11 ms·
It doesn't really surprise me much that lactase persistence should be so strongly selected for in a relatively short period of time. Cows and other ungulates po
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
It doesn't really surprise me much that lactase persistence should be so strongly selected for in a relatively short period of time. Cows and other ungulates possess a rather magical ability to turn something that can't be digested by humans (cellulose) into something that can (milk). Opening up the huge caloric and nutrient resource of cellulose to humans in a relatively replenishable way had to be a giant benefit to those who could digest milk.
- lordnacho 6y agoIf it's so powerful, why did it not take over the rest of the world, or at least the rest of Eurasia? You'd think just a few people having kids with foreign populations would make the gene conquer the whole planet? They had cows in other places as well, right? One guess might be that winters in Europe were harsher than other population centres (China, India, Middle East), and periodic famines meant that some people would just scrape enough calories from milk. You hear stories about people trying everything when they're out of food, maybe trying the cow's milk was a sort of last resort that worked for some lucky people. Then again, you'd think they'd have eaten the cow first. The article does say it happened too fast to be from natural drift or population turnover, but I'm not sure what turnover means. Is that replacement say from a conquering tribe?
- grawprog 6y ago>You hear stories about people trying everything when they're out of food, maybe trying the cow's milk was a sort of last resort that worked for some lucky people. Then again, you'd think they'd have eaten the cow first. Maybe it was more desperation from waiting for cheese or something? I'm guessing if they kept milk cattle and didn't eat it they had a reason? Cheese seems like something that cows would be used for. It's easy to make, it comes from curdled cream, it stores for long periods, and it's calorie dense. Maybe milk drinking came at a time of extreme hunger where people just drank it directly instead of waiting?
- srtjstjsj 6y agoCheese has about the same lactose as milk, doesn't it?
- rwh86 6y agoHard cheeses contain almost no lactose; it's consumed by bacteria during the maturation process.
- njarboe 6y agoA way to store a surplus food that contains high protean and fat is another huge benefit of dairy. Hard cheeses can be stored for years in the right conditions and these conditions are achievable for ancient people (caves).
- eru 6y agoAnd if done right, the cheese becomes tastier as it ages. Not as important today, but more important back then: aging your cheese also concentrates the salt. Salty foods are tasty.
- njarboe 6y agoGood point. Back then salt was valuable in places just short distances from the ocean. Humans need salt, especially when doing hard physical labor, sweating all day.
- grawprog 6y agorwh86 is correct. That was part of my reasoning. I was thinking aged fermented cheeses not fresh cheeses, which do have more lactose. Aged fermented cheese is what I was figuring they would have made, because of the lactose issues. These take several months to years to make. I was lumping in higher lactose things like milk, soft unripened cheeses and yogurts together as 'high lactose desperation foods' as arguably, all were likely consumed for the same reasons early on. I would guess the lower lactose fermented cheeses would have been favoured earlier though. Humans have a history of fermentation and the utility of aged cheese is kind of hard to beat as far as such things go regarding fat and calorie content and preservability.
- undersuit 6y agoEurasia focused more on mare's milk and China and other rice dominated agricultures had no room for large concentrations of herds.
- gruez 6y ago> China and other rice dominated agricultures had no room for large concentrations of herds. Yeah it was discussed recently: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24373939 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24373939 tl;dr: rice was so efficient that there was no point in raising cattle
- Rexxar 6y ago> If it's so powerful, why did it not take over the rest of the world. Time. For going from 1/10 000 000 to 25% of the population in 300 generations (7500 years), you need to have a gene that give you 5% more offsprings at each generation.
- iguy 6y agoAnd distance. Not so much gene flow across the Mediterranean until we got good at sailing. And climate. Milk was an advantage against other food sources available at the time in northern Europe, but this wasn't necessarily true elsewhere.
- restalis 6y agoClimate also reflects on the level of available grass that the herders had to take into account when deciding where to move. Europe receives smaller quantities of precipitation as one goes from west to east, and then Europe's lush vegetation transitions into steppes and harsher climate beyond Volga region (Europe-Asia border). It must have been a tough call to decide to go eastward, and from what history tells us, that herders chose to migrate westward, not the other way around.
- Der_Einzige 6y agoUhh, they just drank different milk. Ox milk, goat milk, etc. Cattle are not always found in other places.
