16 ms·
Debt collector profits soar with people flush and easy to find
- loktarogar 6y agoThe short term gain for many will be enormous, but the long term effect might be devastating on American society.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoSo... working as expected?
- monadic2 6y agoPretty much american society in a nutshell, tbh
- newfriend 6y agoSorry, are we implying that it's better for society if people don't pay their debts?
- aaomidi 6y agoDuring a pandemic? Yes.
- refurb 6y agoAlways? What about the people still working? Or people with significant savings?
- birdyrooster 6y agoThe thing about mass unemployment is that many people end up relying on the people around them for sustenance even though there are government programs.
- gjs278 6y agoi’ll be sure to rack up a bunch of debt and just shrug my shoulders when I can’t work
- anigbrowl 6y agoIn some circumstances, yes.
- Igelau 6y agoWe're talking about collection agencies here. This isn't about paying money back to the people you owe. This is a profitable business that doesn't care what's good for society. Wage garnishment for something like outrageous medical bills that gets paid to some parasite company isn't really better for society.
- monadic2 6y agoYes, 100%. I highly, highly recommend the book "Debt: The First 5,000 Years". Society has repeatedly been stabilized with mass debt forgiveness many times throughout history. I'm no religious person, but there certainly seems to be a certain theme about debt forgiveness... https://www.openbible.info/topics/debt_forgiveness https://www.openbible.info/topics/debt_forgiveness Debt is pretty central to most problems in society, actually.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- newfriend 6y agoForgiving the debts of the irresponsible effectively punishes those who are responsible with money, and leads to a society with no trust.
- syshum 6y agoThe problem with your attempts to equate modern debt with debt of the past is 2 fold 1. Historical debt like referred to in the book that destabilized society was generational debt, passed on in the family. Unlike modern debt where your debt dies with you. 2. Historical debt there was no concept of bankruptcy in the legal systems of that time. There was also debtor prison and indentured servitude to pay off debt. Those 2 factors are what destabilized societies and caused the need for mass debt forgiveness, we solved those by changing the lender risk metric, and allowing for a case by case relief valve called bankruptcy
- Igelau 6y ago> we solved those by changing the lender risk metric, and allowing for a case by case relief valve called bankruptcy Student loan debt breaks both of these. Student loans were supposed to be low risk, but the jobs never materialized, and they can't be discharged by bankruptcy. There's also the matter of people even being able to afford to file for bankruptcy. Just for that you're looking in the ballpark of $1500 in court and attorney fees.
- 6y ago
- mjparrott 6y agoToo late. Those debts are already there, and there is nothing to stop them from piling up new debts in the years ahead. Whether or not uncle sam sends money to debt collectors doesn't change the root problem (the sickening financial position many people find themselves in to start with).
- haram_masala 6y agoThe alarming thing about this is that there are millions of people for whom an extra $600/week is “flush.”
- koolba 6y ago$600/week is $30K/year annualized. Minimum wage ranges as low as $240/week depending on the State, so for many coming from those jobs this has been a bumper couple of months.
- throwaway9980 6y agoPersonally know a business owner whose employees refuse to come back full time. They are still (were) getting the $600 booster despite earning 80-90% of their previous take home. And getting a small “normal” unemployment benefit from the state. Business owner reports as required and tells the employees that what they are doing may not be the best idea.
- koolba 6y agoThe worst situation I’ve seen are workers that work primarily on commissions and were not laid off. They’re stuck at their State minimums without any “Covid bonus” while seeing others get $1000/week sitting at home. It’s very perverse.
- orangecat 6y agoYeah. This would have been a good time to introduce UBI, but instead we doubled down on the perverse incentives of existing welfare systems.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Spooky23 6y agoUI audit is based on samples, and most labor departments process more claims in March-July than they did in the last 5 years. It’s a smart move for the employee to stay away, especially if the job pays that shitty.
- zxcvbn4038 6y agoThis is probably the worst time to be paying off old debts. I think that very shortly the courts are going to be so overwhelmed with debt cases that it’s going to take years to clear the backlog. For people living paycheck to paycheck your basically judgement-proof anyway. As long as you pay your income tax you have noting to worry about. If you owe tax then it’s completely different story.
- Spooky23 6y agoExactly. It’s a great time to be in debt, as inflation is gonna happen. Banks know it — Citi and Chase pretty much stopped cheap balance transfers in April for most customers.
- momokoko 6y agoInflation had almost stopped for several years. We’re still below the fed mandate. Inflation encourages people to work as opposed to living off assets they already own.
- birdyrooster 6y agolooks at the stock market, sees people thriving off of assets they already own during the pandemic Are you sure these people will be going back to work soon?
