10 ms·
Web browsers need to stop. Enough is enough
- michaelhoffman 6y ago> Mozilla just fired everyone relevant to focus on crap no one asked for like Pocket, and fad nonsense like a paid VPN service and virtual reality tech. Not disagreeing with the rest of this, but I love Pocket.
- grayhatter 6y agoI hate that something which only exists to data mine, or serve ads is enabled (by default) in my web browser.
- dgellow 6y agoSerious question: would you pay for an equivalent service that doesn't mine your data?
- grayhatter 6y agoIf I actually believed that I was the customer, and not the product; yes. Obviously, that depends on a lot of things, but something that would recommend, cache/archive, catalog things I find interesting/care about. I would be willing to pay for something like it. I already pay for pandora, I'd absolutely pay for something that expanded my knowledge base.
- pwdisswordfish0 6y agoI loved pocket when it was still ReadItLater. The WebExtension sidebar plugin for Firefox is strictly worse than the old one and they haven’t improved it EVER. Instead we get bullshit pills that tell us that a link we saved is very popular. I’ve already saved it and I don’t want to know this.
- mrvenkman 6y agoI think Pocket is great too ... a great selection of articles.
- m-p-3 6y agoI love it too, and I was delighted to find official support for it on my Kobo eReader.
- avery42 6y agoI'm really disappointed that Mozilla still hasn't open-sourced Pocket, like they said they would when they acquired Pocket in 2017 [0]. At this point, it seems like a broken promise. Given this, I moved to Pinboard, which isn't open-source either, but is faster, easier to use, cheaper, and has taken no VC funding. I'm interested to see if their increased focus on products that generate revenue, like Pocket, will mean that it'll finally be open-sourced... although it doesn't seem like something that will significantly increase revenue, so I doubt it's a priority. [0]: https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2017/02/27/mozilla-acquires-pocket/ https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2017/02/27/mozilla-acquires-po...
- adam_klein 6y agoJust curious, why the author thinks that Safari is a joke?
- sally1620 6y agoSafari on Mobile still has a considerable market share that is not going away. But on desktop Chrome dominates. Even on mobile, Android market share (hence Chrome) is a lot larger than Apple.
- ralls_ebfe 6y agoIs safari free software? I can't seem to find it in f-droid.
- xet7 6y agoNewest Safari is only available for macOS and iOS. There used to be Windows version of Safari, but it is not updated anymore. Safari is based on Webkit/KTHML/Konqueror source code, some of the source code is public and has been contributed back from Apple to Webkit. But full source code of Safari is not public.
- antonyh 6y agoSafari became truly niche when they retreated from Windows. And everyone I know with a Mac uses Chrome. The only place it's relevent is on iOS, and only then because of enforcement by Apple to use their rendering engine - given the freedom, Chrome would use Chromium on iOS, and Firefox would be Gecko. We can't even debug mobile Safari pages without a Mac. So it ends up as 'probably works' because it works in Chrome.
- colesantiago 6y ago> Enough is enough. What I don't like about this post is too much emotion, not much action. > If you’re a Google engineer who is still working on AMP, you are a disgrace to your field. Really? Career shaming? That's very low of the author to do. Why are they a disgrace?
- grayhatter 6y agoI assumed it came from a previous essay. Asserting that engineers should take responsibility for their actions in spite of their job. If your employer is doing something immoral or wrong, and you don't do something. You're part of the problem, and share in their guilt.
- saurik 6y agoSomeone actively sits down and codes all the things that make the world a worse place, and they often do it after and despite all of the arguments for why it is bad; maybe you disagree that AMP is a problem--I, honestly, haven't made a decision there yet--but to be very blunt about it: we tend to attribute too many things to organizations and companies when there should be a list of very concrete names of engineers working at companies like Apple or Google that actively continue to work on technologies like DRM to lock people out of devices and tracking to centralize data... and we should remember it was only due to their willingness to work on these projects that these projects get done.
- m463 6y agoI believe the word you're looking for is quisling. I used to really be happy about computers - they made people's lives better. But business interests have really changed how computers work and I truly hope we can get them to work for us again.
- mathw 6y agoWe live in an unethical economy. Do you expect everyone to be able to live off founding an ethical startup?
