3 ms·
We're not very consistent with this though. We consider it perfectly acceptable to put people in harms way as part of the armed forces. Even though the exact sa
by nicoburns 6y ago
We're not very consistent with this though. We consider it perfectly acceptable to put people in harms way as part of the armed forces. Even though the exact same demographic effects are in play.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- prepend 6y agoThe armed forces aren’t a randomized trial. Many people go into harms way because of a necessary duty (firefighters, etc). The restrictions on medical trials is because of the power imbalance. If I take a job as a firefighter or soldier that’s different from me living my life and being enrolled in some study putting me at risk for harm.
- nicoburns 6y agoI don't see how volunteering to enroll in a study (and being compensated for it) is any different to choosing to take a job as a soldier or firefighter.
- jacquesm 6y agoTaking a job as a soldier is not at all comparable to taking a job as a fire fighter.
- emiliobumachar 6y agoBoth are expected to expose themselves to risk, both get paid. The many differences seem irrelevant to the topic at hand. What am I missing?
- jacquesm 6y agoSoldiers tend to kill people, firefighters tend to save people, the difference - to me - would seem to be obvious.
- emiliobumachar 6y agoThat difference still seems to me not relevant to the topic at hand.
- adrianmonk 6y agoA printer creates documents and a paper shredder destroys them. Therefore, we can't compare the amount of power they draw from an AC outlet.
- throwaway287391 6y agoSoldiers and firefighters also certainly skew less wealthy/educated/powerful, so a priori I'd say the same power dynamics apply there (though it's of course possible that the effect is smaller if you dig into the numbers). It's also entirely possible that some people would feel driven to participate in a medical study out of a sense of duty (e.g. I'm young and healthy and want to put myself at a bit of risk to contribute to our understanding of the virus so that my much more vulnerable (grand)parents have a better chance).
- krageon 6y ago> We consider it perfectly acceptable I doubt people on an ethics board for medical studies would find that perfectly acceptable.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoAnd I agree, but isn't that a strong indictment of medical ethics? If medical ethicists would rather let a fire burn out of control than risk the lives of firefighters to put it out, they're not optimizing for the right thing.
- krageon 6y agoI don't see why it is a strong indictment of any sort of ethics. Waging war is wrong, and saying that it's perfectly acceptable to do so is entirely missing the point. Firefighters are a separate issue altogether, because the subject being discussed is a lot more ambiguous than firefighting (where the problem is clear, and the consequence for sending a firefighter is a positive result).
- sneak 6y agoDangling significant financial incentives to the poor or otherwise disadvantaged is one of their big tricks, too.