- momokoko 6y agoRight. We need a lot more inflation. We need to devalue the dollar to make exports more competitive and rebuild the working class. Push the people making money off the stock market back into the workforce.
- xyzzyz 6y agoSince for moderate levels of inflation (ie low double digits), stocks are inflation proof, if this actually improved competitiveness of American firms, moderate inflation would be a boon for stockholders. Big losers would be wage employers, who’d see their pay not catch up with growth of prices: this is in fact one of the core reasons we even target positive inflation in the first place, to counteract the effect of sticky wages that do not go down when necessary.
- Simulacra 6y agoWhen companies know that people have extra cash, they go after that cash. Whether it's a stimulus check or UBI, companies are not moral beings, they are profit driven machines.
- davchana 6y agoWhen there were talks about $1200 Stimulas Check, the first one, my Car Loan Bank sent series of emails saying We Care For You in this Difficult Times, so we are informing you You might be eligible for $1200 check, Please make sure you are on top of Car Loan Payments.
- lopmotr 6y agoCollecting debts is a moral action though, isn't it? It's part of the system that keeps society working for everyone. I've had people owe me money. It's not pleasant when you know you've basically given money to them for free while they can laugh in your face. Sometimes I've got it back via debt collectors. It's a good thing. Maybe you don't like predatory lending, but that's not the same as trying to help out somebody who's having hard times then getting ripped off by them. Not all debtors are some kind of helpless victim of life's unfairness. Often they're just selfish bastards trying to take advantage of whoever they can.
- darkerside 6y agoIf you're really helping someone, how can they end up ripping you off? Are you helping them in the same way a water salesman might help somebody dying of thirst in the desert, by selling them water at a reasonable price? Sounds more like you tried to profit opportunistically and failed. Don't expect pity.
- abnry 6y agoIf the sale of debt is targeted towards someone vulnerable, as your dying of thirst in the desert example is, then that is immoral. However, the entire system that allows anyone to go into debt is not immoral, and it is generally not targeted. As long as there is no lying and obfuscation, you reap the consequences you make. You should no more expect someone not to collect debt than you should expect to walk out of Walmart with whatever you want. If someone needs charity, that should be supplied OUTSIDE the normal system (non-profits, governments, friends and family), otherwise the system itself is ripe for abuse.
- awslattery 6y agoCurious how much is attributed to the continued adoption of pay-for-delete (PFD) by these debt buyers/factoring/collection agencies. I noticed the trend start in 2018. Midland was one of the first to adopt it, then PRA a few months later. For those unaware, paying a collection account was of little to not benefit for improving your credit score. The negative tradeline(s) would still be present for the typically 7 years (less, depending on type of debt and state in some cases). Put another way, once you were in debt, there was little to no incentive beyond traditional "morals" that these folks would play to for you to pay. That, and legal action, which is still a highly effective source of revenue for these outfits. Most that are sued either ignore legal service, aren't aware of service by publication in obscure notice ads, or don't show up for the designated day in court, awarding a default judgment to the collector. From there, they can garnish, seize, and follow your ass for years, in most cases for a debt they paid pennies on the dollar for in an excel document auction of sorts. In the last few years, most of the debt buyers and collection agencies will delete the negative tradeline when you settle for less or pay in full the amount owed. This was a previously a "one in a hundred" chance you'd see discussed ad nauseum on debtor boards; that is, including a pay-for-delete stipulation in settlement negotiations. If you're in debt, read up on your rights, and how to play the game with these folks. Whether you can pay it easily or not, knowledge in the processes is incredibly valuable.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoDoes anyone have an opinion about how that happens in the UK?
- Galaxity 6y agoThat was the primary reason I paid off a collection in a lump sum a month ago (the expected significant credit repair from a delete). Sure getting a 1200 dollar stimulus check made it a lot easier to drop a thousand in one go, but if pra wasn't pay for delete I would have saved that in my emergency fund, and either never paid since my credit was already damaged or paid some small monthly payment for the next two years (to not get sued). I suppose the thing to know would be how many people are just paying because they have extra money and just assume paying it consigns it to Oblivion.
- hotpockets 6y agoThere is a real opportunity for society to learn a lasting lesson here, mainly how relatively little is gained for the economy from extra cash (tax cuts) to the already flush.
- jedberg 6y agoAlways ask for proof of the debt before paying. If they can't provide proof, you can contest it on your credit report and you don't have to pay. I keep having debt collectors call me for a fake debt. I've been an AT&T customer for 25 years. About a decade ago I upgraded my broadband, and instead of upgrading my account they closed my old one and opened a new one. I got a final bill on the old one and that was that. About two years later I got a debt collector trying to collect on the old account. At first I thought it might be legit, maybe I missed the final bill. So I asked for a copy of the records. They stopped calling. A couple years later a new debt collector called on the same debt. Again I asked for proof, again they stopped calling. I think my name was finally deleted from the spreadsheets they pass around, but who knows. Maybe one day someone will call again.
