8 ms·
U.S. court: Mass surveillance program exposed by Snowden was illegal
- rvz 6y agoTime to give a massive apology and a full pardon to Mr Snowden then.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sneak 6y agoHaving read Barton Gellman’s book that describes and alludes to some of the details of what were in the actual (never published) Snowden files, I do not believe that the US IC would let him continue to live, even if he were fully pardoned. I doubt it will ever be safe for him in the US again, despite his legal status.
- Schiendelman 6y agoSounds like fascism.
- natcombs 6y agoNo, it sounds like a rogue IC agency. The textbook definition of fascism doesn’t apply here. This word keeps appearing on HN without any reasoning
- metiscus 6y agoIn the modern zeitgeist anything authoritarian or that can be interpreted from the center-left to be slightly right of center is being called fascism as shorthand for "bad policy I disagree with". The conflation of authoritarianism vs policy difference is where some danger lies.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Schiendelman 6y agoWhat makes you consider them “rogue”?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- scaraffe 6y agowhat kind of things does the book allude to?
- sneak 6y agoApparently the documents that he provided to the press had specific descriptions of names, cities, places, and events that had occurred that Gellman didn’t find specifically newsworthy but that the IC really, really wanted kept secret. The view of people familiar with the matter is that anything placed into the unskilled hands of people like Greenwald or Gellman (although the latter did get professional assistance and take a lot of steps to protect it) got accessed/copied by any of a half-dozen other state-level intelligence services, so presumably the US IC was concerned about these particular not-published-in-the-media secrets being available to the public. (This is not to say they weren’t concerned about them being known to other intel agencies, just that based on the unprofessional hands in which it was placed, that ship had probably already sailed once it was given to those incompetent in safeguarding it.) Personally, I wish the original unredacted PRISM deck had been published in full to the public. The state derives its authority from the consent of the governed; it is impossible to consent to something of which you are unaware and uninformed. I heartily recommend reading Gellman’s book about Snowden, Dark Mirror. One of the things he mentioned that surprised me was that Snowden told him that they (the IC) would not hesitate to assassinate him (Gellman, a US citizen on US soil) instantly if they thought it would prevent the leak from going further.
- raxxorrax 6y agoThey wouldn't kill him, that would be an amateurish mistake, you would have a martyr. Destroying his reputation, pressure friends and family...
- sneak 6y agoIf the US didn’t freak out when they found out the 4th amendment was simply smoke and mirrors, they wouldn’t freak out if the CIA assassinated one of their own. They’re not freaking out while the CIA slowly tortures a journalist (Assange) to death in prison, in full view of the press and international media. I think most Americans don’t know or care who Ed Snowden is. The Last Week Tonight segment with him was rather instructive.
- pps43 6y agoSnowden does not have the files. Did not have them when he arrived in Russia. That's why it took so long for the Russians to let him in. They could not believe he did not take any intelligence with him.
- rbreve 6y agoWill Trump pardon Snowden? that will be interesting.
- mlang23 6y agoNow would be about the best time for him to make that move. With elections upcoming and all that.
- BLKNSLVR 6y agoTrump's pardoning of Snowden would lose more presidential election support than it would win. Sure, there are plenty of people who would support the decision to pardon Snowden, but I can't see them being the type of people to vote for Trump based on that. Existing Trump supporters, on the other hand, I could see "punishing" Trump for his weakness in pardoning a "traitor who fled to Russia".
- differentView 6y agoHe can pardon him to test the effects on polling. If it helps, great. If it hurts him, get Snowden back, arrest him, and claim it was a trick to get the traitor that Obama couldn't get all along.
- BLKNSLVR 6y agoIs un-pardoning a thing? I'd have figured that a pardon would mean that Trump wouldn't be able to follow it up with his arrest and claiming the pardon was a 'trick'. Just writing that, though, it feels dirtily and precisely "Trump". edit: grammar
- boomboomsubban 6y agoYou pardon certain crimes. As an example, you pardon Snowden for "all crimes related to NSA leaks," and then charge him with some kind if tax avoidance. It'd be dirty as hell, and make any trial much longer, but it's possible.
- LockAndLol 6y agoSo, are the espionage charges against Snowden going to be dropped? Otherwise they want to convict a man of exposing illegal activity, which doesn't make a lot of sense.
- markild 6y agoThere are legal and illegal ways to disclose illegal activity. The fact that the activity was illegal, doesn't automatically make any disclosure of it legal. Not arguing one way or the other here, as I simply don't know enough about the situation.
- autisticcurio 6y agoHere in the UK the security services run the show. You could be forgiven for thinking the UK is a democracy, its easy to manipulate politicians with Whitehall providing the data leading politicians to arrive at a conclusion that isnt accurate. Always do your own research, trust no one, people will go to great lengths to protect their positions, wages and pensions and show me were any of you have agreed to the laws forced on you. Its just legal fascism.
- elmo2you 6y agoDon't be daft. They'll argue that in the exceptional case of state security, exposing any kind of secretive information (illegal or otherwise) is still a crime. They'll just argue that only "normal citizens" shouldn't be barred from reporting criminal activities. Of course it is bullshit .. but since when did that stop them? Exceptionalism has been the key word, used almost every time the government violated a laws or moral boundary (both domestically and abroad). Why would anyone expect sense, from a government that will never receive actual jail time from any national court, in a country were potential punishment appears to be the main motivator for powerful people to not do everything illegal? Why on earth would anyone still expect any sense, after the USA went as far as creating laws to justify military invasion of a foreign country, if an international tribunal would ever charge them with violating international law? Why are so many American citizens still so naive about the real nature of their own government. Always thinking it's the other party that's the bad guys .. never wanting to accept that the party really doesn't matter (just ask any foreign country that received an unhealthy dose of "freedom and democracy").
