15 ms·
Apple says game streaming services violate App Store policies
- adamscybot 6y agoBy this logic, why are any video streaming services like Netflix, YouTube and Amazon Prime allowed on the service given they cant audit every video? It's exactly the same logic.
- sanderjd 6y agoI would say that there is a pretty good chance they will target those services at some point.
- m463 6y agoThey've tried and I think they got netflix to cave to the 30% thing.
- freehunter 6y agoI recently (last week) got a new iPad and had to log into Netflix and typed my email address wrong and was met with a popup saying “If you’re trying to sign up through the app, you can’t. We know, it’s ridiculous.”
- mhh__ 6y agoWould that be grounds for legal trouble?
- coldtea 6y agoIt's exactly NOT the same logic. Videos, security, behavior etc wise, are all the same (as long as they use the same codecs). It's the video player code that matters and might have be audited, not each video. Games and apps are obviously different, as they have dynamic behavior. So it's not the same logic at all.
- koluna 6y agoYes, it is the same logic. The games are streamed, not executed on the phone. For all intents and purposes, you are getting an interactive video.
- mpalmer 6y agoOn top of that, Netflix has already set the precedent for interactive video controlled from iOS devices. What is Apple's argument for allowing the choose-your-own-adventure Netflix titles (without per-title review) but disallowing more fine-grained interactivity?
- coldtea 6y agoThe game look is streamed, the game engine has local dynamic behavior (not just "play/pause/send controls to game").
- koluna 6y agoWhat? That’s exactly what it does - it pipes controls to the server where it’s executed. Nothing runs on the phone other than a streaming agent.
- adamscybot 6y agoThat's not the case. It literally is sending user input to the server, where the game is running, and then you watch a video back. That's the base technology that underlies every single gaming streaming service (to date, at least).
- sjs382 6y agoOn Stadia, games are rendered/run on Google servers. Nothing is running on the user's device. From the device's perspective, Stadia is just an app to capture gamepad input, send it to Google servers and play the video response (AV1, VP9 or h264).
- gmantg 6y ago
- clubsoda 6y agoIf this is Apple's reasoning, then why does SteamLink on iOS exist? I can stream games to my iPhone directly from my library. Is it because I am streaming from my computer?
- Spivak 6y agoAccording to their guidelines, yes. Not that there's any way to really verify this on Apple's end but apps like this are allowed so long as they're used to connect to your own hardware.
- op00to 6y agoWhat about connecting to hardware owned by Amazon or Google or my employer? Is that ok?
- xsmasher 6y ago4.2.7 Remote Desktop Clients: If your remote desktop app acts as a mirror of specific software or services rather than a generic mirror of the host device, it must comply with the following: (a) The app must only connect to a user-owned host device that is a personal computer or dedicated game console owned by the user, and both the host device and client must be connected on a local and LAN-based network. [...] (e) Thin clients for cloud-based apps are not appropriate for the App Store.
- jacquesm 6y agoIt's a matter of time then before Safari will only display apple.com and nothing else. /s
- mensetmanusman 6y agoOh, I use RDP and VNC to play minesweeper on my PC with my iPad.... hope they don’t find out!
- cblconfederate 6y agoI m getting sick and tired of corporate trade wars on top of national trade wars, and the people here who always evangelize these platforms to developers. I hope these platforms die a horrible death and we return to neutral open (and full of spam) protocols.
- bsaul 6y ago"Before they go on our store, all apps are reviewed against the same set of guidelines that are intended to protect customers and provide a fair and level playing field to developers." As an iphone customer and an iphone developer, let me just say apple can just go f* themselves... This hypocrisy is making me mad. the OS is secure, the access permissions are secure, at this point the only thing they need to ensure is that the game store isn't a scam and then it'll be fine. So, please, stop pretending it's to protect anyone (or in this case macOS doesn't provide a secure environment, right ?). Just admit it's for your own personal greed, and that you're leveraging a totally unfair position to impose your app store to win against its competitors.
- marta_morena_25 6y agoYou must be mad a lot. This is how the world works and Apple is nothing to single out here.
- echelon 6y ago> This is how the world works It's broken, and the government is going to slap the shit out of Apple. The App Store eats away more profit than taxes, and is single handedly responsible for teaching the public that an eternity of app updates are for free. They drove the public to expect apps should be cheaper than coffee.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> They drove the public to expect apps should be cheaper than coffee. I don't understand - did Apple set app prices? Or did the app developers?
- spanhandler 6y agoIt's exactly what you'd expect from a low-friction, highly competitive marketplace. They eat everyone's profit in a hurry. That Apple was able to take a 30% cut while this happened leads me to believe they did an incredibly good job of creating a low-friction, highly competitive marketplace. Now, contrary to econ 101 thought experiments, you don't always want to approach the ideal of perfectly-competitive marketplaces too closely. It can be bad for overall market health and even, ultimately, harm choices available to consumers for exactly the reasons cited. [EDIT] actually it could also indicate that they've done one part of market-creation really poorly, which is that they're making reliable information other than price way too hard to discover, though again, that the market has not just survived this defect/cost but thrived indicates they did an uncommonly good job at other parts.
