24 ms·
No... make daylight savings time permanent instead. As the paper states, the biggest problem is with the transition. The paper also argues that standard time
by crazygringo 6y ago
No... make daylight savings time permanent instead.
As the paper states, the biggest problem is with the transition.
The paper also argues that standard time aligns more naturally with our circadian rhythm... but doesn't bother to compare that with the psychological benefit we get from hanging out with friends in daylight after work in the summer, or the psychological benefit of it not being dark when you go home and have dinner with your family.
I totally get that people who wake up early in the winter prefer standard time... but it really seems that for the population as a whole, permanent DST is the better option. And implementing it is so easy: once we're already in DST in the summer... you just never "fall back" to standard in the fall.
- buzzy_hacker 6y agoI came here to make this exact comment. In New York, it gets dark around 4:30pm in the winter. It’s depressing. Keep the sunlight around longer!
- totaldude87 6y agoexactly this, often, when I look out from office window, it feels like the night is already on us, yet the watch says 5pm :(
- AtHeartEngineer 6y agoYes, summer time forever!
- mjevans 6y agoI prefer 'winter time', but would settle for just eliminating the shift. Shifting IS the worst. Heck even the orbital tilt changing the length of daylight in semi-northern latitudes is icky.
- wlesieutre 6y agoEliminate the orbital tilt!
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoPretty much how it seems at the equator. The whole year round: daylight then three minutes later BAM! night with bugger all twilight.
- petre 6y agoAt least that daylight change is gradual, it doesn't skip.
- Spooky23 6y agoThis. Circadian rhythms are based on local noon, not standard time. West coast people don’t get it, because they are mostly in the western half of the pacific time zone. There’s a big difference in daylight between Boston and Ohio... it’s really dark in Boston (Or any other place in the eastern frontier of their time zone) in the morning during standard time.
- geofft 6y agoSolar noon in Boston is somewhere between 11:27 and 11:58 EST (so an hour later EDT), but solar noon in San Francisco is somewhere between 11:53 and 12:23 PST. The earliest twilight in Boston is 4:11 PM; the earliest twilight in San Francisco is 4:50 PM (both in early December). That is, solar noon in San Francisco is pretty well lined up with civil noon or a bit later, and so DST makes it noticeably late, and our circadian rhythms prefer ending DST there. But solar noon in Boston is usually about half an hour earlier than civil time, which means that DST puts it just half an hour later instead. You have to pick one - either you're waking up half an hour earlier than your body wants, or you're staying at work half an hour later. Neither is really great. (The best solution might be to convince businesses in Boston to shift their schedules half an hour earlier - not a full hour earlier, as permanent DST does.)
- spideymans 6y agoThe only thing worse than eliminating the time shift, would be moving to permanent standard time (winter time). Make summer time (DST) permanent
- recursive 6y agoStrong disagree. Permanent winter time would be a huge improvement to currently. I'm not sure why people care which way it goes so much. Obviously, you're not losing total daylight either way. It's the shifting of schedules that causes problems. What difference does it make if the wall clock calls the time 7:00, 8:00, or purple:00?
- ponker 6y agoBecause people have to be at work which is coordinated to a “9-5” office workday and that will be harder to change than a clock.
- wnoise 6y ago> work which is coordinated to a “9-5” office workday and that will be harder to change than a clock. [citation needed]
- _ph_ 6y agoIsn't 9-5 already a reaction to DST? At least here in Germany, office and school hours used to start at 8 or even before that. Stores also used to open at 8. Nowadays, most of that has slipped to later times, many stores only open at 10 now. And people work longer. There is also discussion, to shift school times to later. If we just to back to standard time, it is easy to go back to the "old" times once and stay there forever.
- recursive 6y agoThis is probably the root of the disagreement. I'm pretty confident 9-5 is easier to change than the existence of DST.
- jb775 6y ago
- mumblemumble 6y agoI'm torn on this one. At the latitude where I live (northern Illinois), I both appreciate it staying light past 5pm in the winter, and would appreciate it staying dark past 5am in the summer. But I also spend some time further north, in northern Michigan, and there I'd sure be annoyed if the sun were still up at 10pm in the summer. And might be willing to accept a 4pm winter sunset in order to have the sun up before 8am - that far north, you won't be out much in the evening in the middle of winter, anyway, and shoveling the sidewalk before sunrise is just depressing. Then I realize that this is all kind of beating around the bush, and what I'd really like is an end to the USA's ridiculous culture of 9 hour work days and eating at one's desk, so that I could take a long lunch and use that to get my sunlight in winter. So, meh, I think that I really don't care between permanent standard and permanent daylight time, I just want to get rid of the changing.
