6 ms·
Because 'anti price gouging' laws prevent the price going high enough to make it worth someone going to extreme efforts to upscale production. Without those la
by londons_explore 6y ago
Because 'anti price gouging' laws prevent the price going high enough to make it worth someone going to extreme efforts to upscale production.
Without those laws, the price going from $1 per mask to $10 per mask would still be very much affordable for everyone who really needs a mask, and factories who can successfully get decent production underway will earn lots, making it worthwhile to take on the risk of chasing a (possibly short lived) demand.
- kevin_b_er 6y ago$10 per mask is outrageous for a mask that only really lasts less than a day before becoming ineffective.
- ch4s3 6y agoWho pays for factories to purchase new equipment and hire more workers to produce more masks then? The companies selected by the government to do so have more or less flopped, as they had more political connections than skill in producing masks.
- gizmo686 6y agoHow do you define outrageous? The shortage is because of how short they last (and the massive spike in demand). If that is the price it takes for supply to meet demand, I can see calling it unnaceptable, but I don't see how it is outrageous, unless you can point to some other decision that led to the cost being nessasary. In practice, I don't think $10/mast is unnaceptable. That is about 15 minutes worth of an ICU nurse's time[0]. In terms of costs that this pandemic is causing, even "expensive" masks are a cheep. [0] https://www.ziprecruiter.com/Salaries/What-Is-the-Average-ICU-Registered-Nurse-Salary-by-State https://www.ziprecruiter.com/Salaries/What-Is-the-Average-IC...
- benjohnson 6y agoWe able to get five days of use out of ours if we let them rest and decontaminate for five days between usage. Even after still pass the fit-test and work well - we just throw them away out of an abundance of caution. Even the ones we get from 3M South Korea at about $20 each winds up costing just pennies per hour. Re-use Guidelines: https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/ppe-strategy/decontamination-reuse-respirators.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/ppe-strategy/d...
- SpelingBeeChamp 6y agoIf you don't mind answering, what decontamination method are you using? That CDC link merely refers mask users to the mask manufacturers. How have you found reuse to effect fit and performance? From the CDC page you linked: "Decontamination of an N95 FFR inactivates viruses and bacteria on the device, but does not restore the N95 FFR to “new” performance. Decontamination studies have evaluated the effect of the decontamination process on the fit and filtration performance of N95 FFRs; however, these studies did not consider the likelihood that N95 FFRs worn by healthcare personnel are likely donned and doffed multiple times before undergoing decontamination. N95 FFR performance will decrease as the number of hours and number of donnings and doffings increase. Repeated decontamination and handling of FFRs can damage the fit and filtration performance of N95 FFRs. Fit performance during limited reuse, including decontaminated FFRs, should be monitored by the respiratory protection program manager or appropriate safety personnel. Information about how to assess N95 FFR fit during limited reuse can be found below...."
- benjohnson 6y agoSorry for the delay - we age and rotate resperators. The virus is presumed inactive after four days, so we have a weeks worth rotating at any one time. We store them in paper bags to let them dry out. Given we rarely actually have to go out of our home offices, it works well. 20 resperatore lasts about three months per person. If you need more - you can get 3M N95 from South Korea - about $200 for twenty.
- DominikPeters 6y agoIt’s not just laws, also social norms against “overcharging” and making profits from a crisis.
- xphilter 6y agoAgain, I call bullshit. What social norm says a company can’t put together a business model of making n95 masks and trying to sell those? The only social norm is against re-selling for massive gains during a pandemic. Not manufacturing and making a profit.
- trentnix 6y ago“Massive gains” allow a quicker recoup of the massive investment almost certainly required to procure materials and manufacture masks. Obviously, the current need for masks is artificially high due to the pandemic. And when the pandemic eventually ends, the massive demand for masks will end along with it. Let’s say it takes 5 years to recoup that initial investment to procure materials and manufacture masks at current pricing. Most experts agree the pandemic will have run its course within a year or two. So common sense says getting into the mask business where it will take 5 years to recoup your losses is a bad bet. But if pricing was allowed to follow demand, there is more incentive for aspiring mask manufacturers to take those risks. Maybe the cost to ramp up production can be covered in a couple of years or maybe even a couple of months. That mitigates risk and given opportunity like that, existing mask manufacturers will be better incentivized to scale their production more rapidly. And then more masks get produced quickly, scarcity decreases, and pricing eventually finds equilibrium again. But because we don’t allow “gouging” (whether for legal or social reasons), the mask shortage will continue until existing manufacturers can produce enough to meet demand. And some people that need PPE won’t have it easily available until then, but we will feel awfully good about making sure nobody got gouged. After all, nobody gets gouged if there is nothing to buy.