- timpetri 6y agoIt seems like this exact logic would rule out any and all of the remote screen control apps that are currently available for iOS.
- myhf 6y agoAnd of course the Steam Link app, which does everything a game streaming service does except collect subscription fees.
- ehsankia 6y agoSo if Stadia disallowed the "Store" portion of the app, they could be allowed on there technically?
- amaccuish 6y agoNo because I think it would be rejected under the rule that the user has to own the host machine and it be on LAN... See App Store guidelines section 4.2.7: "The app must only connect to a user-owned host device that is a personal computer or dedicated game console owned by the user, and both the host device and client must be connected on a local and LAN-based network."
- Rebelgecko 6y agoDoes the iOS version of Steam Link not allow you to stream remotely like the Android and desktop versions?
- tanjtanjtanj 6y agoNot sure on steam link specifically but I have streamed games from my PS4 remotely using their app.
- brigade 6y agoThat section of the rules probably doesn't apply to the PS4 app because they mirror the entire OS of the PS4 instead of just the Steam app. (iOS steam link is local network only)
- stefan_ 6y agoSo game streaming is out, but video streaming is in? I take it they don't want to give up any of that App Store game revenue should game streaming turn out to be viable.
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> So game streaming is out, but video streaming is in? Just what I was thinking. They allow Spotify and they don't insist on reviewing all the songs available. They allow the Netflix and the Google Play Movies app (and the equivalent movie streaming apps from Amazon, PlayStation, Rakuten, etc) without reviewing all the films that can be streamed there. I suppose interactivity is the 'category difference' there, but what are they protecting the customer from?
- mschuster91 6y ago> Basically, Apple wants to be able to review every game that graces an iPhone’s screen, even if it’s streamed from a game server somewhere in the cloud. So... two options: Either they're after the 30% revenue cut from in-app purchases or it's once again American prudeness (i.e. they don't want nudity or sexual content in games) at play. Or both.
- bsaul 6y agoBecause you can't access porn using safari ? They create and provide a web browser. Meaning, an app that lets you access all the violence, porn, and degrading content the world has ever produced. By default. Just unwrap your brand new iphone, turn it on, and bam, you got "sex" just by typing it.
- zepto 6y agoSafari is subject to parental controls as are app purchases.
- bsaul 6y agoso, just enforce that the game store has parental control as well ?
- foepys 6y agoThe first thing a child is doing with their phone/computer is circumventing those parental "controls". You cannot give your child a computer and put all responsibility on some software. Whoever thinks that those controls are flawless will have to face a harsh reality. If a child wants to find boobs in a web browser, it will. The only way is to disallow the web browser completely and we all know that every child will at some point "have to do research for homework" and then search for boobs.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoThey might want to start censoring Apple TV to keep out the violence.
- rightbyte 6y agoWouldn't Apple's reasoning apply to eg. ssh-clients, screen share etc? About xCloud I find it quite humourus that a terminal window system's name follows the footstep of the X Window System.
- cheeze 6y agoI feel like you can reductio ad absurdum it to a web browser
- sithadmin 6y agoApple explicitly makes allowances for "generic mirroring of a host device" in their App Store terms. Basically, remote CLI/GUI access to a general purpose computing instance of some sort is fine; remote access clients that are walled in to a specific app experience are generally not allowed unless some very specific criteria are met. Hence gaming-optimized (but still usable for general purpose) VDI like Shadow.tech is permitted, but Stadia and its ilk are not.
- hhjinks 6y agoThen Geforce Now should be permitted, since it's just a virtual desktop you can access your game library from. But they're locked out of the app store as well, afaik.
- bgorman 6y agoWhat is limiting streaming game services from implementing this in the browser? With javascript you can build any kind of controller overlay you want. I guess maybe lack of physical controller support? It seems like iOS Safari supports the W3C "Gamepad API". However I don't use iOS and I don't play mobile games, so I am not sure how it actually works out.
- Sargos 6y agoApple doesn't allow third-party web browsers on iOS and Safari doesn't have a good track record of supporting new web APIs and standards, so making a successful streaming app might be possible but it'd be a precarious project at the whims of a single company. You'd likely also have a hard time adding new features as iOS users would be holding you back which would cripple all of your other users by association.
- ehsankia 6y agoThis was my question as well. Stadia already does run fully in Chrome, although I realize on iOS, Chrome is basically a shell around Safari's rendering engine. Still, PWA seems to be the best path for these services. Stadia's own controller doesn't even need Gamepad API, since the controller can connect directly to the server through wifi, bypassing your phone entirely. Really, it would be no different than watching a livestream on Youtube, which you can control. The only issue is that they use VP9 I believe, which I'm not sure if Safari supports yet.
