11 ms·
Hard disagree. Once you get to the advanced levels of any field, terminology being "accessible" doesn't really matter, but being precise does. Areas like phil
by crazygringo 6y ago
Hard disagree.
Once you get to the advanced levels of any field, terminology being "accessible" doesn't really matter, but being precise does.
Areas like philosophy and law actually suffer in my opinion when they overload common words with uncommon meanings, or descend into weird disambiguations that depend on suffixes.
For example, in philosophy there's "contractarianism" and "contractualism", and trying to remember which is the general term and which refers to a specific theory drives me nuts. (If "contractualism" were just known as "Scanlon's theory" it would be a lot easier.)
Naming things after their creator is actually super-helpful because it's really easy to disambiguate, helps situate things historically, and once you're at that level there often isn't a single unique word or phrase that can easily encapsulate the idea anyways and isn't easily confused with something else.
- didibus 6y agoCompletely agree. And when using common terms, people also make all kind of assumptions from it, and that comes with a bias, before even getting a grasp of the concept it describes in a given field.
- dvt 6y agoGoing to pile on to the agreement here -- for example, much confusion can be had when discussing things like "intentionality" with laypeople. Philosophy is riddled with regular words that take non-regular meanings. It might make philosophers feel smart, but it's a detriment to the field imo.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoMuch, though not all, of this is due to philosophers discussing ideas from the past three thousand years originally in a multitude of languages. How should one discuss a "Platonic Idea" without confusion of a general idea?
- nabla9 6y agoYet another example: International relations theory overloads "Liberalism", "Realism" and "Idealism". It's too easy to project meaning for already overloaded words like these. Long articles and opinion pieces are written by people who saw something with these words and it never occurred for them that they should check out what these words mean in the context.
- ardit33 6y agoI Disagree with you, in Computer Science we have things like: "Quick Sort", "Merge Sort", "Map", "Hashtable", "LRU", etc... etc... They are much more descriptive and easy to remember, even though the Algorithms can be complex themselves. Event the name "Boolean", could be changed to "Conditional"... and be even more readable. Also, Dijkstra algorithm can be generalized to "Shortest Path Algorithm" (there can be more than one). Math, and physics to some degree, have become self-referential to the point that start becoming more esoteric magic black books to beginners... While CS was born out of Math folks, and unfortunately has adopted some of the same esoteric symbolics, I hope Computer Science doesn't follow that path on the long term, otherwise it will become divorced from day to day real life applications. Let me give you a clear example: Now, imagine if we called Double Linked Lists as "Darombolo lists", or whoever invented it. (I made up that name), Double Linked List is very easy to visualize and remember. "Giacomo Darombolo List", is not, and just adds to 'must cram/memorize' things to make things work..... I personally don't like "cramming" useless trivia in order to work in my field. I hope Computer Science divorces from Math, and takes its own path to more logical naming of things and less useless symbols used in it. It is like the whole field suffers because the authors' Narcissism, that they must name things after them.
- tr352 6y ago> Event the name "Boolean", could be changed to "Conditional"... and be even more readable. Definitely not. The term conditional is used for statements of the form “if X then Y”, in computer science as well as logic/philosophy.
- chongli 6y agoin Computer Science we have things like: "Quick Sort", "Merge Sort", "Map", "Hashtable", "LRU", etc... Those are trivial concepts though. The article brings up "perfectoid spaces", as if to suggest their superiority to "Scholze spaces", yet neither name gives any clue as to what they are: In mathematics, perfectoid spaces are adic spaces of special kind, which occur in the study of problems of "mixed characteristic", such as local fields of characteristic zero which have residue fields of characteristic prime p. A perfectoid field is a complete topological field K whose topology is induced by a nondiscrete valuation of rank 1, such that the Frobenius endomorphism Φ is surjective on K°/p where K° denotes the ring of power-bounded elements. [1] Oh, okay. See, the problem is that modern mathematical structures are built on top of centuries of prior work. Computer science, on the other hand, is still in its infancy as a field. I hope Computer Science divorces from Math, and takes its own path to more logical naming of things and less useless symbols used in it. That's silly. Computer science is a subfield of math. All computer scientists working in research are mathematicians by training. You won't get anywhere at all if you try to enter the field without a mathematical background. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfectoid_space https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfectoid_space
- breck 6y agoI strongly agree that precision matters, but in no way does naming a concept after a person help with precision. Almost entirely orthogonal. What does help with precision is typed languages. You cannot use a term until you've precisely defined it in terms previously defined, which can be back-traced automatically by a computer to ones and zeroes. It must be a language both parseable by a human and a machine. At that point you have precision. That doesn't preclude using names as identifiers, but makes that largely irrelevant. I strongly disagree that accessibility doesn't really matter. It always matters. Maybe not during draft time, but in the long run. There are strong economic incentives to make things less accessible for non-experts, but in no way does that help advance the field, or force experts to reduce elements to their most basics, it is just rent seeking.
