45 ms·
Feds seize ‘counterfeit Apple AirPods’ that are actually OnePlus Buds
- romwell 6y agoWhat's next, seizing Surfaces as "counterfeit iPads"? What a sad state of things.
- smnrchrds 6y agohttps://bonkersworld.net/obvious-similarities https://bonkersworld.net/obvious-similarities
- duxup 6y agoHard to be counterfeit if you don't claim to be the thing....
- JCharante 6y agoThey look so similar to the Huawei Freebuds 3 sitting in my desk, except that the top cap is also round. Edit: it appears that the OnePlus buds are also fully round
- wyldfire 6y agoWhat if they're counterfeit OnePlus products and somehow the message to be released to the public was lost in a 'telephone' game? Brand name dilution can cause some less tech-astute folks to refer to earbuds by the popular AirPods brand name. And given the visual similarity it's easy to see how this kinda thing could cascade from a miscommunication like that. That said it's also pretty believable that CBP thought they were intercepting clearly marked OnePlus goods as infringing on Apple's trademarks....somehow...
- dylan604 6y agoIf you're the organization in charge of protecting against counterfeit claims, you better be able to tell the good, the bad, the fake apart. I don't think I'm setting too high of a standard. Also, when making a press release about your "success", it would be a good idea to take a breath and actually look into the seized goods. In this type of situation, waiting 1, 3, 5 or even 7 days until everything was clear would have zero negative effect.
- monocasa 6y agoThe CBP tweet says they're seizing them for not being Apple.
- andrewflnr 6y agoThey used an actual fscking apple emoji in the tweet, which I hate almost as much as the kafkaesque injustice.
- projektfu 6y agoIf they have an identical shape to AirPods, they could run afoul of a design patent. But they look different to me. That’s still not “counterfeiting”. The difference between counterfeits and knock-offs (KERFs) is consumers will help you fight counterfeiting and will go out of their way to buy knock-offs.
- MrStonedOne 6y agoThe legal definition of counterfeit product (as realized by CBP's jurisdiction) boils down to: Bares a Registered Trademark and does not have a signed letter of authenticity by the trademark holder authorizing its import. That is super broad and covers a lot of things most people would think to be false positives like legit items sold second hand. But even that doesn't cover thinking OnePlus Buds are AirPods.
- microcolonel 6y agoIsn't the fact that nobody involved in this seizure could tell that they weren't AirPods counterfeits a form of evidence that OnePlus Buds may in some circumstance be AirPods counterfeits?
- eganist 6y agoNot if oneplus has any protections for their design. But ianal
- lmm 6y agoMaybe it's evidence that AirPods are counterfeit OnePlus Buds. If you want your customers to be assured of getting the genuine article you should put an actual trademark on your product. Apple shouldn't get to claim that anything with a minimalist design is a counterfeit Apple product.
- p49k 6y agoThey look exactly like AirPods, though, which is a design Apple created, as an evolution of EarPods. When EarPods were released, they looked unlike any earbuds ever released, despite the fact that ear buds as a product have existed for 30 years or more. If it were as simple as “minimalist design” any of the 100+ ear bud manufacturers of the past 30 years could have designed something similar. Apple never gets enough credit for their design work in the general tech community. Lots of design work can look “obvious” or minimalist in hindsight.
- Nasrudith 6y ago
- IdoRA 6y agoThis is probably a combination of a Section 337 investigation by the USITC that includes OnePlus in its scope and directs CBP to seize certain OnePlus goods, a bombastic press release from CBP, and The Verge reporter not being insightful and generating clickbait. https://www.usitc.gov/press_room/news_release/2019/er0926ll1167.htm https://www.usitc.gov/press_room/news_release/2019/er0926ll1...
- xvector 6y agoThe Verge’s quality has tanked so hard over the last few years. What happened?
- Causality1 6y agoI'd be interested in a writeup of that as well. The cavalcade of stupidity and maliciousness that was the Verge PC Build debacle leads me to think some quite bad stuff has been going on behind the scenes.
- HeWhoLurksLate 6y agoI think that was more a case of "we need a PC build video, they're trending right now... ...hey Josh, you know about computers, right?" IMO, they should've done more due diligence first to avoid teeing off the super-elitist subset of enthusiast people
- Causality1 6y agoYou need to be an elitist to object to someone building a PC in a way that doesn't work and voids warranties and then fixing it during jump-cuts without telling the viewer? You need to be an elitist to take issue with the Verge using takedown notices to attack everyone who pointed out their failures?