- neurostimulant 6y agoBut can you get minimal input and video latency with standard web stack though? Even 300ms is going to ruin a lot of gameplay. I haven't really check this, but safari is lagging behind chrome and might not support low latency video stuff, which is probably why stadia is still only supporting chrome-like browsers only.
- katktv 6y agoBeen like this for a while, because games are supposedly apps to Apple and thus they don't allow app marketplaces as apps.
- Jaxkr 6y agoThis is so stupid. Every web browser has this same risk...
- msie 6y agoYes, let's not forget Apple is in the business to make money.
- llarsson 6y agoWas it also not forbidden to have your app interpret code, which is the reason both for the still prevalent browser monoculture on iOS, originally (successfully) intended as a killer of Flash? I suppose this is the same, in a way. They can't review what games will be played with a general-purpose game streaming app. So this is to combat the "Flash" of today. Maybe? (Not to mention that they can't get the 30% cut from every new game you happen to request via the app.)
- Macha 6y agoI believe you can still interpret code so long as all code that is interpreted is bundled in your app (so no pulling down code from your server at runtime). There was a C64 emulator way back that was allowed in with bundled legal homebrew, but it got pulled once it was discovered there was an "easter egg" to load arbitrary ROMs. A lot of the JS frameworks work this way, as well as Xamarin I think. If you want to A/B test, both versions need to present in your app and you can use a server side flag to switch between them, but you can't pull them dynamically, though some web view apps seem to get away with ignoring this.
- mimsee 6y ago> Basically, Apple wants to be able to review every game that graces an iPhone’s screen, even if it’s streamed from a game server somewhere in the cloud. Really wondering how Apple can think they need to have that much power. How can they let me, a simple-minded iPhone user use the web browser without checking every website so that the sites don't violate Apple's policies. How do they allow 3rd party web browsers. They display loads of questionable content, too. And actually, I don't think that'd be too far off. Like what Google has their Safe Browsing list containing links to malware sites, Apple could create their own Apple Internet List, and demand through App Store policies that all browsers implement it or else.
- blihp 6y agoNeed has nothing to do with it. They're identifying ways in which people are making money off of the platform and demanding a cut. This is what companies do unless there is competition and/or regulation.
- mimsee 6y agoWell I mean, Apple could be proactive with this. If they simply block everything, unless you paid of course, they could offer unparalleled security. /s
- scarface74 6y agoNot really the same situation, but I would love an App Store where there were no free ad supported apps and the only way for monetization was by paying for the app or the service. I’m not saying that I think Apple deserves a 30% cut of every service.
- robenkleene 6y agoI don’t think this is about revenue sharing, presumably game streaming services could simply not include purchasing games or subscriptions in the app, the same way you can’t buy books in the Kindle app. This is about the much more subtle and insidious way that Apple leverages their control over iOS to block software that Apple deems threatening. App Store guideline 2.5.2[0], disallowing downloading and executing code in most circumstances, is a sister policy to this one about game streaming services. What both of these policies have in common is that they ban things that have the potential to supersede iOS itself, e.g., by becoming a successful app platform in-and-of itself (if you squint you can see the connection, if you can play Halo this way, why not Photoshop?) Ben Thompson has written the definitive article on this protectionist mindset that drives many of Apple's store policies[1]. [0]: https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#2.5.2 https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#2.5... [1]: https://stratechery.com/2013/why-doesnt-apple-enable-sustainable-businesses-on-the-app-store/ https://stratechery.com/2013/why-doesnt-apple-enable-sustain...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y agoWhenever a "violation of policy" is cited, a certain language trick is at play. The term "violation" has a negative vibe, its aim is to make the reader feel as if some real violation happened, almost an act of violence. Instead, what it really means in this context, is simply that Apple doesn't like any loophole that would let anyone avoid the fee for any purchase related to any app available in their app store.
- nrmitchi 6y ago> Basically, Apple wants to be able to review every game that graces an iPhone’s screen, even if it’s streamed from a game server somewhere in the cloud. I don't see how this logic doesn't also apply to Youtube, and other video-streaming apps? I get that it's less "interactive", but it's still content that Apple has "not reviewed".
- javagram 6y agoThe XCloud streaming service has several hundred games. Youtube has millions of individual videos. There’s an obvious difference in scale that makes reviewing one possible and the other not. Apple could never even propose to have each individual YouTube video reviewed by their App Store.
- nrmitchi 6y agoYour argument here is that Youtube is also in violation of these rules, but is allowed because they are too big for Apple to review? I mean yes, you might have a valid point, but that goes straight back against: > "all apps are reviewed against the same set of guidelines that are intended to protect customers and provide a fair and level playing field to developers."
- javagram 6y agoNo, that is not my argument. The rules are online, and if you go and read them you can see that Youtube, netflix, and similar streaming video services and ebook readers, etc are explicitly exempted. As I said, Apple could never even hope to put this requirement on those type of services. It's totally impractical for them.
