disclosing client confidences. But it’s highly illegal to actually assist your client in obstructing an investigation!
- agd 6y agoJournalists have already testified in this case to the contrary of what you said. I.e. They do help sources stay undetected, providing advice and sometimes help where appropriate.
- rayiner 6y agoJournalistic practice doesn’t define what is and isn’t illegal in connection with collaborating with a source.
- sneak 6y ago> Now we have to go through all this theatrics simply so those people can say things like "he got a fair hearing" and "the magistrate ruled against him so that must be the law". This means that the countries involved (in this case, in order: Australia, Sweden, the UK, and the US) don't have the rule of law. It means that the law is theater, always potentially subordinate to dictatorial control should it ever be exercised to overrule it. It's okay to say it, despite it feeling silly. Identifying one of the problems allows us to address it. These countries only pretend to have the rule of law, insofar as the law doesn't contradict what the dictatorial authority wants to happen. It's weird to think of the US or UK or Sweden or Australia, supposedly "free countries", as top-down military dictatorships, because it goes against every fiber of branding they've spent billions to explicitly promote. There's lots of evidence for it, however: what mainstream party in the US wants to reign in the US military's insane overfunding, or illegal US military bulk surveillance, for example? Once you see it, it's hard to unsee. These countries place state security far above almost every other value, including equal protection of the law. Any attempts to change this priority by those with any semblance of power will be frustrated, by force if necessary.
- rtx 6y agoGreat point, though its not only branding. All the things are in open. Its we who think democracy can be real at national level.
- telchar 6y agoIf you want to name a country that has rule of law, in your opinion, it works make your point stronger. The US isn't a particularly good example of the rule of law right now, true, but I think you would be hard pressed to come up with an example that passes your apparently stringent purity test. If you can't point to such examples, your point comes off as trivially weak.
- fsflover 6y agoI don't understand how finding a more democratic country would change the fact that the countries above have no rule of law.
- clairity 6y agowhether you're sympathetic to assange or not, the critical, core problem is the US government acting illegally, immorally, and dishonorably, and using our collective might to hide that and actively obstruct its discovery, rather than the opposite. this is shameful to say the least. and this trial is a crucial part of that misdirection campaign, to place our attention on anything other than that shamefulness. to refute this charade of a trial is also to resist this misdirection.
- bcrosby95 6y ago> Of those that do, the noisy attention payers like us, a sizeable group have decided Assange isn't likeable and so should suffer for upsetting people more powerful than him. Sure, but this is how things have always been. Rosa Parks wasn't the first or only black person that was arrested for not giving up her bus seat.
- monadic2 6y agoI think people care, but the "powers that be" are aware of our lack of power.
- thefucnjosh 6y agoYou realize that by thinking of yourself as powerless you 've actually done so? Maybe you should adopt a different set of beliefs. Maybe that you're less powerful than others, but more powerful than some. You can call your Senator, that already means you're more powerful than Assange.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kanox 6y ago> a sizeable group have decided Assange isn't likeable Or they decided that Assange and WikiLeaks are malicious actors not worth siding with. The powers that be are right to throw Assange in prison.
- thefucnjosh 6y agoI looked through your post history and found this: "Freedom of speech and rule of law is not conditioned on reciprocity." I'd like to remind you that the Trump administration asked Assange for the DNC email leaker as a way to discredit the media tying Trump to Russia. Assange is on trial because he wouldn't give the Trump administration that source. Do you still believe what you said?
- LatteLazy 6y agoOf course, what we're really saying here is that we can censor people we don't like. Free speech is conditional on you only saying things that no one minds you saying anyway...
- kanox 6y agoLeaking classified documents is not a free speech issue.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoPublishing them most certainly is (more free press technically)
- LatteLazy 6y agoYes, it is actually. It sounds counter intuitive right? But all classified means if that the president (or someone under him) does NOT want something published. So if publishing something classified is not free speech then what is? You don't need the first ammendment to publish things the government does not mind you publishing, you already have their permission. The whole point of the first amendment is to protect publishing things the government doesn't want published. If the government could actually prevent publishing of anything it classified, the US would still be fighting the Vietnam war and we would all consider Nixon to be a stand up guy who fairly won re-election...
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Now we have to go through all this theatrics simply so those people can say things like "he got a fair hearing" and "the magistrate ruled against him so that must be the law". This is a theme that Bridge of Spies carries off pretty well.
- sudoaza 6y agoJudge also has conflict of interest and ties to the intelligence community.