7 ms·
Bill Gates calls Microsoft’s TikTok deal a poisoned chalice
- Solstinox 6y agoI guess Microsoft may drop ~$30 billion on this poisoned chalice out of goodwill.
- topkai22 6y agoI think Bill Gates is worried that assets acquired in a $30B deal may take inordinate amounts of time and attention from senior leadership, at the expense of the rest of a $1600 billion business.
- throwaway324343 6y agoHe's chairman of the board. He can stop it if he wants to.
- samfromnz 6y agoNot any more; he stepped down earlier this year. https://news.microsoft.com/2020/03/13/microsoft-announces-change-to-its-board-of-directors/ https://news.microsoft.com/2020/03/13/microsoft-announces-ch...
- blackoil 6y agoHe is no longer part of the board. He isn't chairman since 2014 and left the board in March this year.
- foobiekr 6y agoI can totally see this happening. This is the pathology of large business executives - once you have a mature business, it is boring, and pretty much anything else seems exciting, and so you focus on this new thing, and worse, start promoting it internally as a model for everything _that's actually successful_. Due to my career wanderings, I've seen this a few times, and many times the hot new thing has been a mountain of technical debt that has spent the last few years doing everything possible to juice growth and spinning amazing stories to investors, the press, etc. They've been selected for telling a great story. The executives at OldCorp tend to have a natural immunity to the messaging and scheming of their interior ecosystem, but they are not used to these invasive species. If this is what Gates is getting at, I think that's very astute of him.
- ethbro 6y agoBoiled down to: nobody ever gets a promotion for maintaining the success of something that's already successful. Which is a shame, but the corporate game theory optimality of leapfrogging between hot projects has held true at essentially every company I've ever worked for.
- foobiekr 6y agoI think it's more complex than the stewardship problem - that problem, specifically, is internal, and the executives who engage in change for the sake of advancement usually do so knowingly. I'm talking about something completely different - the executives in this case are not knowing participants, they are in the state of mind to be snowed.
- ethbro 6y agoI haven't seen much difference between the two, if I understand what you're differentiating, as the type of executive that tends to project hop doesn't generally care about the underlying project, past its ability to further their own aims. So whether it's an external acquisition or internal project is somewhat immaterial.
- foobiekr 6y agoIt's the difference between being a knowing and un-knowing participant. Having been quite close to people in this tier, the difference is very significant.
- topkai22 6y agoThey underlying interview is pretty amazing, mostly not about this subject: https://www.wired.com/story/bill-gates-on-covid-most-us-tests-are-completely-garbage/ https://www.wired.com/story/bill-gates-on-covid-most-us-test...
- typenil 6y ago"I personally believe government should not allow those types of lies or fraud or child pornography [to be hidden with encryption like WhatsApp or Facebook Messenger]." Disappointing to see that Bill Gates isn't concerned about the slippery slope of regulating encryption. It frankly sounds like he'd be on board with the EARN IT act. As long as we're only undermining freedom for the children or to make sure there's no wrongthink going on, no problem.
- ethbro 6y agoHis point is more nuanced than that, and oversimplified complex ideas virally spreading through social media is part of what he talks about. "Q: As someone who has built your life on science and logic, I’m curious what you think when you see so many people signing onto this anti-science view of the world. A: Well, strangely, I’m involved in almost everything that anti-science is fighting. I’m involved with climate change, GMOs, and vaccines. The irony is that it’s digital social media that allows this kind of titillating, oversimplistic explanation of, “OK, there’s just an evil person, and that explains all of this.” And when you have [posts] encrypted, there is no way to know what it is. I personally believe government should not allow those types of lies or fraud or child pornography [to be hidden with encryption like WhatsApp or Facebook Messenger]. Q: Well, you’re friends with Mark Zuckerberg. Have you talked to him about this? After I said this publicly, he sent me mail. I like Mark, I think he’s got very good values, but he and I do disagree on the trade-offs involved there. The lies are so titillating you have to be able to see them and at least slow them down. Like that video where, what do they call her, the sperm woman? That got over 10 million views! [Note: It was more than 20 million.] Well how good are these guys at blocking things, where once something got the 10 million views and everybody was talking about it, they didn’t delete the link or the searchability? So it was meaningless. They claim, “Oh, now we don’t have it.” What effect did that have? Anybody can go watch that thing! So I am a little bit at odds with the way that these conspiracy theories spread, many of which are anti-vaccine things. We give literally tens of billions for vaccines to save lives, then people turn around saying, “No, we’re trying to make money and we’re trying to end lives.” That’s kind of a wild inversion of what our values are and what our track record is."
