15 ms·
Journalists’ Twitter use shows them talking within smaller bubbles
- danielheath 6y agoPeople use social media to talk to their friends more than to strangers; news at 10.
- raziel2p 6y agoExactly. I doubt the validity of "who follows who on Twitter" as useful data in the first place, but I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of other demographics followed the same pattern, not just journalists.
- llarsson 6y agoPlease note that this is not about personal filter bubbles, but rather professional ones. I find this interesting and disturbing, as it would no doubt improve reporting if journalists were more aware of all viewpoints across the political (or otherwise) spectrum and what issues seem to matter in different circles, not just their own. What they do during their spare time is of course up to them. But their professional ability to report on the news would surely benefit from a wider range of perspectives.
- watwut 6y agoImo, they would achieve this better by reading what those other journalist write rather then following them on twitter. The latter would most likely to just lead to more ridiculous late night feuds.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThe issue IMO isn't about challenging their views in general; it's about developing a skewed perspective of what's normal. There are a lot of common opinions, even majority opinions, that journalists tend to write about as though they're weird fringe beliefs, and I think this substantially misinforms people about the state of the world.
- paulcole 6y agoWonderful article for any software eng to read. I certainly see some issues (most will), but a great place to start.
- secondcoming 6y agoJournalism is just retweeting, and writing articles about tweets, these days.
- richardARPANET 6y agoHere's a great video on exactly this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4sWcSxVjXcY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4sWcSxVjXcY
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- echevil 6y agoThat explains so much
- auganov 6y agoNote that some journalistic organizations have strong rules on social media use[0]. Not to mention many unwritten ones. Interacting outside the bubble could come with repercussions. I'd wager that if you'd look at people in other public facing professions you'd get similar results. [0] Example: https://www.ap.org/assets/documents/social-media-guidelines_tcm28-9832.pdf https://www.ap.org/assets/documents/social-media-guidelines_... "However, friending and “liking” political candidates or causes may create a perception among people unfamiliar with the protocol of social networks that AP staffers are advocates. Therefore, staffers should try to make this kind of contact with figures on both sides of controversial issues. "
- raxxorrax 6y agoIn an ideal case they should be able to express their opinions and people wouldn't extrapolate them to the respective employer. Journalists not able to express themselves freely because of guilt by association would be a huge problem and being able to do so provides extra information that can put articles in context. Another fact worth mentioning is that large publishers all have a direct business relationship with social media companies, primarily Facebook I believe. Some better newspapers were transparent about it and lamented this fact as a necessity in the current news market. Thanks to companies generally having no backbone and disciplining employees for social media use or generally for their opinions, we are at this bad situation. If they just had ignored the complaints... All that said, the opinions of the most outspoken journalists often seem very predictable and in many cases they actually argued in favor of accountability by social media use by writing their outrage articles about some random tweets. I think a lot of those have missed their profession... Didn't take disclaimers like "opinions are my own" too seriously, but apparently they might be needed for some journalists at least.
- mattmanser 6y agoThis seems like extremely wishful thinking. Say one silly thing, or something that could be interpreted wrong, you could lose your job from an indignant mob. It's not worth the risk.
- watwut 6y ago
- BelleOfTheBall 6y agoTwitter, in and of itself, isn't exactly a platform for useful discourse. A journalist leaning to a certain end of a political spectrum starting a civil conversation with a journalist on the other end of the spectrum would likely lead to both of them getting accosted by readers asking why they're talking to "the enemy" or something like that. I do think journalists need to mix with circles that are out of their bubble. I don't, however, find Twitter to be the most crucial platform for that. Talk in person, communicate in opinion pieces and clash ideas. Just don't let it be filtered through hundreds of users shouting about how the other side is bad.
- wittyreference 6y agoJournalism as a public media profession is highly dependent on social currency for professional prospects. It’s one of the -last- professions that can risk being associated with the wrong tribe, in the current context of culture war. And I see little evidence that journalists are anything but bought-in.
- luckylion 6y agoI believe you're right: most Tweet that are ostensibly talk to somebody aren't meant to be read by them. They're meant to be read by the followers of the person tweeting. You could probably make it much more peaceful while losing nothing of what people use it for by putting all accounts into follower-only-mode. The different groups could scream at each other (and have their ingroup-rituals completed) without the other side ever even noticing that they're being screamed at.