- joe-collins 6y agoLet the federal government dictate a default time per state corresponding to longitude, as we have now. Each state can choose to operate at {-1, +0, +1} hours from baseline.
- labster 6y agoThree hour changes at the state line sounds like fun. I approve this plan.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y ago> sure be annoyed if the sun were still up at 10pm in the summer. It actually does that here in Launceston Tasmanian.. Not full sun, but definitely still twilight at 21:50. And your right: it's fucking irritating for a good three or four weeks. I need a sleep mask.
- pkphilip 6y agoCan't the federal govt leave the the time the way it is and just change the work time alone? Example: 8am-3pm during winters. 9am to 4pm during summers etc?
- Ericson2314 6y agoOn this matter, I do trust the Russians: https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-news-from-elsewhere-28423647 https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-news-from-elsewhere-28423647 I used to be pro "permanent summer time". But beyond the practical arguments above, there is a another reason. First of all, let's be clear that the the number is arbitrary if there are no transitions. It is stupid (as far as I can tell) that we waste the sunlight in the morning, getting more darkness at night. Switching to permanent summer time without tackling the underlying causes why are schedule shift backwards would seem to beget the same problem over again. Switching to winter time however might force us to confront the issue head on. e.g. Maybe we need to drastically curtail light pollution and require that consumer devises have opt-out red shift (if there is more evidence for it) and curfew modes.
- benrbray 6y agoIn my opinion this just hurts everyone, and requires us to make drastic changes to our work culture. Permanent DST is a simple band-aid fix that does a lot of good while we think carefully about solving the hard problems.
- Ericson2314 6y agoI do admit it could be a situation like how monetary policy is easier to do gracefully than across-the-board price controls. Keynesian time here we come!
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoConcur, because we spend most of the year in DST anyways. It's March through October. That's 8/12ths the year.
- throw0101a 6y agoMarch-November is actually a 'recent' change (2005/7): * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Policy_Act_of_2005#Change_to_daylight_saving_time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Policy_Act_of_2005#Chan... Previously it was April-October: 6/12. Some of us IT folks lived through updating all the various TZ files, which was quite an experience since a lot of things were not designed to be updated dynamically at the time.
- audiodude 6y agoI lived through the DST change and it was hell. Some servers got the Java update, some didn't....ugh.
- throw0101a 6y agoJava tzdata is now a separate thing probably because of this: * https://www.oracle.com/java/technologies/javase/tzupdater-readme.html https://www.oracle.com/java/technologies/javase/tzupdater-re... Keep the JRE/JDK the same to reduce the risk of code behaviour changes, but allow updates of the 'dynamic' data.
- stoolpigeon 6y agoI had an Oracle RAC cluster and a number of PeopleSoft servers that were incredibly difficult to get successfully patched for that change. The other super annoying thing about it is it created a window at the beginning and end of DST where the US is out of sync with most of Europe.
- realityking 6y agoI never understood how it came to be that the two biggest economic blocks with a ton of business between them didn’t manage to align on this. Thank you for finally giving me the context.
- echelon 6y agoIf we want to win this fight and keep DST year round, we need to get rid of the confusing "DST" moniker. Most people are entirely unaware of which is which, and they are focused on the time change aspect. We should phrase the battle as "Keep summer daylight" and "abolish winter early sunset". It's imperative that we spin it this way.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xyhopguy 6y agoin seattle that means sunrise at 9 and sunset at 515 in a place that's already hella dark. No thank you.
- echelon 6y agoSunset at 4:15 would kill my will to live. That's so depressing.
- xyhopguy 6y agowaking up 2 hours before sunrise is painful
- smabie 6y agoWaking up is always painful
- Dylan16807 6y agoIf you're waking up before sunrise, it's going to feel about the same no matter when sunrise is. And you'll have sun at lunch time except in extreme cases. So when days are short, mid-morning and afternoon are where the difference is really made. And I'd much rather have sunlight when I go home than have more mid-morning already-at-work/school sunlight.