- bob33212 6y agoI always tell them that I dispute the charges and that they should sue me if they have proof and most importantly I tell them to never contact me again or I will sue
- mixmastamyk 6y agoReminds me of a time I had already paid a hospital bill a few years back. About a year later some guy calls about another $1000+ I owe. "Ok, I paid it, but send an itemized bill," I said as I was curious as to what it was. Got a plain paper print-out in the mail with "medical services ----- 1,234.56." He called again I said, "you're gonna have to do better than that. He never called again, it was BS. Wonder how he even got my details?
- reincarnate0x14 6y agoThere's an incestuous infestation of debt companies of questionable ethics that sell or pass around spreadsheets of names and debts. The provenance of this data is highly suspect, but they're so used to having to act like scammers anyway, what difference does it make? One account from 2017 on the subject: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2017-12-06/millions-are-hounded-for-debt-they-don-t-owe-one-victim-fought-back-with-a-vengeance https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2017-12-06/millions-...
- fallingfrog 6y agoJust look at how much benefit the economy is getting from a relatively modest boost to the lowest incomes, which gets spent immediately or goes to reducing crippling debt, versus tax breaks and subsidies for the wealthy, which get plowed into asset bubbles and expensive wine.
- dylan604 6y agoNo, no. Those wealthy receiving the tax breaks expand their companies which requires hiring more people. /s The recent tax forgiveness that allowed all of those corps to bring their offshore money home proved your statement correct and the obvious falsity of the trickle down theory. The corps used the incoming money for bonuses, stock buy backs, etc. The effect it had on the lower income tiers of society was barely even noticed.
- czbond 6y agoIt doesn't invalidate trick down theory - it highlights a weakness in the human behavior in the personality types making those decisions. Ladder climbers vs conscious capitalists would have different results in 'trickle down'.
- tempsy 6y agoConversely, this must mean that payday loan shops are dying...so yay?
- malchow 6y agoA great startup that I've been telling folks about is Seth Goldstein's Spartacus, which does (as far as I've experienced) a great job of removing your addresses from the internet. [1] [1] https://spartacus.com https://spartacus.com
- rideontime 6y agoCan you elaborate on that? Because the site for Spartacus sure doesn't. I couldn't find any explanation of their "data broker deletion" detailed enough for me to want to give them money. e: Oh, cool, they're going to solve the problem with blockchain. Hard pass. https://cdn.spartacus.com/white-papers/fiduciarydatabanking.3.7.2019.pdf https://cdn.spartacus.com/white-papers/fiduciarydatabanking....
- TwoBit 6y agoHow can they possibly remove the public record of the house you bought?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- timavr 6y agoThe situation with debt for average Americans is criminal. Why lifes and mental health are being ruined, while Fed is just pumping gazillion of free money into corporations? Not taking any debt is the best decision the person can make in their lifetime. In some cases it is OK to do it, when buying a house or using debt for business purpose from non institutional lender: friends, family etc. Companies should just write it off. It is just money.
- ahmedm87 6y agoWhy would the US government further the interests of its own people when another 40 billion could be sent to Israel and its dual citizens could have trillions poured into their corporations? What are you, an anti-Semite or White Supremacist or something?
- GarrisonPrime 6y agoSpoken like someone who has never run a business. Why do you think the government is handing money over to corporations? Hint: It's not just to give their big business friends some moolah.
- illirik 6y agoI'd love to hear the answer, as I have never seen a satisfactory explanation for this strange phenomenon.
- trevyn 6y agoTo attempt to prevent collapse of the regime.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> Hint: It's not just to give their big business friends some moolah. I mean, sometimes it is. Thats why they bailed out banks for making loans to people who could be reasonably expected to default, but failed to bail out the homeowners who were dumb enough to believe the bank when they were said they were able to become a homeowner in America by signing some papers they didn't really understand. Regulatory capture is absolutely a factor in explaining the government's response to many financial crises. I'm pretty sure the average Joe would be better served with a system where corporations that make poor decisions go to bankruptcy court and their assets are sold to other people in order to pay their creditors and reallocate the capital more responsibly. in a capitalist economy, profit is supposed to be the reward for correctly estimating risk and correctly allocating capital. in a socialist economy, the government is supposed to redistribute wealth to people who don't have it. in the current system, profits are privatized and losses are socialized, at least for powerful and connected people. what's your alternative explanation?