10 ms·
The Economics of Skyscraper Height
- renewiltord 6y agoAll new skyscrapers will come only in high-growth places, not high-wealth places. IMHO that's because high-wealth places will settle down to generalized universal veto and stagnation. High-growth places haven't yet had a chance for established players to stall everything. The reason why we won't have NYC or SF looking like Star Trek¹ is that the people are already wealthy and they chose to live here in the way it is so the people who would want Star Trek SF won't come to present-day SF to make it into Star Trek SF. Star Trek SF may be some unassuming town in America or (more likely) one of the emerging economies: maybe East Asia, but maybe if African nations capture their demographic dividend (unlikely IMHO) maybe them. ¹ I will have someone LongBets this on my behalf if someone wants to take the other side. San Francisco will never be like Star Trek's hyper-developed San Francisco. Willing to nail down specifics too. EDIT: Maybe I should make an exception for high-wealth places with dictators/monarchs. There they can bypass any normal human process. EDIT 2: No bets. Bets are off. Looks like I'd just lose money on this one because of NYC.
- jariel 6y ago??? NYC is full of skyscrapers. It may not have 'ultra high' buildings, but those exist for different reasons and the economics are different. SF has earthquakes and a shifty foundation which is material.
- dmurray 6y agoThe right explanation for New York might be that what the "already wealthy people who choose to live in New York the way it is" already expressed their preference, and it's for a city full of skyscrapers. The theory makes some sense if you have a wealthy city that's remained stubbornly low-rise (Paris?). But if you love NYC you probably like the skyscrapers, rather than viewing them as a necessary evil.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoEmpire State Building for example, was built in 1930 and finished a year or so later. NYC predates the nimby movement but not the industrial revolution.
- renewiltord 6y agoRight, my claim is that NYC will not get many more tall towers. It's settling down into a state where there will be few more.
- marc__1 6y agoI believe your hypothesis is not entirely correct. 9 of the 10 tallest buildings in NYC are to be completed between 2000 and 2021. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tallest_buildings_in_New_York_City https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tallest_buildings_in_N... In Europe, if you exclude Russia from the top 20 tallest buildings, the UK (2), Germany (2) and Spain (2) have the tallest buildings, with the UK and Spain buildings built in the 2000s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tallest_buildings_in_Europe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tallest_buildings_in_E...
- renewiltord 6y agoWelp! Thank you! Boy am I glad no one fleeced me on the bet, eh?
- jamiek88 6y agoYou have a refreshing way of accepting when you are wrong, it is a joy to witness on these here pipes.
- Animats 6y agoNew York City has built 50 new skyscrapers in the last 5 years.[1] Including 432 Park Avenue, taller than the Empire State Building. It's an apartment building. Modeled after a trash can. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tallest_buildings_in_New_York_City https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tallest_buildings_in_N...
- renewiltord 6y agoI like 432 Park Ave! It looks very cool, in my opinion, like a rendering error. The 50 new skyscrapers does directly falsify my idea, though. Let me quickly edit so I don't get taken for a ride on the bet.
- gumby 6y agoOnly a small part of nyc has skyscrapers.
- 082349872349872 6y agoIt may no longer be true, but it used to be that one could map the underlying geology via the bioturbation, observing the skyline: the part of Manhattan with skyscrapers was the part with near-surface bedrock.
- fnord77 6y ago> SF has earthquakes and a shifty foundation which is material. Maybe I am misunderstanding your post? Skyscrapers are possible in SF. The Salesforce tower is 1,070 feet tall. They did have to go down 300 feet to anchor to bedrock, though.
- zamfi 6y ago> The reason why we won't have NYC or SF looking like Star Trek¹ is that the people are already wealthy and they chose to live here in the way it is so the people who would want Star Trek SF won't come to present-day SF to make it into Star Trek SF I'm not so sure about this -- the people who've moved to SF in the last 10 years have absolutely changed SF, and did not move to SF because they liked the way it is; they moved here because of work.
- jychang 6y agoThat's a bad bet to take, if only because of black swan events. If an earthquake or something decimates SF, it'll have a much higher chance of being rebuilt differently.
- renewiltord 6y agoWell, what you're saying is it's a bad bet to make. But that's what makes bets interesting. So, interested on taking the other side?
- andrewem 6y agoIf I'm not mistaken, even in Star Trek (at least Enterprise) Marin County has still been NIMBYed and has basically no development.
- majormajor 6y agoI think we see a slowdown in creating of "iconic" buildings in the US because of reasons like this - not just NIMBYism but because there's less need to replace stuff that's already built - but I think you overlook a couple things (in addition to the ongoing construction in NY discussed below): 1) A lot of what makes up Manhattan or SF today won't last forever. Cramming new stuff in is hitting points of diminishing returns. But as those buildings get more and more aged and/or obsolete, there's gonna be a higher need that doesn't exist today. 2) The Star Trek time frame is really long! NIMBY's a hundred or two hundred years from now will probably have very different tolerances for what they'd be willing to see created.
