8 ms·
CNC Fabric Cutting
- pimlottc 6y agoGoogle cache: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://www.neufeld.newton.ks.us/electronics/?p%3D1827&rlz=1C5CHFA_enUS898US898&strip=1&vwsrc=0 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://...
- msla 6y agoArchive: https://web.archive.org/web/20200919222512/http://www.neufeld.newton.ks.us/electronics/?p=1827 https://web.archive.org/web/20200919222512/http://www.neufel...
- wigiv 6y agoSite is down, so I'm winging this comment until I can check again later or find an archive, but I wanted to note that my company has cut all kinds of fabric (and also food!) using a "water-only" (ie, no entrained abrasive) method with an ultra-high-pressure CNC waterjet. Depending on the material and tolerances, you can cut through significant stacks simultaneously to save time, and with the correct settings and setup you get very little splashback or other wetting. Since the 60,000+ PSI stream is coming out of the nozzle at something like mach 2, the water is travelling too fast to make the edge wet!
- mdorazio 6y agoThis is really interesting since waterjet often doesn't work well for non-rigid materials. Do you have to add a backer to keep the fabric stiff/in place or are you able to just rely on the thickness of a stack to keep it properly placed and non-moving?
- wigiv 6y agoFor floppy materials we use a few approaches: first, instead of putting the material on the standard "metal slat" bed, we use a product called Rhino Board, which is essentially a whole bunch of plastic straws glued together into a rigid mat. It provides more granular support. For materials still needing more support, we put a sacrificial board (either OSB or plastic sheeting) underneath. And for materials that we can't glue down, or are even more problematic, we also put a sacrificial sheet on top.
- detritus 6y agoInteresting! So you have a site I can see? A competitor to me (offering laser services) has started offering water-cut plywood, which boggled my mind - I would have expected that to be a terrible idea!
- wigiv 6y agoSure - we're a startup (MODICA Microindustries) working on a related problem (modular manufacturing equipment), and we spun up a subsidiary (Harbor Island Waterjet) offering waterjet cutting services as a job shop since we had excess capacity on our three machines. There are pros and cons to waterjet cutting but for what it's worth, it can cut virtually anything. There are a lot of techniques for reducing splashback and other wetting/soiling from the tank. We cut wood fairly often. Some people like how laser singes the edges better, but to each their own!
- detritus 6y agoHey, thanks for getting back to me - I realised this morning I should've just checked your profile, which I did! I'm very impressed with what you're doing - particularly as I actually had a similar idea a couple of years back, rooted in a plan to perhaps move country (within EU) and so was wondering how I'd a) move my equipment and b) set up shop when there. That sort of spawned a lot of thought about modular container-based systems, and how I'd fit various sizes and types of CNC machines in them. Then I wondered about the use of on-site CNC services for large construction developments - I could imagine the benefit of having a few accurate machining shops in containers that can quickly turn around finished interior elements straight from site measurements, etc. As we know though, an idea's worth precisely nowt if unrealised, so I'm super-glad to see that someone has! Best of luck to you!
- pryelluw 6y agoOT: Im very interested in learning more about modica. Would it be ok to email you?
- wigiv 6y agoSure thing! Looking forward to hearing from you.
- ampdepolymerase 6y agoHere's a datasheet for an industrial fabric cutter: http://www.ruk-tech.com/uploads/137f9456.pdf http://www.ruk-tech.com/uploads/137f9456.pdf
- Pfhreak 6y agoInteresting. Author describes a few methods for cutting fabric on a hypothetical fabric CNC. Lasers are out because of the impact to the material, so they investigate a few cutting options: Blade - Cuts well, but drags material Roller - Cuts well, but needs heavy downforce and overcuts the fabric border Scissors - A mechanical nightmare The author suggests a reciprocating blade might solve the issue, but introduces other complexities (it destroys the material underneath. A reciprocating blade seems like a much more complex solution than trying to solve a fabric rigidity issue or heaviness issue from a rolling blade. Like, if you are already considering a sacrificial material, why not sandwich the fabric between two rigid, high friction materials, and have the knife cut through all three? I think about this a lot, as the partner does a lot of sewing, and a significant amount of time is spent on cutting pattern pieces. It seems like such a solvable problem, but also, such a challenging problem.
- Maarten88 6y agoI can't read the article, because the blog is now down, but it seems somewhat strange to talk about a hypothetical fabric CNC when such machines are readily available and used in industry, including these options and more, as handy modules that you can use for cutting all kinds of fabrics: https://www.zund.com/en/cutting-systems/modules-and-tools https://www.zund.com/en/cutting-systems/modules-and-tools Those machines are probably a bit expensive for private use, but theoretically this seems like it is a solved problem.
- Pfhreak 6y agoThe idea was that a home user cannot afford an industrial machine.
- bsder 6y agoYou should still learn from the industrial solutions. Industrial users have real problems that they are highly incentivized to solve. If they solve it a different way from you, you should ask "Why?" and "Can I adapt their solution?".
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- brk 6y agoSite is down, but from the cache link posted, this looks like an exploration into DIY CNC fabric cutting, recognizing that higher volume/higher price alternatives already exist in the market. Basic CNC control seems to mostly be a solved problem these days, there are lots of options that product reasonably good precision using stepper motors, lead screws, and some open-source software. The challenge for CNC cutting fabric for low cost/low volume applications seems to revolve around what to use to make the actual cut. In this segment, there does not appear to be a clear option for something that works reliably, without a lot of material waste, and within the budget of a bespoke garment producer.