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI was not aware of the takedown notices but I watched a couple of the “response” videos and they came across as extremely malicious/toxic. I can see why The Verge would want to do everything in their power to counter that. There are better ways to criticize something.
- bdowling 6y agoThe products here may be considered legally counterfeit for one or more reasons other than simply using the word mark APPLE. For example: (1) trademark or trade dress infringement if the product's decorative features (color, etc.) or packaging copies a registered trademark of Apple, (2) copyright infringement if the product contains copied Apple code without a license,(3) patent infringement if the product implements some patented Apple technology without a license, (4) design patent infringement if the product is a copy of an Apple-patented ornamental design, or (5) some other copied intellectual property.
- bjt 6y agoI'm scratching my head trying to figure out why you're being downvoted while the least well-informed comments along the lines of "Customs officials are dumb!" are at the top. This is very likely a design patent case, not just trademark. In which case, they could be infringing regardless of the logo on the box. Then again, the article isn't helping, as it also seems oblivious to the design patent possibility.
- fphhotchips 6y agoI think pinning this to the article is a bit rough, as the press release indicates they think the item is counterfeit, which implies that they're attempting to fraudulently pass themselves off as AirPods. To me, the use of the word "counterfeit" implies a trademark violation. That's clearly not happening, as the box indicates. If the press release indicated - anywhere - even a whiff of there being a design patent issue (which is subtler and more nuanced than the word "counterfeit" allows for), I'd say it was fair to criticise the article. That's not the case though, and reading the press release, I don't think CBP thought there was a design patent issue either.
- natch 6y agoShipping counterfeit products through customs with a misleading box that is then removed prior to sale is a common ploy. And one that CBP is aware of. The box means absolutely nothing here.
- pacamara619 6y ago> It can be hard to tell a difference between AirPods and some earbuds that resemble them, but checking the box is always a good start. Seems to me this is very related to a classic RTFM.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xwdv 6y agoMaybe not counterfeit, but you still can’t argue this design is stolen pretty much straight from Apple.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoRight, just like how the iPhone design is stolen straight from the pocket PC. /s Apple doesn't own a product type just by using it.
- watt 6y agoYou think it's funny (the sarcasm), but Apple does go to court arging "look and feel" is copyrightable. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Look_and_feel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Look_and_feel
- nicexe 6y agoApple had the Newton. I would say they have been in the PDA game from the early days.
- Yetanfou 6y agohttps://sites.google.com/site/theworldaccordingtoapple/ https://sites.google.com/site/theworldaccordingtoapple/ 2011 but still valid it seems...
- 082349872349872 6y agoI wonder which lawyer will seize on this announcement as evidence of genericisation?
- anigbrowl 6y agohttps://twitter.com/OnePlus_USA/status/1305366058501509121 https://twitter.com/OnePlus_USA/status/1305366058501509121
- Semaphor 6y agoSidebar: Why has the AirPod design become so ubiquitous? I always thought they were the ugliest earbuds since earbuds became small. Is there some technical reason they have this design? Or do people actually like it? Or is it simply the Apple effect?
- skummetmaelk 6y agoApple is a design authority. If Apple says it looks good, then people believe it looks good.
- mr_toad 6y agoPeople believe it looks expensive.
- irjustin 6y agoThey are expensive - for a pair of wireless ear buds. Putting aside all subjective qualities. People know they are expensive and regardless of whether you agree w/ the decision, you know they cost $195, $249 or whatever. That's a signal of wealth like certain clothing, a super car, or a bloomberg terminal.
- colejohnson66 6y agoIt may be confirmation bias, but it seems people care more about someone else’s phone choice (Android and iOS fanboys) than some more wealthy person wearing a $50,000 watch. For example, Lifehacker posts some articles about how to do something on iOS every so often, and the comments always have those people saying, “iPhones suck; just throw it away and get an Android” with no mention of why.
- uranusjr 6y agoI thought they look funny (although not ugly) when they first came out. But other designs (e.g. round blob sticking out of earholes) are even worse, and convinience outweighs visibility.
- illustriousbear 6y agoPerhaps this is linked to the China and US trade war? Maybe US customs have been instructed to be harsher on Chinese company imports? Not saying it is necessarily unethical considering that China is no doubt doing similar.
- altacc 6y agoI'd be more tempted to apply Hanlon's razor: Don't attribute to malice that which can be explained by stupidity.
- illustriousbear 6y agoThats fair, it just crossed my mind as a possibility given the current climate.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoHow is it malice for CBP to attempt to do the exact job it was created to do? It's job is to block counterfeit imports, and China is a huge state-approved growing source.
