9 ms·
> I'm not comfortable investing the entirety into an index fund, given the current socio-political climate. Over the the long term there is not really anything
by throw0101a 6y ago
> I'm not comfortable investing the entirety into an index fund, given the current socio-political climate.
Over the the long term there is not really anything better to do with it than equities: the Great Depression, World War 2, gold standard retirement, 1980s inflation, etc. Even if you only invested in the peaks, you'd still do quite well over the decades:
* https://awealthofcommonsense.com/2014/02/worlds-worst-market-timer/ https://awealthofcommonsense.com/2014/02/worlds-worst-market...
Jumping in with a lump sum amount can be quite daunting, so what you can do instead is put in (say) 40K every month over the course of a year or so:
* https://ofdollarsanddata.com/even-god-couldnt-beat-dollar-cost-averaging/ https://ofdollarsanddata.com/even-god-couldnt-beat-dollar-co...
Certainly better than sitting in cash. If you're worried about volatility, then also invest in some bonds funds: 60% stocks, 40% bonds? If you want more growth, 70/30 or 80/20 maybe.
And while the S&P 500 gets a lot of the press, a total market fund is what Vanguard is steering their own employees to:
* https://www.marketwatch.com/story/bogle-explains-why-vanguard-employees-wont-have-a-flagship-sp-500-fund-in-their-401k-2018-06-07 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/bogle-explains-why-vanguar...
See also:
* https://www.pwlcapital.com/should-you-invest-in-the-sp-500-index/ https://www.pwlcapital.com/should-you-invest-in-the-sp-500-i...
- quotemstr 6y agoI'm an index fund skeptic. What would happen in a world where everyone invested in index funds? Capital allocation would go haywire. You can't create value out of nothing. ISTM that the more people push on index funds, the more overvalued equities in the index become relative to those outside the index. I'm not sure that retrospective analysis saying index funds are the best applies going forward in a world where index funds are much more popular than they were in the past.
- branweb 6y agoNot the op but I wish downvoters would comment giving their reasons. I remember seeing something about this in the atlantic a while back, and it would be good to know if/why it's a bad argument.
- quotemstr 6y agoThere's this weird social energy surrounding index funds that's very aggressive about preaching that they're the only viable option and that everything else is ridiculous. To be honest, this energy is another input that increases my skepticism of the whole thing. These days, whenever you see an argument downvoted instead of rebutted, there's likely something to it.
- guenthert 6y agoI didn't downvote the earlier comment (and wouldn't as I'm quite clueless about financial matters), but felt the need to downvote another comment in an unrelated article recently. There I noticed, that once I applied the downvote, I couldn't see the comment being downvoted anymore. I meant to reply then to that comment on why I downvoted the comment, but couldn't anymore. I guess, that's the reason why one sees here so many downvotes by anonymous cowards.
- mancerayder 6y agoI think voting can mean different things to different people. Some people upvote or downvote because they agree or disagree. They view it as a "vote" for the opinion. Others upvote or downvote because they thing the argument is strong or weak, or maybe because someone said something nice and positive to another person or someone said something mean or hostile to another person. I strongly favor the second approach.
- hansjorg 6y agoEver since Vanguard started there has been a constant barrage of anti index fund propaganda in the US. One of the early slurs was that index funds were communism (pretty daft, but probably effective in the US). The latest is this scaremongering "what if all investment were into index funds" (answered several times in this thread). From the perspective of index fund advocates, unsophisticated investors are systematically getting ripped off and the daft propaganda only adds to the offense. This is probably why you're picking up an aggressive preachy vibe from advocates. The empirical data is however unambiguous and there is now a lot of it.
- 6y ago
- mensetmanusman 6y agoBecause there are already hundreds of gatekeeper entities involved with getting a company listed. You are basically investing in the idea that: ‘On average, these companies are run by people who want the company to succeed, and as long as the population of the world grows, and the middle class grows, this will make money’ Everyone could invest in index funds, and this would still be true, because if the stock price gets too low, it would be rational for the company to purchase its own stock on the cheap which would set the price floor.
