8 ms·
Android has a plethora of app stores, there have always been tons of them. Some phones have shipped with three or more, one from Google, one from the phone manu
by simonh 6y ago
Android has a plethora of app stores, there have always been tons of them. Some phones have shipped with three or more, one from Google, one from the phone manufacturer and one from the network. Then you could add another one from Amazon, etc, etc.
Google Play Store won out on Android simply because the multitude of stores was a nightmare for customers. They don’t want multiple stores, they want one store on this phone, that will also be on their next phone. Any ‘monopoly’ wasn’t seized by Google, it was pushed eagerly on them by customers craving consolidation and simplicity.
Same for me, I don’t want 5 blasted stores on my iPhone. I want one store and run by someone I trust. The same goes for my Switch too, I’m quite happy for Nintendo to run the store for it. If I don’t like how they run it, I’ll get a PS 5 or XBOX. That’s where the competition is. I have plenty of choices thanks.
- kuon 6y agoI can understand that having multiple store can be frustrating for the user, but why not have multiple stores with federation? You have one app implementing the federated store protocol, and you and browse all federated stores. This would allow multiple actors to be present, while keeping things simple for the users.
- zepto 6y agoWho sets the rules for the federated storefront? The store design has a lot to do with which apps get attention.
- m4rtink 6y agoThis already exists on desktop Linux - all the deb/RPM/Flatpak repositories each have a standardized metadata format, so you just add a URL to the given repo and the OS will work with it the same way as with the default repositories.
- ISL 6y agoI'm really interested in a Debian-quality DFSG Android app store. Debian's apt repository is truly the "app store" that I have chosen to trust.
- cure 6y agoSame for me; Debian's apt repo is my computer "app store" of choice. On Android, the F-droid app store (https://f-droid.org/ https://f-droid.org/) comes closest but it has nowhere near the breadth of the Debian repos.
- nitrogen 6y agoWasn't the old Nokia Maemo OS based on Debian? I seem to remember being able to `apt-get install` things in the terminal on my N770 (or whatever the model was) tablet.
- ISL 6y agoYes.
- heavyset_go 6y agoYes, and it was glorious. I keep one running for fun, and there are people still working with whatever Maemo transformed into.
- m4rtink 6y agoFor the record Maemo spawned among other things Sailfish OS (running on my dakly smartphone) and many current mobile Linux distro projects can trace their lineage to Maemo on the Nokia N-series.
- heavyset_go 6y agoYep, and I think a few Meego derivatives might still be out there, as well. Also, Maemo was revived as Maemo Leste for platforms like the Pinephone, although I'm not sure how active the project is.
- warent 6y agoIs your iPhone primarily a gaming device? I don't understand how you're seamlessly leaping from "Phone" to "Game console" and making equivalency comparisons. In my ways my phone/computer is an extension of who I am as a person. They are my second brain. Having that functionality dictated by a company feels nightmarish to me. Imagine if you didn't want to be blasted by multiple internet forums, multiple news feeds, or even multiple websites. Why have more than one website on the internet? Have the entire internet be a single website run by someone you trust. That's the natural conclusion of where your preference leads.
- refulgentis 6y agoThe 'your iPhone is an Xbox' is the Gruber approved narrative as of last week, the Apple community left defending this is sextupling down on that idea.
- misnome 6y agoOr, it’s an extremely obvious immediate parallel
- refulgentis 6y agothat bizarrely didn't appear till last week, which is odd. Before that it was 'appliance'. But I'll accept the downvotes for the churlish tone
- scarface74 6y agoYou really haven’t been around here long. I’ve been making the argument for months with the downvotes to prove it.
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoI was describing the iPad as an "app console" back in 2010 (https://tracks.ranea.org/post/1432038656/geek-luddites https://tracks.ranea.org/post/1432038656/geek-luddites). It's not at all impossible Gruber read my blog post on that back then, in fact, as it was linked around a few places. I think you're getting a bit hung up on the language -- "appliance" and "console" are trying to communicate basically the same thing, e.g., a device which on a technical level could absolutely be a general purpose computing platform but has been restricted from that by design.
- Larrikin 6y agoOne store is great IF you can load apps independently from other sources
- kmonsen 6y agoWhich you can in android, it's a setting everyone is free to change at any time.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoThis is completely false. The Play Store has "won" by Google chopping the legs off all the alternatives. They have to be sideloaded and you have to enable a scary checkbox to do so, that suggests it's less secure to use any app store but the Play Store.
- oxymoran 6y agoOf course they have to put a scary checkbox, otherwise they would be held liable for any sketchy app that is actually malware people accidentally downloaded. And I guarantee if the checkbox wasn’t there, you would be complaining that there aren’t enough safeguards to keep people safe. I can’t even stand Google, but come on.
- saurik 6y ago> And I guarantee if the checkbox wasn’t there, you would be complaining that there aren’t enough safeguards to keep people safe. I hope what you mean is that someone else would be making the argument that the checkbox is necessary: claiming a crowd of people are a single inconsistent argument is disingenuous.
- pb7 6y agoBut the opposing crowd exists and maybe you personally don't have to deal with it but these companies do. Apple and Google deal with billions of ordinary people, not just tech nerds.