- nrmitchi 6y agoYes, but do you not see the issue at play here? > "all apps are reviewed against the same set of guidelines that are intended to protect customers and provide a fair and level playing field to developers." This strongly implies that all apps have to following the same rules and guidelines. Having the guidelines say that (for example) Youtube is exempt, means that yes, _technically_ all apps are following the same "guidelines", but Youtube isn't following the same "rules". Ie, writing exemptions into the guidelines means that the quoted statement, if it was being honest, would read: > "all apps, except for those granted exemptions, are reviewed against the same set of guidelines that are intended to protect customers and provide a fair and level playing field to developers." The exemptions are quite literally the issue with their statement.
- jrockway 6y agoI'm surprised that they bundle a web browser and allow apps like Twitch, YouTube, Facebook, etc. Anyone could say anything through those platforms and Apple's benevolent Content Curation Geniuses could do nothing to intervene! I guess the reality is that nobody would buy an iPhone if those things didn't work, but game streaming is new enough that Apple can use their large market position to kill them instead of them killing Apple. I guess that's business for you.
- knolan 6y agoLook at the Steamlink debacle. That time the excuse was about buying games through the app (even though you can buy games on the main steam app) and not about what content you stream from your computer to your iOS device.
- smilekzs 6y agoI sincerely hope the service providers sue Apple (and win). This is blatant abuse of their market position. Better if the App Store gets broken up into its own independent company.
- graeme 6y agoWhat does that even mean? If it has a clear meaning, can you point to a single example of the sort of arrangement you’re talking about?
- drusepth 6y agoBreaking up tech companies into smaller companies has been suggested a lot lately, probably most notably by Elizabeth Warren's recent pushes. A relevant quote on her approach is here: >Apple, you’ve got to break it apart from their App Store. It’s got to be one or the other. Either they run the platform or they play in the store. They don’t get to do both at the same time. So it’s the same notion. >If you run a platform where others come to sell, then you don’t get to sell your own items on the platform because you have two comparative advantages. One, you’ve sucked up information about every buyer and every seller before you’ve made a decision about what you’re going to sell. And second, you have the capacity — because you run the platform — to prefer your product over anyone else’s product. It gives an enormous comparative advantage to the platform. You can find a transcript of this full interview at [1], but she's mentioned it several times and other politicians have also made their own, similar suggestions. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2019/3/9/18257965/elizabeth-warren-break-up-apple-monopoly-antitrust https://www.theverge.com/2019/3/9/18257965/elizabeth-warren-...
- codemac 6y agoUsing websites instead of apps becomes cooler and cooler.
- hu3 6y agoNot on iOS where the only browser engine allowed is Apple's webkit.
- dangus 6y agoThey approved the PS Remote Play app, which lets you stream your entire PlayStation including the store. They approved Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, HBO Max, etc, which let you stream TV shows and movies. They approved Kindle, which lets you stream books. I’m failing to see why a streaming game is a violation when all the above examples are okay.
- ianwalter 6y agoNot defending it, but in regards to the PS app, the guidelines specifically allow streaming of the users own personal devices.
- dangus 6y agoTrue...but... If I rent an EC2 instance, is it a personal device? If I rent time on a Stadia instance, is that graphical output of that server a personal device?
- ianwalter 6y agoNo because you don't own the machine. I believe it specifically says "owns" but not sure. I also think the guidelines say that it has to be on a personal network -- which I know makes no sense -- but the language was specifically engineered to allow personal remote desktop apps when the Steam Link app was trying to get unbanned from the store.
- n-gauge 6y agoWait - So you can have Netflix on IOS which is a streaming service, but not game streaming which is essentially the same thing?
- mensetmanusman 6y agoNetflix wouldn’t have been allowed on iOS devices if appleTV would have been out first :)
- ansible 6y agoAnd even so, you're not allowed to sign up or renew your membership via an iOS app. Heck, I don't think you're even allowed to link to a web browser page from the app itself. Well... you are allowed to pay from the app, but then Apple wants a 30% cut to enable that. The video streaming services have balked at paying that. Rightly so.
- kelchm 6y agoWorth pointing out that Netflix has even had a game-like interactive movie called “Black Mirror: Bandersnatch”. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Mirror:_Bandersnatch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Mirror:_Bandersnatch
- lokar 6y agoI don't understand where the line is. There is no good technical place to draw this "we need to review every app". You can do almost everything the streaming service would do in a browser, but they allow browsers.
- m4rtink 6y agoWell, they actually criple browsers by forcing them to use their sub-par web engine & don't support key web standards.
- graeme 6y agoThis is bad for Apple’s customers. I don’t think they’ll find it’s too their advantage to keep pushing this, or it will become a clear advantage for android: you can play all your games on android, and not on Apple. Cloud gaming may be comparatively niche compared to the app market as a whole, but what other use cases will thus extend to? Individual app developers need Apple, but Apple needs apps in aggregate.
