9 ms·
The "Big Semi" salaries are notoriously low for the amount of effort one needs to put into his education, and early career. A physics, or engineering PhD. is a
by baybal2 6y ago
The "Big Semi" salaries are notoriously low for the amount of effort one needs to put into his education, and early career.
A physics, or engineering PhD. is a minimum to be allowed anywhere near actual work on the process, and those guys only get $50k-$60k a year in Taiwan after 5+ years.
A regular "technician," or a PhD interns can get as little as $2000 a month.
Of course, the few real know how holders are kept loyal at just any cost, and I heard rumours of 7 digit incomes for those few. This is by far the biggest "carrot" that keeps luring people into RnD work in Semi.
- haecceity 6y agoThis is good for silicon engineers and tech industry in general. This will make the entire sector more competitive. Unfortunately HN can't see that and would rather have silicon engineers be paid lower wages than to have them go to China. When workers fall for nationalistic rhetoric in the media it's the workers that suffer.
- jszymborski 6y agoNo, I think HN would rather see TSMC offer higher salaries and that the worlds largest authoritarian gov't not advance its agenda for tech dominance.
- tehjoker 6y agoDisagree. I believe what they are after is "tech independence" not tech dominance. They are afraid America will cut them off. Honestly, it's probably a very interesting opportunity for hardware engineers. It's not super often that an entirely new fab, architecture, and industry are set up from scratch. It might be a way to get out from under various legacy assumptions and try something new.
- caycep 6y agoWell, it is a stated CCP goal for "AI dominance", at least. And money designated for such likely will filter through these state-sponsored companies..
- tehjoker 6y agoDominance in a specialized field like that, I can buy. AI is important, but it's also under-delivering on the hype (though what it has delivered is impressive).
- jameslin 6y agoWho stated it is CCP goal for "AI dominance"? Western media? Sure everyone want to be at the top of the food chain, but calling it dominance is just pure scaremongering.
- DetroitThrow 6y ago>Who stated it is CCP goal for "AI dominance"? Western media? After a moment of Googling I found the answer, I don't think HN really benefits from presumptuous statements against a poster - presume good faith. >Sure everyone want to be at the top of the food chain, but calling it dominance is just pure scaremongering. "Market-Dominance" is a current tenet of PRC AI strategy, or at least in the words of a document published by the PRC detailing the country's AI strategy. Sources: (ctrl-f dominant) https://www.newamerica.org/cybersecurity-initiative/digichina/blog/full-translation-chinas-new-generation-artificial-intelligence-development-plan-2017/ https://www.newamerica.org/cybersecurity-initiative/digichin... http://www.cittadellascienza.it/cina/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/IoT-ONE-Made-in-China-2025.pdf http://www.cittadellascienza.it/cina/wp-content/uploads/2017....
- yorwba 6y ago> (ctrl-f dominant) First link: Two hits: "Market-Dominant" and "the dominant role of the market in allocating resources". The second one is obviously about being dominated by the market, not dominating it... and the first one as well: "Follow the rules of the market, remain oriented toward application, ..." It's about investing in AI technologies that already have some success in the market rather than pie-in-the-sky projects without application potential. Bonus: ctrl-f "dominate": "dominated by the market" Second link: Two hits, "give markets the decisive role in allocating resources, strengthen the dominant position of enterprises," and "Strengthen the dominant position of enterprises in the market". While that may sound like the government picking winners, within the context of market reform in China it actually refers to strengthening the position of enterprises as opposed to the government. Repeating this slogan ("强化企业主体地位") signals that the government does not intend to return to a command economy (where the government was in the "dominant position") even when it comes to funding strategic development projects. Googling for policy documents and then ctrl-f'ing for keywords is a good first step, so props to you for doing your own research, but it doesn't help much if you lack the background knowledge to interpret what you find.
- haecceity 6y agoEvery competitor aims for dominance. Engineers should be paid more, telling them not to accept money from firms from authoritarian governments is laughable. You should be encouraging western firms to be competitive not blaming China for being authoritatian or seeking dominance. I suppose it's easier to blame others than encourage western firms to improve though. So much for democracy.
- justicezyx 6y agoJust to point out the context. https://english.cw.com.tw/article/article.action?id=2403#:~:text=The%20latest%20data%20published%20by,wage%20was%2051%2C957%20Taiwan%20dollars https://english.cw.com.tw/article/article.action?id=2403#:~:.... Looks like the local wage is very low in general, 90% percentile is 37,114.60 or 1.09 million in Taiwan Dolloar. So it seems 50-60$ USD is quite high-end after 5 years with a PhD.
- ivalm 6y agoI mean, in the US in 2017 after condensed matter Physics PhD where I did nanofab I could go work for intel/asml/lam and get like 110-140k starting. Or I could do data science/more SWE related and get 140-250k. The choice wasn't very hard. The lowest software job paid as much as the highest hardware job despite me being a specialist in the nanofab/hardware. Also, the opportunities for growth/future earnings/work life balance/etc are all better with software related jobs.