- 6y ago
- amunir 6y agoPeople here must think of time very differently than I do, because this sounds like a strange idea to me. Consider if daylight saving time did not exist and you wanted to do things earlier or later. Wouldn't you suggest they be done earlier or later? You would not suggest moving the hours of the day ... right?
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoHow am I going to get out or work earlier? We run Just In Time manufacturing, there's no possibility going to work earlier than I already do: 05:30 for a 10 or 12 hour day. Never under estimate the ability of people to complain about the status quo.
- selestify 6y agoThat wouldn’t be a problem if work also shifted when it operates. Which is the point.
- geofft 6y agoYes, but that's the very idea behind daylight savings time too - it's easier to change the clock than to establish a norm that every organization opens and closes an hour earlier during the summer (or rather, the easiest way of establishing that norm is changing the clock). "Permanent DST," for similar reasons, is easier than having everyone do a one-time change of their schedules.
- LanceH 6y agoBut...this one goes to 11.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sgdpk 6y agoMy thoughts exactly. Keep 12pm at the time the sun is in its maximum and just do things earlier/later.
- throw0101a 6y ago> No... make daylight savings time permanent instead. There's been plenty of research on this and Standard ("Winter") Time is best for humans. A peer-reviewed paper with plenty of footnotes if you want to dig into the details / weeds: > Conclusion > In summary, the scientific literature strongly argues against the switching between DST and Standard Time and even more so against adopting DST permanently. The latter would exaggerate all the effects described above beyond the simple extension of DST from approximately 8 months/year to 12 months/year (depending on country) since body clocks are generally even later during winter than during the long photoperiods of summer (with DST) (Kantermann et al., 2007; Hadlow et al., 2014, 2018; Hashizaki et al., 2018). Perennial DST increases SJL prevalence even more, as described above. […] > Summary > Discrepancies and misalignments between social (local) clock time, sun clock time, and body clock time can be caused by political decisions: DST is one example. There are multiple health and safety consequences of these misalignments. Our goal is that this article’s facts and reasoning will be used to make clock choices that improve human lives. * https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fphys.2019.00944/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fphys.2019.0094... They explicitly state that always-DST is worse than the current switching regime. Various societies of chronobiologists recommend getting rid of DST completely: > The authors take the position that, based on comparisons of large populations living in DST or ST or on western versus eastern edges of time zones, the advantages of permanent ST outweigh switching to DST annually or permanently. Four peer reviewers provided expert critiques of the initial submission, and the SRBR Executive Board approved the revised manuscript as a Position Paper to help educate the public in their evaluation of current legislative actions to end DST. * http://www.chronobiology.ch/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/JBR-DST.pdf http://www.chronobiology.ch/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/JBR-D... * https://srbr.org/advocacy/daylight-saving-time-presskit/ https://srbr.org/advocacy/daylight-saving-time-presskit/ * https://esrs.eu/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/To_the_EU_Commission_on_DST.pdf https://esrs.eu/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/To_the_EU_Commiss... * https://old.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/dq2nv3/askscience_ama_series_we_are_researchers_studying/ https://old.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/dq2nv3/askscien... * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronobiology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronobiology If we're going to go through the drama of making this change (and some of us had to live through the 'Bush' DST change), then biologically speaking, the best current research says Standard Time is the way to go.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y ago> No... make daylight savings time permanent instead. I so want this, and doubly so in winter. Living at 41 degrees south, I spend too many weeks in a row going to work in the dark and leaving work in the dark. Maybe the trick is to spend the middle two weeks much further north.
- BeetleB 6y agoYou want to look at Indiana. Until recently they were on standard permanent time. Parts of the state were on central time and parts on Eastern. If you want to compare the effect of permanent daylight vs permanent standard then just look at cities near the boundary. Drive a few miles away and voila you're 1 hour ahead or behind - throughout the year. If one is better than the other, it will show up there.
- Cyphase 6y agoCouldn't this comparison be made at any timezone border? Two places, a clock-hour apart (usually), with basically the same sun schedule.
- TylerE 6y agoNo, the point is the time didn't change for people living in the same place.
