10 ms·
I like almost all of this. I have one minor concern, the maximum home size is dropping from 6750 to 2500 square feet. Which is probably fine for a nuclear fam
by klyrs 6y ago
I like almost all of this. I have one minor concern, the maximum home size is dropping from 6750 to 2500 square feet. Which is probably fine for a nuclear family, but in my neighborhood, such homes are largely occupied by multigenerational families. In areas closer to colleges and universities, those homes end up being shared by large groups of students. Both of these populations will take a hit under this policy.
- ogre_codes 6y agoI missed that part. Though both multigenerational families and college students could be served well by multi-structure setups as well. Or in many cases, better served.
- klyrs 6y agoMaybe the college students -- but in my experience, rent in large houses is cheaper per-room than smaller apartments. My brother is a professional musician and lives with others near/at the poverty line -- they simply can't afford to live in smaller places. Maybe that will change on the supply side, but more likely, demand will rise just as fast. Multigenerational families are not better served. If they're doing a new build, it can work. But imagine trying to purchase not one, but four houses on the same lot. That's a helluva coincidence to wait for, for them all to be vacant simultaneously.
- ogre_codes 6y agoHave you lived in a multi-generational home? I am right now and have done so in various ways for the past 25 years, it is vastly better to have some separation. I'm not going to generalize. But for us, multi-generational homes happen over time as opposed to moving the whole family at once regardless. Kids grow up and need space, but can't afford to buy a place. Parents get older and move in with kids, etc etc.
- klyrs 6y agoNo, I haven't. Some of my immediate neighbors do; one household immigrated as a family so they're on the forefront of my mind. I appreciate your perspective; thanks for sharing.
- ogre_codes 6y agoAlso, I think the point about big homes and multi-generational families is on-point and wasn't trying to disparage it. I just was pointing out that there is at least some mitigation.
- bradleybuda 6y agoOr, maybe armchair central planners like you and I and the Portland City Council shouldn’t decide what’s best for people we’ve never met and let them decide instead.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> shouldn’t decide what’s best for people we’ve never met and let them decide instead. I totally agree! I didn't mean to imply this bit about house size is good. In general, this measure removes piles of restrictions on land use and that's one of the big reasons I like it. I was just pointing out that there are some work-arounds.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tick_tock_tick 6y agoI mean at this point I'm confident every armchair planner is more competent.
- jasondclinton 6y agoThe removal of the off-street parking mandate will also impact EV adoption. Parking is already difficult to find in many older Portland neighborhoods. Edit: You need a place to plug-in your EV at night.
- TheGallopedHigh 6y agoIt stated that off street parking was optional...
- jasondclinton 6y agoIsn't that exactly the definition of the removal of a mandate?
- TheGallopedHigh 6y agoYes you’re right.
- jeffbee 6y agoThat's just reality. EVs solve a specific aspect of cars but they still have the main problem: they are unreasonably large. The future of urban mobility is also its past: walking.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoI think this is easy to wish but hard to realize, considering the US population is rapidly aging. There is a balance between prioritizing pedestrians and cyclists while still supporting reasonable mobility for those not in their prime as well as daily freight/parcel services.
- jeffbee 6y agoThat's why you can't have a city based on cars. The very old cannot drive! I don't know why this perfectly obvious and globally well-known fact is so little-known to Americans.
- stirbot 6y agoWould these groups still choose to share a kitchen, bathrooms, etc if they could find co-located, individual units at a similar, affordable price? I doubt it.
- lkbm 6y agoSome of us would, but even if not, why would it be the same price? More housing should lower the cost for both, and paying for 4 bedrooms + 1 kitchen should always cost less than 4 bedrooms + 4 kitchens. Personally, I'd like a private bathroom, but prefer the shared kitchen, dining room, and living room.
- onion2k 6y agoWhile that's unfortunate it's probably worth it in order to block a small number of people taking up far too much of the available space.
- foogazi 6y agoCan’t they still have really large lots ?
- noelwelsh 6y ago2500 square feet is considered a large house in most of the world. I have lived with a group of students, a nuclear family, and with multiple generations in houses smaller than that. It is definitely fine for all the use cases you list.
- rayiner 6y agoMost of the world lives in housing poverty compared to American norms.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- noelwelsh 6y agoWhat does "housing poverty" mean here? As far as I can tell it means "houses smaller than I am used to". In which case I have to ask what is the concern with houses less than 2500 sq ft? I can't find any evidence that housing size, above some minimum[1], is correlated with happiness. See e.g. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-45420795#:~:text=The%20US%2Dbased%20study%20draws,does%20not%20come%20without%20costs https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-45420795#:~:text=The%20U.... https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10902-016-9732-2 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10902-016-9732-2 or do you own search. This desire for extremely large houses just seems to be a combination of prior expectations that houses will be large and status seeking. Expectations can adjust over time and I don't put much value on status seeking. [1] The BBC article lists "4 rooms per occupant" as the threshold beyond which there is no increase in satisfaction.
