10 ms·
Ordeal by Title IX
- fortran77 6y agoAnother good reason not to let kids back on campus! This was a complicated story. But the real issue is a third-party can bring up an issue that happened years ago--even if the primary person involved was ok with it--just because you did or said something they didn't like. This retaliatory complaining should never be allowed or encouraged. If you don't report something immediately, you shouldn't be able to bring it up years later.
- lopmotr 6y agoNot really. Somebody may be discouraged from reporting an abuse because the abuser has power over them. They might wait until after they leave that job.
- cma 6y agoMost people in the US work jobs where they can be fired at will without any cause.
- clusterfish 6y agoThat not being the case for tenured profs is part of their compensation package. The deals other people agreed to are irrelevant.
- cma 6y agoTenure agreements don't protect for sleeping with students.
- clusterfish 6y agoNeither do they protect against witch hunts apparently, nor require so much as an accuser, let alone a non-kangaroo court process to terminate your career. Consensual sex is not a crime, and there are no circumstances in this case that would warrant maximum available punishment for the lowest possible violation of this policy according to the university's own range of possible punishments. This is a witch hunt that never cared about any facts, in all likelihood they just wanted to fire the guy for his political opinions.
- cma 6y agoIt doesn't require a crime to be fired. And even then: We don't know that he would have gotten the maximum penalty under the policy, as he didn't exhaust the appeal that his contract gave him a right to. He resigned and wasn't fired. People working at-will can be fired without any reason. 14 months PTO would be a godsend to them.
- clusterfish 6y agoAgain, people working at will are irrelevant, as his situation is different. You keep bringing it up for some reason, almost sounds like you're just jealous of tenure. He resigned because the process was consistently of a kangaroo court variety. He did get the "sentence" to be fired so there is no need to speculate what would have happened if he didn't resign. There was no point to continue to the one last step because there was no reason to believe that it would be any more fair than the numerous previous steps. You're just finding excuses for his unfair treatment because you don't like the guy or what he did. If a similarly unfair process was applied to a professor you like and respect, you'd be screaming in disbelief at how it's unfair. "Prominent civil rights activist loses tenure", instant 5000 points on HN. And so if you don't care about an unlikeable guy getting a fair process, then I guess you only care that people you don't like are punished by whatever means gets the job done, and that's not something to be proud of. Our society strives to be better than petty tribalism even if the legal protections against that aren't always there.
- cma 6y agoThe tenure agreement doesn't give a right to a trial with due process, just like at will employeement doesn't. You are saying he negotiated something more than at-will, so therefore he deserves something even beyond what he negotiated? And we should consider this a significant problem when the majority of workers who have nothing close to 14 months paid time off and a trial of some sort with an appeals process when they get fired?
- strstr 6y agoThis reads like someone in his department targeted him with the conclusion in mind: termination. Someone wanted him fired. They tried every option available, and they eventually succeeded.
- leephillips 6y agoAnd that’s why Obama’s threat to universities leading them to abolish normal evidentiary requirements did so much damage. When there is nothing like due process, you can use the arbitrary process to do anything to anyone. Rolling back Obama’s abuse and restoring some sanity to Title IX was one of the few good things to come out of the Trump administration.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoHm. It's not a courtroom. A private company may hire and fire, without a judge and jury. Still, there's much that's public about it. Surely some rules are desirable.
- gwright 6y agoDue process is important even in private organizations but a public university is not a private organization so, at least in that context, I think there is a Constitutional argument that due process and respect for other Constitutional rights is required.
- throwaway894345 6y agoDo we know which university it was? Specifically do we know that it was a public university? It’s abhorrent either way, but I’m curious about the identity of the guilty university.
- leephillips 6y agoIn this case (although he doesn’t mention what university it was), it is a “private” university. But the removal of due process from Title IX procedures was due to the threat from Obama to withold federal grant money from schools that continued to insist on fairness. Universities can not survive without this funding, so the government is directly involved in this abuse.