- pjc50 6y agoOne of the odd things about the news business is the kind of omerta that prevents journalists directly going at each other as political actors. There are a few exceptions; everyone feels comfortable abusing Owen Jones, for example. But even journalists and newspapers that get censured for inaccurate or distorted stories (e.g. https://hackinginquiry.org/press-release-islamophobia-times/ https://hackinginquiry.org/press-release-islamophobia-times/ ) don't become the story as much as they should. This is especially relevant when Spectator journalist Boris Johnson became Prime Minister, but evaded being interviewed on the BBC by Spectator chairman and BBC journalist Andrew Neil; or when Russian media oligarch and "Independent" owner Evgeny Lebedev was appointed to the UK's permanent unaccountable legislature, the House of Lords. In the UK, there is no boundary between journalism and party politics.
- npunt 6y agoProbably the most important part of a journalist's work is building sources and chasing stories, which is largely done privately (DMs, etc) for obvious reasons. This analysis misses that. The public face of journalists on twitter is primarily to build personal brand, broadcast, and generate leads for private scoops via their brand and strategically discussion of particular topics. Much of the reason for journalists smaller bubble is they're building each other up professionally, rather than just hanging out and chatting like most other twitter users. I think this study might be confusing these two very different use cases.
- rich_sasha 6y agoAgreed, though I would add that spending a lot of time on Twitter may well distort people’s idea of general sentiment of the wider population. Something like 0.1% of the society tweets actively with a following, you then narrow it down further to people with very similar background, you may well lure yourself into thinking it’s a semi-representative group.
- npunt 6y agoDefinitely. It depends on the industry though, some are well represented on twitter and others are not, and hopefully journalists are good enough to understand their beat and where signal really is. Politics twitter might be an especially bad example since that beat is so all-encompassing. From a design perspective, twitter really is an amazing distillation of the media mindset and approach to the world, focused on soundbites, building a following, 24 hour news cycle, etc. It's totally catnip for people in media, I'm not sure a product could be much better designed for them.
- japanoise 6y agoMy impression of twitter was of an insular bizzaro-world where communities that are essentially invisible in meatspace become enormous and have outsized influence; k-pop fans are huge on twitter and almost always trending, but are barely known outside of their own circles elsewhere, not to mention all the incredibly granular political groups (the long and bloody trad-cath-leninist vs pinetree-eco-fash wars are so drawn out you'd be forgiven for not realising it's only 20 people per side, posting 24/7) It always amazes me that normal people like journalists still use such a strange website.
- Vanit 6y agoJust think how small their bubbles were 20 years ago! /s
- kabacha 6y agoTitles like this make me realize how awful english language is. Actually readable title would be: "Twitter usage of journalists' show them talking within smaller bubbles"
- agumonkey 6y agoAnd also how long do they spend on a topic. I believe journalists use to take their sweet time because to uncover / understand anything substantial you need not to speed.
- checkyoursudo 6y agoI think there have always been dual competing interests of thoroughness and deadline. Though probably the internet has made deadline a stronger interest at the moment.
- agumonkey 6y agoweb clearly made fast pace a semi conscious desire also I believe people mistake lots of quick verified fact with information
- checkyoursudo 6y agoThat's a good point. Brute facts strung together often get mistaken for analysis or synthesis.
- swebs 6y agoAnd these are just the public bubbles. There have also been leaks of private groups such as JournoList (and its successor, Cabalist), and GameJournoPros. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JournoList https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JournoList https://ggwiki.deepfreeze.it/index.php?title=GameJournoPros https://ggwiki.deepfreeze.it/index.php?title=GameJournoPros
- op03 6y agoRecommend - Niall Ferguson's book The Square and the Tower about how the same networks exist in all communities - science, business, politics etc etc. As to the journos, human behavior doesn't change so easily by just showing people their issues. In fact if they feel judged too much, they can get more defensive about their behavior or aggressively attack those pointing at it. The fact that analysis of behavior happens publicly, makes unproductive outcomes even more likely. It just creates spiraling reaction counter-reaction cycles. You can see how well the approach has worked with changing Trump's behavior, even though there are huge armies of people pointing out and documenting his issues day and night seemingly without any awareness that all that work has not changed outcomes. Plus expecting behavior change on top of a social media architecture skewed to self promotion and engagement is unrealistic. So cut the journos some slack. The possible solutions are half baked or constrained by the operating environment, with barely any examples of solutions that have produce good outcomes.
- rsynnott 6y ago> You can see how well the approach has worked with changing Trump's behavior, even though there are huge armies of people pointing out and documenting his issues day and night seemingly without any awareness that all that work has not changed outcomes. Trump is arguably the exception, in that he either doesn't care about re-election or (more likely) at some level misunderstands exactly why he won on the first place. Public opinion often does have a significant impact on government policy, though, especially in parliamentary democracies (where it's easier to u-turn without showing that much weakness by simply sacrificing a minister).