- AlotOfReading 6y agoLactose is present in all mammal milks to some degree and thus lactase persistence can have some benefits regardless of the specific animal the milk comes from.
- nkurz 6y agoYou might be thinking of a different animal. An ox isn't a good choice as an milking animal, as it typically is a castrated male bovine. If female, it would at least produce milk, but then it would just be a cow used for plowing, and would have the same milk as a dairy cow: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ox. Maybe you mean a water buffalo?
- scns 6y agoGoats milk aminoprofile is closer to human milk. Cows milk is 90/10 casein/wheyprotein, goats milk is 60/40 or 40/60 IIRC.
- scythe 6y ago>If it's so powerful, why did it not take over the rest of the world, or at least the rest of Eurasia? You'd think just a few people having kids with foreign populations would make the gene conquer the whole planet? They had cows in other places as well, right? It's cooler in Europe. Food stays better longer there. For example the daily mean temperature in Prague in July is 20 C, with a low of 15 C, so you could easily keep a cellar below that. Cheese will keep for a while. Plus, there's often a nearby mountain range with a convenient glacier: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_trade#Pre-19th_century_methods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_trade#Pre-19th_century_met...
- Spooky23 6y agoMilk isn’t dairy. Because it’s a liability in many parts of the world without abundant fodder or cold climate. Milk can be dangerous without refrigeration in hours. Dairy is much more than milk. You can consume cheese, yogurt, butter and many other products where the process of making the dairy product eliminates lactose. Think about things like cooking oil — an impossible thing to manufacture efficiently if you lack the resources to grow oil crops and process them. With diary, you just make butter, which is trivial to do. Domesticated cows and dairy is a pretty miraculous thing. It’s a shame that the excesses and poor practices around industrialized agriculture and economic policy has made it a ethical problem for some people.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoLet it ferment. Just add https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kefir https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kefir
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoLard was the "cooking oil" of choice before modern industrial production shifted to seed oils.
- eru 6y agoAnd it's still great. (Though to be sure, lard was the cooking fat of choice in much but not all of the world.)
- bad_user 6y agoLard was also very expensive, typically inaccessible to the layman, who preferred to sell all animal products they could get their hands on. Fat was inaccessible for cooking on a day to day basis, for anyone but the rich, until the introduction of seed oils.
- scns 6y agoI prefer purified butter for cooking, milkprotein burns so fast.
- gostsamo 6y agoEurope, throughout most of its history, was a corner of the world. It was a final destination for tribes that were misplaced by overpopulation, decease, and famine from the Middle East and Central Asia. My theory is that in order for this mutation to spread it must give a cutting edge advantage in an equal environment. However, the migration pressure was toward Europe, not out of it. What's more, other populations already had their ways to utilize derry products and the advantage might not have been so crucial. Therefore, the gene spread had been dependent mostly on internal migration and local populations mixing together. Of course, this theory has its weaknesses. It does not account for the effects of Alexander the Great, the Silk Road, the Roman empire or the depopulation of Eastern Europe through slave trade during the middle ages. At the same time, most of these factors would open trade routes and cultural exchange but not the large scale migrations necessary for a significant genetic mix. Slavery might offer something, but it was recent and slaves are usually the most disadvantaged group in a society which does not help their genes being promoted.
- AlotOfReading 6y agoLactase persistence isn't the only (or even first) way to convert inedible flora into food. For one, you can simply eat the cows, the way it was done for most of human history. If you absolutely insist on dairy though, the genes for lactase persistence post-date dairying by a few millennia and many people who rely primarily on dairy today still lack the genes, like most Mongolians. They've adapted different production methods and gut microbiota to take care of the issues.
- pan69 6y ago> For one, you can simply eat the cows It could be more resource intensive to get a new cow each time rather than milk the same cow over and over for a longer period of time.
- hinkley 6y agoMilk production is also a continuum of data samples over the life of the animal. Eating the animal is one data sample and you can’t duplicate the animal after collecting the data. Selecting for milk production would be a lot more accurate than selecting for meat tastiness, longevity or even, to an lesser extent, health.
- solstice 6y agoI can't decide whether that first para is satire or not
- simcop2387 6y agoActually we select for both depending on the line of the stock and have been doing so for a rather long time. You do lose the animal after killing it of course but we have a huge amount data from cattle breeding charts that lets a branch be trimmed if there's some fault with it that will damage the genetic tree.