- sneak 6y agoThey also claimed that the lightning cables were fake, when they looked quite real: https://twitter.com/sneakdotberlin/status/1304911952464867328 https://twitter.com/sneakdotberlin/status/130491195246486732... This is the same portion of the US government that runs the concentration camps in Texas (and has endlessly harassed me personally for exercising basic human rights), so I’m not that surprised that they remain dumb as rocks. They also recently expelled 8800 unaccompanied children(!): https://www.wpri.com/news/us-and-world/about-8800-unaccompanied-children-are-expelled-at-us-border/ https://www.wpri.com/news/us-and-world/about-8800-unaccompan...
- mikl 6y agoTo be fair, OnePlus Buds appear to be counterfeit AirPods in everything but the name. Same shape, same white plastic, same metal endcaps, same black dots, even the same case design. In other words, a straight-up rip-off of Apple’s design with a few minor changes.
- calciphus 6y agoAlso it is far easier to produce counterfeit packaging than electronics in the US. If I was going to smuggle something in, I'd put it in other packages and then repack it here. The best way to hide something is to mislabel it.
- mcphage 6y agoI don't think that's what happened, though—the OnePlus charging cases have a much more rounded one than Apple's.
- celticninja 6y agoIf you are doing that just send them over in the plastic case, no need for all the cardboard packaging which adds to shipping weight and volume.
- natch 6y agoBut if the naive Verge reporter had been working at CBP then the boxes would have worked to do their job of getting the copycat items past customs.
- smichel17 6y agoIt is, however, odd that they didn't say something like "Counterfeit Airpods disguised in OnePlus Buds packaging" or similar. It's a bit too early to tell which is right, I think. Photos of OnePlus Buds from TFA show that they are a different shape on the back, distinguishable from Airpods. The CBP photos don't show this part so it's hard to tell whether they are counterfeits or just a different product.
- cheph 6y agoNot sure I understand how this is newsworthy exactly, people make mistakes (even those on HN) and there is due process and recourse for whoever was impacted by this mistake. If the implication is that if law enforcement make mistakes they cannot be legitimate then I think we should just give up on the idea, but I guess this is more or less what is being advocated for, so maybe it can be stated more directly.
- orf 6y agoI guess it’s the fact that they proudly declared the seizure which was obviously a complete fail at even the briefest glance at the pictures they provided. It’s funny and newsworthy.
- xigency 6y ago> there is due process and recourse for whoever was impacted by this mistake. I wouldn't be so sure. When you're going up against the US government and the largest US corporation it's going to be an uphill battle.
- valtism 6y agoI just noticed a lot of suspiciously cheap AirPods show up on the Facebook marketplace here in Sydney. I think that the shipments here didn't get seized.
- rob74 6y agoInteresting... apparently it qualifies as a counterfeit even though it doesn't say Apple anywhere on the box? Or is the image caption wrong - maybe they're counteirfeit OnePlus earbuds? Oh BTW, it's "seize", not "sieze" :)
- whoknew2020 6y agohttps://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/i-before-e-except-after-c https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/i-before-e-exc...
- veonik 6y agoSeize is listed in the top blue call out as an exception to this rule
- justinclift 6y agohttps://www.dictionary.com/browse/seize https://www.dictionary.com/browse/seize
- trboyden 6y agoSo what exactly is the difference between those and the ones Amazon https://www.amazon.com/OnePlus-Buds-Wireless-Earbuds-Charging/dp/B08CVMXPGY https://www.amazon.com/OnePlus-Buds-Wireless-Earbuds-Chargin... says I can get tomorrow for $79?
- jsjohnst 6y agoI’m fairly certain they are the exact same ones confiscated. It’s a near blatant knockoff of Apple’s patented designs. Now should Apple be able to get said all encompassing design patents? That’s a different debate.