- Cyphase 6y agoAh, I did miss that point, and that does slightly raise the value of data from areas like that. I still think there's a wealth of useful data of the same type that can be found at timezone borders. Many will have the transitions as a slight confounding factor, but it doesn't completely invalidate the applicability of the data. Comparing no-transition borders with transition borders might also yield some interesting findings.
- waterhouse 6y agoThe first results I find talk about this specific study, which measured electricity usage. It found that DST increased energy consumption by about 1%. https://www.nber.org/papers/w14429 https://www.nber.org/papers/w14429
- petre 6y agoWasn't it supposed to decrease electricity usage? If I remember correctly it was one of the arguments for DST. I really dislike it. We do time based reporting and it messes up all the calculations at DST change. All kinds if weird bugs that trigger once per year, especially when time skips backwards. It's also dumb how trains have to stop and wait for an hour at the winter DST change in order to maintain the schedule. It would be a breath of fresh air when it's finally dropped in the EU.
- shados 6y ago> but it really seems that for the population as a whole Our society is calibrated with the assumption that you will wake up early. Early bird gets the worm and all that, but everything is essentially rigged toward it. From the time/daylight, to school start time, going by quiet hours (hope you enjoy jack hammers starting at 7am stats, because by most city's ordinance, that's not only allowed, it's NORMAL. And to start at 7, the trucks and crew have to start getting ready long before that). I assume a large part of it is the emphasis on family and kids, and generally for people with young children, early morning isn't really early. But for a lot of people...ouch. Considering all the literature around the issues related to sleep deprivation, and how so many people are sleep deprived (likely related to a lot of mental issues, stress, and various other health problems), we really need to work and optimize around making it possible for people to sleep enough. As things are, if you can, it's just dumb luck.
- bjo590 6y ago> As things are, if you can, it's just dumb luck. Funny, I've gotten 8+ hours of sleep over 95% of nights in the past 5 years. I must have a string of very good luck. It probably isn't due to lifestyle choices.
- itisit 6y agoYou must have this controversial "free will" I hear so much about..
- dmix 6y agoAs in "free-will" not to live in any (western?) city where 7am is noise go-time, regardless of real life statistics and local cultural differences? I personally think these society-wide policies should reflect the realities of the population. Which often means reviewing them every once in a while to see if it still makes sense. Far too much gov policy is fire-and-forget and obsessed with forever adding new things. In my perfect world at least 50% of time should be spent reviewing and tweaking existing policy.
- briffle 6y agoOregon and Washington have passed bills to just that, but both bills require all 3 states in time zone to do it, so waiting on CA.
- desert_boi 6y agoI think Washington must be including Northern Idaho (Pacific Time) as part of its territory. Also Nevada is in Pacific Time as well.
- riffic 6y agomaking daylight saving time permanent is effectively the same thing as making standard time permanent. Which, if you're going to do, you might as well make standard time the standard. Because it's the standard.
- tzs 6y agoIn the winter, though, in more northern latitudes that would mean going to work or school while it is still very dark out. If you can only have one of morning and evening in light, morning is probably more important for a couple reasons even ignoring the circadian rhythm considerations. 1. We are more synchronized in morning. In morning you have adults going to work and kids going to school. We are much less synchronized in the evening--young kids come home earliest, then middle and high school kids, then adults. Furthermore, more people stay late at work than go in early to work, so you get further spreading out of the commute home. With the morning getting heavier, more concentrated traffic, it makes sense to prioritize giving it the light. 2. The morning before the sun comes up tends to be the coldest time of the day. You are much more likely to have icy roads during a predawn commute than during a postdusk commute, further bolstering the case for prioritizing standard time over daylight savings time during winter.
- beached_whale 6y agoI get paid to go to work, dark or light. I would rather my time be more pleasant. Plus, come December it's dark at both ends anyways.
- nickt 6y agoI think you’re right, and being downvoted by folks who’ve never lived in the North.
- cgriswald 6y agoI certainly didn’t downvote him, but I lived in the north and I think it’s nonsense. The reality is you end up going to school or work in the dark anyway because the sun rises later than your schedule. And then, since all the light is in the morning, you go home in the dark too; or at least it’s dark shortly after your commute ends. You basically get zero hours of daylight for several months. This is the entire reason I’m pro-DST-all-the-time.
- watwut 6y agoNoooo, afternoon is more important. That us when people do activities and would have reasonable chance to go outside on sun to get d. You wont take kids on pkayground or take walk before school and work.
