24 ms·
Facebook is pressuring its independent fact-checkers to change their rulings
- Lammy 6y agoMeta: the headline at the top of the article is too long for HN's title field so I submitted this with the headline in its <title> which is a bit shorter
- mindfulhack 6y agoBias. It affects everything. Science, religion, politics, public policy, company policy, policing, the judiciary, journalism, and (any)one's decision-making regarding 'facts'. Not sure how we're going to solve it on a platform like Facebook. The systems governing over it - government and politics - are not going so well in the bias department themselves. As for 'the people', they're just as biased. In fact, that's where it comes from. The problem is humans, not the technology. Even though I have low regard for them, sometimes I realise Facebook is doing the hardest job in the world.
- tails4e 6y agoThe problem is the technology too. For the first time in history can two people see the same information source (in this case Facebook) but see two completely different worlds, as each one gets their own bubble, and that bubble is biased. I often see friends Netflix accounts and prefer what they are getting suggested than mine, as Netflix presents me the bubble it thinks i'll like, and I never see the other variation that I want (unless I look at others' accounts), so can't easily expand beyond my bubble. In Netflix's case they want me to see more content, but in Facebooks case they are perfectly happy with bubbles as it makes their targeted advertising easier. Sometimes I'd like to know that the version of a site I'm seeing is the same as others as I really don't want to be in my own information bubble.
- mindfulhack 6y agoYes, great point, absolutely. On that level, things can be done. Suppose I'm talking on a bigger / higher level. (My mind tends to go 'straight there'.) Thanks for giving some hope.
- Nextgrid 6y agoIt’s less about technology per-se and more about mismatched incentives and a toxic business model. Facebook and most social networks are not incentivised to give you a “true” or at least unbiased version of the world, they are incentivised to tweak it as much as they want in order to increase engagement. This wouldn’t be so bad if people were aware of this and would check alternative sources or take steps to mitigate that, but a lot of people seem to not know, forget or ignore this fact. As a less serious example, I always create new music streaming accounts and start fresh (as a perk I get unlimited free trials) every month simply because none of them offer a permanent “incognito” mode and I find my recommendations forever poisoned just because I happened to check out an irrelevant song/album (or let friends use my phone to play music for a party and their tastes differ from mine). This is actually what I miss about radio, where you get an unpersonalized view of the current musical landscape - unfortunately ads are a dealbreaker so I just stick to “hacks” like this instead.
- Lammy 6y agoIt's the technology too, down to the little things like (for example) priming somebody to want to comment on a divisive topic by surfacing those topics to their feed as "Friend commented" edge stories if there's an argument going on. FB's model doesn't know it's an argument and that asking a person to take part will increase the overall level of human-to-human hate in the world. The model only knows what to do to make Facebook the most money.
- chillacy 6y agoWhat makes it worse is there are certain topics where there is no objective, unbiased view beyond believing what most of your peers believe.
- swayson 6y agoTechnology amplifies the effect though.
- kingkawn 6y agoThe presumption that there is a possible unbiased perspective is itself the most insidious form of bias.
- hleszek 6y agoThe presumption that there are always multiple perspectives and that they might be equally valid can be another bias. Especially in the news. Sometimes one party is clearly right and the other is clearly wrong.
- luckylion 6y agoThat's very rare though. Usually, the impression is achieved by intentionally leaving out facts to make the picture look more clear cut. Once you go into the details, in most cases, clarity goes away and everything gets fuzzy and grey. But nobody wants to read "it's complicated, here are some facts so you can figure out your thoughts on the matter", so we tend to cut away half and paint the rest in broad strokes to turn that into "This is reality, and here are the monsters who deny it".
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- BrianOnHN 6y agoI'd love to hear these "details" that paint conservative-trump supporters and their quack-anon conspiracies as anything other than monsters.
- luckylion 6y agoIncentivizing people not to work leads to people not working.
- BrianOnHN 6y agoThat's a straw man argument based on your assumption of second or third-order consequences. Edit: No politician anywhere ever introduced a bill with the intentions of "Incentivizing people not to work." Even "shutting down the economy" has the intention of being able to get back to 100% sooner and thus maximizing total output/GDP/work over a period longer than the short-sighted days/weeks immediately ahead.
- bluesign 6y agoI think the problem is ‘wrong bias’ which is directly related to overestimating self, which is basic human nature.
