12 ms·
Assange's crime here is embarrassing powerful people. On the one hand, we are never going to get a law that explicitly states this is a crime. On the other hand
by roenxi 6y ago
Assange's crime here is embarrassing powerful people. On the one hand, we are never going to get a law that explicitly states this is a crime. On the other hand, that seems unlikely to matter. The US is apparently happy to literally scour the world for places where Assange has done something wrong if the Iceland claim is even a half-truth.
The basic issue that this article goes to is that the judge has broad discretionary power to hurry the defence along, and is using it. That is not unreasonable - defence by stalling tactics can't a legitimate strategy, so the judge must have those powers and be free to exercise them at her discretion. It is appropriate for the judge to have powers to guillotine witness time and to make procedural decisions. Even if they are unusual decisions.
The only thing Assange's defenders can hope for here is a great case study of how the US government doesn't care about details, they will reach out and try to grab anyone who makes it clear how they are operating. And then develop a rationalisation after the fact.
Really the most interesting thing in this article is the pervasive misspelling of "Sweden" as "the United States". I seem to recall a whole bunch of people arguing that Assange wasn't going to be extradited to the United States once they extracted him from the embassy. Possibly I am not remembering correctly and nobody admits to arguing that now.
- pjc50 6y agoThe facts change: the charges against him were dropped/timed out in Sweden, and then the US started an extradition request. The idea that it was harder to extradite him to the US from the UK than from Sweden, and that the extradition to Sweden was a pretext, was a very odd one - a priori I would have said it was the other way round.
- belorn 6y agoYou have switched the time stamps. The US started their extradition request and then Sweden dropped the case. The exact date was on 2 May 2019 when the first hearing was held in London into the United States request for Assange's extradition. The Swedish prosecution announced that their 7 years investigation had been dropped on 19 November 2019.
- acqq 6y agoAs far as I remember, Sweden did deliver to the US certain wanted people practically without a court procedure (or with less than it's certain it would be needed in the UK). It's not that Sweden or the UK would not deliver somebody to the US, it's that in the UK the procedure is more complex. Apparently, the US would have needed to fulfill less formalities to get him from Sweden, and that is what Assange worried about. But as he spent enough time in the embassy, that advantage of Sweden became irrelevant.
- sneak 6y agoThere were never any charges in Sweden. Please do not propagate this false belief.
- Gwypaas 6y agoThis is simply basic differences between how different justice systems operate. He was as formally charged as you get in Sweden until the investigation was dropped, only using different words. Assange was arrested in his absence and wanted for questioning in relation to accusations against him of rape and sexual molestation. This was the first step in the criminal prosecution procedure in Sweden, and only after the questioning would the prosecution authority be able to formally indict him.[10] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assange_v_Swedish_Prosecution_Authority#Accusations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assange_v_Swedish_Prosecution_...
- monocasa 6y agoHe was then questioned on Nov 14, 2016, and still not charged.
- foldr 6y agoHe couldn't be formally charged under the Swedish system because he wasn't in Sweden. (And yes, I know that in principle the Swedish authorities could probably have figured out some way to try him in absentia, but they chose not to because it would have been pointless, and they are perfectly free to make that decision.) Everyone repeating this nonsense should just take the time to read the British High Court judgment, which sets it all out very clearly.
- justsee 6y agoIt's important to remember the Swedish authorities were never interested in testimony from Assange. It's worth reading this interview [1] with Nils Melzer, the UN Special Rapporteur on torture, which reveals in shocking detail the level of manipulation around this entire case. As Melzer says "You just have to look at how the case was run: For Sweden, it was never about the interests of the two women." [1] https://www.republik.ch/2020/01/31/nils-melzer-about-wikileaks-founder-julian-assange https://www.republik.ch/2020/01/31/nils-melzer-about-wikilea...
- chippy 6y ago>I seem to recall a whole bunch of people arguing that Assange wasn't going to be extradited to the United States once they extracted him from the embassy. Were you one of the people that said he wouldn't be extradited to the US?
- ben_w 6y agoWhat I remember arguing at the time was: it is easier to extradite directly from the UK to the USA than from the UK to the USA via Sweden. Note also that Sweden only found out that the UK had removed Assange from the embassy because America had begun extradition proceedings against him, even though Sweden still wanted to get hold of him.
- monocasa 6y agoIt's easier to extra judicially grab at least non citizens from Sweden. Sweden has assisted the US before in breaking their own laws to help black bag their residents. The UK instead makes you bounce through their whole court system, not wanting to be overruled by one of their former colonies.
- vermilingua 6y agoI saw someone comment a while ago that Brexit effectively demotes the UK to being a colony of the US through trade dependence once they’re cut off from their special access to Europe. Does this not effectively prove that? The US has made a decision, and like a good vassal the UK judiciary is delivering Assange to them.
- monocasa 6y agoThere's a fairly public trial now though, and this is what the US was trying to avoid with the Sweden route. Sweden has provided it's own police to assist CIA operatives in black bagging it's own residents against it's own laws and process and sent them to an Egyptian prison clearly to be tortured and then blamed it all on a dead politician. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repatriation_of_Ahmed_Agiza_and_Muhammad_al-Zery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repatriation_of_Ahmed_Agiza_an...
- ben_w 6y agoI have the impression that the UK government genuinely (and incorrectly) believes itself to be in a position of strength, at least for now. To the extent that it is now sycophantic towards the USA, it already was — the “special relationship” meme in UK politics has been around for a long time.
- blame_lewis 6y ago> I seem to recall a whole bunch of people arguing that Assange wasn't going to be extradited to the United States once they extracted him from the embassy. At the time a fairly extensive collection of polemic was written that liberally used the word "paranoid". The argument from his opponents seems to have mostly shifted towards "yeah, but he deserves it".
- chippy 6y agoWorth also highlighting that this "whole bunch of people" can still be found here on HN. Often they are still very frequent posters and very well known members of HN. Some, however have given "I didn't know" or "the situation changed" half-apologies since.
- toyg 6y ago> Some, however have given "I didn't know" or "the situation changed" half-apologies since. I hope some people will take this as their "Iraq" moment, where the mechanisms of consensus-building by propaganda are laid bare. This is how powerful interests work: they push people to take sides with selected (or no) information, and by the time the full picture emerges, it's too late.
- AndrewBissell 6y agoAnyone who bought the line that Assange didn't need to fear extradition probably will transition seamlessly from "the idea that Assange will be extradited if he leaves the embassy is a baseless conspiracy theory" to "well, he's accused of breaking the law, so it will be a good thing to extradite him to face trial in the U.S."
- Consultant32452 6y agoHave you noticed how no one who led us into the Iraq war, whether they be government, media, etc. has faced any consequence whatsoever? Even the few who have admitted a "mistake" talk about it as if it's a mistake like I forgot my wallet and not a mistake like I killed 100k+ people. The major red pills in approximate order are 1) I'm being misled systematically 2) I've been misled since school 3) They are fully aware of what they are doing 4) Given the choice, they would prefer me dead over defiant
- ikeboy 6y agoThe argument was that it was strictly harder to extradite him from Sweden than from the UK, therefore his argument against going to Sweden was bullshit.