- viscanti 6y ago> All new skyscrapers will come only in high-growth places, not high-wealth places. IMHO that's because high-wealth places will settle down to generalized universal veto and stagnation. How would we reconcile that prediction with Billionaires Row in Manhattan that was a high-wealth place but not a high-growth place that has built a number of residential skyscrapers recently. What's changed from the example that disproves your hypothesis to the near future?
- renewiltord 6y agoWe would reconcile it by saying that the hypothesis as it stands is falsified. HAHA
- pvg 6y agoLooks like I'd just lose money on this one because of NYC. Isn't the more accurate way of saying this 'My argument is wrong'?
- renewiltord 6y agoI like my style of writing and I'll probably stick to it. I think it's more enjoyable. But if it's not clear for any reason, here we go: I was wrong.
- pvg 6y agoI'm not really commenting on your style, just that the operative thing is the wrongness, not the existence of New York, that's all.
- renewiltord 6y agoHaha, I thought it was quite clear that the statement was an amusing way to say "NYC proves the wrongness" but your feedback is welcome. Thank you.
- 627467 6y agoIf humans are to minimize impact on the rest of the ecosystem I don't see how that is compatible with NO SKYCRAPERS. In long run I think it will make sense both economically and in reducing human footprint on earth[0]. Making high density living bearable and even desirable that's the art we need (and millenia of urbanization has been about) to master. [0] I'm aware that dense cities are not automatically more sustainable. But I suspect is easier to achieve sustainability due to proximity.
- farnsworth 6y agoI think you're right and it's also important to note that high density cities do not necessarily have to be cities full of skyscrapers. Old cities with narrow streets between short buildings can be very dense. American cities tend to put huge 4+ lane roads everywhere, and require setbacks on buildings, and this has a big impact on density and the distance you have to walk to get anywhere, but if you are accustomed to that, you hardly notice it. It's possible to build sustainable density on the "human scale".
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoHaving a lot of space between buildings is actually necessary if you're going to have 50 story buildings for reasons of light and fresh air. But not everything has to be Manhattan. We could get appreciable increases in density merely by rezoning a lot of single-family housing to allow for five and ten story buildings, which don't require that level of offsets.
- 627467 6y agoI have lived in south China (extreme high rise and skyscrapers), a global city in Europe (mid rise) and south America (a sprawling mid rise city with lots of cars). I'd say the south Asia felt much more human scale due to easy access to parks, untouched hills and nature in general. South American sprawl was the worst in terms of easy access to 'nature'. So I guess it depends what you consider human scale.
- farnsworth 6y ago
- siculars 6y agoThe commercial real estate collapse we are just at the beginning of will definitely limit skyscraper height. See Pinterest paying $100mm to break their lease in a new development in SF. See AOC limiting new AMZN business, major banks distributing their work force in NYC.
- sthnblllII 6y agoIm curious to know why this would be downvoted. Everyone has spent the last 6 months talking about the end of offices and “work from home”. Can someone elaborate?
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoMy guess is it was due to the AOC part. Any mention of a politician by name in the US brings forth emotional responses and the responses to her in particular, pro or con, tend to be extra emotional.
- erentz 6y agoI didn’t downvote but I’d also guess it’s not just the mention of a name but 1) it’s kind of hyperbolic to say AOC did that, (she must be extreme powerful indeed!), 2) it doesn’t seem congruent with the point of the comment about the commercial real estate collapse which is not something driven by a representative from Queens but driven by a pandemic and increasing realization by businesses that it’s cheaper to put their workforces elsewhere or in their homes.
- refurb 6y agoMy hypothesis is that the whole work from home will fizzle out pretty quickly for most people, with the exception of a few tech companies. Anecdotally, my company did a survey (10k+ employees) and the vast majority didn't want full-time work from home in perpetuity. I think it works well for some industries and functions, but it's an absolute cluster for others. Add in the inevitable "COL adjustment" for people who live in LCOL areas, it will be a few percentage of employees who make a permanent change. Once Covid is a thing of the past, we'll see the vast majority of people return to work in an office - likely with a lot more "work from home" flexibility, but still an expectation that they are in the office for some percentage of their work week. Just my 2 cents. I could be entirely wrong.
- Havoc 6y agoAnd then covid comes along and says >How are you going to get elevators up beyond 5 floors and social distance?
- joe_the_user 6y agoMasks and well-designed ventilation systems seem like a reasonable approach. Btw, there are reasonable arguments that density was not the primary driving factor for Covid in NYC. see: https://chpcny.org/density-and-covid-19/ https://chpcny.org/density-and-covid-19/
- kevindong 6y agoMy apartment building has ~50 residential floors (each floor holding ~7 units) and 4 elevators. Each elevator is sufficiently large enough to let two unrelated groups be in the elevator while maintaining 6 feet. Something like 60% of the time I'm by myself and 20% of the time I can maintain reasonable distance. Furthermore, <1 minute of exposure is unlikely to spread covid.