- intended 6y agoTrue. But not in this case. FB and most sites which have a bias against, say conspiracy theories, regularly find themselves against conservative forces which for, whatever reason, have a willingness to expound and accept conspiracy theories. > https://phys.org/news/2018-12-political-views-people-false-dangers.html https://phys.org/news/2018-12-political-views-people-false-d... Can't find the original articles which showed how conspiracies thrive in different political groups. This then creates the new phenomenon that people here are trying to explain. IF BOTH groups were equal, the bias in action would be then on FB's end. Both groups are NOT equal, and frankly American conservatives (as a group) are far more often to be targetted and spreaders of conspiracy theories and misinformation. This means they are also the subject of far more actions. Since they are the subject of far more actions, this creates a political opportunity. As you can see in this discussion, there is a difference between Perceived Skew of Moderation, and Actual Skew of Moderation. Now people can say "See, we need to deal with FB in congress, because they do more against Conservatives! We suffer more action!". Since FB is also in california, and accused of being "liberal" this accusation is even easier to sell, since it is already believed. FB responds by giving them extra passes, so that they don't get called out or forced to handle new legislation which complicates an already complicated field. ---------- Its really interesting to see how the argument here hinges entire on people's perceptions of what the world is ("both sides are the same") and reality (one side is more affected than the other)
- linuxftw 6y ago> Both groups are NOT equal, and frankly American conservatives (as a group) are far more often to be targetted and spreaders of conspiracy theories and misinformation. If only this were even remotely true. Every time you hear about 'white nationalists' or 'the alt right' doing X, that's a conspiracy theory. And we know who spreads that nonsense. Also, Russia-gate. And how the Senate refused to call witnesses, some large conspiracy. There's currently conspiracy theories floating around about mail sorting machines being removed. In 2016, there were conspiracies surrounding the destruction of primary ballots that were in favor of Bernie Sanders. It's hard to reconcile the evidence with your opinion. It seems to me, both groups market in conspiracy. Both groups think the other group is full of potatoes.
- 6y ago
- commoner 6y agoFacebook has repeatedly overridden fact-checker evaluations in its two biggest markets, India and the United States. Facebook India: https://www.wsj.com/articles/facebook-hate-speech-india-politics-muslim-hindu-modi-zuckerberg-11597423346 https://www.wsj.com/articles/facebook-hate-speech-india-poli... Facebook in the United States: https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/sensitive-claims-bias-facebook-relaxed-misinformation-rules-conservative-pages-n1236182 https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/sensitive-claims-bias...
- jpxw 6y agoCan you name one specific example of a conservative media outlet spreading a demonstrably false story and not being penalised?
- hatenberg 6y agoBreitbart. Plandemic. It was removed but no penalties were leveraged. https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/craigsilverman/facebook-zuckerberg-what-if-trump-disputes-election-results https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/craigsilverman/facebook...
- swayson 6y agoUncomfortable times. As these FAANG organisations grow ever more powerful. In a way these few organisations control majority people's attention, and thereby influencing behaviour and increasingly knowledge as well. I guess its human nature, conquest.
- bjo590 6y agoIt's uncommon throughout human history for private organizations to have such concentrations of wealth and power. Typical such concentrations have been reserved for the state.
- chillacy 6y agoI recall Harari talks about the cycle of capital in Sapiens, with the Dutch punching above their weight compared to Spain due to how they could fundraise for wars by raising war bonds or selling stock, vs the Spanish king who had to increase taxes but could only get as much out of unwilling people. It turned out to be a powerful idea. Technology is also developing faster now than ever before. To what extent they're related may be up to debate, but at least according to Harari, there's a very virtuous cycle between science and capital (also empire, but that's a separate topic).
- Nasrudith 6y agoIt is the opposite really - opinions are some of the least controlled they have ever been as reach is far equalized and means of control at a low. It is one of the least conquered times. Hell the idea that they can even 'control the attention' is a fallacy that assumes they have active knowledge of what their content will do like the New York Times has an editorial control. It is like the idiot congresspeople who spent their question time complaining about their negative search results for their name. Even the heaviest handed management would fail to exercise the level of control as an editor of a scientific journal who knows absolutely nothing about the underlying field.
