5 ms·
Without a significant drop in the $ per kg cost of putting stuff in low earth orbit, I wouldn't take that bet. I don't think SpaceX starship will be revolutiona
by walrus01 6y ago
Without a significant drop in the $ per kg cost of putting stuff in low earth orbit, I wouldn't take that bet. I don't think SpaceX starship will be revolutionary enough to put probes in LEO cheap enough.
Once in orbit it's possible to reach things in the asteroid belt entirely through very high efficiency ion/hall effect thruster propulsion, which can have specific impulse as high as 8000.
Any probe capable of drilling or melting into the crust of ceres or Europa or similar will have to be quite large...
- eru 6y agoWhat odds would make you take the bet? And, perhaps let's talk about a conditional bet that removes the difficulty of space exploration: The bet pays me X dollars, if human vessels can go to the asteroid belt and not find life. It pays you Y dollars, if we find life. And no payment in either direction, if we can't go to the asteroid belt and don't find life. Say, all limited to the next 100 years. What's the ratio of X to Y that would make you accept such a bet?
- hyperpallium2 6y ago(not OP) Another clarification: before you said "non-earth life". Panspermia[1] implies Ceres and Earth life are related, so that native Ceres life is hard to distinguish from Earth's (and arguably is the same as Earth life). 1. Backtrapolating exponential evolution finds an origin older than Earth. https://arxiv.org/abs/1304.3381 https://arxiv.org/abs/1304.3381
- eru 6y agoTo be more precise: what I meant is life on Ceres that hasn't come accidentally from any of our own probes since eg the start of the 20th century. I'd be happy to pay up in case of pre-historic panspermia.
- valuearb 6y agoThe Space Shuttle payloads to LEO cost $40,000 per pound. Before SpaceX commercial launch payloads cost $5,000 to $10,000 per pound. Falcon 9 payloads cost around $1,500 per pound. Falcon Heavy payloads cost around $1,100 per pound. Starship payloads will cost between $100 and $500 per pound. It will be able to lift at least 100 tons to orbit. And using in orbit refueling, it will be able to accelerate that 100 ton payload 6.9 km/sec, making landing it on Ceres trivial.
- simonh 6y agoTrue, but in orbit refuelling means 3 or 4 additional refuelling launches, so now your cost per kg is back up to a few thousand $ per kg again. Still cheap for Ceres though.
- imtringued 6y agoYeah, orbital refueling doesn't change the rocket equation unless you can manufacture fuel in space. The only benefit is that you don't need a bigger rocket.
- rbanffy 6y agoWe'll eventually get to the point where Starship-like rockets only ferry people, cargo, and, maybe, propellant to LEO for transfer to spaceships that don't need to go deep into any gravity well. These ships will then take you to orbit around your destination so you can board another shuttle to the surface.
- valuearb 6y agoThat would be massively inefficient for travel to Mars, because you can Aerobrake to land and make fuel on Mars for your return.
- UnFleshedOne 6y agoYou could probably aerobrake to get into orbit instead. But eventually it might make sense to build ships that are never supposed to touch atmospheres, or only upper layers. Some design constraints can be relaxed then.
- AuryGlenz 6y agoWouldn’t a nuke work?