- MiroF 6y agoWhy not just massive investment in making masks that everyone can afford, given historically low interest rates the government is basically spending with free money
- deelowe 6y agoI'm not aware of these laws being enforced for covid-19. I bought some masks over the summer and they were much more than $10 per. [EDIT] To be more specific here. Price gouging laws apply to retailers, not manufacturers. Price gouging basically covers retailers hording supply to artificially inflate the price during an emergency. That's not what's going on here. Manufacturers don't have capacity to meet demand. They are free to adjust the price in response.
- xphilter 6y agoIf that was actually a reason, don’t you think the article would have mentioned it? Also, if it is a reason, can you please cite to which law? I’m not aware of a law saying a manufacturer can’t set the price of n95 mask. A re-seller, however wouldn’t be able to hoard supply and then do a 10x price increase, which would be price gouging. If there was a competent firm that could offer n95 masks at any price to any of the hundreds of hospitals, I’d wager they could charge whatever price they want at this point.
- nradov 6y agoRemoving price gouging laws wouldn't fix the problem. Setting up new N95 mask production lines takes huge capital investment. Manufacturers won't make that investment unless they have assurance of long term sales beyond the current pandemic. State and federal governments could solve that by issuing long-term purchase contracts to build up stockpiles.
- beervirus 6y agoIt would also discourage hoarding. If masks are artificially cheap, people will buy more than they need.
- Majromax 6y ago> It would also discourage hoarding. That can cut both ways: the possibility of "price gouging" can also encourage speculation, both for those hoping to turn a profit and for those who over-buy compared to expected use to ensure price stability.
- jdm2212 6y agoThe solution to hoarding is quotas, not price ceilings. Limit how many people can buy, but don't try to control the sale price.
- vorpalhex 6y agoQuotas are hard to enforce meaningfully. They work well when people are already disposed to be helpful - but even then they still have issues. Our local grocery chain had a quota on milk (for good reason) and the amount of fights and nearly brawls over it were amazing, despite being a need for some families and not others (it's inconvenient to me to not have cereal, it's a big deal for someone with young kids to not have milk) and generally reasonable limits (up to 2 gallons, more than enough for cereal/coffee/baking). People go to crazy limits to evade the quotas (visiting multiple stores, making multiple purchases in the same trip, etc) and often times they do simply because the quota exists - how many people actually buy more than 2 gallons of milk normally? TLDR, people are dumb fearful animals and that can cause quotas to backfire in a way that price controls don't (but they have other downsides).
- thedz 6y ago> $1 per mask to $10 per mask would still be very much affordable for everyone who really needs a mask teachers and many essential workers who need masks the most are also most vulnerable to unexpected expenses like PPE costs. and the organizations they work for typically have strict budges and can usually only provide limited supplies. that statement feels wildly out of touch.
- flyingfences 6y agoIs it better for them to be able to buy masks at $10 or to not be able to buy masks at all?
- apacheCamel 6y agoWhat about those where $10 a mask means not buying at all either way?
- flyingfences 6y agoSome is still better than none.
- Vivtek 6y agoDepends on how many teachers you still want to have a year from now.
- briffle 6y agoYou mean the teachers at my school district that regularly spend $3m/year on diesel fuel for busing students (and the drivers wages, half the drivers are 'temps') that are sitting unused?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Loughla 6y agoAre you saying you school isn't transporting students? Also, are you saying the teachers have anything to do with that cost? My district had to double its busing budget this year due to restrictions on the number of students that could be on each bus. This led to even further cuts into the classroom budgets. So, I guess your experience may be different.
- BolexNOLA 6y agoThis honestly reads like an undergraduate understanding of “the invisible hand” and “market forces” to me.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> Without those laws, the price going from $1 per mask to $10 per mask would still be very much affordable for everyone who really needs a mask, and factories who can successfully get decent production underway will earn lots Friend owns a textile factory in India. They immediately began production of masks, which they sold at something like a 10,000% premium. (Re-tooling is expensive, so their profits weren’t exorbitant. Though they were larger than normal, which incentivises the work.) Once the premium diminished, they went back to making clothes. India has anti-gouging laws. But they are loosely enforced to the point of non-existence. In America, we not only have such laws, we also have a media circus and cancel subculture that strongly discourages such responses.
