6 ms·
The last couple months has done more damage than good to me. I'm that type of person who'll lose muscle quickly if stops working out for mote than 2 weeks. It'
by reaperducer 6y ago
The last couple months has done more damage than good to me. I'm that type of person who'll lose muscle quickly if stops working out for mote than 2 weeks.
It's not about you. It's about everyone else.
How can someone be so selfish and self-absorbed that they think their "muscle mass" is more important than the health of hundreds or thousands of other people?
I know this question may violate some HN policy, but I can't help but ask: What's wrong with you?
- ls612 6y agoThis same argument can be made about any infectious disease season. The only difference is a matter of degree. This virus is probably ~5 times as bad as the flu so we should spend ~5 times as much to mitigate the externalities. Not ~500 times as much like we have. I fear that after this every time there's a bad flu season we will see this same shit again because "think of the most vulnerable among us, you're literally killing them!!"
- komali2 6y agoAre you only comparing death rates? My coworker has been told he may never taste or smell again as he "recovers" from covid. There's evidence that COVID survivors might have long term heart conditions https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/health/conditions-and-diseases/coronavirus/can-coronavirus-cause-heart-damage https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/health/conditions-and-diseas... Think of the most vulnerable among us. You are killing them.
- ls612 6y agoThere are rare long-term side effects from many infectious viruses. Anyone who gets pneumonia from anything will be down for the count for a while, but they'll get better, and that isn't unique to this virus. And myocarditis (the heart inflammation people are talking about) is a side effect of all sorts of viral and even bacterial infections (wikipedia lists basically every common human virus as a cause), it will normally get better on its own, although in rare cases it can cause issues. None of this is new! This coronavirus is a novel coronavirus, not a magical one. It has effects that are in line with other viral illnesses in humans. It's just a bit more virulent than them. It's a matter of quantitative difference, not qualitative difference.
- alchemism 6y agoPossible permanent smell/taste loss? Possibly permanent reduction in lung capacity? There is a qualitative difference as well. The lingering side effects of the Lyme-causing bacteria is on a level apart from what happens when you get food-poisoned.
- reaperducer 6y agoThere are rare long-term side effects from many infectious viruses So it's all perfectly fine then? Because there are other viruses that do harm, we should allow this virus to run rampant. Guess how I know you're not a doctor.
- ls612 6y agoYou’re right, I’m an economist, not a doctor. So I look at the world in terms of trade offs. And the trade offs western societies have made with this virus are so unlike the trade offs made with any other infectious disease in recent memory that it makes me concerned about what the new trade offs will be going forward.
- zzzeek 6y agothat's what's known as the "slippery slope" argument. The response to this virus is just so shocking that oh wow, what if this is the new norm? It's not at all. this virus is not "the norm", this is a 100 year event. don't hurt your head on that slope!
- ls612 6y agoHeh, despite the fact that you are being rude to me I'll still answer in good faith because the distinction is important. If we are spending hundreds of times as much mitigating a virus five times as bad as common illnesses (yes a once in a century event) are we now going to spend dozens of times more money/effort mitigating the flu every year? If yes then we will see lockdowns like this regularly going forward. If no, then the vast majority of the response to COVID is an emotional overreaction, not rational risk mitigation/pricing in externalities. I will say in mid-March, when things looked quite different based on our limited knowledge of the virus, that the response wasn't entirely unwarranted. But we've known for months that this isn't nearly as bad as feared. It isn't the second coming of smallpox. Yet we still have most of the restrictions and shaming from March, even to this day.
- liability 6y agoAny flu that clogs your lungs and gives you a fever can give you long term lung or neurological damage. I've seen little to nothing that suggests covid is uniquely dangerous in this regard.
- ardy42 6y ago> Think of the most vulnerable among us. You are killing them. But I like going to the gym, partying, and maximizing the profits of my business! I'm fine with helping, but asking me to make sacrifices is just too much. Isn't what I prefer most important? /s I've also contrived some sympathetic-sounding reasons to justify the choices I already wanted to make, so it's pretty clear that if you disagree with me, you're obviously wrong. /s
- sethammons 6y agoMissing persons in my state are up 22%. Reports of domestic violence are down (but very likely still happening). People are missing health screenings. Lockdowns are killing the most vulnerable among us. We need to take them into account too.
- bobthepanda 6y agono the problem is that severe COVID cases take up space in the hospital for a long time, so it's relatively easy for cases to snowball, people to be unable to admitted into hospitals at capacity, and then for lots more unadmitted people to start dying because they can't get treatment. which is what happened in Wuhan.
