14 ms·
Global Mass Surveillance – The Fourteen Eyes
- eternalban 6y ago“Israel is the 6th - unofficial and undeclared - member of 5 eyes” https://www.richardsilverstein.com/2014/02/09/nsa-maintains-satellite-facility-in-israel/ https://www.richardsilverstein.com/2014/02/09/nsa-maintains-...
- jjcon 6y agoGermany is also currently in the process of joining the five eyes
- dogma1138 6y agoIsrael is not in the 5 eyes it has a bilateral intelligence sharing agreement with the US that specifically forbids further dissemination, Israel is very weary about burning sources there has been a long term ban on sharing certain intelligence with other 5 eye members especially the UK due to multiple past leaks both for political reasons and due to compromise.
- 3jckd 6y agoThe link is dead atm.
- latexr 6y agoWorking for me, but it’s also on The Internet Archive: http://web.archive.org/web/20200825170553/https://www.privacytools.io/providers/#ukusa http://web.archive.org/web/20200825170553/https://www.privac...
- tjohns 6y agoThere's something odd going on. I'm getting an NXDOMAIN error. It looks like I get different results depending on which DNS server I try: $ dig @8.8.8.8 www.privacytools.io (No results.) $ dig @8.8.4.4 www.privacytools.io www.privacytools.io. 3158 IN A 135.181.7.217 $ dig @75.75.75.75 www.privacytools.io (No result.) $ dig @1.1.1.1 www.privacytools.io www.privacytools.io. 1395 IN A 135.181.7.217
- jjcon 6y agoI think it is important that we all take a second to realize that surveillance can be a reasonable apparatus of a well maintained democracy. We should strive to have proper checks and balances on those powers rather than pretend they are not useful or do not exist. With proper checks surveillance can greatly improve national security but it should be kept to that domain and we should seek to prevent abuses. I think us in the EU are due for a Snowden moment at some point here - the public is pretty in the dark on the level of surveillance pervading EU countries. I think it would be better if it was more transparent because we could actually have these discussions and work to prevent abuses.
- adrianN 6y agoHow would such proper checks look like? I don't know of a country which I would trust to protect such data from misuse in day to day policing. Even more concerning is what happens if the country becomes less democratic but the surveillance infrastructure is still there.
- ColanR 6y ago> important that we all take a second to realize that surveillance can be a reasonable apparatus of a well maintained democracy No, I don't think we should just "realize" that. By all means, let's have a discussion; but to accept a priori that some form of surveillance is acceptable reeks of an outlook that has already given up. We should not be fearful and dependent, but rather willing to accept danger as the price of no one looking over our shoulders.
- mindslight 6y agoThis is treason, plain and simple. Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort Foreign spy agencies, even of friendly countries, are our enemies due to their continual mission of attacking us with surveillance. But rather than working to defend the people against these attacks, NSA has chosen to conspire with the attackers!
- swader999 6y agoHow else will we get around laws against domestic spying?
- autisticcurio 6y agoFirstly you were born on a patch of land that imposes its own laws on you. Did you sign a contract to say you would adhere to those laws? This is all about power and control over less powerful innocent people being treated like sleepy idiots. So to answer your question, out smart them to win, and then you will find they play dirty and illegally, against the spirit of the law they claim to uphold. 5 Eyes best demonstrates this by circumventing domestic laws, they dont have the intelligence to win the argument in their own courts. This also tells you that you can out smart them so get thinking, this is an intelligence game.
