15 ms·
We View Nikola’s Response as a Tacit Admission of Securities Fraud
- samizdis 6y agoThat is a patient, clinical, point-by-point dismemberment of Nikola's supposed rebuttal of Hindenburg's original document. Superbly done, and surely devastating. This story just keeps on giving.
- dylan604 6y agoIn today's post fact world, is anything truly "devastating"?
- agency 6y agoAsk WireCard
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoThe fact that NKLA remains as high as it does really is proof of a "post-fact" world, as a sibling commenter put it. Take a look at Twitter, and it's pretty sad IMO to see some of the "I still believe in you Trevor!!" type responses, completely devoid of any logic looking at the actual facts. It's like these kind of cults are everywhere now. And my take on the stock price remaining as high as it is is that there are a relatively small number of cultish-believers (maybe 5-20%, I really don't know beyond that it's a small minority), and then everyone else pretty much knows this stock is a fraud and is eventually going to 0, but is just trying to time it so that someone else is holding the bag. Very similar to how Hertz spiked after they filed for bankruptcy: pretty much everyone knew they were going to 0, it was just a bet on who could time it best.
- DobryMorozov 6y agoTrevor Milton bought $1.3 million dollars of shares yesterday. He's trying to keep the share price up to support the narrative that nothing is wrong
- TheArcane 6y agoAfter Theranos and Wirecard, I'm surprised how much benefit of the doubt Nikola is being given
- ksdale 6y agoAt this point it seems like Nikola is not at all what it seems, but I've actually been surprised in the opposite direction. For a couple days, news of Nikola being fraudulent were all over everywhere, and when I finally clicked on the link, it's from... someone who is obviously shorting the stock. Every short seller ever tries to convince everyone that the companies they're shorting are doing all sorts of shady stuff. In this case, everything in the report looks legit, but the number of people credulously citing this report without anyone mentioning that Hindenburg has a massive financial incentive to have Nikola implode has been surprising.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zwily 6y agoNobody has mentioned they are a short seller? Every article I’ve seen about it mentions it, and Hindenburg themselves are clear about it. You should certainly take that into account when analyzing their report, but it does not mean they should be disregarded.
- tsycho 6y agoBut that's standard, no? The only organizations that publish equity research are investment banks (which rarely publish negative articles since they want to be part of potential future M&A activity), and hedge funds. This type of research takes significant time and effort, and almost no one else does this except short selling hedge funds.
- bhupy 6y agoHindenburg has been pretty upfront about their short position, as has most reporting. OTOH, short sellers actually have skin in the game, they're putting their money where their mouths are. It's an important mechanism in the public market, which counteracts the existing bias in favor of stock value appreciation on account of shareholders endlessly shilling the stock.
- new_realist 6y agoNikola is following the classic Tesla playbook (remember the Cybertruck’s shattered windows, the infamous FSD video, or Elon’s settlement with the SEC?) but doesn’t have enough True Believers infesting the Internet. http://ElonMusk.today http://ElonMusk.today
- carlosdp 6y agoI don't think that's quite the same thing. The shattered window was obviously a genuine mistake, otherwise why volunteer to throw a brick at it live on-stage?
- raverbashing 6y agoSpaceX and Tesla have working products on the market Nikola has a truck that goes downhill
- pvaldes 6y agoAnd should be pronounced as Ni-kool-aid, it seems...
- klmadfejno 6y agoA fairly substantial portion of your comment history, and 2/3 submissions appear to be finding some way to shit on Tesla, SpaceX, or Musk. You also stated at one point, "This is based on my own data, owning multiple Teslas over four years." So... why? Why do you do this?
- revscat 6y agoI wonder the same thing. I first noticed this back when the iPhone came out. At the time, there were frequent posts from guys like this one complaining about Apple/Jobs fanboys, and the language they used was very similar to what you see here. "It's all fraud, Jobs is a fraud, fanboys are zealots," etc., etc. I don't get these people. I'm not sure if they are paid shills, or true believers. I suspect there's a bit of both to be found. But I will say this: in my estimation the haters outnumber the fanboys by at least a factor of 100.
- new_realist 6y agoIt’s amazing how many people believe Tesla and Nikola are different beasts, when they execute in an almost identical manner, and have the same set of short sellers.
- InTheArena 6y agoExcept, you know, building and selling the car that brought the EV market back from the dead, building a high end brand with the Model S, then building the most popular EV in the world, which is more then holding it's own against the rest of the established automotive world.
- new_realist 6y agoTesla is 17 years old, Nikola is much younger.
- mthoms 6y agoSo... they are different beasts? Which is it?
- InTheArena 6y agoOr, even if you want to accept that time frame, Tesla built their own cars. This is the detail of the contract Nikola signed with GM. It's pretty obvious that there isn't anything here at this point.