- eric-hu 6y agoThe stats don’t tell the whole story. China considers Taiwan a province of its own. People from Taiwan legally can work in China with about as much effort as someone can move from Kansas to California for work. As with Silicon Valley, you’ll find people tend to move where there are bigger salaries. (not my personal view)
- beaunative 6y ago$50k~$60k USD is relatively high compare to local living expensives, and average wages. By US standard, or rather Silicon Valley standard, most jobs in most places have extremely low wages. That's not how it works. The currency conversion only works when you go purchase imported goods or export stuff. Use it to compare living standard is only useful when both countries relied heavily on imported goods for essential need, which is not true.
- varjag 6y agoThat's also not how it works for in-demand, global, niche talent.
- beaunative 6y agoConsidering how H1B are getting treated, let's not pretend we live in a world where talents move freely across border without restrictions. This is true for people from Taiwan coming to China for work though, there is almost zero friction besides a plane ticket and some paper work.
- arcticbull 6y agoTo be fair if they really are the cream of the crop, an O-1/EB1A would be the path forward.
- geodel 6y agoSo in-demand global niche talent and just go and take another job which pays double or ten times higher salary. It shouldn't be a problem then.
- varjag 6y agoIsn't that what they did?
- vkou 6y agoThe average apartment in Taipei costs ~$620,000 USD. Given that you need to go to school for ten years, and work like a dog, 50-60K is not a great wage for that environment.
- jjoonathan 6y agoRumors of huge payoffs would be cheap to start. I can't speak to the situation in Taiwan, but in the US it's dismal. The rumors I heard from disgruntled relatives and postdocs I met in nanofab class prevented me from going down that path despite the strong allure and good match to my interests and skills. My current job is nowhere near as interesting, but it pays me with actual money, and though that decision felt overwhelmingly cynical when I initially jumped ship, a quick survey of the others in my cohort who didn't jump ship leaves me with few regrets. They work a multiple harder than I do, on things a large multiple more important than I do, and they get paid a fraction what I do. As a reward for taking the high road, they are likely to lose their jobs as the United States continues shipping semiconductor manufacturing and engineering abroad.
- kamaal 6y agoFor brain-power-application Vs Payoff, Web Software already overpays. I chatted with crossword designer a few weeks back, and it was fairly heavy brain work for little pay. Similarly, there are lots of people, including electronics engineers who put in fairly more brain work and make little out of it. Software outside Web dev is somewhat similar too. You don't get paid that much.
- jjoonathan 6y ago"Overpays" is relative, certainly there are no shortage of examples compared to which it underpays, but it does seem to be a trend that smarter (and physically harder) jobs have poorer pay. I wasn't even including the FAANG/SV premium and that's still true. It's a pity. I would love to apply more brain power in my day job, but there's such a negative incentive for doing so that I can't stomach the cost. So I've got a hobby. Oh well.
- arcticbull 6y agoI take it that's 60K USD per year, but not adjusted for PPP? Adjusting for PPP that's $140,000 per year. > Of course, the few real know how holders are kept loyal at just any cost, and I heard rumours of 7 digit incomes for those few. That's pretty true across any industry. These nominal-to-PPP adjusted salaries are roughly in line re: base compensation for what I would expect a good tech job outside the bay area to pay. If you got a job at the upcoming TSMC fab in the US, $140K would be about right. Converting using exchange rate isn't the right way of comparing compensation as you're not trying to buy something in the US with your Taiwanese compensation. You're trying to determine a compensation figure in the US that gets you as much in the US as the Taiwanese salary gets you in Taiwan. This is when you use PPP.
- inetknght 6y agoWhat is PPP?
- panda88888 6y agoI think purchase power parity.
- arcticbull 6y agoExactly. "Purchasing power parity (PPP) is a measurement of prices in different countries that uses the prices of specific goods to compare the absolute purchasing power of the countries' currencies." [0] The Big Mac Index is a more approachable way of looking at it (and also shockingly accurate). For instance, in this case a Big Mac is $5.71USD in America. However, a Big Mac in Taiwan costs 71NTD ($2.44USD). This means that your $60,000USD salary in Taiwan will go ~2.34X further in Taiwan than a $60,000USD salary in America. So a 60K USD salary in Taiwan is roughly equivalent to a 140K salary in the US. [1] Using market exchange rates only makes sense when you earn in one country and you're planning on buying something from a different country. If you earn and spend in the same country (for instance, looking at moving from Taiwan to the US), you want absolute purchasing power, not relative, so PPP compensates for that. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purchasing_power_parity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purchasing_power_parity [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/274326/big-mac-index-global-prices-for-a-big-mac/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/274326/big-mac-index-glo...
- Keyframe 6y agoIsn't TSMC's operating margin something obscene? Like ~40%. They could afford better comps. People mentioning PPPs and local standard.. that's all bs if your workforce can and will move globally with ease. Tell them their comps are good for Taiwan while they're packing.
- usrusr 6y agoBut on the other hand going too far beyond local levels can put a lot of pressure on your hiring process. You might end up with a workforce consisting mostly of experts in appearing very hireable and little else.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- imtringued 6y agoPack up and go where exactly? TSMC is already the biggest employer.
- Keyframe 6y agoAcross the strait. What we're discussing - the article.