10 ms·
It always starts like that. People agree to very sensible things. Like hate speech is bad and it’s not censorship if it’s not mandated by the government. Eve
by mc32 6y ago
It always starts like that. People agree to very sensible things. Like hate speech is bad and it’s not censorship if it’s not mandated by the government. Eventually the definition of hate or whatever it is that’s offensive is very removed from the original meaning, and now we all bear the brunt of the sensible people who with best intentions wanted to make things better.
- brightball 6y agoThe is what I believe is the goal of placing restrictions on people based on “mental health”. It’s so open ended and not easily verifiable that it becomes a sliding scale.
- claudiawerner 6y agoIf I'm understanding you right, the idea is that some harms, physical ones, are fair game for the law to cover, but other harms (mental ones) or a collection of boundary cases are less (if at all) within the purview of legislation. I think there's a good conversation to be had as to what in particular makes physical harms so special as compared to others, and how existing law in every country (including the US) can constitutionally include some non-physical harms within its legislation (such as laws against sending threatening letters, or child pornography law, or fraud).
- brightball 6y agoSpecifically, I’m concerned about government placing restrictions on individuals based on their mental health history. What is the process to dispute it? You can’t just take a blood test to say this isn’t really a problem.
- claudiawerner 6y agoOh right, I don't think I understood what you were saying, then. That's also a good question.
- fjdjsmsm 6y agoSome problems don’t have easy simple solutions. Any answer will have some outside cases. If a schizophrenic parent has in the past harmed someone, should a court ignore this when determining custody. It is unfair. If you err on being too lenient some people will be harmed. If you err on being stringent some people will be harmed. Complex problem cannot be solved with ideology and maxims. All solutions will fail some people sometimes.
- a1369209993 6y agoThat example seems like a easy problem to solve actually? > If a [] parent has in the past harmed someone, should a court ignore this when determining custody. There you go, no need to place restrictions on people based on mental 'health', just their actual actions.
- nine_k 6y ago> what in particular makes physical harms so special Such harms can be reliably detected, with stringent enough criteria. Mental harms, and the very notion of "normality", are much more nebulous.
- claudiawerner 6y ago>Such harms can be reliably detected, with stringent enough criteria. Mental harms, in many cases, can also be detected by competent professionals; besides that, it is entirely possible for physical harms to heal and for supporting evidence of their infliction be used to convict. Further, many physical harms depend at least partially on the victim's characteristics or situation; a concert pianist is arguably harmed more by someone cutting off his finger than a schoolteacher would be, for instance. Many physical harms that are rightfully legislated against often require the testimony of the victim for the case to succeed. For a wide class of 'mental harms' it is accurate to say that they are indeed physiological responses - from PTSD to lethargy and insomnia. This is in contrast to the caricature that mental harms are necessarily merely 'hurt feelings'. I also have concerns that the difficulty or the fact of sometimes being nebulous features of mental harms should necessarily rule out such lawmaking. At best, the minimum for proving such harm should at least be set out by the legislators or judiciary, if the standard of evidence is the roadblock to legislation. It's also worth remembering that we're talking about harms here, not mere hurts. Harms are much harder to fabricate than hurts are.
- samatman 6y agoHere's where mental harms "detected by competent professionals" leads: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_abuse_of_psychiatry_in_the_Soviet_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_abuse_of_psychiatry_...
- claudiawerner 6y agoIt seems as though you're invoking a slippery slope fallacy; it's possible to say exactly the same about doctors working for the state who minify or trivilazize the examination of physical harm on dissidents too. The fact that expert testimony can be bought off or compelled does not preclude expert testimony from being an important consideration in general. The opioid crisis for instance has shown there are many incompetent doctors, but I doubt you'd refuse the testimony of a doctor to help your case when you are injured by someone else.
- travisoneill1 6y agoYou can prove physical harm beyond a reasonable doubt. Mental harm is frequently concocted as a bullying tactic, e.g. the recent NY Times editorial controversy where employees said running an editorial they disagreed with made them "feel unsafe." https://www.npr.org/2020/06/08/871817721/head-of-new-york-times-editorial-page-steps-down-amid-controversy https://www.npr.org/2020/06/08/871817721/head-of-new-york-ti...