- iphone_elegance 6y agoThe entire apple ecosystem is a sham
- dzonga 6y agomust be good to be a taxman, while not running a gvt. all the benefits none of the downsides
- rafaelturk 6y agoI wonder What kind of policy allows Youtube, Netflix Apps?
- halvo 6y agoHow can they allow game streaming apps like Steam Link but not xCloud/Stadia
- justinzollars 6y agoOf course it does Apple. Thats the point.
- paulpan 6y agoTo be fair, I think both sides are at fault in this specific instance (e.g. XCloud streaming) with some seismic broader impacts. Microsoft is at fault for not realizing that the existing App Store policies did not include game streaming and working with Apple to resolve it from the beginning. XCloud was first announced 2 years ago so to wait until the eve of launch to realize this is a blocker is laughable. Then to try to publicly escalate this is just playing with fire. Seems eerily similar to Nvidia's GeForce Now fiasco of not having properly having agreements with game studios before the launch. Apple is at fault for being behind times and being draconian about App Store policies. It's 2020 and streaming is the new norm, so to claim that it's against policy is a bit anachronistic. App Store is no longer some niche platform so this only strengths the antitrust case against Apple. If this is about micro transactions and getting the 30% cut, then it's a short-sighted move since if anything game streaming will drive adoption of iOS devices (e.g. iPad is almost the perfect streaming display).
- 1propionyl 6y ago> "It's 2020 and streaming is the new norm..." Is it really? While I don't think Apple is doing this for any particularly good reason, I for one would rather streaming of games not become even remotely the norm. When games become services, all kinds of perverse incentive structures are emphasized, in order to continue to produce revenue quarter after quarter. Microtransactions, FOMO based season systems, loot boxes, and various forms of applied captology to name a few. Games, like movies and music, walk the line between commodity entertainment and art. From what we've seen with movies and music, streaming services have tended to shove the balance towards commoditization. A parallel could be drawn to music streaming. See: https://www.thefader.com/2020/07/30/spotify-ceo-daniel-ek-says-working-musicians-can-no-longer-release-music-only-once-every-three-to-four-years https://www.thefader.com/2020/07/30/spotify-ceo-daniel-ek-sa... What Elk is proposing is essentially what some game developers are already doing. Annual releases of the same IP with minor gameplay changes and different skins (Assassins' Creed, Call of Duty, etc). You can see the seeds of a subscription model in Overwatch's "sequel but not really a sequel". Would it really be better if instead you paid a subscription per franchise you want to play?
- deleted 6y ago
- creativeCak3 6y agoNot surprised. Apple will do worse things 6 months from now. And I hate saying that I suspect their customers will just take it. They were ok with a “computer” that has everything glued on. Monopolistic Apps restrictions is nothing compared to that.
- thayne 6y agoWhat makes streaming games different than streaming videos or audio?
- applethrow 6y agoI don't see why this is controversial. Apple is a PRIVATE company and so they can do whatever they want. As a loyal Apple customer, I'm glad that they are doing everything they can to make sure iOS is a consistent experience! People keep on saying that this is an overstep, or worse, that this is just transparent greed. But that is wrong, Apple is merely defending the walled garden they have created. Think of all the value Apple has added to each of our lives. It is only fair that they should get a fair return on that environment that enables us iOS developers to make a meager living.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- not2b 6y agoAt some point, the better-positioned developers need to just say no to Apple, and produce enough content that only works with Android that Apple has to give in.
- ianwalter 6y agoThat's not going to work. Apple has been in that position for so long with Windows that it's built into their DNA. Regulation is probably the only thing that will work.
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoI really like iPhones. But I won't ever own one if I can't sideload apps on it. Two simple reasons: 1) I think that only I should decide if I want to run that app. The manufacturer no longer owns the device after selling it to me 2) The corrupt government if my county likes to block apps and Apple does as they ask. One day they'll remove the apps I really need, and it is not acceptable for me.
- lapetitejort 6y agoIn the last several years I've manually installed maybe two apps on my Android devices. I would be really upset if I couldn't use this oft-used but valuable tool.
- ViViDboarder 6y agoThat’s partly because Google doesn’t rule the Play Store with as much of an Iron Fist as Apple does. For better or for worse.
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoThis capability should exist. If only as a leverage against hostile anti-user actions like the one we are discussing here.
- astlouis44 6y agoClearly, WebAssembly and WebGPU are the solution to breaking this walled garden and slaying the proverbial gatekeeper that is Apple right now. The web has always been and will forever remain to be the last bastion of freedom. What's ironic is that Apple back in it's early founding days positioned itself as a rebellious company that would fight tooth and nail against evil entities that would employ cutthroat practices such as IBM, yet here they are. It's that old adage of living long enough to see yourself become a villain, sadly... Shameless plug - myself and a few other developers are developing a web platform for indie game developers to easily upload their work to the web, with all the tooling necessary to distribute and monetize without needing to pay the gatekeeper that archaic 30% fee. If you're interested in joining our movement, a link to our Discord is below: We envision a future where a new universal platform democratizes the way software is developed, deployed, and accessed, paving way for innovators instead of stifling them behind walled gardens. Link to our Discord server - https://discord.gg/zUSZ3T8 https://discord.gg/zUSZ3T8
- shmerl 6y agoThey shouldn't be dictating such kind of policies, when there are no easy ways to install alternative stores. Same story with ban on non Apple browsers in their store. Anti-trust should really blast them for it, plain and simple. Apple got away with this garbage for way too long.