- hinkley 6y agoYou can’t use the lens of modern agriculture and data collection to look at the birth and growth of animal husbandry. We have enough now that the conversation isn’t about if we can afford to eat our cows but how fast we can eat them. The top of this thread was discussing how we got into milk harvesting so broadly when so few have the genes for it. It was more efficient for people handing down knowledge through oral tradition.
- bonoboTP 6y agoWhy couldn't we evolve the ability to digest cellulose directly like cows, instead of going through cows? My guess: grazing takes extremely long and so we let cows do the boring job of grazing outside all day then we quickly slurp up whe harvested calories in just a few glasses of milk.
- readams 6y agoCows have to go through quite a lot to make it happen, with a multistage digestion process, multiple stomachs, regurgitation and additional chewing of food, the right microbiome. In short it's not an easy trait to just "evolve". Lactose tolerance on the other hand is just retaining a trait into adulthood (lactase production) usually lost after weaning.
- restalis 6y ago"Cows have to go through quite a lot to make it happen, with a multistage digestion process, multiple stomachs, regurgitation and additional chewing of food, the right microbiome. In short it's not an easy trait to just «evolve»." The complexity of digestive apparatus found in Bovidae family and other ruminant mammals is just an optimization. Herbivore monogastric mammals like horses consume cellulose too. There even isn't that necessary for the mammal to be (specialized) herbivore in order have the cellulose digesting ability, as pigs clearly demonstrate. Some extensions in our menu limits are always welcomed. Digesting lactose as adults was nice, but digesting cellulose, even if not that pleasant or efficient, would have been even nicer, as when things went historically bad, it would had came in handy if we could literally just run to the forest for more than to just hide.
- as-j 6y agoWhy wouldn’t we?? Have you seen a cow? :) An enzyme to break down milk seems to be such an easier adaptation compared to a whole series of stomach, which are basically a series of fermenters. Having raised goats the size of their rumens to body is pretty amazing.
- bonoboTP 6y ago
- tus88 6y agoWhen you put it like that I understand why Indians worship cows.
- serf 6y agoHindu folk revere cows, but not all folk from India are Hindu.
- jagannathtech 6y agoWell atleast their ancestors used to be
- User23 6y agoBronze Age Europeans aren’t the ancestors of modern day Europeans. Thanks to modern genetic research we know that they were largely exterminated by invaders a few thousand years ago, at least on the yDNA lineages.
- iguy 6y agoIt's true that they were replaced, almost completely in northern Europe. But the claim of TFA is that these skeletons date from after this Indo-European / Yamnaya arrival, and hence that it disproves the theory that lactase persistence arrived with them. Linguistically, I think we know they had cows but not agriculture, before migrating to Europe & India. (IIRC "cow" comes from PIE?) Which gave credence to the idea that they may have been lactose-tolerant. TFA is one study, so we will presumably eventually see whether this holds up with more data.
- bobbylarrybobby 6y agoDo you know where modern day Europeans came from? Who were these invaders?
- xyzzyz 6y agoYou can find answers to these questions in recent David Reich’s book.
- NegativeLatency 6y agoPossibly the celts and prior Indo-Europeans? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celts
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoIndo Europeans from pontic steppe and farmers from Anatolia. Northern europeans have more ancestry in the prior.
- Bayart 6y agoA variable ancestry of post-ice age hunter-gatherers, Neolithic Anatolian farmers and steppe invaders (ie. Indo-Europeans). The ratio varies depending on areas, but that mix is specifically European.
- burtonator 6y agoOne of the biggest misconceptions of evolution is that it's a slow and gradual process. Under the right conditions it can happen VERY fast.
- akiselev 6y agoVery fast. The canonical example is the peppered moth (Biston betularia) [1] in the UK changing color from white to black and back to white in the last two hundred years. Coal power plants during the industrial revolution covered the surrounding areas in soot and darkened the white lichen covering those trees, which meant that the white moths were more visible to predators. Once clean air regulations and technological improvements eliminated the soot, the gene that turned them black became a liability and the population was once again taken over by the white moths. The specific mutation event was traced to around 1819 [2] and by the turn of the century, the white variant was all but gone around industrialized cities (someone even wrote Darwin about it in the 1870s). Starting in the 50s and 60s, the distribution began to reverse once the air started to get cleaner and now we're back to a largely white moth population. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peppered_moth_evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peppered_moth_evolution [2] https://www.nature.com/articles/nature17951 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature17951
- tomp 6y agoEvolution should be measured in generations, not years. According to Wikipedia, the peppered moth has 1 generation per year; in humans, it's probably like 1 per 20 years. So 50 years moth-time is still 1000 years human-time. Still quite fast though.