- lingxiaoling 6y agocould someone parse the analogy for me. Does he mean a deal like this will undo MS slowly over time?
- blihp 6y agoNot necessarily undo MS, but rather that the deal looks attractive but may actually not be any good. In other words, it could end up being one of those deals where a few years down the road MS has to write the purchase price off as a loss.
- torbital 6y agoGiven the opportunity though, it still seems like a risk well worth it. Businesses rarely (if ever) fail because of an acquisition gone wrong. But a acquisition gone right can have great returns. If Instagram flopped when Facebook bought it, Facebook would still be doing just fine. But since it did go well.. yeah. So I believe that it's still probably in the investor's best interest if MS does the deal even if it's only like a 35% chance that it isn't a complete failure.
- bobthepanda 6y agoI mean some of the biggest examples have been tech. AOL and Time Warner was a hot mess that destroyed both, for instance.
- scarface74 6y agoAOL would have been destroyed anyway. They were a dialup ISP who saw their time coming. They were smart to take their inflated stock price to buy a real asset. Of course they mismanaged it and it should have been a reverse takeover like Next/Apple.
- rhema 6y agoI'm just speaking based on my interpretation. I think the "chalice" is a jeweled cup that seems valuable, but the poison is not what you would expect to drink. So, the deal seems like a big prize, but comes with hard-to-understand disadvantages that make it a poor choice. E.g. someone bought tumblr and tried to make it advertiser friendly by removing NSFW content. As soon as they did, the community that was still flourishing there abandoned it and they had no eyeballs to sell.
- arkitaip 6y agoI totally see Microsoft ruining TikTok simply because of their corporate culture. Microsoft has had an astonishing history of destroying billions of dollars in value simply because they can't manage their products better. Internet Explorer, Bing and their mobile phones represent entire industries where Microsoft has been totally decimated despite enormous advantages in terms of resources and monopolies.
- adventured 6y agoYour premise is very obviously false on the face of it: the notion that a company can own everything, always succeed, and generally dominate every major segment it enters. Your criticism is that Microsoft isn't a $5+ trillion company, doesn't have five plus monopolies (desktop OS, mobile, browsers, search, and a few others that would go along with those positions including advertising), and basically isn't all knowing and all powerful. What you're projecting is impossible of course. No company could ever accomplish all of those things. What you're holding up as a supposed indication of incompetence, is in fact unavoidable: failure will happen, you will not always win, your products will not always succeed, and most likely you will fail the majority of the time; it doesn't matter who you are, or how big you are.
- vikramkr 6y agoI wasnt aware that the bar for having a good corporate culture was to be so utterly successful at everything you try ever that you end up with a monopoly in every single sector you ever compete in and become the most successful company in human history. Somebody should tell Nadella that the new corporate culture he is building at Microsoft that has led to their enormous turnaround in share performance and public perception is all in vain and has failed because ballamer laughed at the iPhone once.
- scarface74 6y agoYou realize that Microsoft is the third most valuable company in the US? It was the most valuable in 2001. The browser wars are old. The only thing having dominance in browser market share is good for is advertising. As far as mobile, it hasn’t been that great for Google either. It came out in the Oracle trial that Android had only made Google $22 Billion in profit from inception through 2016 (https://www.theverge.com/2016/1/21/10810834/android-generated-31-billion-revenue-google-oracle https://www.theverge.com/2016/1/21/10810834/android-generate...), much less than it paid Apple during the same time period to be the default search engine for iOS. There is no reason to believe that the economics are any better now.
- thekyle 6y agoI do expect TikTok to lose users after Microsoft acquires it. But not because of anything Microsoft might do. TikTok just seems like a fad social network that will inevitably lose the cool factor eventually.
- miketery 6y agoNot to mention the psychological effects it has. Research has shown Instagrams rise strongly correlated with rise in teen suicide rates. TikTok seems worse. Only a matter of time before people realize it's like cigarettes if not worse.
- playeren 6y agoCould you please point me towards said research?