- likpok 6y ago4 rooms per occupant is huge. Consider a 3/3 with a kitchen, dining room and living room. For 4 people (two kids and two parents) you have 9 rooms, or a little over 2 per person. This family would need to double their house size before maxing out.
- 6y ago
- dfxm12 6y agobut in my neighborhood, such homes are largely occupied by multigenerational families. In my neighborhood, these are also duplexes (maybe coincidentally, maybe not, I dunno), which are allowed to be bigger. In areas closer to colleges and universities, those homes end up being shared by large groups of students. Yeah, but these big houses are probably old. In the universities near me, such large houses haven't been built in my lifetime. I doubt it's too much different in Portland.
- crooked-v 6y agoAs somebody living in Portland, there just aren't many existing homes over 2500 square feet (relatively speaking, compared to other homes) in the first place. We have skinny blocks through most of the city, so there's less places for McMansions to even fit. The ones that do exist within city limits are generally $700K and up - if you want under that you'll need to look in a high-crime neighborhood. If you want an existing home over 5000 square feet within city limits, expect to pay upwards of $1.2 million if you want to live out towards the suburbs, or $1.5 million for something closer to dense walkable neighborhoods.
- noodlesUK 6y agoThere’s a big difference between 2500 sqft and 5000+
- imtringued 6y ago5000 sqft was mentioned because those types of buildings are no longer allowed.
- throwawaysea 6y agoAlso why is it the city’s business to limit max home size?
- cptskippy 6y ago> ...2500 square feet. Which is probably fine for a nuclear family... Post-War homes (e.g. after WWII) in America were intended for the nuclear family and were typically under 1000 sq/ft. Most 60s and 70s ranch homes were 1200-1700 sq/ft and considered spacious. A modern 2500 sq/ft house is at a minimum 3 bedroom, 3.5 bath, and a bonus room.
- gurkendoktor 6y agoTo spare fellow non-Americans the jump to Google: 2500 sqft = 232 sqm 1000 sqft = 92 sqm I am living in the latter with my wife plus one small child, and it's clear to us that we want more space for children later. 2500 sqft seems pretty large, but not crazy large either, especially with ~3 kids (=just two generations).
- cptskippy 6y agoIn my opinion, 2500sqft/232sqm is more than enough for a family of 6.
- rconti 6y agoAgreed. I grew up in a 2400sqft house, there were 4 of us. Ample bathrooms and bedrooms and an office, and 2 living rooms plus a separate dining room. Not massive, but larger than necessary for 4.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- honksillet 6y agoThat just your opinion, though. Others may want more.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago"The earth has enough for everyone's needs, but not for everyone's greed" - Ghandi
- crooked-v 6y ago> Which is probably fine for a nuclear family, but in my neighborhood, such homes are largely occupied by multigenerational families. In that case, build a duplex or triplex designed with easy (but lockable) access between units. That gives you a lot of living area, and the same building is also suitable for housing multiple families if it ever changes hands. > In areas closer to colleges and universities, those homes end up being shared by large groups of students. Multi-unit buildings with each unit shared between two people, or (now also allowed by the new zoning) 'cottage cluster' arrangements with a number of physically separate homes sharing one driveway/common area.
- tandr 6y agoThese rules (lockable access between units) work well for student-occupied dwellings, but not so much for multi-generation families, that have a completely different dynamics of what "shared" and "private" areas are, and how they are used.
- crooked-v 6y agoI don't really understand what the drastic difference there is supposed to be. If you want to use all the units as a shared living space, just leave the common-area connecting doors propped open. This is functionality that many duplex and triplex units already have.
- SaintGhurka 6y agoWouldn't joining 2 duplexes needlessly duplicate common areas? I would think a large multigenerational family might want a large family room rather than 2 small ones. Likewise the kitchens. They'd have 2 kitchens, one extraneous and both of them insufficient for the task.
- dgellow 6y ago2500 sq feet ≈ 232m²
- jungletime 6y agoThis is an issue in Vancouver. One large house built to house an extended family of sometimes as many as 20 people. Its a way of depriving city of property taxes, that would have otherwise have taxed multiple dwellings for the same amount of people. So the 2500 sqft limit is to collect more tax.
- klyrs 6y agoI live in vancouver and I don't have a problem with high occupancy houses that are actually utilized. It's the jerks in GRVD who have unoccupied mansions that have been blowing up housing costs that I have a real problem with. Vancouver has addressed that, but afaik Burnaby, tricities and north van haven't.
- mech4bg 6y agoI was a little confused by this, but correct me if I'm wrong but the 2500 sq ft limit is just for R5 lots correct? Larger lots, like R10, can have much larger dwellings on them still.
- zjaffee 6y agoYou can still have homes up to the full size you're talking about so long as they're multifamily, if anything that's better for multigenerational homes...
- novok 6y agoThat infographic says 2500 feet, but the article says '2500 sqft in a hypothetical 5000 sqft lot'. So it's a ratio, not a set limit.