4 ms·
The ship epidemics give an indication of whether this is the case. The USS Teddy Roosevelt had an epidemic and everyone onboard was tested. 20% tested positive
by Animats 6y ago
The ship epidemics give an indication of whether this is the case. The USS Teddy Roosevelt had an epidemic and everyone onboard was tested. 20% tested positive for the virus. 60% showed antibodies.
Arctic cruise ship after 21 days: "Of the 217 passengers and crew who remained on the ship for the entirety of the voyage, 128 tested positive for the coronavirus, the researchers said. They added that of those who tested positive, 24 exhibited symptoms and 104, or 81%, did not."[2]
There are many other ship epidemics, but those are ones that had 100% testing.
That puts a ceiling on pre-existing immunity at somewhere around 40%. No floor from that data.
[1] https://www.cnn.com/2020/06/09/health/covid-19-investigation-aircraft-carrier/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/06/09/health/covid-19-investigation...
[2] https://www.cnbc.com/2020/05/27/over-80percent-of-coronavirus-patients-on-cruise-ship-had-no-symptoms-study-says.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/05/27/over-80percent-of-coronaviru...
- jdminhbg 6y ago> That puts a ceiling on pre-existing immunity at somewhere around 40%. Only if pre-existing immunity and sailors/passengers are evenly distributed.
- mike00632 6y agoCOVID tests/PCR tests only test whether a person is actively infected. They look for viral RNA present in your system. Therefor, if you recover (10-14 days after infection, ~7 days after symptoms) then you will not test positive for COVID. https://www.medicaldevice-network.com/features/types-of-covid-19-test-antibody-pcr-antigen/ https://www.medicaldevice-network.com/features/types-of-covi...
- nradov 6y agoThat is not correct. The PCR tests are highly sensitive and continue to show positive results from remaining dead virus particles for some patients weeks after the infection has been cleared. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7237903/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7237903/
- mike00632 6y agoThe point is the OP's math assumed that everyone (ALL) who recovered from COVID-19 would test positive. What you're saying is that SOME people who have recovered could test positive.
- whiddershins 6y agoPre existing immunity may not preclude testing positive? Not an expert here but could preexisting immunity just mean the virus has trouble really taking hold and wreaking havoc before it is shut down, as opposed to never being infected at all? I guess what I’m asking is whether immunity is truly binary.
- dtech 6y agoIt does. To test positive viral load needs to be at a certain level, that can only happens if cells are infected and producing virus particles. If that's happening you're not immune.
- timr 6y agoCurrent US PCR tests are set to be so sensitive that they can detect a single copy of viral RNA. This has been an under-reported fact that should be more widely known: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/29/health/coronavirus-testing.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/29/health/coronavirus-testin...
- faitswulff 6y agoImmunity is indeed not binary. There's sterilizing vs non-sterilizing immunity, for instance, sterilizing immunity meaning that the pathogen is purged before infecting cells (emphasis mine): > Without a strong mucosal response, injected vaccines may be less likely to produce so-called sterilizing immunity, a phenomenon in which a pathogen is purged from the body before it’s able to infect cells, Dr. Durbin said. Vaccinated people might be protected from severe disease, but could still be infected, experience mild symptoms and occasionally pass small quantities of the germ onto others. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/14/health/coronavirus-nasal-vaccines.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/14/health/coronavirus-nasal-...
- sharadov 6y agoThe research says that some people may have T-cells which promote a more robust response to the virus, if their antibodies don't succeed. From the article below "This means that infected people who did not develop symptoms or antibodies may still be immune to Covid-19 via T-cells memory" It does a good job of explaining the difference between immunity acquired by antibodies vs T-cells. https://medium.com/microbial-instincts/if-antibodies-fall-short-of-covid-19-immunity-call-the-t-cells-abeb5cae6832 https://medium.com/microbial-instincts/if-antibodies-fall-sh...
- timr 6y ago"That puts a ceiling on pre-existing immunity at somewhere around 40%." No, you're assuming that pre-existing immunity excludes people testing positive for the virus. You can test positive while mounting a robust immune response. In fact given that most infections are minimally symptomatic, it's arguable that immunity is the norm, not the exception.
- michaelmrose 6y agoThat isn't what the word immunity means.
- timr 6y agoI'm not sure what you're trying to argue, but an immune response in no way precludes testing positive for a virus. Particularly at the testing thresholds we are using in the US, where as little as a single copy of the virus RNA can be detected, a great number of people test positive for weeks after their immune system has defeated the virus.
- sa1 6y agoHe may not be wrong. T-cells are not like antibodies, which is the immunity you are thinking of.
- cblades 6y agoWhat the words means in common usage doesn't have to track what immunity actually is. Colloquially, immunity means sterilizing immunity. Actually, immunity doesn't have to be sterilizing.
- nradov 6y agoYou shouldn't be downvoted. Immunity is a spectrum, not a binary condition. If the pre-existing immunity hypothesis is correct then it probably doesn't provide complete protection in all cases. It might cause some patient to experience asymptomatic or paucisymptomatic infections instead of full blown clinical COVID-19. Those patients can still test positive. The CDC estimates that 40% of infections are asymptomatic. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/planning-scenarios.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/planning-scena...
- belltaco 6y agoMany of the ship epidemic stats counted pre-symptomatic people as asymptomatic.
- nickthemagicman 6y agoThis is assuming antibody tests are accurate. Antibodies decline drastically after 2 weeks and the T cells and other immune systems take over. So, the question is how accurate are the antibody tests for Covid-19?
- cma 6y ago> They added that of those who tested positive, 24 exhibited symptoms and 104, or 81%, did not Does that distinguish pre-symptomatic from true-asymptomatic? 100% testing is not enough without follow up testing for a while.
- argonaut 6y agoFlipping a coin 10 times and seeing that there are 7 heads does not imply that the probability of tails has a ceiling of 30%.