- swayson 6y agoI mean it is of course a complex system and not meant to be interpreted too simplistically. The gist of my point is, never estimate the power and effect of marketing, media, bureaucracy, laws, and policies on collective human behavior. A few big corporate tech players are increasingly growing in power to influence/control collective behaviour. Which includes funding internal departments to lobby to change laws based on some agenda. Those laws control human behaviour. Those tech organisations also determine the information flow of: words, symbols, images, effectively culture. There is a reason why militaries invest money in meme warfare for example, and these organisation effectively have that power.
- dvh1990 6y agoYou can be loyal to truth or loyal to profits, never both.
- teddyh 6y agoYou can’t serve both God and Mammon. — Matthew 6:24
- wombatmobile 6y agoThe blurring of fact and opinion is the inevitable consequence of the decline of investigative journalism which began in earnest 25 years ago, when the internet broke the business model that newspapers had relied upon since the first print ad appeared in 1704.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoNot quite. It’s only in the 20th century with the rise of pass production that every paper had strong advertising income, and thus the need to expand circulation to a geographically defined group (with ad-reading partisans on both sides). This is what made them compete with quality differentiated investigative news content, and that is how you get the news culture in question. If anything today’s decline has produced a regression to the earlier days of the 18th and 19th centuries, where you sold the content itself, reaching for sensationalism - often overtly political sensationalism, which sells great - and yellow journalism. Ad based papers traditionally hated opinion pages because advertisers didn't really want to be next to controversy. But readers love them. Now that you once more need to sell to readers more than advertisers, now that you have a million choices of news instead of maybe two per city, the whole news medium turns partisan, whether it’s the NYT or Fox.
- liability 6y agoRose-tinted glasses seem to often filter out yellow journalism in discussions concerning journalistic decline. In the late 19th century yellow journalists were largely responsible for starting the Spanish-American War. And mainstream publications were hardly saints in the past either, for instance in the mid-20th century the NYTimes made themselves an uncritical mouthpiece for Stalin with denial of the Holodomor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denial_of_the_Holodomor#Walter_Duranty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denial_of_the_Holodomor#Walter... It's hard to have a meaningful conversation about the present state of journalism with such a sanitized inaccurate understanding of the history of journalism. From my perspective, modern journalism isn't doing great, but neither does it seem to be unusually bad. You might say the American press participated in starting the Iraq War, but in that case they were uncritically parroting what a US president was telling them, rather than pressuring a president who wanted peace into declaring war, as the yellow journalists did in the 1890s. Relative severity of these wars aside, it seems to me that journalism is presently better now than it was then.
- aaron695 6y ago“Abortion is never medically necessary” - https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=508941603187665 https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=508941603187665 Fact Check - https://sciencefeedback.co/claimreview/lila-rose-claim-that-abortion-is-never-medically-necessary-is-inaccurate-it-is-necessary-in-certain-cases-to-preserve-mothers-life-young-america-foundation/ https://sciencefeedback.co/claimreview/lila-rose-claim-that-... If you actually watch the video, her point seems to be removing a baby which will die and possible hurt the mother is not an abortion. The fact checkers state it's "No True Scotsman". Ok, but they never would use that against "Defund the police" And that is the problem.
- Aeolun 6y agoThe general public would still call that an abortion.
- bobthechef 6y agoExcept it isn’t. But a good test is to ask whether the opposition would agree to restricting “abortion” to these cases. If the answer is no, then we know that invoking medical edge cases (which are comparable rare; by far most abortions are performed for no medical reason) are just a pretext and a red herring.
- dang 6y agoCan you please stop posting ideological battle-style comments to HN? It's not what this site is for, and you've been doing it quite a bit. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- aaron695 6y agoThis is addressed in my comment and by the fact checkers, it's a "No True Scotsman" Which would be fair comment if the fact checkers applied this to all articles. Like what 'the general public' would consider "Defund the police" or "medically necessary abortion" If you are an adult you will know "medically necessary abortion" is a sometimes used loophole in places to do non-medical abortions until it can be legislated. If the fact checkers also put false on "medically necessary abortion" when it was misused by the other side then that would be fair and unbiased. But they don't.
- Aeolun 6y agoWhy are these called independent? There’s clearly nothing independent about it...
- colejohnson66 6y agoCause they’re “independent” contractors
- ricardo81 6y agoI think the uncomfortable truth is that no one wants social media companies to be the Internet police, and any kind of arbitration they do on the content posted is going to be counted as negligence or censorship. Unfortunately the business model of these companies is user-generated content at scale, which they never could have effectively policed from the beginning.