- justanotheranon 6y agoi am so opposed to mass surveillance that if i could snap my fingers and make both Ft Meade and Cheltenham into craters, i would have zero hesitation. so i am no FVEYS shill. but i still care about the historical accuracy of mass surveillance. in the Snowden leaks, there was a GCHQ document about their policies for targetting US Persons using data shared with them from NSA. GCHQ is not allowed to indiscriminantly spy on US Persons. the document, marked classified as STRAP1, clearly orders GCHQ to apply US laws when targetting US Persons. which means "reasonable, articulable suspicion" before firing up XKEYSCORE and searching for everything a US Person has done in their life. sadly, the reverse is not the same, since the UK has very weak privacy laws compared to the US. NSA can search for anything about any UK citizen without needing some form of probable cause. the Official Secrets Act and RIPA makes the UK into a quasi-dictatorship IMHO, which explains why we see the native population of the UK being so heavily subjugated by their Lords and Royals. part of the SIGINT sharing agreement between NSA and GCHQ is that data will only be shared as long as these rules are enforced. so the myth that the FVEYS is a backdoor to circumvent the law and allow foreign intel to mutually spy on each other's domestic populations is a myth. however, this assumes the FVEYS actually obey the rules in this document. how would we know if they dont? impossible for us uncleared civilians. for all we know, there are more layers of secret laws that allow FVEYS to ignore any and all of the checks and balances intended to limit their abuse of the SIGINT system. that's the problem with secret laws. once you have them, nobody can trust anything about your entire legal system and you become a tyranny.
- PeterStuer 6y agoClicking on the link for Belgium leads to a site with an unbypassble cookie acceptance popup
- ffpip 6y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20200211052201/https://tweakers.net/nieuws/163116/belgische-rechter-verdachte-mag-verplicht-worden-code-smartphone-af-te-staan.html https://web.archive.org/web/20200211052201/https://tweakers....
- freddyym 6y agoOdd. As a team member, I can confirm that we (obviuosly) take privacy very seriously. This shouldn't have happened. Do you have a screenshot?
- hundchenkatze 6y agoI think you misread (I did too at first) it to mean the cookie consent was on privacytools.io. However, I think they're referring to the Belgium link under the "Key disclosure laws may apply" which links to https://tweakers.net/nieuws/163116/belgische-rechter-verdachte-mag-verplicht-worden-code-smartphone-af-te-staan.html https://tweakers.net/nieuws/163116/belgische-rechter-verdach...
- PeterStuer 6y agoYes, this is exactly what I meant, the cookie consent on tweakers.net where you are directed following the 'Belgium' link. I'm sorry for what I can now see as potentially confusing language in my original post.
- freddyym 6y agoAhh, thanks for clarifing. I've told the other team members.
- aborsy 6y agoSurveillance pertains to asymmetric information, a situation where a few in the society (those in power) have access to the information of the rest of the society (those not in power, namely, the public) but not conversely. The asymmetry of the information gives those in power great advantage over public. The rich and powerful claim, we monitor you to protect you, and to better serve you. The scope and the characteristics of the surveillance, the incentives and the historical evidence don’t support this claim. The harm is far more than potential benefits. The public should reread David Hume and stand up against this threat.
- zionic 6y agoWhat I don't see many talk about is how much harm the belief that they harvest everything is, on top of just the actual deed itself. If I am an organization that is well known to be spying on everyone and anything, that means I can very convincingly fabricate evidence against my enemies. It goes beyond simple spying, they now have the ability to manufacture whatever truth they'd like.
- eivarv 6y agoThough not exactly what you're referring to, my impression is that people discuss the chilling effect [0] quite a bit. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chilling_effect#Chilling_effects_on_Wikipedia_users https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chilling_effect#Chilling_effec...
- HugeAcumen 6y agoSome people do - though likely not as many as discuss Love Island. I think the tech community in particular (with both the awareness and the means) has a duty to the public to make clear what is going on to those less tuned in. So far, it has failed in that to a rather astonishing degree. Probably for exactly the reasons yourself and the OP describe.
- nicholasjarnold 6y agoYes, and this so-called Chilling Effect can have a potentially very negative impact on the ability of a democratic society to thrive and possibly to even survive. Democracies require (open, honest) debate. If we self-censor then we hold back on fully-expressing views or positions during debate. This is one of the fundamental issues that I have with this proliferation of population-scale mass-surveillance (domestically in the US and abroad). It will not lead us into any sort of light, despite the promises about safety or less kiddie pr0n or whatever.