- renewiltord 6y agoAsk the folks from Taipei, I suppose. Since they've solved this one.
- oska 6y agoThey solved it by almost completely stopping Covid-19 at the border. So while there are indeed many lessons to learn from Taiwan, I doubt they are the people to look to for how to deal with large numbers of undetected infected persons using elevators.
- renewiltord 6y agoPerhaps the Koreans or the Japanese, then. Or perhaps we can wait ten years for a New York Times article describing a scientific paper, billed "The unreasonable effectiveness of masking to fight last decade's pandemic". It could perhaps start with a few chapters on how "When I was 18, I'd planned to take the summer off to go to the Pyrenees" followed by how the author rarely ever fell sick. Halfway through, there'll be some text about how "But the culture of mask wearing in Asia led to far lower viral loads for those exposed, scientists say, allowing them to fight off the disease. Few, if any, actually fell ill. But in my hometown..." and then some folksy take on what their hometown is like. A small town in Ohio is a good one. "By the time scientists had realized the value of face masks, that hometown had been ravaged by both disease and closures". Now you can insert some tale about a local diner that was open for 50 years and now had to close. Approximately 1400 words later you can quote a few papers that revealed that with universal masking risk of infection is remarkably low. It will be an unprecedented discovery. Then a few Taboola ads at the bottom about how "This new garment will take the world by storm" with someone wearing a mask. And then we can discuss it on HN. If you remember me then, make sure to link to this comment.
- natcombs 6y ago>> Contrary to popular belief, most skyscrapers have a strong economic rational. I doubt there is a popular belief that says "tall skyscrapers do not have an economic rational". Really weird starting point to make this article
- amadeuspagel 6y agoCan't say how popular this belief is, but I've heard it before.
- jpxw 6y agoYep, also should be “rationale” rather than “rational”.
- SilasX 6y agolol yeah it seems like good fodder for /r/imaginarygatekeeping, which catalogs refutations of stereotypes that no one actually makes.
- mimixco 6y agoVegas isn't mentioned anywhere in the article (which focuses on NYC) but it seems particularly relevant. Why do I suspect that, had more effort gone into computing the "economic height" of some Vegas hotels and condos, they would have been built smaller -- or not all all (Fontainebleu/The Drew, I'm looking at you. Resorts World is in this bucket, too.)
- PostThisTooFast 6y agoHas this been revised for the post-COVID era?
- jackdaw12 6y agoThis has to be the most tortured definition of a histogram: "Now imagine that you were a giant and could “harvest” all the world’ skyscrapers and put them into a jumbo pile—like a child might make a pile of sticks of various lengths. Now in our little game, we pick up each skyscraper (stick) and measure its height. Then we place it in one of several bins or buckets. The first bucket will contain buildings that range from 150 to 199 meters. The second contains buildings 200 to 248 and so on. The last bucket ranges from 788 to 836 meters, and which contains the Burj Khalifa at 0.828 km tall."
- woodpanel 6y agoI think much of the "popular belief" against skyscrapers is unknowingly influenced by reactionary thinkers of the 20th century's second half. The shrillest thinking but/thus the most influential is this moronic idea of phallus symbols. According to which, they are a power tool for the patriachy, which albeit being so powerful the patriachy is simoultaniously so immature that it can't refrain from playing with its genitalia in public. The fact that this phallus idiocy is virtually non-rebuked in academia and still considered established, tells you about the influence on popular belief the reactionaries have had. On the contrary, skyscrapers are a sign of a culture's virtousness. Which is why dictators (and also immature policy makers [1]) throughout modern history try to emulate the skylines of these cities [2], but never achieve it [3]. Their artificial skylines either look like an experiment gone bad [4, 5], consist of only a few (one) tall buildings [6] or are confined to some "new business district" on the outskirts of their capital [7, 8]. There are other moronic reactionary, influential, ideas like the one of "clouding" ("Verschattung"), according to which because of skyscrapers we're either dying from Vitamin D deficiency or because of sadness because we can't see our monuments anymore. This is ignoring the fact that a 2 story building is already enough to cast a shadow upon you, thus in most old towns you were already unable to see any landmarks and already were "clouded" (in warmer areas even intentionally). On the contrary, while most skyscrapers will look functional, many achieve a democratization of identity, in that they enable more people see their city's icons. [1] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikingturm https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikingturm [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_Sisters_(Moscow) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_Sisters_(Moscow) [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ryugyong_Hotel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ryugyong_Hotel [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oriental_Pearl_Tower https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oriental_Pearl_Tower [5] http://www.globalpostmark.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/2011-March-China_0410.jpg http://www.globalpostmark.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/201... [6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nabemba_Tower https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nabemba_Tower [7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_City_(businnes_center) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_City_(businnes_center) [8] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nur-Sultan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nur-Sultan
- 082349872349872 6y agoTIL "yonic architecture" is a productive image search term. Not sure if parametricist cat pics =.= are any improvement on Sphynx pics