4 ms·
I agree. You may not agree with Zuckerberg's position of not censoring content (beyond the obscene), but it's probably the smartest position for the business.
by refurb 6y ago
I agree. You may not agree with Zuckerberg's position of not censoring content (beyond the obscene), but it's probably the smartest position for the business.
As soon as you start saying "well, we'll censor stuff that isn't accurate", you've opened a Pandora's box of every single interest group hammering you on every single decision and in the end everyone thinks you're screwing them over.
- deanCommie 6y agoFacebook has access to the biggest and most ubiquitous information delivery platform IN THE WORLD today. To let them off the hook for the role they had in helping letting the idea of ABSOLUTE TRUTH degrade, as well as the role they COULD have in helping fix it, is not thinking big enough. Facebook could choose to be an active participant in the quest to reinforce the value of reality-orientated information exchange. They choose not to because it doesn't help their metrics. That doesn't make them evil, that makes them a logical participant in capitalism. The onus is on the rest of us to make them.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoWould you support this even if Facebook suppressed some ideas you believe in, or are you working under the assumption that Facebook will always agree with you about what's true?
- deanCommie 6y agoI...don't know how to respond to that. Truth is truth. Yes, there is right wing fascist parties that are trying to nullify the meaning of the word, and introduce subjectivity where there should not be any, sowing doubt on the very idea of Reality. But this is not the new normal for society or humanity. I refuse to believe that, or we're truly doomed. This is a temporary hurdle made by desperate people trying to hold on to a world they are being left behind in. If Facebook doesn't take a stance on facts, lies, reality, and fiction. Then they are by definition agreeing with those that say all these things are subjective, and are therefore themselves unimpeachable and above repercussions. Not taking a stand is taking a stand in this case.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoMaybe I'm misunderstanding you. Do you recognize the possibility of good-faith disagreements on matters of fact, or do you expect that every reasonable person should agree in all cases about what's true and false? In the latter case I agree I don't see a productive discussion to be had here.
- deanCommie 6y agoIn ALL cases? Certainly not. But this isn't a mathematical proof. Just because we cannot guarantee something in 100% of the time, doesn't mean it should not be attempted. Truth is being degraded not about ethically controversial subjects with a clear scientific consensus, and not even controversial subjects with SOME scientific doubt. We're talking about situations where leaders of hundreds of millions of people will deny statements they made, and everyone falls along, in an Orwellian fashion. These are not good faith disagreements. There is a massive contingent out there in the world that are not arguing in good faith, they care not about the argument, but about the results. And if you want to give them all the benefit of the doubt, and say that "there are fine people on both sides", then you are correct, there is no productive discussion to be had here.
- DonHopkins 6y agoPeople who deny climate change and other settled science and don't wear masks because they think it's a political statement aren't "reasonable people".
- splintercell 6y agoOh you're throwing climate change into the group of "absolute truth". Philosophy of science isn't that objectively finalized btw. The whole Vienna school which got obliterated by philosophers because it said that only valid scientific statements are those which can be empirically verified. I understand that majority of the people making a certain viewpoint may be stupid but don't take it as the strength of your scientific statements. Even theory of evolution may need major corrections tomorrow and could even turn out to be completely false.
- matz1 6y agoThere is no such thing as absolute truth, its relative and subjective.
- riffraff 6y ago> beyond the obscene I mean, that's pretty arbitrary too, e.g. FB censors female breasts, which is not considered obscene in many places. It's a difficult line to walk.
- chmod775 6y agoWhere I live even full nudity would not be considered obscene at all, unless something sexual was going on. However it is becoming more and more the case. With American platforms and media, their learned attitude of being overly prude also made their way here. Though I'm not sure whether "prude" is the right word to describe the crippling self-consciousness many experience when faced with nude humanity. I suspect it has be actively instilled by your parents and society around you while you are still young, or you won't ever have it.