- jagged-chisel 6y agoIf you take a Backstage Magic Tour at Walt Disney World, the costuming department has some kind of [magical] CNC fabric cutter that does a single layer of fabric quickly and cleanly, apparently cookie-cutter style. You see the design on an LCD screen, the operator places the fabric, the machine closes on the fabric, it makes quiet slapping sounds for a few seconds, and it opens revealing the perfectly cut piece. You're not permitted to take photos of the machine. Textile cutting isn't my thing, so I don't know how it works, but I found it mildly interesting.
- NileTheGreat 6y agoRelated question: any good recommendations for garment/fabric specific CAD software out there? As purely a passing interest I recall trying to find a platform years ago but being disappointed with what I found. I've always wanted to design the 'perfect' (for me) laptop bag but found the task daunting. This is coming from someone whose worked with Lasers/CNC Mills/CNC Routers/3D Printers/traditional mechanical & electrical CAD enough to be comfortable with the concepts of computer aided design and machine operation.
- throwaway9d0291 6y agoUnfortunately most of the standard stuff (Optitex, Gerber) is industrial software with "contact us" pricing. What I've found works best for me is: - Seamly2D (https://seamly.net/ https://seamly.net/) and Valentina (https://gitlab.com/smart-pattern/valentina https://gitlab.com/smart-pattern/valentina) - these are two forks of an open-source project. They do pretty much everything I want them to do. - Clo3D: https://www.clo3d.com/ https://www.clo3d.com/ - horrendously expensive subscription software ($50/month or $450/yr) but there are.. Uh... Less legal options available online. My favourite aspect of this particular software is that it lets you view the constructed object (usually a garment) in 3D and run physics simulations on it. I've tried Optitex and Gerber as well but despite being the standard in industry, I don't find them to be great pieces of software. Of the two, Optitex is much better than Gerber but both are really hard to use. I think Clo3D is probably the most approachable option but it does cost. Seamly2D/Valentina have a steeper learning curve than Clo3D but they're also much more capable when it comes to design and in particular, parametric design.
- bsder 6y agoOkay, I'll bite. This is an interesting idea, but "Why?" The hypothetical use case "Made to measure suits for women" is one that a human with scissors does just fine. I suspect a single person with scissors can do this in less than an hour. The tailoring and sewing is FAR more time consuming. The point of CNC is either to 1) enable repeatable volume or 2) enable something that couldn't be done before. This falls into neither category.
- UncleEntity 6y ago> ...enable something that couldn't be done before. They want to take critical measurements and automagically generate the pattern for the suit. Kind of like the custom bra manufacturer that was making the rounds a while back I suppose.
- bsder 6y agoErm ... she did a post mortem on that bra manufacturer. Something like "cutting the fabric" didn't even rank on why the business failed.
- rtkwe 6y agoFor industry it already exists, for hobbyists it's a neat challenge that can remove a remove a boring part and for small scale companies it lets more people be on sewing machines instead of pattern cutting.
- cptskippy 6y agoThe variability of clothing isn't great. You can buy 4 pairs of the same pants and they'll all fit differently. When you're ordering online this is even worse as you can't try before you buy. Having consistent fabric pieces would go a long way to reducing that variability.
- throwaway9d0291 6y agoAs a hobbyist, once I have a pattern, cutting out the fabric is by far the most tedious aspect of making a garment. It's just lots of precise handwork. Typically, when I'm making something, it's ~80% cutting, 20% sewing. By removing that cutting, I'd cut 3h of work down to ~40 minutes.
- throwaway9d0291 6y agoI actually went down the laser route but I'm mostly interested in synthetic fabrics. To address the TFA's concerns: - You don't need a whole lot of power for the kinds of synthetic fabrics you'd want to wear. I use a 20W laser from AliExpress that outputs ~7.5W of actual energy. - Safety is definitely a big concern. The biggest problem is that a lot of synthetic fabrics produce lethally toxic gases when cut with a laser. However if you build an enclosure, you can filter the exhaust to ensure that it's safe. - Don't know why liability is a problem, not American. - It won't scorch most synthetic fabrics, it will melt them. However this is often a good thing, as it seals the edges so that they won't fray. They also have a huge advantage: they're cheap and easy. My 1000x1000mm laser cutter cost me ~$120 from AliExpress. Just had to screw it together and it worked out of the box. At the very least, you can use it to cut out paper patterns for you or put cut marks onto the fabric.
- leoedin 6y agoWhat model of laser cutter do you have? $120 is very cheap - is it any good?
- throwaway9d0291 6y agoIt's AliExpress, they typically don't have model numbers. It's nothing life changing but it does what it says it does. It doesn't need to be expensive for a job like this. It's just: - An Aluminium profile frame - Stepper + belt driven axes - A laser module - Probably <$10 worth of control electronics (an Arduino and some cheap stepper drivers) - A cheap DC power supply I'm pretty sure the most expensive part is the laser module but those go for ~$30-40 on their own.
- imtringued 6y agoI'm really confused. What this person is looking for is a "oscillating tangential knife". Lots of hobby CNC machine manufacturers offer it as an option. A medium sized CNC machine + knife will probably cost around $5k. Smaller machines are cheaper but you get less value per dollar.
- robga 6y agoOne of the most abiding memories of my trip to North Korea 8 years ago was the ubiquity of the CNC Song https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sPPlTX2a974 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sPPlTX2a974 I can't read about CNC's without whistling the tune.
- 082349872349872 6y agoI can think of only one other CNC-themed pop video, and that requires thinking of string-trio Rammstein covers as pop.
- 5m17h 6y agoHave a link?
- 082349872349872 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UfFtPFJWufs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UfFtPFJWufs