- treis 6y agoThis guys not wrong about Title IX being kangaroo courtish. But he also had a sexual relationship with a graduate student that he advised. The fact that it happened after he de facto stopped advising her doesn't help his case much. She's still very dependent on him for recommendations and his connections for her career growth. The potential for abuse there is very high and it's not a relationship he should have engaged in. Was he railroaded? Hard to tell when it's just one side of the story. But he's not innocent.
- leephillips 6y agoSo he did wrong because of the “potential” for abuse, even though the woman involved had no complaints, and even stated that there was nothing abusive in the relationship?
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoJust because the relationship wasn't coerced (one form of abuse) doesn't make it appropriate. As noted, its a very bad idea to 'go there' because of the confusion of further favors (recommendations/appointments) with sexual favors. Its reasonable for an institution to discourage this kind of relationship. Just like many private corporations do.
- sukilot 6y agoIt's called a "conflict of interest" and is simply handled by recusal.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoBut a Professor's recommendation is very valuable - in some industries, the only path to employment. The temptation to forego recusal is large, especially for a valued graduate student. Unequal relationships (mentor/student etc) are so full of pitfalls, they've been forbidden by many, many institutions.
- csa 6y agoMisguided politics like this is one of the reasons I left the academic world. Universities may have crossed the Rubicon in terms of becoming farcical entities. Bloated bureaucracies, commodification of faculty and students, financial structures based on questionable lending practices, focus of form over function (like in this story), and a big bag of other misaligned incentives make me think that universities don’t have a bright future (at least in their current form). The author of this story is no angel — he certainly should have been more careful with that relationship with his former student in several ways. That said, I can’t really see that he did anything worthy of destroying his career. This was just another case of modern-day witch-hunting.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bufferoverflow 6y agoAbsolutely awful process, very unconstitutional. The guy doesn't even know what the charges are, who the accuser is, can't face the accuser, and has to prove his innocence, instead of them proving his guilt.
- theplague42 6y agoHN should not allow linking to Quilette.
- mcherm 6y agoI'm not in favor of banning ANY particular source. I think it wiser to evaluate any particular article on its own merits.
- cortesoft 6y agoReputation of a publisher is one of the ways you evaluate things.
- RonanTheGrey 6y agoIndeed, and would therefore be up to each reader to decide how that reputation factors into their evaluation of what they're reading and the subsequent conversation.
- jonstewart 6y ago+1. It seems to sneak in on the weekends.
- zimpenfish 6y agoWhilst Quilette is a trashfire of snide insinuation and right-wing batloonery, there does seem to be a non-trivial amount of support for their kind of politics on HN (as evidenced by the links and supportive comments). I'd not want them blocked, per se, but I don't know how best to combat the false narratives they tend to spin.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI don’t follow Quillette avidly by any means, but when they crop up here the articles tend to be well argued and well-supported. In this case, the author presents a truckload of verifiable facts—if he’s lying, it would be easy to demonstrate, and it would rightly destroy his (and Quillette’s) credibility. I have no doubt that he’s “spinning” the story a bit, but provided he’s not overtly lying about the verifiable evidence then it’s already damning of the university. Further, there are lots of publications which have egregiously lied about verifiable events and which we still welcome on HN, but I won’t get into that since it would probably only lead to comments which would run afoul of the guidelines.
- cma 6y agoSo he started a relationship with a student after she had mostly finished, but hadn't walked to get her diploma yet, and he issued her grades during that time that were considered perfunctory. Every professor knows tenure protects from almost everything except sleeping with a student, especially if you are their advisor or involved in their committee. Before revealing he had a relationship with his student, he gives a bunch of innuendo that he was only fired because he mentioned opposing some kind of affirmative action in a hiring committee, but he doesn't prove that was why and doesn't give the committee "due process" to defend themselves. The vast majority of people in this country are hired at will and don't get anything like a long trial to stay on and are subject arbitrary firing with no real due process. It is the norm in employment rather than a new trend (unless you are unionized), but professors have just been protected from it by tenure. But it isn't a new trend that tenure doesn't protect you if you sleep with or have a relationship with a student. It's the one thing everyone with tenure knows isn't covered by tenure.