- eivarv 6y agoThe Norwegian parliament recently passed a bill that implements bulk metadata collection here as well. I tried debating with ministers, writing op-eds, and even organizing petitions (over 1000 security, privacy and tech professionals in a couple of days) before the vote. While every informed person I know thinks it's a bad idea, and every organization consulted massively criticized it as mass surveillance, a huge majority of our nation's decision makers apparently disagreed. Watching video from the proceedings made me realize just how few of them have any real understanding both of the practical consequences of the technical implementation, as well as of privacy in and of itself (my jaw was literally agape from some comments). How can we do something about this sorry state of things when politicians are not only ignorant, but ignorant of their ignorance – and unwilling to listen to experts that are critical? Besides using privacy-preserving technologies, how can we work against this on a technical level?
- pdonis 6y ago> how can we work against this on a technical level? As the saying goes, you can't use a technical solution to fix a social problem. One way to fix the social problem is to vote politicians out of office when they make bad decisions--not just about surveillance, but in general. People who don't have to pay a cost for bad decisions have no incentive to make better decisions. Another way is to not give powers like this to governments in the first place. If politicians don't have decision making power at all over something, they can't harm the rest of us by making a bad decision.
- vkou 6y ago> Another way is to not give powers like this to governments in the first place. If politicians don't have decision making power at all over something, they can't harm the rest of us by making a bad decision. It is generally impossible for a parliament to pass a law that forbids a future parliament from repealing it.
- pdonis 6y ago> It is generally impossible for a parliament to pass a law that forbids a future parliament from repealing it. Not giving powers to governments in the first place would be something at a higher level than parliamentary. In the US, it would be something like a Constitutional amendment. I agree that no such action, at any level, can ever be completely irreversible, in the sense that future citizens would never have to worry about the issue again. Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty.
- dsbleia 6y agoI'm asking this question not to spark a contentious debate or be ridiculed. But I'm genuinely curious, as someone who has little experience with China and only lived in the US, is the US just as much of a surveillance state as China? We often hear a lot of 'information' (bordering propaganda), about China being an "authoritarian surveillance state". I don't mean to sound absurd, but is the US that much better in terms of authoritarianism or surveillance? If so, why?
- crispyporkbites 6y agoThe US is much better. Take for example internet surveillance: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_and_surveillance_by_country https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_and_surv... China is in another league. They are using deep packet inspection to block services they don’t allow access to, they force some people to install apps on their phone that track them. The great firewall of China is far more visible and impactful than the real Great Wall of China.
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>Take for example internet surveillance: There are three somewhat current reports on there. One comes from the US State department, one from an organization started by Eleanor Roosevelt with strong US ties, and one lists both China and the US as "enemies of the internet."
- jjcon 6y agoThe US and EU countries have processes, checks and balances on those powers (though not always enough, I think they need more). These checks keep abuse low and keep mass surveillance limited to national security domains. This is in stark contrast to China where this power can be used/abused with almost no oversight or limitations.
- casraso 6y agoWhat is a specific example of such a process, check, and/or balance that the united states has that china does not?
- bouchard 6y ago> In Canada key disclosure is covered under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms section 11(c) which states "any person charged with an offence has the right not to be compelled to be a witness in proceedings against that person in respect of the offence;"[10] and protects the rights of individuals that are both citizens and non-citizens of Canada as long as they are physically present in Canada.[11] >In a 2010 Quebec Court of Appeal case the court stated that a password compelled from an individual by law enforcement "is inadmissible and that renders the subsequent seizure of the data unreasonable. In short, even had the seizure been preceded by judicial authorization, the law will not allow an order to be joined compelling the respondent to self-incriminate."[12] >In a 2019 Ontario court case (R v. Shergill), the defendant was initially ordered to provide the password to unlock his phone. However, the judge concluded that providing a password would be tantamount to self-incrimination by testifying against oneself. As a result, the defendant was not compelled to provide his password. According to the Wikipedia article cited when "Canada" is clicked, key disclosure laws don't apply which is the opposite of what the site claims. Or am I misunderstanding something here?
- justanotheranon 6y agoin the Snowden leaks, there is a document that lists the opinions of NSA's legal counsel about a list of collection practices. one of the questions is whether passwords sent across the network are considered metadata or content. NSA legal says passwords are metadata. which means NSA can scan all traffic for passwords and steal them and no FISA warrant is needed, nor a subpoena. of course NSA already has a dozen programs just for extracting passwords from UPSTREAM passive collection. and presumably this means everyone in the FVEYS gets access to everyone's passwords, since they pool their capabilities and collection. whatever the Courts rule about local cops and passwords, it doesnt apply at the level of SIGINT collection, which enjoys its own separate and secret system of laws.