- osmarks 6y agoI'm sure they'll stop all their illegal surveillance any day now.
- uCantCauseUCant 6y agoIllegal Memory access at 0xDEADBEEF Watching_the_watchmen_recursive has detected a stackoverflow and was aborted. A core dump has been created and can be viewed at constituion.hex.
- captn3m0 6y agoSo does the data get deleted?
- softwaredoug 6y agoThis will certainly be appealed to the Supreme Court. I’d be surprised if the to uphold this ruling.
- sneak 6y agohttp://www.hasjamesclapperbeenindictedyet.com/ http://www.hasjamesclapperbeenindictedyet.com/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- parsimo2010 6y agoSince there are multiple comments about how the US government must/should pardon Snowden now, I'd like to make a top level comment to clarify some things about how this does not obligate the government to change his status. 1. The court only found that a single program exposed by Snowden was illegal. Snowden released a bunch of other information that was a violation of the NDA he signed when he was given a security clearance. 2. Even if all the information he disclosed revealed illegal activity, Snowden's actions make him ineligible for whistleblower protection. Whistleblower protection for the intelligence community[1] is only provided if a person follows the proper procedure to securely notify their Inspector General and/or Congress. Since he's not automatically protected, it would take Congress or the President to decide to offer him protection. Snowden (allegedly) did not even attempt to notify the proper authorities before going public with the information, so not only is he ineligible, it's not likely that anyone will take pity on him. 3. There's a chance that this ruling won't stick as the legal system chugs along and a few more judges look at it, and even if they were willing to help Snowden, nobody in Congress is going to take action until there is some permanence with the ruling. IANAL, but I think this would be decided if the Supreme Court either decides to decline or hear the case. If it's declined, then it's pretty much final. If they decide to hear the case, then it could be another year or so before they make a decision. [1] IC whistleblower protection is a little different than standard whistleblower protection: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_Community_Whistleblower_Protection_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_Community_Whistle...
- syshum 6y ago1. All of the other things he exposed should also be illegal 2. He tried they denied him. I think the entire process of "exposing" illegal acts that has to be done through the very system that is committing the illegal acts is asinine, and anyone that is defending that process is complacent in the abuse of human rights 3. Highlighting the pure and total corruption that is the 3 branches of government, no longer is there a check and balance they have combined into a single corrupt abusive state
- raxxorrax 6y agoI think this is true and that is why fleeing to Russia was the correct choice. Because the whistle blower channels don't work.
- nabla9 6y agoI think it's time to get into discussing how Snowden should be judged or pardoned. (1) There is no question that he broke the law, he is not denying it. (2) There is very strong evidence and argument to be made that legal routes were blocked and/or broken and the only way forward was to go public outside the US. Snowden paid attention to what happened to three earlier attempts to report illeagal activity using leagal means in the NSA global surveillance program–Roark, Binney, Wiebe, Drake and Loomis–for example. They complained to their superiors, to the NSA general counsel, to the Defense Department Inspector General Office, and to both the Senate and the House intelligence committees. The DoD Inspector General Office violated confidentiality agreement and gave their names to the FBI and falsely accused them of leaking. FBI raided their houses and started to investigate them instead. Pardon exists just for cases like this. Breaking the law for common good can be morally justified, even heroic.
- harry8 6y agoCrimes are no issue for the persecution of Snowden. Clapper lied, on camera, under oath, admitted it and has had zero consequences. Kept his job. Has not had to defend a prosecution. Now he's using is former position and influence to get rich. It's lawbreaking from the top. Nothing to discuss about it. Sadly the rule of law and equality before it is a thing that needs to be re-established.
- chrisbennet 6y agoI doubt Snowden was ignorant about what happened to those who "followed the rules". Their lives were ruined and nothing changed. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/22/how-pentagon.. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/22/how-pentagon.... "None of the lawful whistleblowers who tried to expose the government’s warrantless surveillance – and Drake was far from the only one who tried – had any success,” Devine told me. “They came forward and made their charges, but the government just said, ‘They’re lying, they’re paranoid, we’re not doing those things.’ And the whistleblowers couldn’t prove their case because the government had classified all the evidence. Whereas Snowden took the evidence with him, so when the government issued its usual denials, he could produce document after document showing that they were lying. That is civil disobedience whistleblowing.”
- defnotashton2 6y agoAll of this legal infighting is our tax payer dollars fighting tax payer dollars to stop the spending of tax payer dollars on the spying of the tax payers..
- prtkgpt 6y agoOf course, it was. Snowden has been saying it for years now. May be Prezi DJT will pardon him.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ashjsf 6y agoObama-Biden administration was wrong on this issue.
- merricksb 6y agoHuge discussion still active on the front page: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24356741 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24356741
- oxymoran 6y agoOk but what is going to change? Is anybody going to be held accountable? Is Snowden going to be pardoned? If the answer is no to any/all of this, then this is just window dressing.