- LudwigNagasena 6y ago> no one wants social media companies to be the Internet police I wish. Facebook wouldn’t do anything if there was no angry mob to demand such measures to be implemented.
- linuxftw 6y agoThere's no angry mob on FB. The people that don't like the fact FB doesn't censor content left a long time ago. Everyone that's outraged about FB doesn't use FB. They want to be the arbiter of what other people see and think. This seems to be highly prevalent for a certain political ideology.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoMany politicians quoted in the article are quite explicitly calling on Facebook to be the Internet police. Senator Warren says that Facebook has a responsibility to ensure people have the right beliefs about climate change.
- pault 6y agoI'm no fan of Warren, but a more charitable view would be that she wants people to have the right information, and let them form their own beliefs.
- Ansil849 6y ago> The removed labels are among more than half a dozen instances in which Facebook managers have interfered with fact-checks in ways that appear at odds with the program’s spirit of independence and nonpartisanship. At times, its employees have used a broad exemption for opinion content and previously undisclosed powers to make editorial decisions in ways that favored certain publishers. Content that has been deemed false by its fact-checkers has not always been labeled false on Facebook. In some cases, Facebook has reevaluated fact-check labels or penalties after fact-checkers had acted, often in the wake of political, financial, and PR pressures. > In one previously unreported label change, for example, Facebook pressured fact-checkers to downgrade a label on a video shared by influential conservative publisher PragerU from “false” to “partly false.” So standard question when terrible stories like this are posted: there are many HN members who work at FB. How do you deal with stories like this and continuing to work there?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- intended 6y agoBecause FB is probably one of the few places actually trying to grapple with the scope of this problem in a manner that makes business/practical sense. Not at FB. Content moderation is developing so fast, and with problems so thorny, that the difference between intuitions of normal people and trust and safety teams is whiplash causing. Current moderation practices are perhaps analogous to the ages of proto police forces. Since there is also no separation of powers, moderation is a cost center, and comprehension of moderation principles is nascent and disregarded outside of T&S teams, you have people from sales/strategy/Personal connections overturning rules/policy. The speaker at this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J19Xa3-SN1M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J19Xa3-SN1M, has a book on this topic which discusses some of the many problems this field throws up. FB is trying to resolve this problem by offloading the problematic thought policing to the state, in some way or form - white paper sent in the UK is a case in point. This is likely the way forward for major firms, it seems unfortunate, but unless someone reframes the incentives and problems, government sanctioned censorship is the likely future.
- rndmize 6y agoI bet this kind of mess is exactly what Zuck was trying to avoid when he didn't want to implement free speech restrictions or fact checking, because there's no solution to be found here - if you don't mark anti climate change material as false, your fact checkers are worthless and you're kowtowing to political/moneyed elements that are against it; and if you do, those elements will declare you biased, claim censorship, and seek political action. Of course, the other side will eventually seek political action in the first case as well, so there's no winning. It's been entertaining to watch him gradually tightening the screws on speech over the years though, as if this kind of end result was ever in doubt. Outrage is stronger than principle, and the same thing can be seen on reddit at smaller scale (in the last decade reddit has banned, more or less in order - pedo-adjacent, hate, violence, harassment/doxing, gore and illegal commerce communities). I don't think there's any way for a social media giant to avoid these kinds of restrictions - communities will spring up around any kind of material, other people will find them and the news will write about them (with the amusing side effect that you'll get a Streisand effect if you don't shut it down due to the increased attention). Facebook has it worse it seems - they're actively taking money from some of the groups they're restricting/fact-checking, which is all kinds of messy and filled with conflicts of interest. It seems the money is winning out, which is about what I'd expect. It'll be interesting to see how they resolve these issues in the coming years.
- Lammy 6y ago> It's been entertaining to watch him gradually tightening the screws on speech over the years though It's sad to read the Terms of Service and easily count Facebook PR scandals like rings in a tree-trunk. My "favorite" example is the years-long fights over breastfeeding photos on individual profiles and in parenting groups: https://bc.ctvnews.ca/facebook-policy-on-breastfeeding-photos-sucks-b-c-mom-1.752277 https://bc.ctvnews.ca/facebook-policy-on-breastfeeding-photo... When a policy gets so specific that it starts talking about times the "child is latched" my eyes just glaze over and I can only read it like "DEAR WOMAN, please remember your body is disgusting, you're disgusting for having it, and it must remain covered aside from these extremely-specific legally-mandated exceptions. With love, everyone at FB."