- AviationAtom 6y ago*We don't want anyone to bypass us getting a cut of their revenues
- jedberg 6y agoI wonder, if streaming video on the internet was just starting to be a thing now (like Netflix 10 years ago), would they even allow it on the iPhone, or would they use some BS excuse about not allowing streaming apps because they can't vet all the content first.
- martell 6y agoNetflix has interactive videos with multiple story path choices which is by definition a kind of game. In this context it is the same as a game streaming service. So they have already allowed Netflix to do exactly what they are banning here. The only technical difference is you have 1 game input every 2-3 minutes vs inputs every 2-3 ms.
- recursive 6y agoIs there really a game input that runs more than 300 Hz?
- bisby 6y agoI'm not going to debate whether or not the services violate Apple's handcrafted policies. I'll just say that Apple has stupid policies. Stop using products that exist solely to lock you into a walled garden.
- freehunter 6y agoThe problem comes when someone likes 95% of what the Apple ecosystem offers but only 40% of the Android ecosystem. It’s not that easy to say “stop using them” if the person believes the competition is even worse.
- lern_too_spel 6y agoThe Android ecosystem offers strictly more than the Apple ecosystem, so there is no problem in practice.
- freehunter 6y agoBut it doesn’t. For what I’m looking for, it offers less. Far less. Less stability, less support from app developers, less support from manufacturers, less support from the vendor, less polish, a lesser tablet ecosystem, less cross-device functionality. The Android ecosystem “offers strictly more” in the same way a restaurant’s trash can offers more food choice. Technically true, but I don’t want to eat any of it. I’d rather order off the limited-but-actually-desirable menu.
- lern_too_spel 6y ago> Less stability Not my experience at all. > less support from app developers There are more apps on Android, and the apps do more things. I'm not sure how you came to this conclusion. > less polish The productivity apps on iOS are near useless. Then Apple moved to its own Maps, which was a disaster. > a lesser tablet ecosystem Android's tablets are called ChromeOS. They are a strictly better experience than iPad, with a built-in keyboard and Linux support. > less cross-device functionality Its default cross-device functionality (installing apps on your device from other devices, phone calling, voicemail, SMS, email composition sync, photo sync, document sync, music sync) is strictly better and existed long before iOS had anything. All of your perceived disadvantages don't exist, and there are many other advantages that Android has on top like system app updates without rebooting, better security, better privacy, better development for your own devices, better web browsers, better car apps, better multiuser support, more app discounts due to app store competition, better gaming through streaming services and emulation, etc.
- psukhedelos 6y agoI can’t help but wonder if this is a larger existential debate for Apple than gaming. Maybe they perceive this as a first step on a path of streaming apps in general? As internet connectivity continues to improve, what’s to stop all apps from simply being streamed? If they allow interactive remote gaming, why not allow us to stream text processors, photo editing apps, etc? How would they make any money off the App Store in a future where all apps are streamed bypassing their system all together? I’m not advocating for this, just bouncing the ball in an attempt to understand their perspective. Where do you draw the line?
- bob1029 6y agoStreaming apps are a huge threat to Apple's current business model. Arguably, the gate to the kingdom had already been thrown wide open years ago with all of the capability that currently exists in the web browsers. It's mostly just a matter of engineering at this point to get around the censors and gatekeepers. There is probably nothing Apple could do to prevent some determined engineer from building a streaming application framework that targets web instead of native apps for delivery of final server-side rasterized content. Best they could do is start blocking websites by IP/DNS which is arguably immediate grounds for Apple being split up and scattered to the seven winds by the FTC. Hypothetically, you could develop this framework and build your own app store at myappstore.com. Instead of downloading binary images of applications from this site, it would actually host the application directly as a streaming web experience. For instance, accessing myappstore.com/MySocialMediaApp would be the resource that loads a full-screen server-side-rendered view of that specific application. All clients would just need to store a 256 bit cookie that is used for identifying the session. Everything else could live on the server, including 100% of the client view state. This model also makes it trivial to share application state between users or devices. This kind of approach should sound like a massive boon to Apple in terms of them having absolute control & visibility, but I think they are just playing the current development ecosystem right now.
- eclipxe 6y agoWhy did you specify the bit size of the cookie?