- claudiawerner 6y agoI don't see this as an argument against such legislation; consider that many physical crimes are also hard (or even impossible) to prove beyond a reasonable doubt, considered case-by-case. Rape very often qualifies here, as does the mens rea of various other crimes, which may rely upon testimony. Both actus reus and mens rea are required for a conviction, and while the actus reus may be easier to prove (but again, in many cases not beyond a reasonable doubt), we do not abolish the role of intention in the justice system simply because it's hard to prove. Accusations of physical harms can also be concocted as bullying tactics too, in which the harm was suffered as a result of either a self-inflicted injury, or inflicted by somebody else. Such cases can be thrown out due to insufficient evidence. I see no reason why the same cannot be said for a subset of mental harms, in which there are equivalent doctors available to use their expertise to judge the harm.
- mountainboot 6y agoThe article you link did not mention the employees saying running the editorial made them "feel unsafe". Neither the word safe nor unsafe appears in the article. It says the article "reportedly elicited strong objections" from the staff.
- rootsudo 6y agoWould lacking spirituality or belief in a higher existence make you mentally healthy or unhealthy? I agree, the sliding scale only strengthens whomever is in power. In Florida, the baker act is used like this.
- sixothree 6y agoThe persecution faced by doubters and non-believers is always surprising to me. I guess nothing should surprise me in the deep south though.
- vbezhenar 6y agoIt might be Apple forcing them to do so. For example you can't publish app with porn content. Even if your app is some kind of forum, you're obliged at least to filter out explicit content in the app. Browser seems to be an exception.
- emteycz 6y agoApple is forcing Google to remove apps from play store? How?
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoLet's see their owners first.
- afwaller 6y agoI know nobody reads the articles but what about reading the title?
- lotsofpulp 6y agoDoes reddit filter out porn in the reddit iOS app? And what would Apple have to do with Google’s Play Store?
- cecja 6y agoYes with the standard settings in place you have to navigate directly to nsfw subreddits and even then there is a age restriction in place. There are no auto fill suggestions nor search results and there is no nsfw content on the /r/all page inside the app.
- Barrin92 6y ago>It always starts like that. many places have cultures and also law that for decades has worked perfectly fine reigning in the very worst forms of hate speeech (say holocaust denial in my country) while not descending into a sort of activism that starts to get silly. There's no automatic mechanism that turns sensible rules into insensible ones, and it's also need not be the case with sensible hate speech rules. With cases like Google's play store the issue seems more concrete. On the one hand it's the overwhelming power and lack of due process that large firms have over software. Decentralise this and put authority into the hands of people who know their networks and the situtation will imporove. Secondly it also seems to be a very activist employee base at companies like Google that's gone somewhat overboard. Again, an accountability issue. If these things were decided publicly, it would moderate to reasonable levels.
- rightbyte 6y agoHistoric revisionism as an subgroup of hate speech is a prime example of slippery slope and moving of definition. I would add "fake news" to hate speech.
- Barrin92 6y agosorry I have no idea what you're trying to say. Holocaust denial is generally considered to be both historical revisionism and hate speech, the former being a tool for the latter. Is this just semantics?
- sumtechguy 6y agoOut of context is the favorite goto for most news orgs that want to push a particular set of ideals.
- rightbyte 6y agoYe it is semantics alright. Not taking the debate to the Holocaust, hate speech is not just incitement to hatred (quite broad) or incitement to crime (quite specific), against a group anymore. It is like "fake news", in that sense, when Trump comically turned the term against its creators. I feel that when it comes to Google its not about if it is hate speech or not, but who controls it. I.e. Zuckerberg is fine although there are multiple long-lasting Facebook groups that have been used to incite crimes, but Aaron Swartz would not be (today). It is quite amusing how Facebook is not shut down in Europe even though many European countries would shut down any local company being so lax and arbitrary with moderation as Facebook.
