4 ms·
Interesting you bring this up - why don't normal businesses also setup endowments like this? How come i've only seen universities do this?
by chii 6y ago
Interesting you bring this up - why don't normal businesses also setup endowments like this?
How come i've only seen universities do this?
- Aeolun 6y agoNormal businesses generally don’t have enough free money to do something like this. While the business has value by virtue of its assets, the amount of free cash is much less. Software is an exception in this since you basically only have free cash, there are no physical assets as such.
- mschuster91 6y ago> Normal businesses generally don’t have enough free money to do something like this. And why don't they? Decades ago, having cash reserves was a Good Thing. We need to get at the root of the issue and that is that companies have gotten used way too much on government bailouts and redistributing everything possible to shareholders/customers.
- bsder 6y agoErr, no. The problem started with people like Carl Icahn. If your company has too much cash, someone will attempt take control to carve it up and get their hands on the cash. So, every business basically runs fairly close to cashless or even carries debt in order to avoid corporate raiders unless they have SO much cash that nobody can even hope to buy them (see: Apple).
- ghaff 6y agoAnd then people complain that they're holding onto cash rather than 1.) Doing something "productive with it" or 2.) Returning it to the owners (shareholders)--the latter of which at least is not a wholly unreasonable position as it isn't really the company's money to hold on to at some level.
- fouc 6y agoI imagine there's a way to setup a trust such that hostile takeovers can't access the money.
- Aeolun 6y agoI was thinking more of the corner store, with tons of inventory that make up a large part of their value. But relatively it probably applies to bigger manufacturing companies as well. Hell, it probably applies to Amazon (the retailer, not AWS).
- mschuster91 6y ago> Hell, it probably applies to Amazon (the retailer, not AWS). That's perhaps the most genius thing in the Amazon system: the actual amount of cash bound in warehoused inventory is negligible - they only have the risk for stuff they directly sell. For all the other products, the sellers are on the hook towards the manufacturers. Essentially they are an online Walmart with next to zero of the risk a real Walmart has because most of their inventory risk is shifted towards the "sellers"...
- treis 6y agoMost retail has net 90 day payments and forced returns where manufacturers have to accept unsold product. Walmart and other big retailers likely have little money tied up in inventory. They sell a product before they have to pay the manufacturer for it.
- rudiv 6y agoWalmart is specifically famous for having some of the most onerous terms amongst all large retailers. Anecdotally, Walmart has asked for net 270 terms from a supplier I am accquainted with.
- Spooky23 6y agoWalmart is tough on terms but meets obligations. I worked on a farm in high school that sold would sell them Fall stuff — pumpkins, cornstalks, etc. They would pay net-10, which was unheard of, most of their big buyers habitually paid late. The local grocery chain would pay 60-90 days late on a 30 day invoice. The cash in hand was worth sometimes losing a little money.
- mschuster91 6y agoBecause having "leftover cash" that is not immediately redistributed to shareholders is seen as a Bad Thing (tm). Because in the end, when shit hits the fan like with the 'rona, the government will be conveniently pressurable to bail you out. Personally, I rather have government bailouts than mass bankruptcies - but bailouts should come with "strings attached" like, let's say, a requirement to always keep one year of expenses at a reserve to avoid the need for future bailouts.
- chii 6y ago> "leftover cash" that is not immediately redistributed to shareholders is seen as a Bad Thing (tm) sort of a short sighted view if that's really the case - since the cash being in the company's books, or in an endowment, is still value owned by the owner. The small penalty of it being illiquid shouldnt be a problem.
- thomasahle 6y agoI guess, from a shareholder perspective, why would I want my investment to invest in other things/companies? Then they might as well pay out the money, so I could invest it myself.
- mschuster91 6y agoAnd that is why government regulation is overdue to ensure a fair and level playing field without leaving the government on the hook in crisis scenarios.
- Spooky23 6y agoOne reason is that it makes the enterprise more resilient, and that is valuable in many industries. Look at how quickly oil and gas companies implode when there is a price shock.
- thomasahle 6y agoTrue, and I personally think it's a good idea. The stockholders though would probably say that they can just supply the capital themselves, if the business is in trouble.
- senko 6y agoI'm not sure it would make sense for normal businesses, as owners want to, well, profit from the profits (share price rise, buybacks, dividends, sale of business at a higher valuation, etc). However, in Mozilla's case, the owner of the corporation is a non-profit, and (to me at least) it'd make a perfect sense to set up something like this.
- tomrod 6y agoLawsuits. If the endowment becomes known it becomes a target.
- bovine3dom 6y agoShareholders generally like businesses to use their money on things only that business can do. If the best thing the business can think to do with the money is put it in the stock market or a low-interest cash account, which anyone could do, investors usually demand that the money is returned to them (via dividends or share buybacks) so they can choose what happens to it.
- saalweachter 6y agoI additional to the "no one has the money for that" / "profits go to shareholders" angle, also consider the systematic perspective. If every business has an endowment, what are those endowments invested in?
- sukilot 6y agoThey are invested in the business or diversified, obviously. Look at any corporate balance sheet
- sukilot 6y agoBecause "endowment" is a simply the non-profit term for "capital" in business. Harvard's endowment is invested in profitable business to raise money. It's a non-profit so it doesn't pay out the profits. A profitable business invests its funds itself or returns them to the owner institutions, who chose whether to keep funding the business.
- andrepd 6y agoGreed? For too-big-to-fail companies, also the thought that profits go their pockets and losses come out of ours.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]