- andrewflnr 6y agoAs an American, I don't think it's "crippling self-consciousness", we're just trained to think of nudity as sexually provocative in itself.
- rhizome 6y ago"It's not the nudity that's bad, it's the sexual provocation! I mean, I don't care if they're topless in their own homes, but do they have to flaunt it? They're so in-your-face."
- jariel 6y agoNo obscene, inappropriate. But it can very quickly descend into the obscene, and if they didn't filter you'd get nasty dick picks all over the place. Every social place has rules, not exception. It's just a matter of how they are impressed.
- bachmeier 6y agoIt's more than that though. It's not just the quantity of stuff you wouldn't want to see, but that FB would then be known for that type of content, and they'd lose the other content that brings in the money. Purely from a business model perspective, they want to keep that stuff off.
- skosch 6y agoRadiolab has a wonderfully deep episode on this topic: https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/post-no-evil-redux https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/post-... The main issue is the sheer volume of content. Four seconds – that's their estimate for how much time employees in Facebook's "censorship farm" centers have, on average, to make a decision about whether a reported post gets deleted or not. As a result, management decided to aim for the lowest bar: consistent enforcement of a limited set of rules. That's hard enough as is: is all blood gore? Are all references to race hate speech? Etc. etc. So the censors simply have no capacity to fairly fact-check every single political post, and when in doubt, they err on the side of free speech. ML can help suppress certain viral posts, but not consistently so. I'm not a fan of Facebook by any means, but in this case they really are in a tough spot.
- kazagistar 6y agoFacebook seems to still have some profit, so it clearly has capacity. The insufficient number of people looking at reported violations is by design.
- berkes 6y agoThis assumes that there is a solution 'if you just throw enough money at it'. I'm not familiar enough with how large scale moderation works, so is this solvable, with near unlimited funds?
- emn13 6y agoIt really only assumes the solution gets better if you throw more money at it. And that, frankly, is essentially certain given the fact that they need to pay for human eyeballs. Also, the problems facebook has are somewhat misrepresented often - they don't actually need to moderate everything equally intensively - most of the impact will be there with the things that get shared publicly and are viewed often. Comparing the amount of moderator time with total posting volume is thus misleading, trying to make it appear like a hopeless case. But look at it the other way around, not from the poster's side, but the reader's - clearly reads aren't distributed evently; so it's plausible you might catch 90% of post readungs with just 10% of post writings (I don't know the proportion, but I'd expect it to be heavily skewed).
- mattigames 6y agoI think the solution is clear: If governments want to censor they should do it themselves not externalize costs to the foreign media company, meaning Facebook should give them access to an API/dashboard with all the posts created or viewed on Brazil and government employees should pick manually (or by algorithm) what to censor. After that any request of censoring anything coming from Brazil should be directed at the government and never again to Facebook itself.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoI wonder what could go wrong with that.
- mattigames 6y agoThat at some point Facebook has to isolate Brazil on a separate website to stop it from censoring people that has nothing to do with Brazil and their government realizes that policing by themselves a global communication channel is not the best idea?
- microcolonel 6y ago> ...position of not censoring content (beyond the obscene).. I don't think this accurately describes Facebook's position. They have deleted several people for essentially pure ideological reasons, including people who they readily admit violated no rules.
- rhizome 6y agoOnly governments censor, what you're talking about is editorial policy. However, Zuck doesn't want to risk Facebook's §230 protection which is the door that the hammerers are behind. It's not a Pandora's box, though, because these laws have been around for decades and centuries. But they don't want to, they haven't built the tools to do so, and they make money from it. It's the same as their rationale around moderation in general: "well we built this to be wide open and have zero tools to control it, and now it's just too complicated to do so!" It's like building a car without brakes and saying "Look, congressperson, we're in the business of helping people get to wherever they want to go. We don't think it's our place to dictate the speed of travel, and there are many companies making brakes for these cars, for people who want them. Competition!"