- Voxoff 6y agoThis is a cursory criticism but this seems to be suggesting that journalists who, say, specialise in Middle Eastern politics talk to other journalists who specialise in Middle Eastern politics than others. And that’s supposed to be surprising/vaguely interesting?
- lol2143651 6y agoWhat's interesting is that circle is smaller than it was 4 years ago.
- keiferski 6y agoI’ve been wondering what would happen if enough people and companies simply ignored Twitter, entirely. Pretended that it didn’t exist, that tweets are on the same level of relevance as graffiti messages scribbled on sidewalks or the headlines on grocery store checkout conspiracy magazines. As in, nonsense. I have a feeling that essentially nothing would change, and that in the long run, totally disengaging from Twitter would make sense from a cost-benefit point of view for most people and organizations. It really seems like it isn’t an accurate indicator of anything except a very tiny percentage of the population.
- marcus_holmes 6y agoI found this to be true. I was involved in selling a newspaper, and Twitter speculation from the journalists involved was rife and, frankly, full of bullshit. I decided there was no way to rationally deal with this. So I stopped looking at Twitter. That turned out to be the best thing to do. People still said things, but as I wasn't listening it didn't matter. The gossip and malicious slander reached a crescendo as the sale went though, but ultimately had zero impact on what actually happened. As far as I can work out, what happens on Twitter stays on Twitter, and if you don't pay it any attention it really doesn't matter. However, the caveat to that is that journalists are on Twitter, pay a lot of attention to Twitter, and report it as reality. Getting dogpiled on Twitter may not matter, but having it reported in newspapers may make it matter.
- sumtechguy 6y agoI have a few tech people I want to follow as they use it as a blog. But I do not want an account on twitter as it is too easy for me to get dragged into conversations that are unproductive for everyone involved. So I picked a method where I link about 5 people created a folder in firefox and linked to their pages. Then if I am wanting to 'see what is going on'. I open all links in that folder. I do that maybe once a month. Twitter is an attention machine. It feeds on getting your attention. Outrage does that quite nicely so they boderline openly encourage it.
- 6y ago
- m3kw9 6y agoBut how does one know they are in a bubble?? For example, am I in some tech info bubble with the sites I regular visit or is it diverse enough?
- throwaway122378 6y agoIt’s called an echo chamber
- whack 6y ago> Ng collected all the tweets, retweets and replies posted on most of those accounts over two months in early 2018, using Twitter’s application-programming interface. She winnowed those further to only those sent between or referencing other Beltway journalists. The final data set consisted of 133,529 Twitter posts from 2,015 journalists, about one-third of all credentialed congressional correspondents. Couple things stood out here: - they are looking only at tweets/comments, not the people being followed - they have filtered the dataset to include only journalists, so you wouldn't see any engagement they have with people outside their profession - What they have found isn't so much "bubbles" but rather "hubs" - there's no comparison to similar data on other professions. I would expect that almost all professional networking falls into hubs that are either based on exclusivity (eg, FANG employees, ivy league alumni) or professional niche (eg, television producers, startup founders). Are these journalists really exhibiting insular behavior, or is it perfectly aligned with every other segment of society? We really can't tell without any basis for comparison
- moduspol 6y ago> they are looking only at tweets/comments, not the people being followed Journalists have already been called out for this, so it's likely not a useful metric any more. The accounts they choose to follow are likely carefully calculated since they're aware it's visible and people look at these things. Anyone can have multiple Twitter accounts, so it'd be trivial to have another account that follows a different set of accounts that one scrolls through normally.
- ketzo 6y agoTo state the obvious, it’s also very easy to follow someone and just mute them so you don’t actually see their content in your feed.
- secondcoming 6y agoYes, but people will look at who you follow on twitter to see if you're a white supremacist or not.
- ravenstine 6y agoHaving worked at a media firm, I find this very plausible. At one point I decided to take a look at my journalist coworkers' Twitter profiles. ~95% of the people they were following were not only other journalists, but other journalists of similar, if not identical, political bent. This makes sense, of course, because people will always prefer to hear viewpoints that reinforce their own, but for journalists this is a problem because they're supposed to be providing information, yet they are especially subject to feedback loops created when they fail in attempting to understand viewpoints that aren't intuitive to them. Worse yet, extremism is almost always rewarded on platforms like Twitter, and because journalists are partly driven by a need for fame and brand recognition, they're encouraged to be openly biased. EDIT: I don't want to paint all journalists in a bad light. What I described just seemed common in my experience.