- adrianmonk 6y ago> As the paper states, the biggest problem is with the transition. It does? I only read the abstract because trying to download the PDF says it's embargoed. The abstract says that (1) the transition creates "significant" risks and (2) "remaining in daylight saving time year-round ... could result in circadian misalignment ... [and] increased cardiovascular disease risk, metabolic syndrome and other health risks". I don't see anything in there that says 1 or 2 is a bigger or smaller problem.
- nickt 6y agoIt’s only embargoed because you’re an hour behind!
- m463 6y agoWe could go the other way. Make our clocks start at sunrise.
- _ph_ 6y agoThat is not a very practical thing as the time of sunrise changes every day. However, there used to be a very practical solution, to center the clock at noon, which drifts only a few minutes over the year. The daytime then will be symmetrically around the noon point, 6am sunrise means 6pm sunset. Isn't that neat?
- m463 6y agoI think time is fundamentally analog, and our bodies are analog too in the sense that we adapt and adjust to the rising sun and bright sunlight. Clocks are wondeful, but I kind of wonder if it fits our analog round-peg bodies into square holes. I think it would be interesting to embrace the analog. instead of an hour for a meeting, have a amount of time to talk about something, while people have attention with biological support. Instead of going to bed at the same time, sort of predict when your body will get tired and have a tapering of the awake portion of your time. And matching thinking to alertness, and relaxing to its waning might be productive and pleasurable.
- CydeWeys 6y ago> However, there used to be a very practical solution, to center the clock at noon, which drifts only a few minutes over the year. Noon drifts by just over 30 minutes throughout the year, not just a few minutes.
- austincheney 6y agoOr, get to work an hour earlier and leave an hour earlier. I doubt most of the people who read on HN are hourly employees on a fixed hourly schedule.
- captainmuon 6y agoWon't our activities just move forward in the day to compensate after a while? The soviet union tried this, supposedly because Stalin liked summer time more (decree time). I think since the numbers we ascribe to points in time are arbitrary, it doesn't make much sense to change them. Short term it will work to fool people. But long term, we should just mandate the concrete things we want to achive, for example: * School should not start too early * Evening events, Prime-time TV should not start too late * Allow flexible working hours Unfortunately I think we are as a society ill-equiped to make such coordinated changes across government, businesses, entertainment industry, schools and so on. Maybe the government could provide financial incentives for businesses and institutions that follow along. Large unions could push something in the next rounds of collective agreements. And maybe the idea gets enough momentum that others will follow.
- guitarbill 6y ago> we want to achive, for example [...] School should not start too early If only it were that easy. Of course, you might think it's obvious, study after study shows kids and teenagers would benefit. But you could argue another or maybe even the main function of school is to be able to offload children while the parents are at work. And flexible working hours don't work in customer-facing roles, so...
- pmontra 6y agoI guess this depends on the country. I have experience of European countries. As a general rule (lots of exceptions, probably) it seems that the workday in the countries in the north is centered around the 8-17 cycle, with lunch at 12. Countries in the south are more like 9-18 with lunch at 13 or later and dinner at 20 or even 22-23 (hi Spain!) It makes sense for them to have light in the evening at the cost of some dark early mornings in winter. Not so much for countries getting up early.
- cerved 6y agoIt's dark up here all the time in winter so it doesn't matter. In the summer it's nicer when the sun rises at 3 instead of 2.
- prerok 6y agoI find it really funny that a lot of people are supporting keeping DST. Basically, we wanted to sleep in so we started to shift our work time from 6 to 7, then to 8 and now we start work at 9. Then we realized that we have no time in the evening so let's shift the clock so that 7 o'clock is actually earlier. At normal time, on an equinox the night is from 6 in the evening to 6 in the morning and midnight is actually in the middle of the night. With DST it's from 7 to 7 and midnight is at 1. So keeping DST basically means you are shifting to a different "non-natural" time zone. Let's just stop the DST keeping the natural local time and get up earlier anyway.
- Pxtl 6y agoWorking from 9 to 5 is so culturally ingrained that it is in song lyrics. Perma DST is the easier change.
