12 ms·
The ‘-ize’ have it (2012)
- sawaruna 6y agoI noticed this lately, I think when getting a new OS installed and making the dictionary UK English instead of Canadian English, thinking there would be little difference. The main issues have been with words that may end in an 'ism', e.g. criticize, nationalize, like those mentioned in the post. I've always spelt (purposely ignoring Canadian version, 'spelled' which I grew up with) these words with the 'ize' ending but the OS' UK English dictionary is now always flagging these as wrong, preferring the 'ise'.
- mercer 6y agoSee, to me 'spelt' just feels wrong, but 'ise' does too. I've found that I generally lean toward US English, but then they're the weird interactions with my own language (Dutch) that make me uncomfortable with words like 'aluminum'.
- mathieuh 6y agoI am not a linguist, but I do speak BrE natively and to me "-t" and "-ed" are used in different context. The "-t" ending is used for adjectives ("dinner is burnt", "that child is spoilt", "it's spelt like this"), and "-ed" is used for conjugations of the verb ("I burned dinner", "you have spoiled your child", "I spelled it like this"). I honestly don't care either way, it's a bit jarring to me to see American spellings of things, and I've done work for gov.uk before where the style guide says to use British spellings, but I think it's just being obtuse if you have some evangelical adherence to either way.
- stordoff 6y agoAlso a British English native speaker, and I'd generally use -t for both cases, though sometimes I'll use -ed. I seem to slightly bias away from "spelt" though, possibly due to it having another meaning. I suspect it's regional, and -ed feels slightly more passive to me (similar to 'it burned' vs 'I burnt it').
- ferzul 6y agoI have heard it described that -ed is used more often when the speaker is conceptualising the time it took, but -t is used as a default. That would mean “it burned” brings to mind images more like “it was burning” and “I burnt it” brings to mind images of having something that is burnt. Neither of your examples are passive btw.
- ealexhudson 6y ago"Seise" and "televise" don't look right to this UKian either. To a large extent, I think this is just a reflection of our education system being very right/wrong focussed, and these rules get put in place just to ensure there is a right and a wrong. We don't get on well with maybes.
- anonytrary 6y agoAmerican here. Does "seize" actually count? AFAIK "se" is not a word that got ize'd (as in "incentivize"). I can actually stand "televise" because the base word "television" uses an "s" after the "i". It looks weird on some randomly ize'd word, for example, if I want to make up a word for "making something more like an adventure" I'd say like "adventurize", because "adventurise" looks super weird.
- ealexhudson 6y agoI mentioned it just because it's in the article; I would never write seise but it does appear to be in the dictionary. I think British people have more issue with turning words into verbs rather than the precise spelling - eg we'd never say "to alphabetize" or "to adventurize".
- vmilner 6y agoI used to think the shot of "HMS Surprize" in the Star Trek:Enterprise(ize?) intro was some weird Americanism, but the spelling was indeed that in the 18th century, and flipped to HMS Surprise in 1796. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Surprise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Surprise
- vr46 6y agoI decided that I would use ‘ize’ endings about 23 years ago, and I was in good company as many newspapers did so too. Oxford Spelling, as it is known (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxford_spelling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxford_spelling) has fallen out of favour in domestic use, but is still found in international use, as my own observation. On my own choice, I felt that there were not enough ‘Z’s in everyday writing, and that it was too good a letter to ignore. It is bloody annoying that device dictionaries do not support this. I have occasionally switched to US English but this is not quite right. Knowing the correct suffix is a bit of a minefield.
- MattBlissett 6y agoSome of the international use might be because the United Nations uses Oxford spelling [1]. My employer does too. GNU Aspell has several variants of "British English", including "British English (United Kingdom) [-ize suffixes and with accents]". KDE seems to use the same dictionary, so in KDE applications I have full support for "Oxford spelling". There's a Firefox extension which includes -ize endings, but also includes -ise endings, so it's less useful. [1] http://dd.dgacm.org/editorialmanual/ed-guidelines/style/spelling.htm http://dd.dgacm.org/editorialmanual/ed-guidelines/style/spel... [2] http://aspell.net/ http://aspell.net/ [3] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/british-english-dictionary-2/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/british-engli...
- rjsw 6y agoThe International Organization for Standardization (ISO) uses British English too.
- vr46 6y agoNot all of the ise/ize endings are interchangable, so the Firefox extension might be correct. -ize is only applicable for words with a Greek root, I believe, which is why choosing Oxford English was hardly a masterstroke on my part but it does make things more interesting. I have little experience of Aspell short of seeing it pop up as a dependency now and then, but I will now try and attempt incorporating it into my Mac's dictionary, ideally it would work on iOS as well.
- Digit-Al 6y agoShould this have a (2013) suffix? Interesting article.