- JacobAldridge 6y ago“Punctuated Equilibrium” - long periods of stability, and then short periods of great change. I find it interesting to see the effect in other fields in my life - for example, I’ve been tracking net worth each month for almost a decade, and it follows a similar pattern of slow (or no) growth ... and then big jumps.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoThere are bacteria that can eat nylon, a man-made molecule. Nylon was invented in 1935 and these bacteria were discovered in 1975. The enzymes used by these bacteria only work on nylon. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nylon-eating_bacteria https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nylon-eating_bacteria Bacteria have much shorter generations and this facilitates rapid evolution.
- raxxorrax 6y agoI think the actual genetic factors for lactose intolerance are very rare. It probably has more to do with gut flora and consumption. I am slightly intolerant and have symptoms if I stuff myself with raw milk. Other than that it is no problem. I have a friend with the genetic condition and even he drinks milk. He does get problem quickly, but not if he drinks coffee with some milk or yogurt. I think all people develop an intolerance with age naturally, but people that consume much milk will have that process slowed down. I think the genetic factors can just accelerate the process that is responsible to induce intolerance.
- seszett 6y ago> I think the actual genetic factors for lactose intolerance are very rare. It probably has more to do with gut flora and consumption. Not really, lactose is basically converted straight into glucose by lactase, and if you don't produce lactase the lactose is going to be digested by a variety of bacteria and turned into a whole host of products (some of them usable by the body) but mostly gas. There isn't really a way to avoid that, even though gut flora can be more or less efficient and allow non-lactase-producers to mostly digest milk, it's never as efficient as using lactase. > I think all people develop an intolerance with age naturally No, it's a well-researched thing, some populations of humans keep producing lactase after their childhood and some don't. It's not related to the milk consumption of an individual, either.
- cannedslime 6y agoThere is fats in milk, the energy is not exclusively lactose.
- dalbasal 6y agoMaybe not surprising biologically, considering the role of nutrition as a limiting factor on human (and most organisms) population. Say an ancient culture developed a lifestyle heavily fishing relient. If the resources (fish) were plentiful, it's not hard to imagine fish becoming a staple diet fast and subsequent adaptations to the nutritional pros and cons emerging within just a few generations. OTOH, milk requires domestication of mammals. For milk to be a staple (as it is among many existing pastoralist cultures), processing and preservation techniques (yoghurt, cheese, etc) need to be developed. It's (IMO) a pretty complex assortment of dependant cultural and biological adaptations in both humans and animals. Genetic evidence like this suggests that the adaptations spread fast. It also suggests a substantial role played by pastoralist cultures in neolithic and bronze age prehistory. Neolithic history is tends to emphasize grain agriculture. These people left more artifacts. They left large settlements (eg Jericho) for us to dig up. They became urban "civilizations." Common, orthodox interpretation (eg the common marxist narrative) focuses on these a lot. Complex relationships between economics & social structure are inferred. etc. Pastoralism gets a lot less attention. They left few artifacts, fewer settlements. They weren't urban, making them less interesting to most 19th and 20th century historians. Yet, we have lots of evidence that they were both many and significant. Some of the earliest histories we have (Sumerian, 1st Dynasty Egyptian) suggests all sorts of contact, cultural exchange and conflict with large populations of pastoralists. Ancient historians attributed many innovations in weapons (eg chariots, compound bows) and other technological advancements (eg wheels) to pastoralist cultures. While speculative, I'd also suggest that the earliest "nations" may have been pastoralists in the Yuval Noah Harari sense of the term. This also makes them the first civilizations in the same sense. They were also likely to have been innovators and originators of long distance trade and communication. None of that is proved by the spread of lactose tolerance, but it does suggest that pastoralism was a very significant lifestyle in the lead up to pre classical cultures.
- throwaway5938 6y agoNote that there's still no evidence the ability to digest lactose is an actual adaptation as opposed to some allele that got accidentally fixed in some populations due to genetic drift.
- KuhlMensch 6y agoMinor note: The puzzlement around gene-selection isn't, "Why so fast?" but "Why so fast and LATE (between 3000 and 1500 years ago)?"