5 ms·
The short life span always interested me, especially being high intelligence. It lives long enough to breed, serving it's short singular purpose. I'd love to s
by dmix 6y ago
The short life span always interested me, especially being high intelligence. It lives long enough to breed, serving it's short singular purpose.
I'd love to see a comparison of the life spans of various animals/species. It would make for a good graphic/visualization. I'm guessing this sort of lifespan is more common than not, compared to say whales living ~50yrs.
Edit: I found two good infographicy examples, although Id love something far more in depth
https://payload.cargocollective.com/1/13/443926/6626429/ANIMALS_o.jpg https://payload.cargocollective.com/1/13/443926/6626429/ANIM...
https://www.alansfactoryoutlet.com/how-long-animals-live-the-life-spans-of-50-animals https://www.alansfactoryoutlet.com/how-long-animals-live-the...
- UncleOxidant 6y agoGiven their intelligence, one wonders what they would be like if they lived say 20 years? Would they be ruling the oceans?
- vharuck 6y agoI've wondered this, too. If they lived long enough after the new generation is born, they might've developed language or some other communication system.
- anonAndOn 6y agoI thought they communicated via semaphore? Their cousins the cuttlefish certainly do.
- vharuck 6y agoOne researcher has seen "communication" in one species of octopus, but it's mostly looking big and dark to drive away others, or small and light before being driven away[0]. It's a very primitive communication, like rattlesnakes do to scare away dangers. Not the kind of complex system I was thinking of. I'm being very human-centric, though. It just seems like if they're intelligent enough to recognize individual faces, use tools, and learn from what other octopi do, a complex language would be inevitable. And from there they'd accrue oral histories and localized cultures. [0] https://www.livescience.com/53514-octopuses-lead-social-lives.html https://www.livescience.com/53514-octopuses-lead-social-live...
- colechristensen 6y agoTheir reproduction strategy would have to change, when you produce 100,000 eggs and die taking care of them there’s not much chance to develop culture.
- seesaw 6y agoI highly recommend the Netflix documentary ’My Octopus Teacher‘. This is the story of a photographer diving everyday for a year, and developing a two way bond with an octopus.
- koheripbal 6y agoEspecially true since living longer often means helping to raise and teach children - passing on knowledge. Many land animals are intelligent and raise children so it's not clearly the only requirement for advanced development. ....they do certainly have the finger like dexterity for fine object control though.
- mindfulplay 6y agoI find this amusing as this is an inherently human emotional evaluation. Perhaps that is not the point in the grand scheme of things? Octopuses have survived for 500+ millions of years and I would say more intelligent and peaceful than humans who 'ruled' or savaged their own species for... what benefit actually?
- Natsu 6y agoI'm not sure about the 'peaceful' claim, that seems to me to be something of a romanticism. It's called the 'law of the jungle' for a reason, after all, e.g. - https://www.livescience.com/47982-octopus-cannibalism-video-captured.html https://www.livescience.com/47982-octopus-cannibalism-video-... But I think it's true that human intelligence has made us have a greater impact on the world, both for good and for evil.
- r3trohack3r 6y agoA viable chance at getting off this rock. 500+ million years is a blink of an eye on a cosmic scale. Humans are the only species we’ve observed that has a viable chance or surviving on cosmic time scales; and we will likely bring other life along with us for that ride. Short of another human-equivalent species evolving, or a hyper resilient organism that can piggy back on space debris, humans are literally the only shot life on Earth has.
- mindfulplay 6y agoWhy does that matter? Why are humans so special? I 'feel' like octopuses are the better candidate :) putting aside trivial human aspirations....
- r3trohack3r 6y agoWhen they successfully escape earths orbit, get back to me. Until then, all odds are stacked against them. They’re going to go extinct in an instant on a cosmic timescale. Unless, of course, humans choose to bring them along and save them from that fate.
- wonderwonder 6y agoIf you like sci-fi, Children of Ruin by Adrian Tchaikovsky plays with this concept. It's the second book in a series though, first being Children of Time. Super imaginative and well written, I really liked them.
- agumonkey 6y agomaybe self destroy their own species and so only the short lived one persist
- amelius 6y agoI wonder if animals are aware of their own mortality. How would you test this?