- Lammy 6y agoI thought the title would be too overwhelming with the already-parenthesized "(UK practice)" v(._. )v > Updated 20 May 2012 edit: So this comment makes sense now that a mod edited the title, I originally submitted it as "The ‘-ize’ have it — About the use of -ise or -ize as an ending (UK practice)" :)
- nextaccountic 6y agoCan't you edit the title? Or maybe dang can
- Lammy 6y agoI got on this topic tonight while playing with TeX's word hyphenation patterns, because the text-hyphen RubyGem responds to both :visualise and :visualize and I was trying to decide what the canonical one should be in my codebase :p irb(main):079:0> hyphen.visualise('visualize') => "visu-al-ize"
- SagelyGuru 6y agoDid not read past the subtitle, which has a verb (is) missing. Somewhat cast a shadow of doubt over the linguistic expertise of the author.
- _0o6v 6y ago> London Transport invariably used the ‘- ize’ form in posters and other public communications There's no such thing as London Transport, it's Transport for London, and they invariably do not use -ize, they use -ise, as per by their editorial style guide. I think if TfL started using -ize on their posters there would be a riot in the UK.
- DanBC 6y agoTfL was created in the year 2000. Before that it was called London Transport. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_public_transport_authorities_in_London https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_public_transport_au... 2.1 1933-1948: London Passenger Transport Board 2.2 1948-1963: London Transport Executive 2.3 1963-1970: London Transport Board 2.4 1970-1984: London Transport Executive 2.5 1984-2000: London Regional Transport 2.6 2000 onwards: Transport for London EDIT: genuinely confusing why this got downvotes. The article says this: > Many of the great publishing houses are happy with ‘ -ize’ etc endings, and large, influential organizations such as London Transport invariably used the ‘- ize’ form in posters and other public communications, though their modern PC-originated material leaves much to be desired. The article is comparing historic material with modern TfL materials. Historically, it wasn't called Transport for London, it was colloquially known as London Transport because 1) that was their branding and ii) the names were variations of London Transport X. Branding for London Transport: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Transport_(brand) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Transport_(brand) Here's a poster for London Transport: https://serendipityproject.wordpress.com/2012/01/08/jan-8-2012-thirty-two-advertising-images-from-the-festival-of-britain-souvenir-programme-1951/festival-of-britain-souvenir-programme-advertising-1951-london-transport-executive/ https://serendipityproject.wordpress.com/2012/01/08/jan-8-20...
- echelon 6y agoDespite Mark Twain's joke about the notion of simplifying English spelling [1], I believe a gradually engineered shift in spelling could reduce the friction when learning English as a second language. Our spelling rules are obtuse and absurdly disconnected from the underlying phonemes. A better system for spelling would have a clear 1:1 mapping between the graphemes and the phonemes with a simple and concise rule set. [1] https://www.plainlanguage.gov/resources/humor/spelling-in-the-english-language/ https://www.plainlanguage.gov/resources/humor/spelling-in-th...
- elric 6y agoYup. English spelling is an absolute mess. If you have an interest in linguistics, it's fun and interesting to be able to tell the origin of a word by its endings (-ize likely being of Greek origin etc). And sometimes it helps you when you're trying to spell a word of which you know the origin. But in the vast majority of cases, no one cares about any of that. Everyone who can read even a tiny bit of English can make sense of -ise and -ize endings, so it's not really an issue in that regard -- it doesn't change the meaning of words, and the difference is inaudible. Things like "through trough though dough doe doff tough" are far harder (tougher, one might even say) for non-natives, and fixing those kinds of messes is a lot less obvious.
- 6y ago
- m0nty 6y ago> On the whole the ‘z’ alternative has nothing whatever to do with America I was told that using a 'z' is old-fashioned, and using it or an 's' is optional - just be consistent. Only recently have I noticed a trend to condemn it as 'American', and if anything is sure to bring out a rather nasty, old-fashioned snob in some English people, it's being 'American'. Personally I cringe at this and quite happily use the 'z' form. On the subject of anti-American snobbery, one of my friends whom I have known for over 30 years was adopted by a very old-fashioned English couple and (sure enough) often had a disparaging word about anything American. When he was about 20, his natural father made contact with him ... from America! After things had settled down a bit and he had met his 'new' family, I put it to him that, you know what, you are basically an American now. Foolish to pretend otherwise. He's changed his view quite a bit since then :)
- akvadrako 6y agoAmerican is old fashioned English, so those are basically the same thing.
- philwelch 6y agoExcept we did a spelling reform.
- Razengan 6y agoThat’s amazing. Do you remember what went into the reform, whether you had to convince many people, and your personal feelings at the time?