- itronitron 6y agoTitle IX is some weird shit though, and I doubt that any US company holds itself to the same crazy standard. For example, under Title IX if your colleague shows up with a black eye one day and says they got it from their roommate then you are required to report it to the university.
- cma 6y agoMany (if not most?) companies will fire over a relationship between a boss and a subordinate, or order them to work at separate locations and not be in either's chain of command. He resigned so we don't know how it would have even played out. The process sounds kafkaesque in his telling, but most people subject to at-will barely get any process at all when they are fired.
- csa 6y ago> Many (if not most?) companies will fire over a relationship between a boss and a subordinate, or order them to work at separate locations and not be in either's chain of command. This may be the rule at a lot of places, but it is very rarely implemented, and these relationships are typically just overlooked.
- tus88 6y agoAnd to think this is just a trial of what they want the actual legal system to be. Always experiment on campus first.
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoWho is "they" precisely?
- tus88 6y agoThe lizard-people obviously.
- sukilot 6y ago> Even though they were all dismissed, these three cases implied a pattern of harassment on my part. The other possible interpretation—that this was an organized campaign to damage my reputation for reasons that had nothing to do with sexual harassment—was not considered. He's missing the obvious "systems" answer -- the current culture is to investigate every suspicion, and human nature is to suspect that where is smoke there is fire. The drastically lower bar for investigation -- fine on its own, but then combined with the assumption that accusations likely have some merit (even if they are merely notifications, not accusations!), leads to "guilt by slippery slope". It's the same thing that happens with "mandatory reporting" for child abuse, and the same thing that BLM and similar complain about with overstrict policing.
- kilo_bravo_3 6y agoIt is interesting that quillette chose to publish this piece. The private machinations of rationally acting rational actors acting in accordance with the terms of their voluntary associations seems to be something that quillette would support. For example, they wouldn't support the assertion that a manager at McDonalds conduct a trial where evidence, chain of custody, jurisprudence, and counsel for the defendant be guaranteed before firing an employee. In fact I bet they have published numerous pieces asserting the exact opposite, consistently, in the past. But here we are, criticizing a university for firing an employee. I guess their internal logic is not consistent and freedom only apply to job creators, and not "THE LEFTIST ACADEMIC ELITE".
- throwaway894345 6y agoI don’t see how it’s in the university’s interest to malign and railroad a professor, presumably because he challenged the orthodoxy a bit with respect to its sexist policies. Especially when the cost is him more-or-less idle for the better part of the year (but still paid) as well as the cost for all of these administrators and lawyers fabricating nonsense for over a year. Further, the employee in this case had tenure protection; the university abuses Title IX and other policies to railroad him out of his position. If there is an inconsistency, it’s that the folks who love reducing everything to power dynamics are somehow not analyzing this as a clear-cut case of powerful university administrators abusing their considerable power over an employee. I mean, the provost made the unprecedented move of prosecuting a case that her underlings were adjudicating and flouted the requirement that she present her argument a week in advance. The author provided lots and lots of verifiable supporting evidence.
- kilo_bravo_3 6y agoIt's a straight up reaction to the market. The majority of people in the market the university cares about think that professors who bang their subordinates should be railroaded out the institution. The power dynamics bit is the best part. The voluntary collective of rational actors known as "the university" can choose to ignore violations of unjust policies (the absolute authority given the assent of the managed) the same way jurors can choose to ignore violations of the law though jury nullification. Freedom includes the freedom to bend the rules and have an arbitrary and subjective number of people nod in agreement, thus making it "Okay", no? If the above statement is not true, then literally, in the literal dictionary definition of the the word "literal" every single aspect of society will have to be destroyed and rebuilt from the ground up.