- julianozen 6y agoI think apple caving on 3rd party app stores might be the easy regulatory solution for Apple. As a consumer there is definitely a tangible benefit to having the App Store be safe and consistent. Apple can impose its technical, moral, safety, and design philosophy on every app in its own stores like Disney or Whole Foods might with their retail products. But if Hey Email or ClassPass or anyone else doesn't like Apples offerings, they can go to a 3rd party store and be available there. Like the new browser entitlement, Apple can choose which 3rd parties are able to allow installs (and hopefully some regulation prevents this from being anti-competitive). There is no anti-competitive measures because there is no singular channel to install an app on an iphone anymore. And then Apple can make their App Store even more tightly controlled because every developer there is there by choice. Apple can cut custom deals to keep Google, Facebook or anyone else there, but Apple has to earn those partnerships like on the Mac App Store
- madeofpalk 6y ago> But if Hey Email or ClassPass or anyone else doesn't like Apples offerings, they can go to a 3rd party store and be available there. I absolutely do not want that to happen. This is no way is an actual benefit to anyone. If Hey or ClassPass was relegated to some other app store on iOS, it may as well not exist.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- anchpop 6y agoWhy would people be willing to pay $99/year for Hey but not willing to download a seperate app store?
- valuearb 6y agoVery, very few people want to pay $99/year for Hey. Their needs don’t represent the needs of iPhone users in general. And if Hey is typical of the vast majority of SAAS services, they pay affiliate fees and other marketing fees based on a percentage of sales to third parties that promote their service. So why not play Apple their 15% for a seamless in-app purchase system to add new users with?
- slumpt_ 6y agoThis is also why they drag their heels supporting MSE in mobile Safari. They want control. Technological possibilities be damned. Apple doesn’t give a shit about moving the world forward, they give a shit about moving Apple stock upward.
- vertis 6y agoNext they'll be saying that remote desktop clients violate their policies because you can technically use apps on the remote desktop. Honestly. This is pure greed from Apple. When is someone going to come along and bring Antitrust cases against them.
- Animats 6y agoStrange. The game isn't running on the phone. It's running on some server elsewhere. The client is just a video player with more controls.
- DevKoala 6y agoThis is the first thing that will make me considering dropping from the iOS ecosystem. However, if Microsoft or Google were in the same position, they’d act the same. This has to be fixed at a legal level.
- r3muxd 6y agogoogle wouldn't though because they already allow sideloading
- bookmarkable 6y agoTired of all the whining of people upset that Apple enforces its own rules of its own store on its own platform. If you install a cloud gaming product, it effectively acts as a wrapper for any and all games added. Yes, Apple wants and requires games to be installed to use their latest hardware. Not just stream from Microsoft, Google, or anyone else. Duh. They sell hardware and related services. Why would they allow a product that is antithetical to their core businesses? An iPhone is not just a dumb terminal for any company to sell anything for any price. If you don't agree and want a free for all, other companies make other products. Don't buy an iPhone. As for this immature notion that Apple is "greedy" - it is a BUSINESS. Tim Cook and every other exec have a legal responsibility to increase revenues, profits and ultimately shareholder value. They don't get to sit in a drum circle and smoke out until someone suggests "hey, let's just let Microsoft take over the AppStore Games category and hope whatever they stream to our users will leverage our newest innovations and drive new device purchases every once in a while." It doesn't work that way. It never will.
- fermienrico 6y agoI kind of support the gatekeeping Apple does. Usually, that leads to better services, safety and privacy. I don’t want a third party app for parental controls for example. I trust third parties far less than Apple.
- Darthy 6y agoSo Apple claims that Netflix is okay but that new Microsoft service is not, because the former one is a video streaming platform while the latter is a interactive game streaming platform. Now Apple, please explain me this: Netflix is also a interactive game streaming platform. They have Bandersnatch, Interactive Carmen Sandiego, Interactive Puss in Boots, the Interactive Bear Grylls You vs Wild, and freaking Minecraft Story Mode which for all intents and purposes is a fully real game. Netflix is a game streaming service, and it's on the app store! Apple is massively inconsistent here, and has some major explaining to do!
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Apple is massively inconsistent here The one consistent truth of the app store.
- zaroth 6y agoWhat's missing from Safari in order to just implement this directly in a browser window? AFAIK, Apple has never stepped over the line of blocking specific websites. As soon as it's possible to reliably remote stream an interface through the browser then the App Store and pretty much any native app at all can become totally irrelevant, offline mode aside. If a device is reduced to a touch interface, video stream decoder, and a bunch of radios... your upgrade cycle becomes essentially driven by the carrier baseband upgrade cycle, which is quite slow. Who care how fast the phone CPU runs Javascript, when the Javascript is running in the cloud? It's like thin terminals all over again.
- mmcconnell1618 6y agoThe Stadia app is available in the ios store and has been. Not sure where this article got the info that it isn't available. https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id1471900213 https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id1471900213
- qcz 6y agoDid you actually read the app description? "You can’t use the Stadia app to play games directly on an iOS device, but you can use the app to manage Stadia on other devices." It is a Stadia manager, not Stadia itself...