- bloak 6y agoElephants could easily be aware of their own mortality. They are social, long-lived, and have been filmed interacting in an interesting way with elephant bones. There was a nice article on elephants posted here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19828113 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19828113
- Guest19023892 6y agoI imagine it's a very small number, likely including elephants and great apes. However, even I struggle to grasp the concept of my own mortality. I feel like most people are in the same situation. They can tell you they're going to die one day, like they're reciting lines from a book, but they don't seem to truly grasp what it means.
- disown 6y agoOne way is to see which animals have self-awareness or have a sense of self. But that test is difficult because we can only rely upon our human-biased perspective and hence any test we developed will be skewed towards our way of thinking/being. For example the mirror test works well for humans, but what about animals that rely mostly on smell, sound, etc? But even if they are self-aware it doesn't necessarily mean they would be aware of their own mortality. It's assumed that most, if not all animals, live "in the moment". So it's hard to imagine an animal that always lives in the moment to think about their own mortality. It's mostly likely that most animals aren't aware of their mortality and they don't even have the capacity to even consider it. It would be like wondering whether an ant understands calculus. They simply lack the capacity. And finally, what evolutionary benefit does the awareness of their mortality confer on any animal? In nature, where competition is fierce and unforgiving, I doubt animals who dwell upon their own mortality outcompete those that live in the moment.
- ashika 6y agoI've been wondering if their short lifespan is in any way related to cephalopods' recently discovered use of RNA editing techniques[1]. [1] https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(17)30344-6 https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(17)30344-6
- mindfulplay 6y agoI have often wondered about this aspect of lifespan. Octopuses are amazing. Perhaps their relatively short lifespan and lifecycle after mating is somehow correlated with them being around for 500+ million years. Somehow I find that more fascinating. I feel like humans are inherently lower on this scale: we definitely live longer but I wonder as a species if we would be better off with shorter lifespan (and life cycle) like octopuses that helps the entire human species survive (peacefully?) as opposed to an optimization around single individual lifespan.
- lisper 6y agoHuman life spans are driven by the fact that newborn humans need the support of their parents to survive until they reach sexual maturity. So there is selective pressure on humans to live just long enough to see their grandchildren born and not much longer. Octopi don't have that constraint. They just need to reproduce, then they're done.
- mindfulplay 6y agoActually not. Octopuses (female) breed their young for months without eating and then die off. Seems like they have perfected this system over millenia via evolution?
- dmm 6y agoHumans being of the few animals that go through menopause is strong evidence that grandmothers contribute to the survival of their grandchildren.
- ch4s3 6y agoThat seems rather bleak and somewhat Malthusian. I'm further perplexed by the idea that anti-individualism or some sort of collectivism would be "better for us". Historically, collectivist thinking hasn't been positive for anyone who's interests fall outside of the narrow interests of those in power.
- jbay808 6y ago
- 29ebJCyy 6y agoPeter Godfrey Smith has a great summary of this in "Other Minds": > Why should an organism devote all its resources to one brood, or one breeding season? Much depends, again, on the risk of death by predation and other external causes—especially on how this risk changes over an animal’s lifetime. Suppose in some animal the juvenile stage is risky, but once you get to be an adult, you can expect to live for a while without being eaten. Then it makes sense for adults to reproduce more than once. That applies to fish and many mammals. If, on the other hand, the adult life stage is very risky, it might make more sense to “go for broke” as soon as you get to a stage where you can breed. Seasons also play a role. There might be a good season for laying eggs, or for hatching. That will determine a timetable within each year; perhaps it makes sense to mate in spring, or in winter. Then the question becomes: During how many years should you try to reproduce? Initially it might seem obvious that there is no harm in leaving it open, at least, that you will be around for another couple of years. You might make it through. Why fall apart in the meantime? But here the Williams argument returns, along with the need to think about these evolutionary questions by considering vast numbers of individuals and many generations. In the abstract, you would like to live and mate forever—at least from an evolutionary point of view. But who will leave more descendants, an organism which spends everything on one mating season, or a rival which spends less now in the hope of reproducing again later? If you spend less now to save something for later, that will do you no good if animals of your kind have little chance of making it to the next breeding season. In that case, it is better to put everything into one mating season, embracing all the options which give you an advantage now, even at the cost of breakdown once the season is done.
- alikim 6y agoSuch a great book! I thought the whole section on why we age was compelling. The idea that nature can select for mutations which may be beneficial earlier on but have harmful effects after a given time period was new to me.
- joe_the_user 6y agoOne thing that occurs to me is for a social creature, a long life span allows knowledge that is passed on. But if an intelligent species wasn't a social species, then it's hard to see the value of a long life span.