- prepend 6y agoIt seems that these investigations are a huge revenue source for the firms conducting them for the university. If it cost the author $27k to defend, it must be far higher for the investigating firm. Since they have multiple attorneys on the case, and spend more time. So this seems like a situation where there is a vested interest in conducting lots of these investigations.
- mcherm 6y agoAll of the author's complaints come down to issues of "due process". Due process doesn't mean running a trial or decision-making process in the particular way that US courts do, rather it means running such a process in some fashion that is consistent and reasonable. Personally, I believe that it is extremely important to maintain due process in our trials and procedures. In this case the author fundamentally has two complaints. The first complaint is that when he was accused of a Title IX violation, the procedure was so unreasonable and so biased against the defendant that winning cost him $27,000 and an entire year of no contact with his university and no response to the charges (thus destroying his reputation). The second complaint is that he was slated to receive an extremely harsh punishment (loss of tenure and being fired) for what he considers a rather minor violation (having a consensual relationship with a former student who was technically still associated with the university). All told, I agree: the ultimate outcome (him resigning) may be reasonable, but the process for reaching it clearly was not.
- sukilot 6y agoWhat's reasonable about firing someone for doing nothing wrong where no one got hurt exceptthr feelings of a puritanical busybody invading people's private affairs ?
- tomohawk 6y agoWhy colleges need their own court system is beyond me. We have a perfectly usable one that actually has reasonable protections for the accused. It's sad that officials in the Dept of Education can put in place such an egregious system, which is literally designed to infringe on people's rights, and not face any consequences. Like so many things at that level, there are expectations for officials to act properly and protect our rights, but when they don't, there is no specified punishment.
- sukilot 6y agoTitle IX / DOE is a misdirection. This was driven completely internally by Uni administration, with Title IX only mentioned as the excuse. There was never a Federal complaint.
- xondono 6y agoThe amount of this “new puritanism” that the US is displaying is amazing to me. The idea of a bureaucracy like university administration controlling the love life of the professors is ridiculous IMO.
- colejohnson66 6y agoIt’s not “puritanism;” it’s about conflict of interest. If you’re sleeping with, say, a student, you’d be more likely to give them a better grade than Jane/John Doe.
- xondono 6y agoTitle IX and all of this controversy has nothing to do with conflict of interest. The so-called sex-negative feminism that forms the ideological bed for most of it, is in it’s heart very puritanical
- throwaway894345 6y agoOf course, that’s not the case here since the relationship took place after the student left the university. Further, many Title IX cases aren’t related to conflict of interest at all. Here is a list, mostly of such stories: https://reason.com/tag/title-ix/ https://reason.com/tag/title-ix/. A common theme is consensual drunken sex in which one party expresses regret at some later time and reports the other party. Title IX defines “consent” such that drunken sex cannot be “consensual”—drunken sex is rape per Title IX guidelines. If this sounds dramatic, please give that link a read; this is the most charitable interpretation. The interesting thing about this “drunken sex is rape” interpretation is that logically it would imply that if both parties were drunk, then they’ve raped each other. Of course this is ridiculous, so universities either decide that the man is guilty (presumably in a “Believe all women” sort of way) which is ironic in that Title IX ostensibly prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex. Another way in which universities resolve this dilemma is by assuming the first to report is the victim and the other party is the rapist. There are probably other universities who elect not to address the dilemma at all and are happy with the mutual rape interpretation. In all cases, this seems per puritanical to me. EDIT: I forgot my favorite example—the Northwestern University feminist professor whose Title IX criticism was deemed to be a Title IX violation. Criticizing Title IX is a violation of Title IX, but you still have a swath of people arguing that Title IX is a Very Fine Law (indeed the law is fine; the guidelines are problematic).