13 ms·
This is really sad. On the one hand, sure Apple should be able to make a cut on their app store, on the other hand, they shouldn't be allowed to force apps to d
by giancarlostoro 6y ago
This is really sad. On the one hand, sure Apple should be able to make a cut on their app store, on the other hand, they shouldn't be allowed to force apps to do this sort of thing. This will only drive domain prices higher on iOS in order to compensate (in the case of Automattic). If I were in a position where Apple is forcing me to pay a 30% tax, I would literally add "30% Apple Tax" to the check out screen on top of the regular fees to make consumers aware. Course I'm sure Apple wouldn't like this at all either.
- iphone_elegance 6y agoIsn't that against their guidelines? the closet I've seen in a 'mobile' tier of pricing that has to apply to android as well but that's only possible with some usecases
- dylan-m 6y ago> On the one hand, sure Apple should be able to make a cut on their app store Apple makes a cut: they charge developers a not insignificant yearly fee of 99 USD per seat, they sell iOS devices and services at great profit, they happily earn 15-30% from in-app purchases and subscriptions wherever developers choose to use those features, they earn 30% on any apps that choose to be paid, and they reserve the right to set a minimum price if free apps inconvenience them. (But free apps very much do not inconvenience them, ever, and this idea that they do and Apple of all companies is doing all this from the goodness of their hearts is a disease). The only reason Apple needs more of a cut here is because their shareholders would probably sue them if they stopped.
- djxfade 6y agoThe 99 USD fee is not per seat
- wwright 6y agoEven if it was, that’s definitely not significant. Each engineer is probably paid more per day than that. (I’m not a fan of the flat 30% charge, but developer program fees are not a challenge for any group with a revenue stream if any kind.)
- dylan-m 6y agoYeah, I meant per developer. Wires crossed. But it certainly doesn't matter what each engineer is paid. Apple has 20 million registered developers. [Edit: And let's say a third of them pay that fee, which is admittedly probably a stretch. The finer details are not my point here other than to say here's a bunch of money that comes in no matter what] I don't care what those developers are making: that's serious income right there. If Apple think they are entitled to more, that's their problem, but don't act like they're making any kind of sacrifice here, and for fuck's sake people need to stop trying to convince themselves that Apple are their friends.
- cwhiz 6y agoIt’s not $99 per developer, either. https://developer.apple.com/support/purchase-activation/ https://developer.apple.com/support/purchase-activation/
- LeonB 6y ago20 million * $99 certainly is real money. For a popular income generating app, the $99 will make an insignificant impact on the marginal cost. But the vast vast majority of apps are not in that category, and the $99 does have an impact.
- christoph 6y agoAlso, the enterprise accounts are $299 and I imagine other than the overhead of the initial on-boarding checks, these generally have pretty low overheads as the enterprise signed apps go through no review process.
- wolco 6y agoIt limits the types of apps found in iOS.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoAnd it limits spam.
- giancarlostoro 6y agoWe're also all very quick to forget not only do they profit off the developer license tiers, but also the selling of hardware. The cheapest brand new Mac you can get is a Mac Mini, used to be $100 cheaper, that alone is per developer so the true costs are much higher.
- rstat1 6y ago>I would literally add "30% Apple Tax" to the check out screen... I've heard from other iOS devs in a similar bind that Apple forbids you from doing anything to recover the 30% cut they take. You either just have to eat it, or make your prices 30% higher everywhere.
- scarface74 6y agoThis is not true. Both Spotify, when they were in the App Store, and NYT have higher prices in the App Store than outside.
- frabcus 6y agoApple enforce the rules capriciously, and change them on a whim. Almost certainly, they allow Spotify and the NYT because iOS customers and potential customers would object too much if they were removed from the store. A well as the 30% tax making all apps worse in quality by removing money from development, the unpredictableness and unfairness destroys many businesses before they even start.