- nba456_ 6y ago> You can’t use the Stadia app to play games directly on an iOS device, but you can use the app to manage Stadia on other devices.
- Rapzid 6y agoHeh, it's not really the game streaming Apple takes exception to; it's the revenue streaming.
- jmull 6y agoA lot of apps have a mix of executing logic locally and remotely. A “streaming” app just means more of it is executing remotely. It’s hard to see why the App Store review criteria should be different for an app depending on its internal execution architecture. Now, I don’t agree with various App Store policies. But that’s a separate issue. I think they should revise those policies for everyone, not just have a loophole for some apps that run more of their logic remotely than others.
- julioo 6y agoIt’s time to rollback and put priority on web app and webgl.
- post_break 6y agoI can stream games from my PC to my Apple TV, but the second the game comes from the cloud it's not ok? Ok apple. I hope some laws are written that force your hand.
- dang 6y agoUrl changed from https://www.gsmarena.com/apple_says_game_streaming_services_like_microsofts_xcloud_violate_app_store_policies-news-44656.php https://www.gsmarena.com/apple_says_game_streaming_services_..., which points to this.
- darrinm 6y agoThe Roblox iOS app is entirely populated with non-Apple approved user created games. It also streams/downloads (non-Apple reviewed) code on demand. This seems to be against a number of App Store policies. Maybe Apple is OK with all of this when they get their 30% cut as they do with Roblox because it uses Apple's in-app purchases?
- antonber 6y agoAgree with this. Roblox is a cross-platform games store and both Apple and Google constantly feature and promote it.
- newbie578 6y agoCan't wait for the App Store to get regulated by the EU so that Apple finally has to drop at least some of its monopolistic and hegemonial behaviour. And by reading the (irrational) comments here, that will be a day of griefing which I will be more than glad to gloat at.
- chj 6y agoYou can ignore AppStore policies and guidelines, they keep reinventing new interpretations. The one true rule is hand over our cuts.
- bertronic 6y agoiOS is a competitor to Xbox in gaming. Apple sells games in the App Store and they have their own game subscription service, Apple Arcade. Should Microsoft be forced to allow Stadia or Steam Link on Xbox? Must Sony Allow xCloud on PlayStation? Of course not. Just because you can do more than play games on your iPhone doesn’t mean that Apple has some obligation to bolster their competition by allowing them on their platform.
- OMGCable 6y agoYoutube? Netflix? How are they approved?
- berbec 6y agoWhat they mean - Apple says game streaming services that don't do billing through Apple Pay, and give Apple their tithe, violate App Store Policies.
- ellis0n 6y agoThat confuses me, we will not be able to see an independent live broadcast from Mars
- gerash 6y agoI don't think there's any point in discussing the nuances of an arbitrary set of rules. Let's hope Microsoft or Google give Apple a more serious competition on the hardware front. Apple will continue to make it more and more expensive for its customers to switch away (as any other company would) so there better be more leverage for the consumers either through competition or regulation.
- vaxman 6y agoThe worst part is how they are inspiring the next generation of tech gangsters to behave this way. I seriously doubt Tim Apple could be this moronic and still be brilliant on the process side. The fail idiots will be fine in retirement, really. But in the meantime the kids are thinking this is the way to make my crumb-based startup into the next two trillion dollar company just like Steve Jobs did.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 6y agoQuestion: isn't this thing valid also for tv shows from, e. G. Netflix?
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 6y agoHow is Steam handling this by the way? It is accepted on iOS, but the steam library is way bigger and it includes adult-only games
- jpalomaki 6y agoThese kind of streaming apps are app stores themselves. They are a window to another world that is not controlled by Apple. Apple is likely worried that it may not stop at streaming games. Why not stream other apps as well. Usability will be fine if you come up with clever ”codecs” to encode transmission of UI. It’s true that Safari already enables this, but it has its limitations and Apple is controlling what can be done there.
- figassis 6y agoSeems like apple has become the Microsoft of old, with the developer and consumer antagonistic policies.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- eqtn 6y agoEverything can be made to steam. Adobe can make all its apps steamable with a subscription, then they don't have to create separate versions for each. They even can have customized hardware in their datacenters. Maybe Apple is worried about this losing game.
- Keverw 6y agoI wonder if Microsoft with the xCloud project could just web WebRTC in Safari full screen? There's a gamepad API for bluetooth controllers, It seems like mobile safari supports it from a quick Google search. Disappointed in Apple here :( I'm a fan of them generally, but as someone interested in game development makes me want to use Windows more lately, and the Windows Linux Subsystem seems interesting even though haven't played with it... I think I'd miss magic mouse and swiping between spaces... Not sure what hardware I'd get, I have Windows in Bootcamp and it feels so awkward using it so barely use it. Kinda irritates me it seems like there's always 2 choices... Windows or Mac, iPhone or Android... Kinda a concern not more competition. Sure you can run Linux on the desktop, but you have limited app support and not as commercially supported.