- 6y ago
- alpineidyll3 6y agoIt's undeniable that someday chrome will end, and when it dies several Manhattan projects worth of work will die with it, with very few positive side effects besides V8. But hey I guess serving ads is really important?
- The_rationalist 6y agoWas this mostly thoughtless comment AI generated?
- galonk 6y agoThe argument that browsers should stop trying to become an OS on top of the OS (e.g. webUSB) deserves better than this overly emotional rant. The browser that has been holding the line in this respect, Safari, is dismissed without explanation.
- m463 6y agoMobile safari has intimate links into the OS, intercepting links and sending them to apps, and no real ability to filter content. (content blockers are opt-out - and you have no ability to even know what is loading)
- sthnblllII 6y agoBrowsers should be linked to the OS. The problem is that Google is trying to replace your OS with Chrome so they can track everything you do. Apple has resisted implementing a lot of bad stuff Google is trying to push, and made serious, if insufficient, attempts to stop tracking.
- the_hoser 6y agoMozilla fired the XR team.
- blub 6y agoThis is a vicious cycle of Google pushing new APIs to cement their grip on the Web and the web developers chasing fads to reduce their permanent sense of inferiority compared to native developers. You can see that this is the case when you look at Safari which tried to limit features. It's arguable whether that's because Apple limits the best APIs to native apps, or those features don't make sense or because of a combination of the two. But it's undeniable that web developers mercilessly criticized Apple and relentlessly put pressure on them to keep adding all sorts of nonsense to the browser. Ironically this is why today Safari has a partially negative reputation, which the author seems to be unaware of. To put it bluntly, the web as shaped by these two forces is fucked. There is no one that matters which still cares about the idea of a user-focused, privacy-respecting web. There's too much money to be made in an ad and tracking laden, kitchen sink APIs web.
- detaro 6y agoAnd you can see a bunch of the "fad" APIs, that make up the term "PWA", that Apple rejects as a form of an "user-focused, privacy-respecting web" - allowing cross-platform alternatives to native apps that can easily spy on more of the system. Especially on desktop platforms. Even extreme ones like WebUSB: between the choice of "download an application and run it with normal privileges so it can update the firmware on a connected device" and "go to a website, confirm in a browser prompt the specific device the website can access, have it update the firmware and know that it didn't leave any traces elsewhere on the system and couldn't access other hardware", the latter has some good about it.
- ecf 6y ago> to reduce their permanent sense of inferiority compared to native developers. On the contrary, you make it seem like native developers all have a superiority complex. The world of already filled with people wanting to divide us, can we please not try to ostracize one group of developers?
- sally1620 6y agoIf Microsoft cannot stand up to Google, what do you expect from individual developers? Google has monopolized the power over the web. And soon they are going to use it to their advantage.
- bishalb 6y agoWhat do you mean soon? They have been doing so for years now.
- imvetri 6y agoWe can stop complaining about them and start creating an interface that abstracts web APIs.
- Havoc 6y agoThis does ring true but stop everything isn’t the right answer either. Maybe rather a slowdown and less niche stuff. I mean the whole point of a browser is that it’s pretty generic and universal. The trend to make everything an app annoys me more (ie each news service, Reddit etc). Whole point of a browser is to avoid that.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoThought that name sounded familiar, and sure enough, this is the Drew DeVault behind SourceHut, a project very much in keeping with the ideal of a web that is both usable and technically simple.
- kennethh 6y agoThis is the same rant one said about windows many years ago, one should not bloat and add more and more features. The answer is still the same, things need to evolve if it gives meaning and give improved user experience and value. It is only natural to bundle more and more functionality in a product. Many years ago IE 6 won the browser war and was set in maintenance mode for many years, but no progress made it easy for someone else to take over. First Firefox and then later Chrome. I think the Chrome team have learned their lessons and will continue to improve the product and make everyone else follow as long as there is user demand for the features and it gives strategic sense for Google.
- kasabali 6y ago> I think the Chrome team have learned their lessons and will continue to improve the product There's a fine line between improvement and churn
- boomlinde 6y ago> The answer is still the same, things need to evolve if it gives meaning and give improved user experience and value. I don't think critics disagree with this notion. Rather they disagree that the bloat gives meaning/improved user experience/value. It admits the existence of incompetence and perverse incentives. The latter seems like a natural consequence of profit-driven development when user satisfaction is only loosely and partially tied to profit.