- dathinab 6y agoAlso the more healthy change from a scientific point of view. Ironically the parent post seem to be a person with a social yet lack (i.e. forced to stand up earlier then their inner clock, i.e. often stands up late). But especially people like that are biologically negatively affected by permanent summer time.
- thescriptkiddie 6y agoOff topic, but what is your native language? Your use of "stand up" suggests German, but "yet lack" sounds vaguely... Scandinavian?
- dathinab 6y agoIt's German and it's a Typo, maybe autocorrect. I meant Jet Lag, which is also used in German as Jetlag. But I somehow thought it's written Jet Lack and typoed it as yet lack. No idea why I thought it's Lack, maybe because you lack sleep after taking a jet ?
- 6y ago
- pishpash 6y agoThere is no difference. It's a relabeling of hours.
- sings 6y agoIf the transition is the biggest problem what about doing it gradually between the two extremes. Now that most devices adjust their time automatically it seems like non-standard day lengths wouldn’t be a huge problem.
- minusSeven 6y ago>The paper also argues that standard time aligns more naturally with our circadian rhythm... but doesn't bother to compare that with the psychological benefit we get from hanging out with friends in daylight after work in the summer, or the psychological benefit of it not being dark when you go home and have dinner with your family. Why can't most people wake up early instead. That's precisely what will happen once dst goes away. I still don't understand why you need to change time at all. Countries that don't have dst will never understand why you will have dst in today's day and age. It feels like a tradition you won't let go of.
- Broken_Hippo 6y ago"but doesn't bother to compare that with the psychological benefit we get from hanging out with friends in daylight after work in the summer, or the psychological benefit of it not being dark when you go home and have dinner with your family." We have lights. We use them on warm autumn days with friends and family and when folks are sitting around outside playing cards late into the evening. I'm not convinced daylight is needed to enjoy time with friends and family. Sure, you might enjoy it, but it isn't exactly a deal-breaker. And no, I don't get that "not being dark when I go home". I'm in Noway, and if you work first shift - or heck, even business hours - you'll only see sun in December on your lunch break. Again, though, we have lights, and they are a pretty wonderful thing. Outdoor heating and blankets extend outside time too. Not just that, but folks with a later rhythm are going to suffer more. I'm going to guess especially teenagers (in general) will suffer, as doctors already complain that school is too early: Permanent summer time pushes it an hour earlier.
- mynameishere 6y agoYeah, and stereos shouldn't even have "1". The dial should go from 2 to 11. Geez. Numbers.
- Amygaz 6y agoI don’t disagree that the transition part is the worst, but more people are supporting standard time because it fits better with the schedule of most people. I used to be on the DST camp, but a few years with a family and house of my own, and suddenly ST makes more sense. Then playing the game of placing oneself into somebody else’s shoes, and I realized that only young adults in rich countries really benefit from DST.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fullstop 6y agoBesides the headaches of updating timezone information, I want to move it 30 minutes and be done with it.
- dheera 6y agoWell sure, that's equivalent to just changing the timezone. There are places in the world that don't use DST where the timezone is such that it's not dark when you go home. But yes, we agree, it's good for it to not be dark when you go home. Not only for psychological benefit, but I would bet it would prevent a lot of accidents and crime on the way home as well. Personally I solve this mess by just using UTC for everything. All of my schedules, computers, clocks are set to UTC.
- verelo 6y agoWhatever, just pick one and stick to it. Please!
- taf2 6y agoI’d argue it doesn’t matter nearly as much as just keeping time constant. If we can eliminate the change in our lifetime I think it’s good enough and we can leave future tweaks like optimizing what hour makes the best sense for optimal living to the next generation... at least we will have fixed the transition problem which IMO is the biggest issue right now
- beezle 6y ago"The position statement also cites evidence of increased risks of motor vehicle accidents, cardiovascular events, and mood disturbances following the annual “spring forward” to daylight saving time." I really would like to see stats of those same events for people who have just traveled one, two or three time zones.