- miketery 6y agoI heard it from Jonathan Haidt. Tweet: https://twitter.com/jonhaidt/status/1083018993991077888?lang=en https://twitter.com/jonhaidt/status/1083018993991077888?lang... Study: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2664031 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2664031
- playeren 6y agoThank you!
- miketery 6y agoThe video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CI6rX96oYnY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CI6rX96oYnY
- seppin 6y agoMost users will never feel any change despite who owns it, unless MS pull a FB and inject multiple streams of ads into it overnight.
- xoxoy 6y agoI agree in the sense that TikTok is a trust and safety disaster at the moment and I’m not sure Microsoft realizes the investment required to clean it up and make it truly safe. One of the most disturbing features to me is that you can be logged out and download nearly any video to your phone. It would be naive to think pedophiles are not actively downloading videos of minors dancing provocatively and sharing it.
- dcow 6y agoVideos of minors dancing is by no means native to tiktok or in any way illegal. If you think those videos are socially problematic (which many do), then you need to attack the incentive structure that breeds that type of content.
- xoxoy 6y agoagreed the algorithm is especially geared to minors to make mini music videos that are highly sexualized
- dcow 6y agoYes, but so is Hollywood’s, for example. The algorithm is geared around imitation style creative proliferation. It shows you videos similar to others you've liked. It simply seems like lots of people like to watch other people dance to catchy tunes. And even watch people react to watching other TikTok videos. The top videos on the platform get hundreds of millions of views, far more than what you’d expect if this content was supported by pockets of underground “pedophiles”. On one hand TikTok is an amazing and disruptive tool for creative expression. On the other hand, it simply reiterates our timeless cultural desire for sexualized female-gendered expression. If you find this aspect of human nature problematic we have also developed tools and institutions to combat it: religion. But those seem to have pedophile problems too. Joke aside they have fallen out of popularity of late.
- rchaud 6y agoMicrosoft in talks to buy TikTok's operations in 5 Eyes countries only strikes me as strange. Why not their European operations as well? Was this acquisition even on their roadmap before talks of a ban started making the rounds? It seems completely out of sync with the type of acquisitions MS makes, like Github or Linkedin. What do MS shareholders have to say about forking over $30b or thereabouts to bankroll POTUS' China panic?
- siliconc0w 6y agoCan someone explain how encryption comes in play with social media moderation? I'd understand that from less technical 'thought leaders' but I imagine Bill is still a pretty technical guy so I was kinda surprised to see that.
- skybrian 6y agoFacebook has announced that they want to move to end-to-end encryption for messaging, similar to Whatsapp. This would mean that any moderation being done would have to happen on the device. But a company that's promising end-to-end encryption presumably wouldn't do that. That's kind of the point; switching to end-to-end encryption means the company is (supposedly) getting out of the moderation business, at least for these messages. The kind of thing to worry about is social media's role in encouraging mob violence, massacres, and genocide. I assume Bill Gates is taking a global perspective on this.
- Havoc 6y ago>President Trump suggesting the US Treasury will need some type of cut from any acquisition. uhm what? Has Mr ArtOfTheDeal still not understood that he's a president not profit seeking CEO? How bizarre.
- solarkraft 6y agoHas he heard of taxes?
- bobbydreamer 6y agoTiktok is better than YT new 15-30 sec videos and far better than fb as well in content and keeping the user in. Entire thing deal and stuff it's a waste of time or distracting people. Somebody figured out something better, newer algorithm. At this point in world you have a mobile you are being tracked. In last one week YT reco is all about bomb after watching couple of Beirut videos. That clearly says algo is broke. Tiktok was on fire during BLM protests but still keep regularly showing other contents then and then. Microsoft first has to figure out and tell why have Teams and Skype. At this point people are migrating from SharePoint to confluence or other s/w to manage documents. Shrpnt GUI pretty much suck. New IE copy of chrome for the first week, it was consuming less CPU, now I could hear CPU fan just like chrome. MS should focus on improving software rather than media or unrelated things. Right now only s/w I like in Win10 is task manager, I use it soo much, thank god that UI has not changed. Google never had luck with social media platforms. Fb came tookout Orkut, so many other things they started all closed down. Google search also needs improvement, it's fast but content is not as good as how it used to be 5yrs back or before.