6 ms·
Do-it-Yourself Vaccines for Covid-19
- bArray 6y agoI distinctly remember that Scientists researching Ebola ended up getting Ebola - and perhaps the same for Zika too. I also know many people who work in the field of Psychology whom have the condition they research to some degree. I have zero idea how ethical any of it really is, but, it exists out there. It seems like something that should at least be declared in any research outcomes.
- scottlocklin 6y agoTLDR: gasbags oppose scientists brewing their own vaccines for specious reasons. "A second misconception is the idea that this is research that could benefit others." "Senior scientists benefit from many layers of privilege: investment in their education, expertise in specialized areas, and access to information or materials. Arguably, these privileges come with a responsibility to use expertise for the benefit of society. " Seriously, while there may be good reasons this behavior is unethical or bad or whatever, the clowns who wrote this disjointed nonsense are apparently unable to discover them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoI guess you didn't get the memo that only approved experts can do "science" now[0]. Return to your pod and await further instruction from the authorities. [0]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2020/07/30/you-must-not-do-your-own-research-when-it-comes-to-science/#665e06cf535e https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2020/07/30/you-...
- scottlocklin 6y agoThe levels of insanity among "muh experts" is really reaching some kind of escape velocity of stupid. On a given subject we've traditionally delegated to "experts" I might as well ask a fry cook or stevedore.
- cwhiz 6y ago>Some scientists are self-administering an untested product. Is that legal? Yes, of course. Obviously. >Some scientists are self-administering an untested product. Is it ethical? Who cares? They are self administering. This whole article can be summed up to "Bureaucrats are annoyed that some scientists aren't playing ball with their giant piles of unnecessary paperwork and invented regulations."
- adventured 6y agoSome scientists are engineering a new, more potent version of smallpox, in their home lab; who cares? Some scientists are building a gene drive using a highly infectious airborne virus to deliver it, testing the ability to wipe out humanity; who cares? I do, I care. For the same reason I care if some scientists make the mistake of creating a lot of new strains of SARS-CoV-2 that are more difficult to vaccinate against. Russia's potentially dangerously rushed vaccine is an example of this behavior in action by a very large state actor. Without proper large scale testing (and over enough time to make the necessary observations in the population) they could screw up and unleash a new dominant version of the virus that our in-development vaccines will not work well against, significantly setting back global vaccination efforts.
- castis 6y agoSurely you see the difference between developing and giving yourself a coronavirus vaccine, and engineering a new smallpox virus. Anyone can screw up, trained professionals in every field make mistakes.
- cwhiz 6y agoThat's quite the sensationalist take. How did you travel from "doctors self injecting a covid vaccine" to "doctors may accidentally wipe out humanity?"
- jfoster 6y agoAn incomplete vaccine can apply evolutionary pressure on the virus. From my understanding that's probably not so likely if just a few scientists use their own vaccine (someone more knowledgeable please correct me if I'm wrong), but may be a valid concern regarding some countries rushing through vaccines that have had limited testing. (eg. the Russia example) I'm just repeating what I've heard, as I don't have specialist knowledge of this area, but one logical problem that occurred to me about this was whether the breadth of coverage of a vaccine is even testable. I would love to know how that gets tested in trials, because what I've heard about how vaccines are assessed has sounded a lot more primitive than anything that would indicate breadth of immunity.
- leemailll 6y agohttps://www.technologyreview.com/2020/07/29/1005720/george-church-diy-coronavirus-vaccine/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/07/29/1005720/george-c... This article gives more details
- roenxi 6y agoAlso notably in this article; major life saving discoveries would have been delayed. Maybe we'd still be arguing if bacteria cause gastritis and peptic ulcers. "Improving" the ethics of medical research will have a cost of 10s of thousands if not hundreds of thousands of lives. Maybe more. Entire towns worth of people condemned to disease and suffering. I disagree with any ethics system that thinks that is a good outcome.