- bsza 6y agoPeople's names can be confused too. A few weeks ago I referred to the Legendre symbol as "Lagrange symbol" by mistake when talking to a colleague. Such things are inevitable however you name things; some words happen to have small Levenshulme-distances...
- kergonath 6y agoParticularly if the names are hard to pronounce or remember because of the cultural and language difference. Few French-speaking people would confuse Legendre ('the son-in-law') and Lagrange ('the barn').
- mwcampbell 6y agoI assume your misspelling of Levenshtein distance was intentional. Figured I'd drop the correct spelling here for anyone trying to look it up.
- Tainnor 6y agoLagrange vs. Legendre is kinda really easy to mix up, since you have Legendre polynomials and Lagrange polynomials and both are important in numerical analysis...
- tareqak 6y agoWhat about names like Page Rank?
- bsza 6y agoWhat about it? It is just pure luck that Larry Page happens to have the perfect name for the algorithm named after him. Doesn't happen to everyone.
- Rebelgecko 6y ago>Naming things after their creator is actually super-helpful because it's really easy to disambiguate For the most part I agree with you, however there are some notable edge cases where someone's name can be heavily overloaded (e.g. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_things_named_after_Leonhard_Euler https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_things_named_after_L...)
- csours 6y agoI ran into something like this with Perrow's 'Normal Accidents' - he defines common words with specific meanings, when he could have just as easily used two common words with no ambiguity. If you use three words, you're in real danger of forming acronyms, but I think two words are a sweet spot.
- Godel_unicode 6y agoI've always thought there was a nice breakdown here in math; name things after what they are if they can be stated concisely, name them after discoverers as a short hand for here-there-be-dragons.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoThere's no system. Abelian groups are a concept that is simple, intuitive, and easy to describe concisely.
- dmurray 6y agoIs that the breakdown? Euclid's Algorithm, Pythagoras' Theorem, Fermat's Little Theorem are all elementary, but the example upthread of a "perfectoid field" which is a "complete topological field K whose topology is induced by a nondiscrete valuation of rank 1..." is much more abstruse.
- karmakaze 6y agoAbsolutely. When defining new areas the most important things are not bringing along baggage of irrelevant context and being distinct from other things--anything that's unique and visibly distinct (e.g. not like Q123512). Using common words would be the worst as we have ideas about them but the analogies break down fast and get in the way.
- bumby 6y agoTo a certain extent both sides are right. What it really comes come to is communication. The real question is who should the language be optimized for? One side feels the intended audience is of the same field and sufficiently sophisticated enough to understand the somewhat obscure naming. Others don’t understand it because it simply isn’t for them. The other side may come from other tangential domains with their own unique language. They don’t understand why those specialists use such obscure language meanwhile they do the same in their own field. You see the same in any large organization. Seemingly random acronyms get created as lazy shorthand that conflict with other orgs understanding. It’s of course no consequence to those in the “in crowd” but it hampers communication between groups. Considering communication is one of the ever present hurdles between groups it seems reasonable to me to optimize communication between groups rather than within groups.