- justanotherc 6y agoWhat does the NSA have to do with Canadian law? Last I checked we weren't the 51st state...
- justanotheranon 6y agothere is no techinical solution to mass surveillance. Pandora's Box can never be closed and the average person will never throw away their cell phone and stop giving their Patterns of Life data to various Internet megacorps. Likewise, there is no political solution. Given the Patriot Act was so well designed to deceive is about mass surveillance, which we never would have voted for if we the governed were asked for our consent, it is therefore cosmically improbably that any politicians will be strong enough to cast the Deep State's One Ring into Mt Doom. that leaves only one option. acceleration. i have slowly become convinced that the only solution to mass surveillance is to expand it as fast and as large as possible, in order to trigger a "Sum of All Fears" scale event, a spying scandal that eclipses all prior scandals, and which outrages hundreds of millions of people like never before. faith in govt and Democracy itself will be shaken and may not survive. that is merely the cost of restoring equillibrium and justice.
- RonanTheGrey 6y ago> to trigger a "Sum of All Fears" scale event, a spying scandal that eclipses all prior scandals, and which outrages hundreds of millions of people like never before Yep. I've spent most of my life searching for solutions that don't require that level of excess, but the problem is, it is a feature of human cognition that we don't learn until we are forced to (more precisely, we do not fix social, economic and political problems until something so extreme comes along that we can't ignore them anymore, usually due to some version of a threat to survival). E.g. - consequences. The alternative is the boiled frog, and yet another feature of human cognition is the ability to normalize our conditions. If something goes on long enough, it'll simply become "the way things are" and go unchallenged. You avoid this by flashing quickly to the worst outcome so people realize that it exists. This is a long way of saying "Humans perceive consequences on short timescales, not long ones" and it really, really sucks.
- shirakawasuna 6y agoMy general sense is that offensive capabilities are much better than defensive ones when it comes to security / surveillance. e.g., even using a VPN and a vanilla browser with no history and arbitrary window size is nearly worthless when it comes to many forms of surveillance. Are there any guides out there that consider all the means by which you can attempt to shield yourself from these intrusions, including a description of the attack vectors?
- acoard 6y agoThe first thing to do is answer what's your threat vector? What are you trying to protect against? And the second thing is answer and what are you willing to give up? The best way is, of course, to not use technology. But that's not worth it to most folks. If your threat vector is general dragnet government surveillance over the entire populous, you're fighting against a shadows. Basically all we know of these techniques come from Snowden. Assume all internet data is logged, whether encrypted or not, and they have direct access to the ISP infrastructure. Room 641A shows the USA has been at this since 2006[0]. Even if your messages are encrypted, it's possible the agency has a 0day. For example, the NSA had decrypted all BBM traffic which was advertised as encrypted. The lesson here is avoid new and popular tools. Instead, just use PGP or other arcane yet reliable encryption methods. If everyone used PGP, I bet the NSA would exploit it too. Don't use a smart phone at all. Using bootable Linux USB of something like Tails on a public computer is probably the best bet, but unsustainable. Even Tails and TOR isn't perfect but it's miles better than Windows, Mac, ChromeOS. If your threat vector is a specific intelligence agency spying on you, (i.e. an APT), you have already lost. I don't think it even makes sense to try and protect against this level of threat. It's like worrying about a tank coming through your frontdoor. If your threat vector is private companies spying on you (be it Facebooks or even private intelligence companies), you have a lot more power here. Besides ISPs, private companies don't own the infrastructure and are not legally allowed to use 0days like the NSA is. In general, end to end encryption is sufficient here. It's all a sliding scale of compromise between security and convenience. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A
- 6y ago
- croes 6y agoIs it five eyes or five Is like in Intelligence services? If it is eyes shouldn't it be 10 eyes? Two eyes per country or is it meant like "in the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is king"?
- mseepgood 6y ago> If it is eyes shouldn't it be 10 eyes? Rather imagine Sauron eyes.