6 ms·
...We are now on month 7... And if people had actually sheltered in place back in March, we might be opening back up (or opening with fewer COVID clusters).
by alistairSH 6y ago
...We are now on month 7...
And if people had actually sheltered in place back in March, we might be opening back up (or opening with fewer COVID clusters).
- jdhn 6y agoI don't believe this for a second. The total number of people that managed to contract it in New Zealand within the last week was under 10, and they locked down an entire city because of it.
- alistairSH 6y agoSo you're saying the lockdown worked?
- jdhn 6y agoNo, I'm saying that the response in regards to the number of people who have contracted it is utterly ridiculous.
- monocasa 6y agoTheir response _allowed_ them to keep the number of people who contracted down. As of now, the US has more than 100x deaths per capita from covid than New Zealand because of measures like that.
- ceejayoz 6y agoWhy? "Everyone stop moving around for a few days so we can contact trace and test these people without it spreading more" seems like a very good mitigation. It has worked well for NZ thus far; they've been able to demask, hug, and live life pretty much normally for a while now. I'd happily take the occasional few days hard lockdown in exchange for that.
- albedoa 6y agoThis is absolutely crazy. You are arguing the point of the comment that you say you don't believe.
- imtringued 6y agoYou have to consider what would happen otherwise. If you lock down cities at 1000 infections then how many other cities manage to reach 1000 infections before you take action?
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoThey locked down the city so that they wouldn't have to lock down the country and bury thousands. The US death toll is over 170.000 now because both people and government alike did not take the measures needed to contain the disease. But hey, 170.000 is just a number, right? Just like the trillions gained in the stock market. Fuck the people that died, they were weak. Right?
- recursive 6y agoI don't understand this. Under what circumstances are you proposing that we'd be able to open back up? What's different now (or could have been) than it was when you claim we should be been locking down the first time? Certainly no amount of locking down would completely eradicate the virus, so what's the exit strategy?
- aspaceman 6y agoIf people listened. There's a genuine culture difference in America, call it American Exceptionalism if you want, that's caused all sorts of normal preventative measures to be ignored or actively rejected. Many businesses actively rejected the idea of requiring masks, today some businesses still refuse service if you're wearing a mask. That's pretty ridiculous if you ask me. Moreso in this thread you have hundreds of comments hemming and hawing, nitting and picking at every detail of proposed lockdowns and mask requirements. People hate this stuff and they call it an imposition on their freedom. In other countries people just put on masks and stayed home. They didn't make nearly as much of a fuss about it all.
- recursive 6y ago> They didn't make nearly as much of a fuss about it all. Yes. But my point is, I don't see how that could make them any closer to re-opening. The virus still exists. All the factors in play when the lockdowns started are still in play.
- alistairSH 6y agoThe problem is the relaxed attitudes to COVID is causing clusters to appear and expand, delaying efforts to re-open. Remember, lockdown isn't about 100% prevention, it's about keeping infections at a level that's acceptable (generally defined as keeping enough ICU beds and ventilators available for COVID+normal use). If people all wear masks, keep distance when possible, and generally "follow the rules", we should be able to return to a more normal lifestyle. But, as politicians force schools to open, pastors insist on in-person services, and the "mah rights!" crowd refuses to play by the rules at all, we get more COVID clusters than we might otherwise.