5 ms·
I think the main difference here is that Musk's other ventures are all about technologies that already existed, but were prohibitively expensive or difficult to
by kelnos 6y ago
I think the main difference here is that Musk's other ventures are all about technologies that already existed, but were prohibitively expensive or difficult to sell to a mass audience. He and his companies have done great things to promote these technologies, and to refine the tech to make it cheaper and more sustainable, not to mention fighting entrenched players who have a financial interest in seeing him fail.
But figuring out how the brain works and how to interpret its signals using a computer is in a completely different league. Maybe he'll prevail nonetheless -- he's assembled some really smart people in the field to tackle the problem -- but I think it's reasonable to remain skeptical at this point.
- paulyacoubian 6y agoYes exactly! He prefaced his presentation by saying the purpose of it is to attract the more talent. That’s the right move but by definition it will be very promotional in order to convey a vision for engineering things that are physically possible but face significant engineering hurdles. To get this technology to work as envisioned will require hundreds of technical breakthroughs across many fields.
- pxtail 6y ago> by definition it will be very promotional in order to convey a vision I think that this is where Musk's endeavors are different and why Tesla stock prices are constant source of disbelief. He is able to successfully sell grand vision - and moreover - support it by showing results. Sure there is good old Toyota, it makes good reliable cars but it's just a car, there is no vision - I think that some people may want to buy Tesla or other Musk's company product just to indirectly support other projects. > true scientists lose their jobs because of the lack of NIH or NSF grants for their quality research Advertising and marketing is important. Doing things in the open does matter, live streaming double booster landing, pointing out that small steps here and there lead to big grand dream of landing on other planet does matter.
- newyankee 6y agoI am skeptical but hopeful as the technology can make a big personal difference for me. However i think one must be happy that someone is tackling the problem in the way Elon is doing.
- kelnos 6y agoAgreed! We're not going to get anywhere if we don't work on the problem. But I think people are expecting Neuralink to put an AI in their brain in 10 or 20 years, which isn't realistic. And sure, as another commenter posted, a monkey could control a prosthetic back in 2008, but even now controlling a prosthetic with your brain is fatiguing to the point that you can't do it for very long. Time and research will improve that, but I think people are expecting that on a pretty short timeline too.
- ofou 6y agoIn a loosely sense, this is also a very old technology but refined. There are some fotages of monkeys able to brain control a prothetic arm back in 2008 on Youtube. [1] So, what they're currently doing is just an update on steroids from old science. It will remain a mistery to me if they'll be able to crack some basic science about consciousness as Hodak pointed out. The side effect while developing this tech will produce improvement of countless lives. That is highly doable, no doubts about that. [1]: https://youtu.be/sm2d0w87wQE?t=49 https://youtu.be/sm2d0w87wQE?t=49
- Balgair 6y agoNot only can you have animals control stuff, but you can control the animals with just thoughts too: https://www.cnet.com/news/scientists-connect-a-human-brain-and-rat-cyborg-brain-together/ https://www.cnet.com/news/scientists-connect-a-human-brain-a... Intercontinental control via human-brain to rat-brain happened in 2016: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0060410 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal... Heck, you can buy a controller kit for roaches right now, marketed for the kiddos: https://backyardbrains.com/products/roboroach https://backyardbrains.com/products/roboroach If you'd like, you can also hook your brain up to the cockroach : https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0150667 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- kelnos 6y agoThis kind of control is nothing compared to what Neuralink has set out to do. Also note that all of these existing brain control devices are incredibly fatiguing. You get minutes of use before you just can't do it anymore. That's light years away from embedding an AI in someone's brain. Their goal isn't steroids on old science, it's all the steroids in the entire world, plus all the cocaine in the entire world, plus all the caffeine in the entire world... and then some. Also not sure how 12 years old is considered "old technology", when we're comparing this to SpaceX, that has been improving on tech originally developed in the 1960s.
- Isinlor 6y agoRetro-propulsive landing of an orbital class booster has not been ever demonstrated. Falcon 9 First Stage is the only booster that ever existed able to do it. The full-flow staged combustion rocket engine is also a new technology that will fly for the first time in Super Heavy Starship. Rocket science is literally a synonym with "difficult". Here you have how SpaceX looked like in 2002: https://i.redd.it/00ikcxo2z0f01.jpg https://i.redd.it/00ikcxo2z0f01.jpg My guess is that in 20 years people will be also saying how he took an existing technology and sold it to a mass audience.
- garmaine 6y agoDC-X.
- puranjay 6y ago> Here you have how SpaceX looked like in 2002: https://i.redd.it/00ikcxo2z0f01.jpg https://i.redd.it/00ikcxo2z0f01.jpg I've seen that dancing Elon picture everywhere but now I finally know the source. Thanks for sharing!
- mempko 6y agoYou should compare apples to apples right? SpaceX is a government contractor. The question is, in 18 years as a contractor, have they done more impressive work than other contractors. It took them 18 years to send people to space. Is that impressive for a military contractor? Just for context, project Mercury took 3 years to send someone to space. The sad thing about SpaceX is that because NASA was tasked to build a commercial space industry (funding SpaceX and others) they slowed the pace of development of the technology by limiting the funds. I'm sure if NASA made SpaceX and it's other contractors cooperate, the funds would have been spent more efficiently too.
- sitkack 6y ago> project Mercury took 3 years to send someone to space. On Nazi rockets. It wasn't from scratch.
- zhoujianfu 6y ago