- Metacelsus 6y agoBased on my understanding of immunology I don't think this peptide nasal spray is very likely to be an effective vaccine. In order to actually trigger an immune response, the peptides would need to get taken up by cells and displayed on MHCs. I don't think simply spraying them into the nose will be good enough. It's an interesting idea but I think they should test it on animal models before dosing humans.
- jhou2 6y agoWell, I think they're trying to stimulate mucosal immunity, rather than trigger MHC presentation. But yes, more research is needed to determine effectiveness. "This highlights one important advantage of an intranasal vaccine: a robust mucosal immune response should greatly reduce or prevent this systemic response by abrogating initial infection."
- garraeth 6y agoI'd like to suggest a title change to somehow illuminate the fact that scientists are the ones doing it themselves, not the general public.
- James_Henry 6y agoThere are "non-scientists" who are doing this too, though they aren't highlighted by the article. Zayner: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-06-25/one-bioha.. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-06-25/one-bioha.... Justin Atkin: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HjDH6bXF4ow&t=67m47s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HjDH6bXF4ow&t=67m47s
- motohagiography 6y agoGood of them to do it, and I admire the risk taking aspect of it. however, it's a gambit and a forcing function, where it comes down to the researchers word they tested on themselves, presumably to achieve a fast tracking of some sort, or to force a decision point. I can think of a lot of people whose word they tested something on themselves would be suspect, especially in a situation where it was in a situation with a high cost to reverse the decision they were forcing. In negotiations, it's called a commitment ploy. So some scientists would I take their word, sure. Most? Absolutely not.
- donor20 6y agoGood lord - we have an opiod crisis - thousands overdosing and commercial providers making billions and a larger drug and alcohol abuse problems (plenty of folks injecting and drinking things they shouldn't). - we have a pandemic - thousands dying and millions impacted. Thousands not even wearing masks, going to covid parties etc. And we get this - legal and ethical issues around someone taking some pretty innocuous stuff that may or may not reduce various risks around exposure where there are public benefits - and taking it themselves. Has the US become the country of can't do news writers, outraged and offended at everything. We get it - don't wear masks - they don't help, take off your mask if healthy, don't get tested unless you traveled to china. How about trying out some of these ideas (testing, mask wearing, vaccines)?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- m348e912 6y agoHere's my own personal vaccine for Covid-19: A daily dose of zinc plus a zinc ionophore, as been shown to prevent or lessen the effects of coronavirus (not just Covid-19)[0] An ionophore is a fat-soluble substance that can transport non-fat soluble elements across the cell membrane. Zinc-ionophores are zinc transporters in and out of the cell and can increase the effects of zinc in the cell. There are several zinc ionophore options: Prescription: Ivermectin, (Hydroxy)Chloroquine Over the counter: Quercetin, EgCg (Epigallocatechin Gallate), Reservatrol Personally I take quercetin and zinc every day and wear a mask in public just so others feel comfortable. [0] Just google coronavirus and zinc ionophore
- pax 6y agowhoa, detail from: 'Many cardiac procedures are based on a 1929 experiment by a German doctor who inserted a catheter into his own heart' > In 1929 the physician Werner Forssmann saw a picture in a book showing how a tube was inserted into the heart of a horse through a vein. A balloon at the other end of the tube showed changes in pressure. He was convinced that a similar experiment could be carried out on people. Despite the fact that his boss forbade him, Werner Forssmann conducted the experiment on himself. From the crook of his arm he inserted a thin catheter through a vein into his heart and took an X-ray photo. The experiment paved the way for many types of heart studies. nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1956/forssmann/facts/ > He persuaded the operating-room nurse in charge of the sterile supplies, Gerda Ditzen, to assist him. She agreed, but only on the promise that he would do it on her rather than on himself. However, Forssmann tricked her by restraining her to the operating table and pretending to locally anaesthetise and cut her arm whilst actually doing it on himself [more] reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/hbjm5w/til_the_first_man_to_perform_a_cardiac/fv96mpo/