- ahazred8ta 6y agoThat happened in the 1800s and very early 1900s. US dictionary makers favored phonetic reform. -IZE has been standard since the 1920s. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simplified_Spelling_Board https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simplified_Spelling_Board
- rbg246 6y agoWell this is intensely disappointing. I shall have to find something else to be snobby about - I feel like I have been living a lie, I have spent countless hours changing the dictionary in windows or osx to be UK English just so it didn't correct me on this. What other spelling idiosyncrasies are there that I can get on my high horse about?
- throwanem 6y agoHow about webpages that flow their text across multiple columns?
- Lammy 6y agoVery impressive text justification / linebreaking algorithm though. I didn't know FrontPage could do that! <meta content="Microsoft FrontPage 12.0" name="GENERATOR" />
- throwanem 6y agoThere's a longstanding and widely implemented CSS working draft for columnar text, that even IE 10 apparently supports. No idea if this page is actually using it, since I'm not going upstairs just to pull up this page and poke around its stylesheet, but I could imagine Expression Web (aka Frontpage 12) making it available. edit: Being upstairs anyway for other reasons, I've just had a look. It's just two <div> elements as columns in an old-school grid style system that predates CSS Grid. Text is flowed within the columns using a text-align: justify; rule, so the impressiveness of the result is properly credited to the browser rather than the site design.
- RandomBacon 6y agoI just use: <p style="columns:3;">
- throwanem 6y agoYes, that's specified in the WD I mentioned. https://www.w3.org/TR/css-multicol-1/ https://www.w3.org/TR/css-multicol-1/
- laurent92 6y agoCultural point about the joke in the title: It’s a pun on “The AYEs have it”, the sentence said by the speaker of the UK Parliament when the MPs vote AYE in majority (Aye = yes in old English). If the opposite, the NOes have it. Often mistaken for “the eyes have it” and “the noses have it” for first-time viewers.
- worble 6y ago>Aye = yes in old English I know the south likes to pretend we don't exist, but us northerners still say it every day.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y agoI use it daily. Picked it up when living in the UK's midlands. No londoner has ever commented on it nor gotten confused.
- sukilot 6y agoIt's more the western freedomers the imperialists.
- tannhaeuser 6y agoThat indeed was puzzling to me, but I figured it out by the very entertaining live coverage of parliament sessions last year (with John Bercow still as Mr Speaker). I only knew Aye from pirate movies (and Highlander), so I thought it was a reference to Royal Navy history or some such lol. In US congress (?) they display Yea/Nee on voting displays I believe; anyone knows where that originates from? Edit: there's also the "the Ayes to right, the Noes to the left" thing which contributes to the confusion; it's sad that the House of Commons can't congregate in close proximity like they used to due to coronavirus I guess
- stordoff 6y ago> the Ayes to right, the Noes to the left The Cambridge Union Society, being based on the House of Commons, has a slight extension to this - Ayes to the right, Noes to the left, abstentions down the middle. You're counted as you leave the chamber, so anyone abstaining leaves through the unmarked central door. https://miro.medium.com/max/908/1*ut4G1Vo8C8Uc4sqQ4A6m-Q.png https://miro.medium.com/max/908/1*ut4G1Vo8C8Uc4sqQ4A6m-Q.png
- m4r35n357 6y agoZeds are cool! Ask the Cornish.
- meditative 6y agoSlightly off topic, but since there are linguists here I thought I'd ask. Does the word winningest seem wrong to other people? It's such a foreign word to me that feels absolutely wrong. I only really hear it when watching US sports. I'm from Australia, where we follow en-GB relatively closely for perspective.
- Lammy 6y ago"ultimate"? Then the runner-up is the penultimate.
- pacaro 6y agoIt feels ugly to me, but there doesn't seem to be a concise alternative. It's usually used to refer to a person's record of wins, as in the coach who has lead a team to more wins than any other coach, at which point they are the winningest. He's the... winningest coach most successful coach when measured by how many wins coach with the best win-loss ratio ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- cik2e 6y ago“Most winning” would be the correct alternative, with the same number of syllables although to me it does feel more concise. As an American, I also hate this made up word.
- PhineasRex 6y agoWhile it looks weird written down, "winningest" feels lovely in the mouth
- ojhughes 6y ago-ize is better for scrabble players
- throw_away 6y agoHeh, this is similar to how the British English accent developed after the American Revolutionary War, and thus the American accent is closer to Shakespeare's than that of modern Brits': https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20180207-how-americans-preserved-british-english https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20180207-how-americans-p... I'm also amused by all the former commonwealth people who call Americans backwards for refusing the metric system, yet still quote things in pints, miles, or, heaven forbid, stones.