- dathinab 6y agoSummery from what I posted in a long top level comment: - Permanent summer time would have negative biological consequences for everyone having social yet lack, i.e. everyone who frequently stands up earlier then their inner clock indicated. I.e. people who tend to stand up late. - This is soundly researched. - The exact degree of how bad the consequences of permanent summer time are unknown and hard to say as they are long term effect, BUT only <2% of people (in Germany) have a negative yet lack while much more have a positive yet lack because of this it's generally better to opt for permanent winter time then summer time
- cnst 6y agoIt's a little more nuanced than that. In Russia, they got rid of the DST a few years ago, but then the folks in Moscow (+0300/+0400) were really upset during the winter still living in DST's +0400 from the summer -- they'd never see the sunlight the whole day -- go to work in the dark, come back home in the dark as well. Moscow being quite North (with less sun in the winter) helped exaggerate the issue. So, after a few years, they've had to change the time in Russia once again -- now to permanent Winter (standard time), with +0300 in Moscow. What happened in Saratov, which would normally have had +0400/+0500 if sunset/sunrise alone were to determine the timezone? Because having Moscow Time is very convenient, it always used to follow Moscow Time, because there was only a 1h difference from the natural sunlight-based timezone. However, now the difference would be as high as 2h during the summer (+0300 from Moscow instead of +0500 from DST from +0400). So, after a few years of living with permanent +0300 from Moscow, they've finally had enough, and decided to finally abandon Moscow time, and switch to the permanent standard time more appropriate for the geography -- year-round +0400. There's been similar issues elsewhere in Russia, which, basically, had quite a bit of the timezone map completely re-drawn during all these switchovers of the 2010s when the summer/winter time change has been abandoned. tl;dr: in the US, we can't simply abandon DST but keep the timezones the same otherwise; we'd probably have to re-draw some parts of the whole map so that each place gets the option to align the permanent time either with the Winter or the Summer. It'll be a bit of a mess. The law in the US only lets the local folk to decide whether or not they want DST (e.g., Arizona has permanent winter time); you cannot decide to keep DST permanently (which is what the parent poster wants, or which is what the folks in Nevada want), or switch to a different timezone easily. I do hope we end up abolishing the time change; but it won't be easy; especially if we simply assume that everyone wants permanent non-DST or DST of their existing timezone. another tl;dr: basically, in Nevada, a 1h difference from their proper sunset/sunrise timezone is fine to align themselves better with California, but if we abandon DST, then their time will be 2h off in the summer from sunset/sunrise; so, they should be allowed to keep PDT permanently, or, in other words, switch from PST/PDT to a permanent MST like Arizona, which requires US DOT approval. Of course, because so many steps are involved, it becomes complicated to even say what you actually want.
- bloak 6y agoI don't want children to have to travel to or from school in the dark. It's dangerous by bicycle (a lot of children cycle), and unpleasant in any case. If you're at a reasonably high latitude that means you need the middle of the school day to be around local noon in the winter. Round here, in the UK, school days typically run from a bit before 09:00 to a bit after 15:00. So something close to astronomical local time would be a good choice of time zone. You could move the time zone three hours and at the same time change school hours by three hours, but what would be the point of that? School hours is the main thing that isn't flexible. Office hours vary. Shops can easily be flexible. There's the stock exchange, I suppose, but most people don't interact with that. So the obvious thing to do is to abolish summer time and leave winter time as it is.
- BurningFrog 6y agoFine. Set it all to UTC for all I care. Maybe it's the delusion of grandeur of pretending to rule over time itself that annoys me more than the practical inconvenience.
- burtonator 6y agoWhen I go camping my body almost immediately reverts to a more primitive cycle of waking up immediately at dawn and going to sleep at sunset. Takes about 3-4 days. It's just so much better psychologically and physiologically but it's also amazingly practical. I don't need a flashlight and the BEST time to hike and be active is dawn and dusk when it's cooler. I'll even start taking naps in the middle of the day the same way other large animals do (bears, deer, etc).
- grzm 6y agoDaylight saving time is the idea that you switch time zone offset during the year. The specific time zone offset is not really the issue. As you point out, it’s the transition that’s the problem. We can pick whatever time zone offset we want. Without the change, there is no “daylight saving time”.
- jozzy-james 6y agoas someone in the midwest, i do not look back fondly on the days where i would get up to work and it's dark, and leave work and it's dark - all while spending my 9 hours in a windowless server room
- jozzy-james 6y agoaddendum - this was also before indianapolis adopted DST, the winter is just shit
- spullara 6y agoFor sure in California. Standard time in winter is just awful.
- snarf21 6y agoI agree. People seem happier when they can have "free" time after work. It is depressing to leave work and it is already dark (in winter).