- _qulr 6y ago> Of course they have to put a scary checkbox, otherwise they would be held liable for any sketchy app that is actually malware people accidentally downloaded. What do you mean by "held liable"? It can't be in the legal sense, because Microsoft has never been held legally liable for Windows malware, and Apple has never been held legally liable for Mac malware.
- pb7 6y ago
- rbecker 6y ago> iPhone, Switch, PS5, XBOX [..] I have plenty of choices thanks. I can hardly imagine anything more pathetic than listing 4 locked down, corporate controlled devices, and calling that "choice".
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gjs278 6y agook... and I'd rather be allowed to install on my phone what I want. so you can have your main store, let us have your side stores. gentoo has a main overlay of software, but I'm free to checkout anyone else's overlay and install software, this should be no different.
- jrockway 6y ago> Same for me, I don’t want 5 blasted stores on my iPhone. I want one store and run by someone I trust. The individual stores thing is actually really annoying. If you play games on Windows you're familiar with this situation. They all want to run 24/7 and cram their UI in your face at every opportunity, and you just want to play that publisher's one game. They are trying to become chat apps, and web browsers, and it's just crazy. I think my computer will explode if it sees one more web page wrapped in a "start at login" script claiming to be an "app store" or "game launcher". (Why can't these things just let me "chocolatey install" them? I know how to keep Windows apps up to date. Just accept my credit card number from inside the app. Or, horrors, a web page.) On Windows, the underlying cause of this is "because we can". Everyone that wants a game will install an app store to get it from without thinking, because the one Microsoft offers is too limited. (They don't use Steam because it's run by a direct competitor, and Steam games kind of have that feeling like there are 3 good games in there next to 100,000,000 "I downloaded Unity this weekend, give me money!" games.) Where I'm going with this rant is that unlimited freedom is the worst form of app distribution -- except for all the others. (I guess I have zero qualms with "go get". It works 100% of the time. Apps can't explode files all over my computer. Google provides a CDN for free.)
- whatch 6y agoThere is GOG Galaxy[0], that is trying to gather all your games from different platforms in one place. However all platforms (except Steam) constantly disconnects from the Galaxy which is really annoying. I understand there can be a lot of reasons for this. But I like to think that those emerging platforms simply do not want being accessed from the Galaxy. For this reason I prefer buying games from GOG and Steam when possible. Also, to install games from those 3rd party platforms one still needs to install and launch those platforms. So this limits usefulness of the Galaxy. [0]: https://www.gog.com/galaxy https://www.gog.com/galaxy
- Errsher 6y agoIt's just like technology standards. https://xkcd.com/927/ https://xkcd.com/927/
- rkagerer 6y agoAre there any well-curated and maintained app store alternatives? I'd love to keep Google Play off my phone if there were a competitor who did a better job at surfacing truly great apps (rather than the garbage suggestions Google spams me with) and passed on a bigger piece of the pie to publishers.
- m4rtink 6y agoFDroid and also the Aurora alernative Google Play client.
- beastman82 6y agoThis is an anticompetitive argument. You're asking to be taken advantage of.
- gknoy 6y ago> Same for me, I don’t want 5 blasted stores on my iPhone. I want one store and run by someone I trust To be honest, I wouldn't mind having the option to specify multiple stores that I trust the same way I do the Google Play store. I could imagine having Google Play, the Epic store, the Blizzard store, and Steam on my phone if that were necessary. I am not worried about being spammed with stuff, as apps don't run until you open them, normally, and I already have granular controls over what notifications spam me on Android as it is.
- mirthflat83 6y ago> I could imagine having Google Play, the Epic store, the Blizzard store, and Steam on my phone if that were necessary. This sounds like an absolute nightmare.
- gknoy 6y agoOh, it really would be. :D I meant more that if one did have it, I would not be afraid to get spammed with notifications, any more than i already am (and turn them off...) for any other game or app I install.
- kgwxd 6y agoI want 0 stores.
- enos_feedler 6y agoExactly. Consumers don’t want stores really. They want the content that comes from them. Businesses want stores.
- yazaddaruvala 6y agoI'm a customer. I do not want to vet all brand quality for each brand individually. I want to be able to choose between a few pre-vetted options that I can already trust. I want stores like Costco and Apple's AppStore because I trust those companies to vet brand quality and provide me a basic level of trust for the products. I'm happy to pay a 30% premium for that piece of mind.
- CarbyAu 6y agoOn the one hand I agree with this. On the other hand I would like the option to add another App Store who's "Brand of quality and trust to vet apps" I can compare to Apple's store... and so the layers go... On the gripping hand, it is the "benevolent dictator" problem. A benevolent dictator really can be an efficient and great way to run things. For the people that agree with the dictator. But who determines who the dictator should be and what makes them benevolent?
- kgwxd 6y agoVetting is separate from selling. There can be a vetting service that just links to direct downloads. I use stuff like that on my PC all the time. The only reason to lock the obtaining of a product behind the vetting service is to grab money.