- LudwigNagasena 6y ago> People agree to very sensible things. Like hate speech is bad and it’s not censorship if it’s not mandated by the government. This doesn’t seem very sensible to me, I would even say it seems to be the opposite of sensible, probably because I am not American.
- riffraff 6y agohate speech is a crime in many european countries too[0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech_laws_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech_laws_by_country
- LudwigNagasena 6y agoThat’s a non sequitur. What do you mean “too?” What does this have to do with the claim that “it’s not censorship if it’s not mandated by the government”?
- MiroF 6y agoI suspect they thought you were saying "hate speech is bad" sounds the opposite of sensible, when really you were referring to the part following the 'and'.
- valvar 6y agoI really don't get that logic. Of course, everyone agrees that hate speech is bad (and so are a lot of things, but I digress). But how is it not censorship when one of the world's most powerful companies does it? Do they get a free pass because they are governed by shareholders and make a lot of money? I can see how it's not censorship if Bob does not want people to post things he disagrees with on his cat picture forum with 200 users. When a few massive companies effectively control the possibility of reaching 95ish% of the audience on the Internet, it's censorship in the very worst sense of the word, and I don't see how it's possible to support it without being an unequivocal opponent of free speech.
- orclev 6y agoIt's a question of what is meant by the term censorship. In the strictest sense, moderation and censorship are very often the same thing. If for instance, I post something terrible in a comment on here, and the administration of HN deletes that comment, then that's censorship. However, when most people talk about censorship they're using it not in the strict sense, but rather as a shorthand for someone violating their first amendment right. In this case this is really only a crime when it's a government entity doing it, although people don't typically differentiate between the government and any large organization, which technically are legally allowed to censor you on their platform or property. There's a larger discussion that needs to happen with regards to censorship. There are two extremes at play here, on the one hand there's the absolute freedom stance of literally nothing censored (only example I can think of for this is maybe the dark web, but really everyone censors if only a little), even shouting fire in a crowded theater or posting child pornography. On the other extreme is the absolute censorship of someplace like China, where only permitted thoughts and expressions can be posted. The US and most of the rest of the world tends to fall somewhere in the middle. The big struggle right now is that everyone has recognized that there's clearly some kind of problem. We're seeing unprecedented levels of misinformation, and a frankly weaponization of social media both for profit, and for international politics. I don't know that anyone has a good solution for how to address that problem, but the pendulum seems to be swinging towards a more censorship focused response.
- deleted 6y ago
- tenebrisalietum 6y agoKindly take this as a devils advocate post before you reflexively downvote. It looks like letting people say anything they want on major social media platforms is only having one major positive effect: a few advertising companies are becoming very rich. The negative effects include: - incited violence (gang-oriented gun crime in Chicago is often fanned by social media posts for example) - bad medical decisions (vaccine/COVID misinformation) - cancel culture/political manipulation (people taking other people's posts as facts when they are not) I would like to uphold the principle of free speech and forcing social media providers to be free speech agents even though they are private companies, but it's starting to get hard to defend. I am losing faith that strict adherence to free speech is going to result in a smarter, happier humanity. It might be better if less people speak their mind.
- silveraxe93 6y agoI think it's obvious that if less people speak their mind, we could have a smarter, happier humanity. But I also think it's obvious that I shouldn't trust you to make the decision of who needs to shut up. And definitely not the government.
- tenebrisalietum 6y ago> But I also think it's obvious that I shouldn't trust you to make the decision of who needs to shut up. And definitely not the government. Well right now social media companies seem to have that power. How is that better? I hear this point all the time. Is there a better response than this?
- a1369209993 6y ago> Well right now social media companies seem to have that power. How is that better? It's not; we're attempting to fix that, and TFA is about Google maliciously attacking one such attempt.
- kanox 6y ago> I would like to uphold the principle of free speech No, you completely against that principle.