- lebedsalavat 6y agototally agree. Stop living life because there's a chance of dying.
- seppin 6y agoHow did "do three things to prevent mass death" (distance, mask, wash hands) become "we're all going to die anyways so i'll keep doing whatever I want thank you." Is America really that filled with narcissists?
- labster 6y agoIt's called "rugged invidualism" here, not narcissism, thank you very much. And the answer is yes.
- Chris2048 6y agoNarcissism is usually associated with self flattery or egocentricism, as opposed to selfish self-determinism/control (unless in the form of performant displays of anti-lockdown value-signalling). COVID inspired woke-scolding is more narcissistic.
- seppin 6y agoThat's one trait of narcissism, the main one is thinking that the world begins and ends with you. A virus doesn't begin and end with you (by definition), so any argument about self-determinism/control is a red herring meant to distract from what is happening. Wearing a mask isn't about you, the same way that a virus isn't interested in infecting one host. It about communal safety, not yours. > COVID inspired woke-scolding is more narcissistic. I have a feeling you would say the same thing with or without a deadly virus ravaging your country.
- Chris2048 6y ago> the main one is thinking that the world begins and ends with you i.e "egocentricism", as mentioned. Are you arguing about the perception of a narcissist, or your own? I'd rather not bite, thanks.
- blargmaster33 6y agoThis kind of thinking is what leads to genocidal government policies.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y ago> I know this question may violate some HN policy, but I can't help but ask: What's wrong with you? There have been times in the past where I've made HN comments that were meant as constructive criticism to another HN user. But my accidental tone ruined any chance of my comment being helpful. @dang was gracious enough to provide me detailed feedback [0], and it seems to be working for me. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24100238 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24100238
- nitrogen 6y agoIt's been a while since I've seen mention of actuarial analyses of the pandemic vs lockdowns. Could millions of people with muscle atrophy cause more economic harm?
- reaperducer 6y agoCould millions of people with muscle atrophy cause more economic harm? Who cares? Why is "economic" harm so important? I'm really tired of people saying "But what about the economy?" I really don't care. I care about my health and the health of my family members. If some artisan dog biscuit company goes out of business, so be it.
- mam2 6y agopeople need money to eat. 60% of americans have 0 savings. It's not just about you
- reaperducer 6y agoYou can't earn money to eat and go to the gym if the hospitals are overflowing with virus victims and society collapses.
- yryan 6y agoHospitals are not overflowing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- abduhl 6y agoI'm really tired of people saying "But what about my health?" I really don't care. I care about my job and the businesses of my family members. If some work from home keyboard jockey gets sick because they left their house instead of locking themselves inside, so be it.
- kyleblarson 6y agoIf you want to be Howard Hughes that's your choice. If someone wants to stay healthy through exercise that's their choice.
- reaperducer 6y agoBy all means, stay healthy. But don't endanger other people's lives to satiate your vanity. And let's be clear here: This isn't about the "health" of the gym-goers. It's about preserving their self-image.
- gnusty_gnurc 6y agoHow about we ship you to a deserted island, or you can confine yourself to your house indefinitely. The rest of society can carry on enjoying their life.
- hadleybelter 6y ago"Staying healthy" can be done with zero equipment and no gym membership. If you think otherwise, then your goal isn't to "stay healthy", your goal is to show off at gym bunnies. And no, your showing off and vanity is not a choice you get to make during a pandemic. Tough.
- ryandrake 6y ago> It's not about you. It's about everyone else. Sadly, this is the source of your downvotes. For so many (even here on HN of all places), it's all about ME. My freedom. My choices. My comfort. My convenience. My need to eat at that restaurant or buy that ranch dressing. My absolute right to do squats next to some random person at a gym. Anything that gets in the way of my freedom to do every little thing I want to do any time I want to do it is bad. We're not talking about genocide here or shredding the constitution. We're talking about sensible and temporary public health policy. But no, I just have to go get my hair done.
- dragosmocrii 6y agoI am neutral towards your comment, but I feel you're judging me for my beliefs and opinions, even though you don't know where I come from and what's important for me.
- mam2 6y agoeh another incel here
- spanhandler 6y agoThere are several decent ways to keep oneself in good shape for a few months while gyms are closed. Insisting this is a big, important problem for you while also (apparently) not taking advantage of those options means the way you're presenting yourself in your comment doesn't look so great, to put it mildly.
- dragosmocrii 6y agoI am taking advantage of the other options, and I am in good shape (well, lean and slender xD). But I can't really replace the gym and the swimming pool with the other options. Also, I am not concerned how others perceive my beliefs because I know what works for me, so to each their own.