- yellowapple 6y agoThe answer, then, is to have a single "store" app with multiple sources, such that you can add and remove sources at will. This is exactly what F-Droid is able to do on Android, and what nearly all reasonably-popular Linux distributions have been able to do for decades.
- mulmen 6y agoDidn't Linux package repos solve this like 20 years ago? The store app (or yum/apt/whatever) is the entry point then you load in as many repo URLs as you want. Can't that model expand to phones? It's basically how my Fire TV worked. I could search for a title in the home screen and it would tell me that it was on Prime Video, Hulu, Netflix or I could rent from Amazon or whatever.
- threeseed 6y agoThe only reason Linux doesn't have malware/viruses is because the number of people running it on the desktop is basically zero. And the people using them are much more technically savvy so it's really not worth anyone's trouble. Now if you were to take the package model and move it to Windows it would be the same mess we have today. Many of us, including Apple, do not want ransomware, malware and viruses on their phone. It's not a computer. It's a phone.
- mulmen 6y agoGreat then don't install the other repos. IIRC FB and Uber both got caught doing things other companies couldn't do. Apple's vetting process is not foolproof either. Apps still do things I don't want them to do, on my own device. Apple can still control the OS and device and sandbox the apps and app stores. It's not an insurmountable problem.
- m4rtink 6y agoAnother thing many dont know is that distros rebuild all software from source code, so any mallware is hard to hide.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- heavyset_go 6y ago> Android has a plethora of app stores, there have always been tons of them. Google put restrictions on Android so that third party app stores can't install in the background, auto-upgrade or batch install. > Google Play Store won out on Android simply because the multitude of stores was a nightmare for customers. The Play Store is the only app store on Android where users can install apps in the background, auto-upgrade apps or batch install apps. The reason the Play Store won out on Android is because it the only app store that Google allows to have the features app stores require.
- scarface74 6y agoJust maybe because of things like this? https://www.cnet.com/news/just-as-critics-feared-fortnite-for-android-came-with-an-epic-security-risk/ https://www.cnet.com/news/just-as-critics-feared-fortnite-fo...
- heavyset_go 6y agoPerhaps people want the ability to choose between fully featured app stores, because of things like these https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2020/01/researchers-unearth-malicious-google-play-apps-linked-to-active-exploit-hackers/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2020/01/resea... https://blog.trendmicro.com/trendlabs-security-intelligence/first-active-attack-exploiting-cve-2019-2215-found-on-google-play-linked-to-sidewinder-apt-group/ https://blog.trendmicro.com/trendlabs-security-intelligence/... https://www.techrepublic.com/article/new-android-bug-targets-banking-apps-on-google-play-store/ https://www.techrepublic.com/article/new-android-bug-targets... https://www.zdnet.com/article/popular-apps-on-google-play-linked-to-old-remote-code-execution-bugs/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/popular-apps-on-google-play-li...
- scarface74 6y agoSo either use Google’s insecure App Store, use someone else’s insecure app that’s sideloaded or by an iPhone. I think you just made a good pro-Apple argument.
- barrkel 6y agoWhat you're describing is a natural monopoly.
- rpdillon 6y agoThe problem I have with one-store-to-rule-them-all is that it has to be run by somebody, and I never agree with the decisions of one judge 100% of the time. So I like to have the option to get software somewhere else. I purchased the device, after all.
- variable11 6y ago>I want one store and run by someone I trust. Google is not trustworthy. Look how every time someone criticizes Google on here, a horde of pro-Google paid commenters appear, like magic.
- kccqzy 6y agoNot just the user, but the developers want a single store. As a developer you are focused on writing apps; you don't want to spend energy to figure out how to upload apps to 5 different stores, understand their individual requirements like app descriptions and screenshots, manage 5 sets of credentials and certificates, deal with 5 different review processes, etc. Just ask any android developer who develop for the Chinese market where Google is absent. It's a nightmare.
- gfxgirl 6y agoThat seems like such a ridiculous attitude. I want one just one grocery store! Want less common ingredients? NO! I just want one store! I want just one hardware store! Want some part they don't carry? Sucks to be you. Just one car store, etc... If nothing else I at least one two stores. One for regular apps and one for porn apps. You can see steam now has lots of adult apps.
- bromuro 6y agoWhat about _no stores at all_? I am fine downloading the app or buying it from the dev website.
- birksherty 6y agoAre you saying people avoid other stores even though they know about them? Then I disagree. If I ask people I know in real life, they can't tell any other app store besides Google's. Even if their phone includes others. Every phone comes pre-installed with play store. Then they don't look for another store, they never need that. People learn and teach others how to install apps only from play store.
- smichel17 6y ago> I don’t want 5 blasted stores on my iPhone I don't want 5 blasted distribution methods on my (Android) phone. I'm perfectly happy with 5 different sources, though. Put plainly: I want repositories, not stores. I get to use the same tool (app) to manage all of them, and I can add different sources if I'd like.
- coliveira 6y ago> I don’t want 5 blasted stores on my iPhone. I want one store and run by someone I trust. You must be representing the first generation that is anti-competition and pro-monopoly. It makes no sense that you would really want to have fewer options to buy a product. If the problem is trust, then clearly what you need is regulation, not a monopoly.