4 ms·
Considering that there's organisms that live at ridiculous pressures, with absolutely no sunlight and at the extreme temperatures of deep sea volcanic vents, I
by walrus01 6y ago
Considering that there's organisms that live at ridiculous pressures, with absolutely no sunlight and at the extreme temperatures of deep sea volcanic vents, I would not be surprised at all.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrothermal_vent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrothermal_vent
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrothermal_vent_microbial_communities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrothermal_vent_microbial_co...
- crowbahr 6y agoThe question is can life arise in such an environment, or only migrate to one. That's yet to be determined as far as I know: extremophiles have all evolved from less tolerant life forms as far as I'm aware.
- eru 6y agoThough, of course, you might expect to see that, even if life can arise in extreme environments: It's uncontroversial that life is much denser in more hospitable environments. If the extreme environments are in regular contact with the hospitable environments, and if evolution is sufficiently random, you would expect over time that most organisms anywhere have an ancestor in the hospitable environment. Even if life can arise in the extreme environment.
- bitreality 6y agoWhat is the most hospitable environment? A tide pool? Also the most hospitable environment for genesis is likely different from the most hospitable environment for a complex ecosystem.
- Symmetry 6y agoFor life without photosynthesis, which takes a while to develop, some place with a lot of free chemical energy because the first replicators will be very inefficient. White and black smokers under the sea are usually put forward as candidates.
- eru 6y agoThat's an additional good question that would complicate the simplistic model I suggested in my comment.
- sfvisser 6y agoLive on earth might actually originate from geothermal vents at extreme (for us) conditions. See the excellent book The Vital Question by Nick Lane.
- guerrilla 6y agoOne of the theories I heard recently was that life could arise anywhere there are energy gradients, conditions for forming bubbles and the right substrates. I'm not sure how accepted that is (heard it in a popsci lecture) but it seems plausible.
- eru 6y agoI would still be surprised in the sense that I would gladly give you 100 to 1 odds that we won't find non-earth life on Ceres in the next hundred years. What are your odds?
- walrus01 6y agoWithout a significant drop in the $ per kg cost of putting stuff in low earth orbit, I wouldn't take that bet. I don't think SpaceX starship will be revolutionary enough to put probes in LEO cheap enough. Once in orbit it's possible to reach things in the asteroid belt entirely through very high efficiency ion/hall effect thruster propulsion, which can have specific impulse as high as 8000. Any probe capable of drilling or melting into the crust of ceres or Europa or similar will have to be quite large...
- eru 6y agoWhat odds would make you take the bet? And, perhaps let's talk about a conditional bet that removes the difficulty of space exploration: The bet pays me X dollars, if human vessels can go to the asteroid belt and not find life. It pays you Y dollars, if we find life. And no payment in either direction, if we can't go to the asteroid belt and don't find life. Say, all limited to the next 100 years. What's the ratio of X to Y that would make you accept such a bet?
- hyperpallium2 6y ago(not OP) Another clarification: before you said "non-earth life". Panspermia[1] implies Ceres and Earth life are related, so that native Ceres life is hard to distinguish from Earth's (and arguably is the same as Earth life). 1. Backtrapolating exponential evolution finds an origin older than Earth. https://arxiv.org/abs/1304.3381 https://arxiv.org/abs/1304.3381
- eru 6y agoTo be more precise: what I meant is life on Ceres that hasn't come accidentally from any of our own probes since eg the start of the 20th century. I'd be happy to pay up in case of pre-historic panspermia.
- koheripbal 6y agoWithout any volcanism, it's hard to imagine there are hydrothermal vents at all.