- carlosdp 6y agoTesla actually has working products in production with waitlists to buy them, I'd say they are very different...
- lacker 6y agoThe main difference is that I can drive around in a Tesla and it seems like a pretty nice car. I don’t own one but it can’t really be a hoax at this point.
- switch11 6y agoyeah, Nikola pretty much admitted they lied It's interesting that everything they have done is not PROVABLY fraud, and yet is on the very line between slightly unethical and actually illegal pretty crazy
- dahart 6y agoThe article here seems to make a decent case that the fraud is provable, no?
- csours 6y agoWhen something is in a gray area, perception of facts depends on your point of view. As someone not personally involved, I find things like this and Theranos fascinating. I'd love it if Theranos was real; Holmes obviously played on that very well. Green tech is also prone to this effect. Add to that the "fake it till you make it", and "only cheerleaders allowed" attitudes at startups; the "reality disruption zone" of founders, etc, etc. Are you stopping another Theranos, or are you killing another Tucker? Disclaimer: I work for GM, but not on anything related to Nikola. I have no personal knowledge about Nikola from work. Personal Opinion: Nikola is in the darker side of the gray area; I think there could still be good outcomes, but it looks pretty marginal.
- altdatathrow 6y ago> "The entire infotainment system is a HTML 5 super computer," Milton said. "That's the standard language for computer programmers around the world, so using it let's us build our own chips. And HTML 5 is very secure. Every component is linked on the data network, all speaking the same language. It's not a bunch of separate systems that somehow still manage to communicate." [1] https://www.truckinginfo.com/330475/whats-behind-the-grille-of-the-new-nikola-hydrogen-electric-truck https://www.truckinginfo.com/330475/whats-behind-the-grille-...
- rayuela 6y agoOk is this actually real? Is truckinginfo.com a reputable site? That quote sounds so outlandishly crazy I'm hesitant to believe someone actually said that.
- cultus 6y agoI've seen it a few times elsewhere. I should really just quit my job and become rich by bullshitting investors with technobabble.
- gruez 6y ago>I've seen it a few times elsewhere A cursory search on google shows that all the references link back to truckinginfo.com, so I wouldn't put too much weight on that.
- gwd 6y agoIs that an exact quote or a summary? Having talked to reporters before, there is a possibility that something more reasonable was said but then got garbled. Like, if during the interview someone said the UI is using HTML5, which is standard everywhere, so it will be easy for people to extend / we have lots of options; and also we're using ARM so we can build our own chips; ARM is in everything from smartphones to supercomputers. I can totally see a non-tech reporter getting confused and morphing that into the sentence above. Obviously the other outlandish / false claims make it more likely that this is an example of BS as well.
- InTheArena 6y agoThe following two things can both be true: 1) The short sellers exist to build bad press to drive down valuations so they profit by short-selling and engage is very shady practices to do so. 2) Fraud has occurred at Nikola. Unlike Tesla and the never-ending $TSLAQ "Tesla is nothing but fraud", it appears that they really have something here with Nikola, even though my knee-jerk reaction to the short-sellers is one of mostly disgust.
- ForHackernews 6y agoWhy do you dislike short-sellers? I think it's wonderful when they're pointing out the emperor has no clothes! In order to have a functioning market, we need to base valuations on more than just "stonks go up".
- skrtskrt 6y agoSeriously Wirecard was sniffed out by so many short sellers, and eventually shorting it was banned... look at it now.
- rootsudo 6y agoSame rhetoric, companies, securities, politics. Everyone with the right ideas, the right motions, is always attempted to be silenced. Life really is a circle.
- charwalker 6y agoThe regulatory process failed but was revealed. Hopefully Germany will do better. But the US has more companies and activities going on and likely more fraud just by volume if not the regulatory capture and other issues from the current administration like secretaries who want to dismantle their departments. The administration itself is fraudulent, laundering campaign money to private property or court/lawyer costs, or simply rewarding friends like the current USPS head donating a bunch of money to the GOP then getting their position while holding millions in stock of USPS competitors. It's just so blatant and corrupt but nothing happens.
- 6y ago
- textech 6y agoLooks like next Theranos to me. You have to give credit to the guy though since he is showing how easy it is to fool the so-called "smart money".
- mercer 6y agoAfter reading his wikipedia page it's mind-boggling to me that this guy was trusted at all. He's literally a (failed) car salesman!
- jiveturkey 6y ago> Nikola’s Response Had Holes Big Enough to Roll a Truck Through. Love it.
- tibbydudeza 6y agoWell the truck works if you roll it down a hill , who needs hydrogen or electricity when you can just use good old free gravity. Next up ... perpetual motion.