- sildur 6y ago"The road to hell is paved with good intentions"
- kleer001 6y agoI love that aphorism. Unintended consequences. We should teach unintended consequences in grade school, high school, and have advanced degrees in it. How to see them before they explode, how to mediate them, and how to fix them once they're running at full steam. Lately I've been imagining it along with the slowly boiling frog story and the crab-mentality too. As in some people can't tell we're headed to hell because it's coming so slowly, and some people will actively stop others from escaping hell or trying to fix the situation.
- godelski 6y agoThere's a hypothesis I came up with awhile ago and it seems to hold pretty true. If we talk about problems as O(n) where n is the causation distance[0] we've solved the vast majority of O(1) and O(0) problems. It makes sense that biologically we would be primed to think in this way because they are decent approximate solutions for small groups. But the world we live in now is much more complex and many events are coupled and the low order approximations aren't good solutions. The problem I see is that people are treating O(5) problems like they are O(1). As a society we discuss things in this way instead of trying to understand the complexity, nuance, and coupling that exists in many of our modern problems. A good example of this is global warming. People treat it as "if we switch to renewables then we've solved global warming" when reality is substantially more complicated. But I don't know how to get people to realize problems are higher order problems and that the first order approximation isn't a reasonable solution. [0] So O(0) means x causes itself. O(1) is y causes x. O(n) is n causes y causes ... causes x. This is just a simplified framework and not meant to be taken too seriously.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI agree, I've been thinking along these lines for a while too; thank you for phrasing it so clearly. My current thinking led me to conclude that we don't have sufficiently good tools[0] for modelling O(n) problems with n > 2. Particularly when (what your simplification doesn't capture) there are feedback loops involved. Take this O(2) problem: x causes more y, y causes more z, z causes less y but much more x. Or in a pictorial form: (++) X<-------\ | (-) | | ------Z \ / ^ (+) v | (+) Y-------/ You can't just think your way through that problem, you have to model it - estimate coefficients (even if qualitatively), account for assumptions, and simulate the dynamic behavior. I argue that we lack both mental and technological tools to cope with this. Speaking of global warming, a year ago I presented this problem: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20480438 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20480438 - "Will increase in coal exports of Poland increase Poland's CO₂ footprint?" Yes? No? How badly? The question is at least this complicated: Coal exports ^ | [provides Z coal to] | | [needs α*X = A kWh for coal] Mining coal <---------------------\ | | | [provides X coal to] | v | Coal power plants | | | | | | [γ*X = Y kWh burning coal] | | v | | Electricity --------------------/ | | [burned coal into β*X = N kg of CO₂] v CO₂ emissions (Presented this way it not only tells you that, ceteris paribus, it will, but roughly by how much and what are the parameters that can be tweaked to mitigate it.) Why aren't we talking about climate change in these terms with general public? Why aren't feedback loops taught in school? -- [0] - Or, if they exist, they aren't sufficiently well known outside some think tanks or some random academic papers.
- dang 6y ago(We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24305296 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24305296)
- colordrops 6y agoHanlon's razor has hobbled everyone's ability to see what the establishment is doing. This isn't about good intentions gone wrong. The loss of control of the narrative due to the internet has been a severe setback for the powerful, and they have been slowly clawing it back by limiting access to alternative media. Various think tanks, NGOs, board members with multiple irons in the fire, foreign interests, and the government itself exert a lot of influence on large players to shut down harmful narratives. Most visible was when the deplatforming activity started with threats from lawmakers against outlets if they didn't remove certain content. You've also got various orgs with CIA connections acting as "fact checkers" on Facebook. The influence happens in subtle and many ways.
- andi999 6y ago"threats from lawmakers against outlets if they didn't remove certain content." Could you be more specific what that certain content was?