- 6y ago
- Kapura 6y agoI would like to reiterate: delete your facebook account. Do not allow yourself to be party to a clearly corrupt system, when the upside is a messaging app and a convenient way to share baby photos. Facebook's power is it's ubiquity; you do not need to make yourself an instrument of that power.
- capableweb 6y ago> Facebook's power is it's ubiquity Exactly. Facebook is much more than just messaging app and sharing photos. If you're running a restaurant and want to bring people via ads on Instagram and Facebook, you gotta have a Facebook account. There is tons of other things where you could survive without a Facebook account, but it makes business harder.
- rcthompson 6y agoI think that comment was talking about individuals, not businesses. Businesses are on Facebook because people are there.
- capableweb 6y agoI'm fairly certain you need to have an individual account with Facebook in order to setup a business. At least that's what the signup flow makes you believe, maybe there is some hidden options of skipping that. Just went through this a couple of weeks ago.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- type0 6y ago> If you want a vision of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face - forever. George Orwell
- dang 6y agoMaybe so, but please don't post unsubstantive comments to Hacker News.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoThis is an example of people arguing past each other because Americans are not trained in how to dialogue. Sociologists have shown that the introduction of television and the ‘race to the bottom’ that it brought to the masses has dropped population-wide IQ and the ability to form reasoned arguments. In this example, one side is using a definition of abortion which is essentially ‘taking the life of an unborn human for the sake of taking the life.’ Under this definition, a procedure to save a mother is not abortion, because the intent matters. The other side is defining abortion as ‘whenever an unborn human dies’ and this could therefore include procedures that are intended to save a mother but result in the death of the unborn. These definitions do not overlap in a Venn diagram. tl;dr Americans are not educated enough to discuss these topics
- dang 6y agoPlease don't take HN threads into nationalistic flamewar. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- squibbles 6y agoI see the big issue here as whether people want free speech or not. Technology continues to greatly amplify what a single person can accomplish. A person can give their opinion, offer advice, relay misinterpreted or misunderstood information, or even outright lie. The point is that free speech is just that -- free and without constraint. If there are going to be limits to free speech, then who gets to set those limits and who enforces the limits? Whoever gets to set those limits and enforce them assumes control over public discussion. I think the point of free speech usually has been to protect the people from unbridled power. Unfortunately, excessive free speech makes the signal-to-noise ratio intolerably low, and free speech itself becomes a weapon used against free speech. Adjudicating free speech is a very hard problem when everyone has the ability to communicate with everyone else. It is not clear that Facebook, even if it were to prioritize ethics over economics, can address the issue in a manner satisfactory to all (or even most) stakeholders.
- gedy 6y agoThey want free speech for themselves, not for others. They want to shut up people they hate or disagree with.
- xg15 6y agoA different perspective: If most of the speech is spam, hoaxes and lies, and if as a recipient, I have no meaninful way to detect those, then what value does the speech still have? So if everyone can say whatever they want (which is a good thing), the recipients must have some tools at their disposal to verify whether someone should be listened to or not. > If there are going to be limits to free speech, then who gets to set those limits and who enforces the limits? Denying facts that are backed by the overwhelming majority of scientists would be a good candidate for a limit.
- squibbles 6y agoSeeing "facts" and "scientists" in the same sentence makes me uncomfortable. Science is wonderful for exploration, but not so much for adjudication. For example, contrast papers published in peer-reviewed journals with the press releases and news stories that cite those papers.
- twirlock 6y agoAny retard on the planet can figure out all the fact checkers are campaigning for various special interests and ideologies.
- travisoneill1 6y agoI would just like an app where anybody can say what they want and I can choose whether or not I see it (FB used to be this). I'm not interested in their little Ministry of Truth.
- Wolfenstein98k 6y agoThey should never have been in the fact-checking business. They're a platform, not a publisher - or at least they ask to be regulated that way.
- egberts1 6y agoMake a meme that is 99% accurate and Facebook will plaster a cover over it once it finds that largely irrelevant error.