4 ms·
> The question that the parent comment tries to answer is "what do we do so the backup driver does not watch his phone?". We should do the same thing we do to
by robertlagrant 6y ago
> The question that the parent comment tries to answer is "what do we do so the backup driver does not watch his phone?".
We should do the same thing we do to stop regular drivers watching their phones.
- tsimionescu 6y agoNormal drivers have to drive, so they can't watch their phone. Requiring a human to do nothing while being attentive is simply not realistic.
- toyg 6y agoPeople used to be employed as lookouts on ships for days on end. Patrols have been a thing for as long as humanity had to deal with dangerous wild animals. The fact that we cannot countenance something like this in the current world is testament to the power our devices have on us.
- derangedHorse 6y agoI doubt any lookouts were good enough to spot a potential threat the second it came into one’s range of vision (which is what something like this requires)
- nradov 6y agoLookouts on ships typically don't stand watch for more than 4 hours at a time. Often they're rotated more frequently.
- toyg 6y agoThe point is that it can be done (on and off) for extended periods, unlike what the parent comment stated.
- tsimionescu 6y agoLookouts aren't expected to react in milliseconds. They also likely communicated pretty often with the rest of the crew. Patrols... patrol. Also, all of these jobs would be done in relatively short shifts. Note that I'm not saying that the scape gal wasn't grossly negligent in watching a video on her phone. I'm saying that Uber was also negligent in making their safety system just be 1 person sitting there, expected to react in milliseconds.
- tobyhinloopen 6y agoYou’re not supposed to do nothing. You’re supposed to watch the road and ensure the safety of yourself, the car and the other road users. I’m not saying it is realistic to expect the driver to be attentive the whole trip, but watching a video on a phone is just gross negligence. Watching something while doing nothing is a job that has been around for a long time. If you’re employed to do that job, you cannot watch a video on your phone, especially when a failure kills someone. The whole reason you’re hired to watch a thing is to prevent that from happening. Comparing it to the lifeguards discussions above: you wouldn’t allow phone usages as a lifeguard either.
- tsimionescu 6y agoAgreed - watching a video on your phone is gross negligence. But so is employing one person alone in the car to react in milliseconds to possible dangers. And note that watching and ensuring are not doing something, they are precisely doing nothing. Most, if not all, human beings are not very good at paying attention while doing nothing which is what Uber is requiring of their test 'drivers'.
- randycupertino 6y ago> Requiring a human to do nothing while being attentive is simply not realistic. Isn't this basic security guard job description? Fire lookout spotters, etc? It's totally realistic. Sit there, pay attention, and be ready to take action if needed.
- onetimemanytime 6y agoSecurity guards have more a split second leeway to react.
- Volundr 6y agoAs someone who spent years working as a security guard... No. At least not in the way your thinking sitting at a desk eyes constantly on the cameras. Depending on the site we are expected to check and log them on a given interval and generally keep them in our field of view, but no one is under the illusion that there's perfect attention there. For higher security sites this is solved by having several rovers in constant communication and coordinatation with the (often multiple) people sitting by the cameras. So both the rovers and the desk are constantly doing not just sitting. Fire watch is the same thing. Your not just up in your tower eyes constantly peeled on the forrest, ready to react in milliseconds.
- u801e 6y agoThis is the reason that self-diving cars that require human intervention is a flawed concept. We should be designing vehicles that we manually control, but have a computer take over when needed.
- andyjohnson0 6y ago> This is the reason that self-diving cars that require human intervention is a flawed concept. We should be designing vehicles that we manually control, but have a computer take over when needed. This makes sense if the objective is to reduce fatalities. Unfortunately it makes no sense if the objective is to merely reduce the cost of operating commercial vehicles by eliminating the need to employ a driver - which is where the money is.
- emiliobumachar 6y ago> Normal drivers have to drive, so they can't watch their phone. Despite being a huge legal and moral issue, a large minority of normal drivers can and do watch their phone while driving.
- gpm 6y agoThe crime here isn't failing to be attentive enough, it is actively choosing to direct your attention elsewhere. You don't accidentally start watching a video on your phone.