- colordrops 6y agoSuspected Russian bots, Alex Jones, Covid misinfo, then there's this sort of thing: https://theintercept.com/2018/01/03/my-life-as-a-new-york-times-reporter-in-the-shadow-of-the-war-on-terror/ https://theintercept.com/2018/01/03/my-life-as-a-new-york-ti... https://theintercept.com/2014/09/25/managing-nightmare-cia-media-destruction-gary-webb/ https://theintercept.com/2014/09/25/managing-nightmare-cia-m... https://theintercept.com/2014/09/04/former-l-times-reporter-cleared-stories-cia-publication/ https://theintercept.com/2014/09/04/former-l-times-reporter-... https://twitter.com/ggreenwald/status/1097834759181553664?s=19 https://twitter.com/ggreenwald/status/1097834759181553664?s=... https://old.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/apu3oz/with_the_recent_chinese_company_tencent_in_the/ https://old.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/apu3oz/with_the...
- frank2 6y ago>The loss of control of the narrative due to the internet has been a severe setback for the powerful How was the narrative controlled by the powerful before the internet became a part of everyday life? Specifically, how was the narrative controlled in the US in the decades before 1993? I'm asking for recommendations of books written by historians, journalists and other serious people. (Understanding the situation decades ago is probably a lot easier than understanding the current situation -- partly because the powerful will take pains to hide their controlling actions from the public.) In the US I get the general sense that politicians and holders of government offices have never been able to exert a lot of control of the narrative with the result that journalists and the prestigious universities have so much influence that they are best thought of as essentially part of the government. That suggests that the efforts of the establishment to rein in the big social media companies will prove largely ineffective with the result that Facebook and Google will probably join the New York Times and Harvard as parts of the de facto governing structure of the US. EDITED: changed "rein" to "rein in".
- gamblor956 6y agoEveryone is constantly complaining about private censorship being a slippery slope... And yet today, despite decades of "censorship" by Facebook and Google, you can see whatever porn you want, snuff films, terrorist propaganda, hate speech, libel/slander spread by instigators like Glenn Beck and Alex Jones. Just not on Google or Facebook. Different private entities and people have different levels of tolerance. If you want filth, use Gab or 4chan/8chan. If you want forums that are partially moderated, use Facebook/Google/Reddit. If you want forums that are fully moderated, join a private or niche board like HN.
- k8skil0 6y agoIt’s removing resilience for perception of efficiency. There’s value in normalizing around shared needs, food and infra. But beyond that the normalizing always happens in a direction of the haves. It’s a biological truism of our society we’ll avoid confrontation with each other. Which enables exactly the issue we have socially: everyone is too scared to say no, enabling that does not align with an ideology of freedom for the public. Freedom from having our consciousness filled with the narrative all the choices society has made to this point were reasonable regardless of the alternatives offered at the time (they’re usually many, and arguably many would have been better benefit to humanity, like the Navy getting Congress to pivot away from a decade of thorium reactor funding and research to Uranium reactors so the Navy has weapons grade materials available. True story, learned about researching energy policy and infra). Anyway, the point is, normalizing around the basics, food, shelter, medicine. That makes sense. Normalizing around social frameworks outside that above just leads to gate keeping. Gotta get through HR, interviews, don’t even bother with FAANG you aren’t that smart. They’ve smoothed off interviewing for a what feels like efficiency. Are they even hiring smart people or good role players? You can’t get scientific with HR that’s law so the bar has to drop at some point. Lots of capital to leverage on lots of output isn’t evidence of especially clever engineers. How easily we discard variables to get to a task we can accomplish in a day. I have a hard time believing these giant tent pole ideas humans try to build are ever anything more than a whole lot of emotional indirection to glorious past (which by any real measure was usually awful for the masses) and a whole lot of “same old shit different generation.”
- api 6y agoCensorship always starts with unpopular speech. Historically it's been raunchy porn, religious blasphemy, and direct opposition to the state. Hate speech seems to be a new one that works well to sell censorship to liberals (who should know better).
- epistasis 6y agoThis is only "censorship" in the sense that Fox News censors me by not giving me a 5 minute slot to advocate for Medicare For All. In reality, it's not state sponsored censorship at all, and it doesn't lead down any slippery slope. These claims of censorship are extremely selectively applied, to only certain types of political speech. I wonder why that is?