- DonHopkins 6y agoEven with people's names, you get bizarre confusions and mutations. https://www.tek.com/blog/window-functions-spectrum-analyzers https://www.tek.com/blog/window-functions-spectrum-analyzers >Hamming and Hanning >These two similarly-named Hamming and Hanning (more properly referred to as Hann) window functions both have a sinusoidal shape. The difference between them is that the Hanning window touches zero at both ends, removing any discontinuity. The Hamming window stops just shy of zero, meaning that the signal will still have a slight discontinuity. The Hamming Window is named after Richard Hamming. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Hamming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Hamming But the Hanning Window is named after Julius von Hann, and lots of people just throw in an extra "ing" to make them sound alike, but its excruciatingly correct name is Hann Window. But it seems fitting that they're almost but not quite alike, and so is their spelling. Maybe for symmetry there should be a Halling Window that stops just below zero. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julius_von_Hann https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julius_von_Hann https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Window_function#Hamming_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Window_function#Hamming_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hann_function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hann_function https://numpy.org/doc/stable/reference/generated/numpy.hanning.html https://numpy.org/doc/stable/reference/generated/numpy.hanni... https://numpy.org/doc/stable/reference/generated/numpy.hamming.html https://numpy.org/doc/stable/reference/generated/numpy.hammi...
- xamuel 6y agoI think people have a misconception that mathematicians get together with pomp and ceremony and someone pounds a gavel and declares, "By order of the secret council of mathematicians, such-and-such theorem is hereby dubbed 'Davis's Theorem'", or something. Rather, what really happens is that mathematicians are a community, and they refer to things in whatever way is convenient. Davis's colleague refers to such-and-such theorem as "Davis's Theorem" not because of some committee on naming, but rather because they were there at the conference where Davis announced the theorem, and everyone at said conference excitedly talked about "Davis's Theorem" for the whole rest of the conference because it was so exciting.
- kergonath 6y agoYou can have only so many Riemann theorems before it becomes confusing, though.
- srtjstjsj 6y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_things_named_after_Leonhard_Euler http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_things_named_after_Leon... > Many of these entities have been given simple and ambiguous names such as Euler's function, Euler's equation, and Euler's formula. > In an effort to avoid naming everything after Euler, some discoveries and theorems are attributed to the first person to have proved them after Euler.
- kergonath 6y agoYou know you've made it when you need a Wikipedia article to keep track of what you've done. Gauss' is similar, if maybe a bit shorter: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_things_named_after_Carl_Friedrich_Gauss https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_things_named_after_Car...
- amelius 6y agoYeah, but after a while you'd have Smith's rule, Smith's law, Smith's corollary, ...
- DonHopkins 6y agoI love how they named the inverse spectrum the cepstrum, which uses quefrency, saphe, alanysis, and liftering, instead of frequency, phase, analysis and filtering. It should not be confused with the earlier concept of the kepstrum, of course! ;) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cepstrum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cepstrum >References to the Bogert paper, in a bibliography, are often edited incorrectly. The terms "quefrency", "alanysis", "cepstrum" and "saphe" were invented by the authors by rearranging some letters in frequency, analysis, spectrum and phase. The new invented terms are defined by analogies to the older terms. >Thus: The name cepstrum was derived by reversing the first four letters of "spectrum". Operations on cepstra are labelled quefrency analysis (aka quefrency alanysis[1]), liftering, or cepstral analysis. It may be pronounced in the two ways given, the second having the advantage of avoiding confusion with "kepstrum", which also exists (see below). [...] >The kepstrum, which stands for "Kolmogorov-equation power-series time response", is similar to the cepstrum and has the same relation to it as expected value has to statistical average, i.e. cepstrum is the empirically measured quantity, while kepstrum is the theoretical quantity. It was in use before the cepstrum.[12][13]
- xg15 6y ago> Once you get to the advanced levels of any field, terminology being "accessible" doesn't really matter, but being precise does. If you really want to build knowledge barriers, then yes. This might have been true decades ago when advanced academic concepts really might have been relevant for a small group of experts - but today, advanced math is the foundation of huge industries - and not everyone working with it can be assumed to have a formal education in the field: Often, you want to make use of an algorithm and simply need to know the concepts necessary to understand that algorithm. Also, being precise doesn't have to mean being opaque - a name should give an uninformed reader at least enough information to roughly categorize the concept: Even "Timsort" is better than "Tim's algorithm", because this at least gives me a hint that I deal with a sorting algorithm.
- dtwhitney 6y agoI'm with you on the "Hard disagree", but I'd say something like: one of the great rewards to being a Mathematician is that things are named after you, and you get that legacy. God knows the pay ain't great.