- scarface74 6y agoSo even though I pointed to two well known cases where that isn’t true, you’re getting your information from where exactly? Yes and the 30% cut is moving money from poor Epic’s pockets so they can’t sell virtual coins for dance moves. Most money on the App Store comes from whales playing pay to win games like Candy Crush. You have no proof - not in the rules that are published or anywhere else. You can simply go to the App Store and go to NYT website to show that you are wrong.
- frabcus 6y agoYou're right, I don't have tangible evidence of specifically disallowing charging different amounts on different platforms. It's possible I've conflated that with not being able to call out the charge difference (e.g. by using the words "Apple Tax" on the payment page), and not being able to link to other payment methods (e.g. on web), which massively devalue any benefit from charging more. I agree that Epic are in it to line already rich pockets, and extra money wouldn't improve their service. There are lots of smaller developers where an extra ~42% revenue would make a huge difference, and charging more doesn't work as the customer is price sensitive.
- dshep 6y agoYou would actually need to raise your original price 43% to cover Apple's 30%. And yeah I agree, I am surprised more Apps don't take this approach. But perhaps it is discouraged somehow.
- xoa 6y ago>But perhaps it is discouraged somehow. I think it's primarily "discouraged" by, just, you know the market and basic economics. Think such a statement through: if a business could simply increase pricing 43% without losing anything, they'd just do it. Like, everywhere. There'd be no reason to leave tons of money on the table on any platform at all. But of course in reality raising prices at some point tends to depress sales more than what is gained from the rise, so maximizing revenue means finding the sweet spot of $/unit * unit# = total revenue. And buyers only react to the price they are charged, not the developer's margin. So presumably in general developers have already optimized their pricing, which means there is only limited room to increase it before it's not worth it. Obviously it's somewhat more complex than pricing 101, in reality user populations are not fully randomized samples of the general population. iOS users overall may be somewhat less price sensitive for example, many apps are not completely elastic or substitutable goods, and users who've bought into a given platform face barriers to leaving it. So there is some room for some devs to raise prices a bit, and of course they can't sell at a loss. But most can't simply raise prices by nearly half without losing customers to competitors, or for that matter losing customers to their own free offerings (which themselves they deem necessary).
- nico_h 6y agopretty sure you have to offer the same price as on your website if you offer IAP. it’s one more of the developer unfriendly move of the developer program, alongside that you cannot even hint that you can purchase or subscribe somewhere else.
- dragonwriter 6y agoI think Apple only restricts how you can tell people about lower prices, but I forget the details. Pretty sure you can't include in-app information or links about/to lower-cost options, and maybe you arent allowd to advertise that the iOS IAP price is higher elsewhere, either.
- pwinnski 6y agoThis hasn't been true for a long time. It was true, but changed years ago. You can offer purchases elsewhere at a cheaper price, you just can't push people toward that within the app, or even link directly to a website for it.
- YetAnotherNick 6y ago> If I were in a position where Apple is forcing me to pay a 30% tax, I would literally add "30% Apple Tax" to the check out screen on top of the regular fees to make consumers aware If you don't know that, it is not allowed to sell for more in iOS than in your site, and the app will get banned for attempting that, forget about displaying 30% apple tax to the users explicitly. Edit: Heard from somewhere, likely not fully correct.
- strombofulous 6y agoTwitch charges $5.99 for a subscription to a streamer in their app but $5 on their website. Are they breaking this rule too? How are they getting away with it?
- programmarchy 6y agoWell, Apple doesn't actually allow you to sell an app for $5. You can only choose $4.99 or $5.99.
- saagarjha 6y agoI'm sure they're really hurting for that cent, you think?
- programmarchy 6y agoNot at all. Just explaining why there’d be a price difference. Apple has a good reason for not allowing weird prices like $3.61 but also excludes prices like $5. They also used to require that subscriptions outside the App Store match In-App Purchase prices, but dropped that requirement. Pricing $5.99 in-app and $5 outside is a good strategy. It’s a nudge to get users to buy outside the app and save 15%, but if not they’re effectively splitting the Apple tax.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoYour second paragraph explains why you think there would be a price difference. That you can only choose 4.99 or 5.99 seems unrelated to your actual theory, and it doesn't make sense on its own.