- john-shaffer 6y agoI don't watch Fox News, but even I know that Fox invites Democrats on to talk about their opinions. Here is an interview where a BLM leader rants for 5 minutes: https://youtu.be/FTjBJiXalHU?t=59 https://youtu.be/FTjBJiXalHU?t=59
- epistasis 6y agoAnd yet I have had my pleas for time go unanswered... which is "censorship" of me.
- notyourday 6y ago> People agree to very sensible things. Like hate speech is bad and it’s not censorship if it’s not mandated by the government. I'm paraphrasing what was here a few days ago: Our banking partner is uncomfortable that the realistic sex toys modeled after magical creatures have the colors that strongly represent human organs. You will either have to change the colors or we will not be able to continue providing you with our services.
- a1369209993 6y agoTo be fair, they didn't claim that people don't also agree to very stupid and malicious things, and in fact rather implied that that's the likely result of supposedly sensible starting points.
- wonnage 6y agoThis is like having a bulletin board in your store and not being able to take anything down from it. Yes, Google and Apple are big. You can say well, it’s different because in this world there’s only two boards for the entire country, that’s true! But it’s not a censorship problem, it’s an antitrust problem.
- RonanTheGrey 6y agoYou hit the nail on the head, if they were just "more alphabets in the soup", people wouldn't have much leg to stand on; but because the internet has no analog to the actual PUBLIC square, when you have 1-3 companies that control access to what 95% of the internet sees, you have a problem - because there's no alternative and no public square on which to register your complaint.
- em-bee 6y agothe real problem here is that we allow google, apple or facebook to control public discourse. we let companies decide what we are allowed to talk about. regardless of wheter we agree with what's being removed or not, this can't be healthy. i am not american, so my interpretation may be off, but here is how i understand the problem: many people would like hatespeech to go away. jet the US constitution prohibits government censorship, so the government can't do much about it. instead they rely on companies like google and facebook to do the work for them. the companies are also compelled by public pressure to do what the government can't. contrast that to germany, where hatespeech like the promotion of nazi ideas is outright illegal. while i haven't verified this, this puts less pressure on companies to censure anything that isn't mandated by law. public demands for the control of speech can also more easily b etranslated into law, so that the public doesn't need to resort to pressuring companies. on the contrary, they expect the government to protect them from companies that act in bad faith. it is hard to say which system is better. if there were many small companies each making different decisions about public discourse, then things would be fine. the problem is not so much the removal of outright hatespeech, but the more subtle influence in for example what is allowed to be posted about the covid epidemic, or other sensitive topics like political opinions, fact checking and all that. as it stands, i prefer that decisions about what speech is allowed is controlled by law such that we can use legal means to combat abuse.
- FactolSarin 6y ago> It always starts like that. That's the "slippery slope" fallacy. There's a knee-jerk reaction in America that any censorship is bad and will somehow always lead to more censorship. But there area places where censorship has been implemented in small ways and it hasn't led to some sort of free speech apocalypse. In Germany or Israel, for instance, it's illegal to deny the holocaust. That's a pretty sensible limit considering their history. All these years later, they're still free an functioning democracies.
- FeepingCreature 6y agoI believe you will find that's the fallacy fallacy.