- untog 6y agoNone of that is particularly surprising or alarming if you consider Twitter to be a networking tool, though. It seems like that's exactly what it is for many, including people in tech. You talk to people in your industry, exchange advice, possibly even look for a job. The assumption in the study is that journalists are also using Twitter as a source for their journalism but that isn't really substantiated anywhere. Yes, there's plenty of clickbait crap that recycles whatever the latest X is on social media, but in terms of actual original reporting? I'm not so convinced.
- Talanes 6y agoPurely anecdotal, but the couple of local journalists I follow on Twitter will directly ask for leads on things they are working, over Twitter.
- tolbish 6y agoWhy would they need to substantiate that Twitter is used as a source for their journalism? That would be a common-sense assumption.
- madeofpalk 6y ago> but for journalists this is a problem because they're supposed to be providing information, I do not expect journalists to use their twitter timeline as the foundation of all their reporting.
- DamnYuppie 6y agoI have worked on systems for large media companies back in 2008-2010. The main feature they always wanted were as follows: 1. The ability to create a poll on their website, but only count votes that aligned with the desired outcome they wanted. So they could create a poll and before posting on their site they could set a target outcome of the various options. 2. For comments if it was flagged they wouldn't hide it or notify the user, instead it would be removed from everyone else's view except the users. There were a few other very eye opening requests as well. Since that time I have assumed all media is in the business of manipulating and forming opinions. Trying to tell this to regular people seemed to only get me labeled as a conspiracy nut and that there was no way their beloved institutions would behave in such a way.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Nacdor 6y agoThis reminds me of a piece Glenn Greenwald wrote after Trump won the election. He'd been saying the same thing for a while but Clinton's loss finally proved his point: > opinion-making elites were so clustered, so incestuous, so far removed from the people who would decide this election — so contemptuous of them — that they were not only incapable of seeing the trends toward Trump but were unwittingly accelerating those trends with their own condescending, self-glorifying behavior. https://theintercept.com/2016/11/09/democrats-trump-and-the-ongoing-dangerous-refusal-to-learn-the-lesson-of-brexit/ https://theintercept.com/2016/11/09/democrats-trump-and-the-... Many of the most influential journalists and politicians are shockingly out of touch with (and often hostile towards) the everyday people they're supposed to represent. It's now painfully clear that the media has little or no interest in reporting the truth, they want to create it themselves.
- chillwaves 6y agoTrump's win was the product of an antiquated electoral process, not some "will of the people" or he wouldn't have received 5million fewer votes.
- arkanciscan 6y agoAre journalists not supposed to have friends? Is Twitter use indicative of a person's entire communication pattern? Perhaps Twitter is best used as a tool for communicating with close aquaintences than with the broader world. Everyone is a dickhead on Twitter, so how can you blame anyone for muting/blocking the hell out of everything on there?
- sharker8 6y agoTake this conversation to clubhouse.
- jb775 6y agoNo wonder there's so much division in the world considering people live in their own echo chamber, and consume media that's an echo chamber comprised of journalists creating their own echo chambers.
- GFunc 6y agoSo, like tech twitter...
- dang 6y agoThis is the silo effect. Sorry for the parochial comment, but I think about this in HN's context a lot, because it's one of the rare cases of an internet community (possibly the largest? at least that I'm aware of) which is non-siloed: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=silo%20by%3Adang&dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=silo%20by%3Adang&dateRange=all.... That is, everyone's in the same big room and sees the same things. This leads to paradoxical effects, such as people subjectively experiencing the community as more fractious when objectively it is less so: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23308098 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23308098.
- pvg 6y agoI don't think this is really a sensible interpretation - the clustering is derived by tracking twitter interactions and relationships on twitter. You could do something similar for HN and identify some clusters, although you'll be missing things like 'follows' which twitter makes public and explicit.
- dang 6y agoI assume those relationships are based on who people choose to follow, which is what I mean by 'silo'.
- DubiousPusher 6y agoI've really been enjoying this guy's little viewed YouTube channel. It mostly consists of his journalism school lectures but it hits so many of the ideas I've been considering about journalism lately and takes them places I hadn't been able to. https://www.youtube.com/user/robertwilliamjensen https://www.youtube.com/user/robertwilliamjensen It's really brought me back to a pre-aocial media mindset of journalism. The important things about the journalism we consume are somewhat irrelevant to social media. So I'm fully off Facebook, mostly off Twitter and am consuming as much as I can through periodicals and books. P. S. Several of the videos of Anthony Shadid's conversations about the U.S. involvement in Iraq are very compelling as well.
- moomin 6y agoNot to be funny, but for anyone with even a slightly high profile, Twitter is horribly broken. You fix it by muting everything. So yeah, I’m not surprised that the only people they speak to are ones they know professionally or personally.