- blisterpeanuts 6y agoN95 masks? or conventional cloth masks? A real N95 requires an expensive high tech layer called meltblown textile that a textile factory can't just start making overnight.
- jk700 6y agoMeltblown isn't that limited in supply and from all the masks it is wasted mostly on surgical masks, not N95, since surgical masks use the same sickness meltblown layer, but are produced in much higher quantities.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sudosysgen 6y agoAt 10$ per mask the cost would be too high for many usages, so there would be an effective outage still.
- woeirua 6y agoThat's not accurate at all. Allowing the price to float freely would help with short term supply and demand issues, but it would not fundamentally solve the long term uncertainty for suppliers about whether or not a large quantity of masks are still going to be needed next year given that supposedly multiple vaccines will be coming onto the market at the same time. Case in point: there was a great piece a while back about a domestic mask manufacturer who ramped up production for the H1N1 outbreak only to see demand collapse when the pandemic turned out to be far less severe than expected [1]. They almost went out of business because there was no where to sell their masks at a profit and had to unwind most of their operations. The solution here is for the federal government to backstop the orders. If no buyer can be found at price $x / mask, then the government will buy them and put them into the national stockpiles for the future. [1] https://www.wired.com/story/surreal-frenzy-inside-us-biggest-mask-maker/ https://www.wired.com/story/surreal-frenzy-inside-us-biggest...
- ardy42 6y ago> Because 'anti price gouging' laws prevent the price going high enough to make it worth someone going to extreme efforts to upscale production. While theoretically price gauging is an incentive to increase production, if that's all you're thinking about, you're dealing with a toy model that has little connection to the real world. Toy models can be super compelling and elegant, but that doesn't make them reality. You have to deal with other factors, like * The influence of parasitic middlemen only looking to flip goods and drive up the price for quick personal profit. In most of these cases, the period of increased demand is so short this is the only effect you'll see, since there's no time to bring new capacity online, but you have all the downsides of increased prices. * Does price gouging actually direct the scarce resource to where it's needed? Markets often are very irrational, so this can't reasonably be assumed (e.g. during a famine, the market would direct food to the rich and well-fed even if they just were going to waste it on opulent banquets, because they have the money to pay the price). * People are actually motivated by things other than greed, even though models of behavior are simplified by assuming greed is their only (or main) motivation. * New production will come online to meet demand, even without price gouging. How much more production would price gouging motivate? Is that production worth the social cost? * You can't build a sustainable greed-motivated business on building factories to price-gouge. A brand new market entrant is likely to have a pretty poor product compared to established players, and will likely go bankrupt once demand returns to normal. They might not even get their product out the door in time to take advantage of the high prices. It could be a predictable case of "buy high, sell low." * New techniques will be developed to more efficiently use current production, which may pull the rug out from under anyone who made a heavy capital investment based on the surge demand. * Etc. > Without those laws, the price going from $1 per mask to $10 per mask would still be very much affordable for everyone who really needs a mask, and factories who can successfully get decent production underway will earn lots, making it worthwhile to take on the risk of chasing a (possibly short lived) demand. IIRC, the price gougers drive up the price even higher than $10.
- CraigJPerry 6y agoIn some ways i agree but i can't help wonder, is this one of those cases where something doesn't work very well (in this case capitalism) but the suggested answer is MORE capitalism. What i've just said obviously over-simplifies and in some large respects does a dis-service to capitalism BUT i still can't help but feel we need an improvement. It's not good enough yet.
- jerry1979 6y agoI think that anti-price gouging laws allow the government to easily protect people who would otherwise have to pay very high prices for goods they need right now. On top of that, anti-price gouging laws coupled with Defense Production Act measures and purchase limits within stores should prove effective at alleviating shortages. Despite a lack of DPA measures and the existence of anti-price gouging laws, masks remain readily available. For example, asimpleshop.com (made by a fellow HN user) has masks ready for a reasonable price. The fact that everyone does not have access to good KN95 masks comes from a national lack of will, not a lack of national resources.
- downrightmike 6y agoBack in March when this all started, the machines and fabric are all available, but without a contract that companies can guarantee a market on, the companies won't do it. Price may help with the Extreme part of your argument, but plenty of businesses did their due diligence and are not jumping in because they need to sell a lot of these at scale for a while to start making a profit. Ideally, once we found the ones in the national stock pile were being hoarded by Jared, and that they were falling a part due to age, it should have been a priority to offer businesses contracts to get the masks produced.