- eblanshey 6y agoI recently watched an excellent speech concerning freedom of speech and freedom of protest by Rowan Atkinson, and feel it's very appropriate to share here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BiqDZlAZygU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BiqDZlAZygU
- EGreg 6y agoIt also goes the other way. Section 230 was about child pornography and became used as a safe harbor for anything. I am not usually agreeing w the Trump admin but they do have a point there. In general our thinking about freedom of speech is itself idiosyncratic in the same way. Human FREEDOMS means doing what you want. It’s not the same as a right to a megaphone maintained by thousands of employees and infrastructure of large corporations to give you a platform to say anything unfiltered to 5 million people at once. I would argue that such interpretations of the First Amendment have been detrimental to society. Speech on giant platforms should be vetted like on Wikipedia’s Talk Page, where mutually distrusting people engage in responsible fact checking BEFORE the crowd sees the main page with these claims. But hey I also argue similarly that the supreme court’s Heller decision similarly obviated the Well Regulated Militia clause into irrelevancy, so now anyone can have a gun no matter whether they are part of any well regulated organization or not. No checks on individual action that can affect others. Now we reap what we sow as a society. Yes FREEDOM of speech is important but what we call freedom today has greatly expanded even to unlimited political donations by super PACs and so on. Again a supreme court decision where expanding freedoms in Citizens United harms democracy. A win for ideologal purity I guess, but is socity better off? PS: before someone objects with “who will be the factcheckers/watchers I will say it will be self selected and self policed like on Wikipedia, as long as there is a healthy mix of views, it’s better than one wacko with a megaphone. Who does this celebrity culture help? It further divides us. And that’s why we can’t have nice things!
- DetroitThrow 6y agoLife, liberty and the pursuit of happiness was chosen for a reason in contrast to the term Locke used (estate): individual freedom was supposed to be balanced with the interests of the society that allowed them to exist and be pursued in the first place, which are what courts consider fundamental rights.
- ryukafalz 6y ago>Section 230 was about child pornography What? It most certainly was not! The CDA as a whole was an attempt to regulate indecency and obscenity on the internet. Think "pornography that might be seen by minors"[0]. (Remember, this was the 90s.) Most of it (with the exception of section 230) was struck down in court for obvious first-amendment reasons. Section 230 was added later during the process by the House, after the bill had passed through the Senate, and was more about defamation than anything else[1]. [0] https://www.congress.gov/bill/104th-congress/senate-bill/652/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/104th-congress/senate-bill/652... - search for "This title may be cited as the ``Communications Decency Act of 1996''." [1] https://www.theverge.com/2019/6/21/18700605/section-230-internet-law-twenty-six-words-that-created-the-internet-jeff-kosseff-interview https://www.theverge.com/2019/6/21/18700605/section-230-inte...
- mgleason_3 6y ago>it’s not censorship if it’s not mandated by the government Censorship can be conducted by private institutions, governments and other controlling bodies. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship
- trentnix 6y agoAnd that's why I'm incredibly cynical about politicians and activists who use amorphous political terms like "hate speech". It eventually becomes a club wielded by whoever is making the rules of today's Calvinball game.
- rdiddly 6y agoAny issue about which there's a cultural movement going on can serve as a handy pretext for measures that consolidate one's own power. It kind of seems obvious to point out, but nonetheless let's continue to be open to the possibility that such consolidation is not mere coincidence, or more to the point, that the measure is not even well-intentioned and in fact has nothing do to with the ostensible issue/reason (in this case, hate speech). The most cynical of power grabs are usually cloaked in the most noble of pretenses. That's how you make the unpalatable, palatable.
- baryphonic 6y ago> People agree to very sensible things. Like hate speech is bad and it’s not censorship if it’s not mandated by the government. We have two things to unpack here. First, hate speech. What is it? Who gets to decide what the word means and what is their procedure for deciding? Is the definition stable or fluid (or even very fluid)? Is hate speech universally wrong, or only wrong when issuing forth from certain speakers? If we all agree that it's wrong, then why are people engaging in it, even unintentionally? Second, censorship. Is self-censorship not censorship? Why must the state be involved in order to censor? We're TV networks that for decades voluntarily forbade their programming from portraying homosexuals being censored or not? What is unique about state authority versus corporate authority as it relates to censorship? "Hate speech is bad" is a very abstract statement. The sentence conveys almost no actual concrete meaning. It seems like a rational or sensible statement, but it delegates almost all of the actual work to feelings and emotions, and highly subjective ones at that. I don't find "wanna grab a cup of coffee" terribly hateful, but apparently some people do. I get the overall sentiment of your post, and I think I mostly agree. Nevertheless, the way we stop this nonsense is to say at the beginning that it is an abstraction over extremely subjective feelings and emotion, and thus has no basis other than eventual mob rule authoritarianism.