- rocqua 6y agoThe thing is, there is a trade-off between making math (at any level) accessible to outsiders, and making things easier for the heavy practitioners. For naming things after their inventors, you are very much losing accessibility to outsides (that includes mathematicians working outside the field). I could see the trade-off for clarity (for most people) not being big enough to off-set the loss in accessibility. The easier a field is to get into, the quicker it will grow. Moreover, it also makes the field a lot more fruitful to work in.
- ABCLAW 6y ago>Areas like philosophy and law actually suffer in my opinion when they overload common words It's more that people take material from our fields and misuse them in casual contexts. >If "contractualism" were just known as "Scanlon's theory" it would be a lot easier.) It would also be wrong as it isn't his theory, he's just a philosopher with a recent in-vogue formulation of it. The source of the theory in modern western philosophy is Rousseau. There's no issue with discussing "Scanlon's theories"; but that term refers to his theories, not contractualism at large.
- crazygringo 6y agoSee, you're actually making my point. ;) Social contract theory is known as contractarianism. [1] (And the source was first Plato, but is best known through Hobbes. Rousseau was then the next best-known iteration after Hobbes.) But "contractualism" is generally used to refer to T.M. Scanlon's theory specifically. [2] This is my point. They're too easy to mix up. ;) [1] https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/contractarianism/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/contractarianism/ [2] https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/contractualism/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/contractualism/
- ABCLAW 6y agoAm I though? The preambles of the articles that you're citing do not agree with your position, neither does a number of other definitions found easily online, neither does the academic publication record (you'll easily find 500+ articles on Contractualism penned before Scanlon). See: "There is no necessity for a contractarian about political theory to be a contractarian about moral theory, although most contemporary contractarians are both. It has been more recently recognized that there are two distinct strains of social contract thought, which now typically go by the names contractarianism and contractualism." [...] "Contractarianism argues that we each are motivated to accept morality “first because we are vulnerable to the depredations of others, and second because we can all benefit from cooperation with others” (Narveson 1988, 148). Contractualism, which stems from the Kantian line of social contract thought, holds that rationality requires that we respect persons, which in turn requires that moral principles be such that they can be justified to each person. Thus, individuals are not taken to be motivated by self-interest but rather by a commitment to publicly justify the standards of morality to which each will be held. Where Gauthier, Narveson, or economist James Buchanan are the paradigm Hobbesian contractarians, Rawls or Thomas Scanlon would be the paradigm Kantian contractualists. The rest of this entry will specifically pertain to the contractarian strain wherever the two diverge." In other words, this isn't about Scanlon the person, it's about two different schools of thought regarding people and their relationship with society. To dumb them down significantly, one's about the selfish, desperate flight from the state of nature, the other is about the crafting of a persuasive encompassing rationality of co-operation. ---- Also, just as an aside, while this difference might seem like it's a small nitpick, it's actually one of the fundamental theoretical divides between continental European and American/British legal systems. So yes, there's a reason why the terms are distinct.
- guerrilla 6y ago> Areas like philosophy and law actually suffer in my opinion when they overload common words with uncommon meanings, This is definitely true. It doesn't matter as much as a technical person learning it but at a certain point it becomes absolutely impossible to communicate with regular people not steeped in the terminology about it (e.g. object, property, event, part, substance, sort, kind, type for analytic ontology).
- roenxi 6y ago> terminology being "accessible" doesn't really matter, but being precise does. There is also an argument that for experts names are even more accessible than the alternative - if a descriptive name is used but is wrong, then it becomes more confusing. Math already has a problem with overloading common words with special meanings.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- BluSyn 6y agoCould not possible disagree more. "Contractualism" is far easier to remember for most people than remembering the name "Scanlon". Proper names do NOT easily translate to concepts for majority of people. If you can't properly define your concept without the use of a proper name, you aren't trying hard enough. I think this trend needs to die, and luckily it seems to be falling out of favor. Similar to naming companies after the founder. Tesla Motors could easily have been "Musk Motors" if it was started in the era of Ford and Lockheed.
