3 ms·
It's a tautology. You cannot observe time slowing down, because anything that would affect the "speed of time" affects your brain also in the same proportion.
by jiggawatts 6y ago
It's a tautology. You cannot observe time slowing down, because anything that would affect the "speed of time" affects your brain also in the same proportion.
Hollywood movies are not how physics works. The plucky protagonist can never look down at their hand and see a stopwatch run slower or faster! There is no such thing. If some sort of science-fiction field existed that would affect a clock, it would affect the protagonist also.
If the clock runs at half speed, your brain runs at half speed, so you see it ticking forward at twice the rate, and 2.0 * 0.5 = 1.
Now, of course, I tell a small lie: There can be differences in the tick rate over some distance. But these differences are necessarily small. Big differences in the rate of temporal flow create gravity, as per Einstein's General Relativity. To get an observable difference in time flow over the space of, say, a meter would require a fantastically huge gravitational field that would instantly crush the poor scientists into a pancake.
Conversely, in the gentle field of Earth's gravitational field, if you hold an atomic clock in your hand a meter from you head, and an atomic clock in line with your head, then yes, you can see a tiny difference in the tick rates, on the order of nanoseconds per century or somesuch (I'm too lazy to work it out).
However, as the distance decreases between the clock and the observer, the difference gets smaller. Extrapolating down to atoms and the like the conclusion is inevitable: time locally always ticks forward at one second per second.
- rl3 6y ago>If the clock runs at half speed, your brain runs at half speed, so you see it ticking forward at twice the rate, and 2.0 * 0.5 = 1.0 Consider changes in gravity affect cognition. Likewise, if the brain has any quantum mechanisms, then that 1.0 might not be exactly 1.0.
- jiggawatts 6y ago> Consider changes in gravity affect cognition. That is literally what it does. It slows down cognition. In the exact same way that it slows down clocks. The "clock in your brain" and the "watch in your hand" are all operating on the same physical and chemical principles. It's all just atoms and electromagnetic interactions at the lowest levels. > Likewise, if the brain has any quantum mechanisms Again, this is a pop-science misunderstanding of all of physics, not just Quantum Mechanics (QM). The rules of QM either apply to everything or nothing. The laws of the universe do not begin or end at the edge of the laboratory bench top. Similarly, there are no special rules that apply to just the human brain. The rules that govern galaxies, particle beams, atomic clocks, mechanical watches, and human observers are the same. They all tick along at the same rate. One second per second, locally at least.
- tsimionescu 6y ago> The rules of QM either apply to everything or nothing. The laws of the universe do not begin or end at the edge of the laboratory bench top. Similarly, there are no special rules that apply to just the human brain. Well, for now we don't really know how the rules of QM apply to macroscopic objects. The exact physical interpretation of wave-function collapse (if any) is still a matter of speculation, with all options still being on the table - maybe there is no collapse (e.g. many worlds theory), maybe there exists a collapse when interacting with large enough systems (measurement - the Copenhagen interpretation), maybe collapse is a physical process that happens at precise scales (Roger Penrose seems to believe something like this), maybe the wave function is a physical wave (pilot wave theory) and there is no collapse in another way.
- jiggawatts 6y ago> Well, for now we don't really know how the rules of QM apply to macroscopic objects Sure we do, "we" just refuse to acknowledge this, keeping a 100 year old debate alive for no good reason. Macroscopic objects follow microscopic rules. That's that. There's no further debate. There can be none. I can't even begin to describe how absurd it is to argue anything else. It's like... saying with a straight face that software doesn't "really" follow the rules of boolean algebra if it has enough lines of code. That somehow once a program gets "big enough", it can transcend truth tables and somehow go analog or something. It's like a mathematician saying that really big equations, the kind that span several pages stop following the rules of algebra. Get it? It's just... insane. The rules of the universe are the rules for all things in it. They apply to everything, at all scales, at all times. If they don't, they're not the rules!
- tsimionescu 6y agoHave you ever observed an interference pattern for tennis balls? Have you ever been unable to place a stationary object in space because you knew it's velocity? Furthermore, leaving behind direct observations which could perhaps be waved away with discussions of probabilities, we have one big problem: there is no gravity in QM and we have no idea how to account for it or curved spacetime in QM. So for now, we have one working model for the macroscopic world (general relativity) and one for the microscopic world (QM), but the two are mathematically incompatible, they can't be simultaneously true, and we have not yet found an experiment which contradicts either of them.
- dreamcompiler 6y ago> Conversely, in the gentle field of Earth's gravitational field, if you hold an atomic clock in your hand a meter from you head, and an atomic clock in line with your head, then yes, you can see a tiny difference in the tick rates, on the order of nanoseconds per century or somesuch (I'm too lazy to work it out). This is why GPS satellites need time correction. GPS satellites contain atomic clocks, and they are further from the center of the Earth than you are. Therefore they experience slightly less gravity than you do. Therefore their clocks run slightly faster than atomic clocks on Earth's surface. That's the General Relativity correction. But GPS satellites also move a lot faster than you do, because they are in orbit. That makes their clocks run slower than clocks on the ground. That's the Special Relativity correction. Both corrections have different signs but they do not cancel each other out.