- DarthGhandi 6y agoThere only one I regularly hear as a former British penal colonist is pints and if it's stinking hot while sitting outside most would prefer a schooner or middy. Refusing to accept the metric system goes far beyond regional dialects and you all know it but are so fucking stubborn to ever change :)
- zapzupnz 6y ago> all the former commonwealth people who call Americans backwards […] yet still quote things in pints, miles, or, heaven forbid, stones. Only Brits seem to do that. The rest of the Commonwealth and former Commonwealth nations have fully transitioned.
- ferzul 6y agoCanada seems to use a lot of traditional measures. Australians from the country seem to measure in feet and inches - not just peoples heights. And a foreigner might think an Australian asking for a pint of beer is asking for a measure of beer, although a pint is just the name of a size of glass (like a schooner or pot).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gnufx 6y agoI'm skeptical of anything with connexions to the wrong university. ["the universities ... both of them" -- Sir Humphrey Appleby]
- SeanLuke 6y agoThis has happened many times: British spelling or pronunciation deviates in modern times -- often due to classist tensions special to England -- but then ultimately the British incorrectly suppose the American way is the "ahistorical" one. Another famous one is "solder". Until about 1920, the British universally pronounced it like the Americans did (derived from the French "souder"). Then the British slowly revised their pronunciation.
- giancarlostoro 6y ago> It must be admitted that there are words with a ‘z’ in them that are purely American, like advertize This is the first time I've ever seen anyone spell it like that, does anyone truly use this form of spelling advertise?
- yantrams 6y agoWhenever I come across these quirks, I can't help but think of how extremely codified the grammar of Sanskrit(and other Indian languages that are influenced by it) is to handle situations like this. Visarga Sandhi is one example comes to my mind. It is primarily used to handle the negative cases. For example, devoid of people is 'Nirjan' which is built using 'Nih'(No) and 'Jan'(People), whereas 'Nishchal' which means devoid of motion comes from 'Nih'(No) and 'Chal'(Motion). I'm not exactly sure but the rule probably goes along the lines of - When amalgamating "Uh" sound with Hard Sounds(Ka, Cha, Ta, Tha, Pa) you add a 'Sh' sound as in Nishkalmash, Nishchal, Nishchinth etc whereas when amalgamating with Soft sounds(Ga, Ja, Da, Dha, Ba) you add a 'Rr' sound as in Nirbhay, Nirday etc. You have hundreds of these rules that deal with all kinds of transformations, sometimes simple rules like Ka => Ga, Cha => Ja etc. and sometimes more complex rules which are conditional on the consonant sounds that precede the object of transformation(Namah + Te => Namaste). Lot of them feel arbitrarily imposed but they just feel right when you say them out aloud. Here are a couple of examples involving vowel transformations. Mahaa(Great) + Indra(Lord) => Mahendra(Great Lord) (aa(as in car) + e(as in kick) => ae(as in vent)) Mahi(Earth) + Indra(Lord) => Mahindra(Lord of Earth) (e(as in kick) + e(as in kick) => ee(as in screen))
- tankenmate 6y agoIn fact the -ise ending is pronounced with a 'z' sound because of French spelling rules, but since most English speaking people don't learn French spelling rules they don't realise the etymology and hence (not henka) the spelling. The rule in its most basic form is either an 'i' or an 'e' before or after and 's' changes the sound to a 'z'. In a similar way and 'i' or an 'e' before or after a 'c' changes it into an 's' sound; this is why France is spelt France but Francaise is spelt Française, the cédille is there to remind you that the base word has a 'e' after the 'c'. So one could say that the '-ize' ending may have a more Germanic feel to it. In a similar way "metre" versus "meter". When I was in primary school I was taught basic French, German, Latin and Greek spelling and etymology so that spelling in English would make more sense (not senze!)
- ferzul 6y ago> So one could say that the '-ize' ending may have a more Germanic feel to it. In a similar way "metre" versus "meter". although one shouldn't, since West Germanic didn't have a z sound or a letter to spell it with - it had become r (hence was/were, where “was” originally had an s sound and were originally had a z sound). Later, when Germanic languages developed z again, it has mostly been spelt with s as in “was”, since it comes from s. In English no matter the origin of the word, z is spelt s in core vocabulary. Borrowings from Greek have z but they are mostly learned. If there were no zoos, z would feel entirely odd.
- DonaldFisk 6y agoIt's really a Greek vs. French difference, rather than an American vs. British one. I prefer -ize, but either spelling is acceptable to me. Being a spelling pedant isn't a good idea, because unless you're an etymologist, you'll often get it wrong. (Sometimes mistakes even become Standard English, e.g. "ptarmigan", "sovereign", and "burgle" in UK.) Then there's the issue of Latin and Greek plurals. If you don't know those languages well enough, with a few exceptions (e.g. "crises", "phenomena") it's safer to just add -s or -es to the end of the word in English.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]