- elmo2you 6y agoLooks like rather generic design to me, especially since a substantial parts of are basically dictated by the human anatomy. So regardless the questionable nature of design patents in the first place, this design certainly does not warrant such patents. But in any case, that's for a court to decide. Does the USA actively seize other products that violate patents without a court case? How would they even determine infringement? I don't remember Apple winning any court case against OnePlus, so that can't be the reason for this seizure. If these buds were seized as counterfeits, then there had to be an express intent to sell these as imitation Apple products, which I find rather hard to believe (for starters because the packaging isn't the same). Also, when producers remove any brand markings, like logos and other distinctive material unique to that company, knock-off/imitation cases are always weak. For good reasons too, just as with trademarking generic names. You don't want a single company to dictate the use of generic things. Maybe most import is that this seizure will unlikely have happened on a whim. Almost certainly, somebody has requested for this to happen. That itself should give rise to some serious questions. Because it would likely make this a rather blatant (and probably unlawful) case of economical warfare. To use the extraordinary powers of border guards for that purpose, without any court case, is downright corrupt. Like mafia style corruption. I wonder which highest ranking official signed off on this. That person has some explaining to do, for he/she just made the USA look like a tinpot dictatorship. Ignorant too, to boast about it on their web site. Unless that's done intentional, as propaganda to convince the locals this was legal or good "to protect America". People abroad will likely have a very different view on that. What the American government often forgets, in its self-centred and mostly domestic focus, is that the rest of the world is observing things like these. Behaviour like this always has consequences, even if it can take a while.
- nightcracker 6y agoSo this is just theft by the government in open daylight, right?
- unixhero 6y agoI for one, cannot get over this: https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_nkw=tsa+lot+of&_trksid=p2332490.m4084.l1313 https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_nkw=tsa+lot+of&_trksid=p233... Pretty much theft and resale.
- caleblloyd 6y agoJust a guess, but the TSA probably pays a contacting company to take all of the confiscated items away. Then the contacting company disposes of can't be sold and sells the rest.
- admax88q 6y agoIn other words, using a fence to offload stolen goods.
- steerablesafe 6y agoWhat is the TSA supposed to do with these other than auctioning them off?
- jstanley 6y agoIf they consider them to be safe enough that it is not unethical to sell them in job lots to members of the general public, maybe they shouldn't be seizing them in the first place?
- michaelt 6y agoI don't think it's TSA policy that water bottles are too dangerous for anyone to posses - they're merely not allowed through TSA checkpoints.
- villgax 6y agoWow, & what exactly is the objective of boasting such dumb claims on social media for a govt body?
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI imagine some employee needed to show they were doing something so they got the idea of making a twitter account for their department. Or it benefits them if they can add a bullet point on their resume such as “managed social media acccount”. Even better if they can increase their budget and headcount and hire someone to post things. But then they need work to do, so you tell the person to make posts bragging about busts a government agency is making.
- navbaker 6y agoPositive media exposure can be used as evidence of effectiveness in annual budget request battles, as it is a pseudo-metric that government leaders find impressive.
- topkai22 6y agoUS Government bodies do a lot of public outreach, many have twitter/social media accounts as part of that effort. There are many reasons for this- the aforementioned help at budget time, Government officials geniunely want to be seen and celebrated as doing a good job, and a surprising amount of belief that the American people should see what "their" government is doing. The interplay with that last point (belief in transparency) interacts with institutional secrecy in weird and hillarious ways. I remember one project I worked on was shrouded in secracy to the individual teams working on it until a news program showed up and talked to the public affairs office and senior leadership. After watching the broadcast, we all of sudden understood what the heck it was we were working on!
- fullstop 6y agoWell this is just dumb, but it might be cheaper than any advertisement OnePlus could have done to increase their brand recognition. I have had a OnePlus3 and a OnePlus 7T, both of which were, and are still, fantastic phones.
- JshWright 6y agoMy 7 Pro is a fantastic phone. My next phone will likely be OnePlus as well.
- tyingq 6y agoThe CBP is very hard to deal with. I once bought about 100 electronic items that come with AC adapters to power them. Unknown to me, the AC adapters had fake UL marks on them. So, the CBP seized the shipment. I asked if they could just seize the adapters, and explained that I hadn't even asked for UL listed adapters. No dice. The adapters represented less than 10% of the value of the shipment. Argh. And, of course, the Chinese supplier wasn't willing to reimburse me. Now I have the adapters go in a separate shipment in case something unexpected is shipped.
- MichaelZuo 6y agoDid you try sourcing adaptors without fake markings?
- tyingq 6y agoI thought it was pretty clear that the fake markings surprised me and that the adapters were not the main item sourced.
- arghwhat 6y agoIt was, but the follow-up action designed to minimize risk of loss when caught by customs rather than avoiding import of fraudulent goods blurred image of your intentions. If you can get the shipments split, I'm sure you could also get them to not send the power adapters at all. If, however, you needed power adapters, you need to import proper ones - not just for legal reasons, but for the safety of the end-users.
- tyingq 6y agoAs a smaller player, it is very difficult to get the Chinese suppliers to guarantee they won't ship the wrong thing. Separating the shipment is a relatively low cost way to protect the main item. Edit: Another example that happened to a friend. He ordered some single board computers that came with some software on a CD...he wasn't even aware of the CD. The CD had a fake "Compact Disc" marking, which is a trademark. Whole shipment seized.