- slaymaker1907 6y agoI think that labeling the extra 30% is also against app store rules.
- grumple 6y ago> Apple should be able to make a cut on their app store They get paid by the phone owner and force themselves to be a middleman. I work on an app that is forced to use the App Store. It would be far easier for us if we could self-host and users could download the app with a click on our website. The submission process is annoying. A hot fix on iOS can take days just waiting for approval.
- GeneralTspoon 6y ago> If I were in a position where Apple is forcing me to pay a 30% tax, I would literally add "30% Apple Tax" to the check out screen on top of the regular fees to make consumers aware. Course I'm sure Apple wouldn't like this at all either. They straight up won't allow you to do this.... I've tried before, and got a call from the Apple Reviewer to say that they won't allow anything like this to be published.
- LeonB 6y agoDo you have more information about this?
- gsich 6y agohttps://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines 3.1.3b >your general communications about other purchasing methods must not discourage use of in-app purchase It's vague (probably intentionally) but having a higher price in the app is certainly discouraging compared to the "normal" way.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoI wonder if Apple did start requiring the IAP price to be the same as the price everyone else pays - would that definitely be illegal? I have a B2B app in the app-store which only has a login-screen on the app - so hopefully that won't attract Apple's attention, but if they do I was thinking about making our service-fee an Apple Pay ("real-life") purchase with lower fees where we'd mail the customer a brick with an activation code printed on... tempting...
- LeonB 6y agoA normal business would not get away with that as it is an unreasonable request. If apple were to do that then it would only be because of their market power. Hence they’d be (further and more clearly) demonstrating that they are in breach of anti trust laws. So yes, my guess is it would be clearly illegal.
- dathinab 6y agoOh, but they also require you to sell thinks for the same price! It at least they do for some goods.
- dwaite 6y agoreference?
- dathinab 6y agoMy bad, I was wrong about that. Through they do have a rule that anything which discourages buying in Apple is forbidden. And what that means is very open for interpretation. What we know is that normally you get in trouble if you are transparent about your pricing. Edit: Fixed phone autocorrect moving up words.
- ransom1538 6y ago"here Apple is forcing me to pay a 30% tax" Well! Let's be clear, you mean "Apple Ireland" gets that cash? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EU_illegal_state_aid_case_against_Apple_in_Ireland#/media/File:EU_State_Aid_Case_Ireland_Apple.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EU_illegal_state_aid_case_agai...
- nicky0 6y agoPut that way it's really a 42% Apple tax.
- anticensor 6y agoIt is an Apple App Store VAT actually. Way higher than VAT rates around the world (the world average is ~20%). VAT: value-added tax
- SahAssar 6y agoThat makes it sound like you're not already paying VAT.
- anticensor 6y agoThat is the point, though. They make you pay VAT twice: once to the state, once to them.
- wp381640 6y agoCounter argument: what would you think of vendors who list products on eBay or Amazon to only drive customers to their own website via the descriptions to avoid listing fees and commissions?
- AsyncAwait 6y agoeBay and Amazon are not the only places one call sell things on. AppStore is the only way to reach millions of people.
- amelius 6y ago> On the one hand, sure Apple should be able to make a cut on their app store Absolutely, but imho it shouldn't be a percentage, but a flat fee. It's not like Apple does more work for more expensive apps.
- innagadadavida 6y agoThis is not just about money to Apple. If it was just about money, then Apple would've accommodated Epic somehow - they generated 100s of millions in revenue per year. This is about control of the platform and Apple is fighting to set and enforce the rules on their platform as they see fit - just like how Wordpress controls how you can distribute changes to their code (to enforce the GPL).