- sthnblllII 6y ago“The Chrome team” hasn’t just made ‘mistakes’. The problem is that Google’s whole reason for making its own browser in the first place was to entrench the web features it uses to track you and veto any efforts to replace them. Engineers are not the ones making these decisions.
- ben_utzer 6y agoWe should start from the foundation and rewrite the specifications for CSS. Once that is made more human, more rendering engines will pop up.
- tibbydudeza 6y agoChrome and it's bastard stepchildren like Electron is an OS upon themselves using Windows just as a glorified launcher and then sucking up all possible computing resources to render web pages. Older versions of I.E are nimble and fast compared to it.
- mark_l_watson 6y agoI would argue against the comment in the article that Safari is a joke. It is a fair criticism of Apple that they limit new experimental features to promote native apps, but looking at this a user perspective (OK, just my perspective) is that I want functional web apps that perform a service (good examples our the web interfaces for ProtonMail, FastMail, and Gmail) for use cases that truly need a web app, but for most "content centric" web sites I want great content and pleasant looking layout - things that can be achieved with HTML and CSS. To continue my little rant, the noise to signal ratio is getting so bad on the web that I now try to find people who really have something useful to say (Ryan Holiday, Azeem Azar, Matt Taibi) and pay for content. I think tech like WASM is cool, but its proper use cases are few and far between.
- Justsignedup 6y agoWhat I dislike about these rants: - the web is technically open but the browsers are the gatekeepers. - browsers are FUCKING HARD to build. Very very hard. So many details. And you are the #1 target for malicious hackers. - Rewriting the renderer for things like Firefox Quantum takes a lot of work, because every freaken webpage has to work on firefox. Every single one ever. That has been a HUGE challenge. So at the end, yeah, lots of companies are trying to make money making a browser that everyone else (especially google) is giving away for free. So of course they are gonna try to do anything in their power to make money. Of course Mozilla is gonna start positioning themselves as the "privacy focused" browser and sell a VPN. The list goes on. The question is: What can we do differently?
- lolsal 6y agoFrom the article/rant: > Safari is a joke. Why? I use it daily as my primary browser. I am a software developer. Anytime I enter a discussion about this, I get a lot of responses that are _completely irrelevant to me_ about plugins or ... rendering? or whatever other stuff I honestly can't even remember. None of that stuff matters to me. Safari is a great browser - it's simple, fast, and the only annoying thing about it is there are sites that will display modals saying I should use a modern browser like Chrome. Get real. If you dismiss Safari as a 'real' browser, your opinion loses credibility to me. I honestly wonder if you've ever used it, or are hopping on some bandwagon about it.
- surfearth 6y agoI agree wholeheartedly and gave up on the article when I read that line. On my Mac, Safari is quick, resource efficient, and does everything I need it to do. I'm sure there are some downsides, but to dismiss it as a joke is ridiculous.
- adamredwoods 6y agoDoes Safari still use webkit? So a part of Safari is open source, contrary to the blog post.
- SergeAx 6y agoThe problem with Safari from the web developer viewpoint is that it constantly doing something different. There was a horrible time back in early 200x years when we needed to check our HTML and CSS in all the browsers. Today this is mostly over: 99% of layout and scrips are behaving the same in Chrome, Mozilla and both Microsoft IE and Edge. Except for Safari. It is especially annoying for devs working on Linux or Windows machines: we need to have a separate Mac machine to debug Safari issues, and it is twice annoying to be forced to deal with MacOS/Apple special ways of implementing UI/UX.
- lolsal 6y agoYou helped illustrate my point though - I don't care at all what you have to do to do your job as a user using a browser. Sort of like how I don't care about how the engine in a Subaru works compared to the engine in a Honda.
- pellaeon 6y agoThis is definitely something that should be fixed by the vendor, but as a (Firefox) user if you want a quick fix you can use https://github.com/pyllyukko/user.js https://github.com/pyllyukko/user.js
- dsleno 6y agoLong live gopher space. Gopher://magical.gopher
- MavropaliasG 6y agoLets hope that Falcon can serve as a good alternative in the future https://www.falkon.org/ https://www.falkon.org/