- afiori 6y agousing suffixes and syntactic variations to distinguish concept also does not translate, in the literal sense of translating to other languages, especially those that have different rules for suffixes. Scanlon or whatever other name is much easier to translate to any other language than random unusual words
- afiori 6y agoIn addition names have another huge accessibility advantage: they are easy to translate. using pedantic suffixes for precise meanings sometimes means that some languages run out of variants
- yellowapple 6y ago> Once you get to the advanced levels of any field, terminology being "accessible" doesn't really matter, but being precise does. And in what multiverse is "Calabi-Yau manifold" a precise terminology? Literally all that can be gleaned from that is that it's a manifold and it's the invention of some mathematicians (or maybe one mathematician with a hyphenated surname). > If "contractualism" were just known as "Scanlon's theory" it would be a lot easier. My disagreement would make diamonds look soft in comparison. "Contractualism" at least conveys it might have something to do with contracts. "Scanlon's theory" tells me absolutely nothing about what it might be. That is worse by every objective measure.
- andykx 6y agoBut why do you have to be able to glean meaning from the phrase alone? And how often does that really happen in other situations, when last names aren’t involved? The term “polymorphism” is a good example. It isn’t named after someone, but could anyone without a background in computer science have any clue what that term actually refers to? Sure, they could examine the root words and try to figure it out, but would they be any closer to the actual meaning of the word? I don’t think it makes sense to make field-specific jargon accessible to the masses. Instead I think it makes more sense to make it easily researchable and distinct from more commonplace words.
- yellowapple 6y ago> But why do you have to be able to glean meaning from the phrase alone? Because it helps me wrap my head around what it is, what it does, and why I should care about it. And by "me", I more importantly mean a rhetorical "me", i.e. a random layperson who happens to be a politician or someone else with disproportionate power over things like scientific endeavors. More on that in a sec... > Sure, they could examine the root words [of "polymorphism"] and try to figure it out, but would they be any closer to the actual meaning of the word? I mean, a little bit, yes. "Poly" = "many", "morph" = "form", "ism" = some kind of state of being, and from that someone could figure out that if something exhibits "polymorphism" it means it has many forms (and this does indeed provide at least some intuitive understanding of e.g. how a function can have many different implementations under the same name, and that implementation being decided by the form of its arguments). > I don’t think it makes sense to make field-specific jargon accessible to the masses. Instead I think it makes more sense to make it easily researchable and distinct from more commonplace words. And this is why the masses write off science and "them nerds telling us how the world works" as useless, and in turn why our planet is dying and humanity's decline into stupidity is accelerating. It's precisely why so few people trust science: because they don't understand it, because every effort seems to have been made to make it entirely opaque to anyone without decades of academic background that the vast majority of people cannot afford (schoolwork doesn't put food on the table). Maybe - just maybe - we could instead try to remove barriers to entry into making STEM some elitist Kool Kids Klub that deems laypeople as unworthy because they don't have the time or energy to memorize the names of a bunch of dead white men, and maybe then we can live in the world we all want: one where science and scientists are taken seriously, and where we don't wait until it's already too late before we even start thinking about addressing a self-induced extinction event.
- laingc 6y agoAbsolutely agree. I'd go so far as to say this is one of the real strengths of mathematical naming conventions. You are absolutely on point with the contrast to Law; I have degrees in both subjects, and this has also been my experience. Jargon exists for a reason. The deeper the field, the better the jargon needs to be to allow proper communication. The fact that we can communicate complex mathematical ideas in language at all is a minor miracle.
- scsilver 6y agoSimply being able to look up the luminarie's name, years of life, and location helps alot with defining an ideas part our knowledge evolution. I hear a theory made by someone in england in th 17-1800's I already know this theory has probably sprang out of the enlightenment and should looking at contemporary works for context of the thinking at that time.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoI disagree with your hard disagree. Because I don't give a shit about who discovered something allegedly first. I do care about what it means/does. Maybe it's a language problem, because some languages make it more easy to add words into a new word describing that new thing. edit: Otherwise it's just protocol overhead, line noise, gibberish to me.
- boyobo 6y agoAny name given to object is necessarily going to be an incomplete description of said object. It's a tradeoff between the length of the description and the precision of the description. If you want to know what the object does you can look up its definition.