- whoknew1122 6y agoIt's patently ridiculous that CBP seized competing products as "counterfeit AirPods", but at least no children were hurt and/or caged in this operation. I'm ready to give this win to CBP. Keep stifling the free market rather than caging children.
- retox 6y agoWhat a bizarre non-sequitur.
- whoknew1122 6y agoIs it a non-sequitur? The same agency here seen seizing competing products for not being Apple products is the same agency responsible for caging and mistreating children unto death. I'd prefer them stifle competition rather than kill children.
- pja 6y ago2 days before, the CBD confiscated a pile of real "fake airpods": https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/local-media-release/cbp-seizes-over-650k-fake-apple-wireless-earphones-charging-cables-lalb https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/local-media-release/cbp-seizes-... so this is clearly a thing. Unfortunately OnePlus have got caught in the crossfire.
- hatsunearu 6y agoHeck, there are fake AirPods in every store ever, go to Walmart (tall order with the pandemic) and you can see fake AirPods in the checkout shelf... lol
- mattacular 6y agoAren't those just knockoffs rather than fakes being passed off as brand name Apple AirPods?
- hatsunearu 6y agoThey are, but I'm assuming customs seize shit that "looks like" brand name goods while claiming they are totally not pretending to be. If that's the case, I'll take a hundred Totally-Not-Yeezys please
- np- 6y agoI am no CBP fan either, but has anyone considered the case that these are counterfeit AirPods in counterfeit OnePlus earbud boxes? If you look at the opened box picture in the CBP memo, you will notice the earbuds do NOT match the picture on the OnePlus box and look much much more similar to actual AirPods.
- commoner 6y agoNope, these are definitely OnePlus Buds. CBP image: https://www.cbp.gov/sites/default/files/u50683/Ear%20Buds%20001.jpg https://www.cbp.gov/sites/default/files/u50683/Ear%20Buds%20... AirPods: https://www.apple.com/v/airpods/k/images/overview/airpods__dh7xkbort402_large_2x.jpg https://www.apple.com/v/airpods/k/images/overview/airpods__d... OnePlus Buds: https://image01.oneplus.net/ebp/202006/30/1-m00-15-97-rb8bwl77rhwatgyiaab-p75syzg370.png https://image01.oneplus.net/ebp/202006/30/1-m00-15-97-rb8bwl... OnePlus Buds are shaped like rods attached to muffins, while AirPods are shaped like quarter notes (on a musical staff).
- scott_s 6y agoI did a double-take based on your comment, but after looking closely at the CBP pictures, and the pictures in this review [1], I think they are likely to be OnePlus pods. The thing that caught me (and maybe you) is that the OnePlus pods have a flat part, and the CBP pictures have no flat part. But looking at the pictures from the review, the flat part is the end of the stem, and then the bulbous round part that goes in the ear is attached to the stem, with the flat part on the other side. The CBP pictures may have the flat part facing away from the camera. I had to look at several of the pictures in the review which showed two pods next to each other to build a mental model of their shape. [1] https://www.theverge.com/21331910/oneplus-buds-wireless-earbuds-review-price-design-sound https://www.theverge.com/21331910/oneplus-buds-wireless-earb...
- np- 6y agoGood call. You’re totally correct, I was thinking about it from the wrong angle.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vmchale 6y agoCBP remains the worst law enforcement agency in the country
- x87678r 6y agoOnePlus official reply to CBP tweet. Hey, give those back! Upside-down face. https://twitter.com/OnePlus_USA/status/1305366058501509121 https://twitter.com/OnePlus_USA/status/1305366058501509121
- canada_dry 6y agoYah, what's with the 1+ logo on the package?? They just came out with their new wireless headphone a couple months ago. Edit: saw others comments re: possibly at Apple's behest due to perceived infringement. Though I'm sure we'd have read about that before now.
- zaptheimpaler 6y agoThey do look like Airpods from the picture, not OnePlus - i dont see the chrome/metal disc on the back of the earbuds that OnePlus pods have. The case matches the OnePlus case though. So its possible they really are counterfeit. Admittedly the picture is very low-res so its hard to be sure.
- OldHand2018 6y agoI think it's highly likely that the shipping manifest said Apple AirPods on it in an attempt to avoid importation tariffs. This stupid business of implementing tariffs and then giving specific companies exemptions is not exactly fair, but its also not the fault of CBP.
- modzu 6y agosums up my opinion of the bp