- bryananderson 6y agoObviously not “everyone” will ever invest in index funds. HFT firms, leveraged buyout folks, and prop traders at investment banks aren’t going to stop betting on individual securities. The people who have more information, quicker ability to act on information, or superior ability to analyze information shouldn’t buy index funds (they’re also the people who contribute meaningfully to price discovery). A smart individual retail investor is statistically unlikely to “beat” those people, and should buy index funds.
- mancerayder 6y agoI hear this over and over again. Beating the HFT firms, insiders, big money shops and so forth. It's not a zero sum game necessarily. A stock picker approach that you have as a retail investor that many trading shops do not have is this: time. You can make your bet, and if it fails in the short term you can hold onto the stock long term, unless the company is going bankrupt (which hasn't been a common occurrence up to now, given the overall number of stock symbols). Traders are individuals and groups with books, quarterly numbers to meet and yearly returns to care about. They'll beat you if you're a day trader, sure, but I think it's a false dichotomy to say, you're either a) a day trader or b) a boglehead.
- throw0101a 6y ago> It's not a zero sum game necessarily. It is, actually. William F. Sharpe laid it out in the 1991 paper "The Arithmetic of Active Management": * https://web.stanford.edu/~wfsharpe/art/active/active.htm https://web.stanford.edu/~wfsharpe/art/active/active.htm * https://www.jstor.org/stable/4479386?seq=1 https://www.jstor.org/stable/4479386?seq=1 Sharpe won the 1990 Economics Nobel for other work: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_F._Sharpe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_F._Sharpe The more active a trader is, over a longer time frame, the more likely they are to underperform the market. This has been shown through SPIVA over 15+ years, at least in the US and Canada: * https://www.tma-invest.com/spiva-data-reveals-15-years-of-active-underperformance/ https://www.tma-invest.com/spiva-data-reveals-15-years-of-ac... * https://www.ifa.com/articles/despite_brief_reprieve_2018_spiva_report_reveals_active_funds_fail_dent_indexing_lead_-_works/ https://www.ifa.com/articles/despite_brief_reprieve_2018_spi... As of the end of 2019, internationally active managers didn't do too well either: * https://dividendstrategy.ca/what-is-spiva/ https://dividendstrategy.ca/what-is-spiva/ This has been known to varying degrees since at least the 1970s: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Random_Walk_Down_Wall_Street https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Random_Walk_Down_Wall_Street
- throw0101a 6y ago> ISTM that the more people push on index funds, the more overvalued equities in the index become relative to those outside the index. What "index funds" are you referring to? The S&P 500? Dow Jones? NASDAQ 100? If you purchase a Russell 3000 index fund you are purchasing a piece in every publicly traded company in the US: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell_3000_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell_3000_Index Any 'pricing irregularities' are discovered, then they will be pounced on any few remaining active investors. I recommend you read up on the following: > So what would happen if the majority of investors started to buy the market and stopped trying to beat the market? > Mispricings would start to develop regularly, and the people that had continued to try and pick stocks would be able to profit. The profits that these people made would attract other people, and eventually everyone would return to chasing the dream of beating the market. Behavioral finance plays a huge role in market efficiency; nobody wants to accept being average by taking what the market gives them when there are hot shot managers that promise to consistently beat their benchmark. There is a lot more emotional attraction to investing with the guy, or to being the guy that can beat the market. * https://www.pwlcapital.com/the-grosman-stiglitz-paradox/ https://www.pwlcapital.com/the-grosman-stiglitz-paradox/ * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grossman-Stiglitz_Paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grossman-Stiglitz_Paradox
- loopz 6y agocurrency != value
- bluedevil2k 6y agoWhile I don’t agree with your skepticism, there is a fund who goes off that theory that an S&P 500 index fund would become top weighted, or that the companies that have shown the most past growth are more heavily weighted, instead of focusing on future growth. It’s RSP, and it holds equal positions in all 500 companies equally.
- gcb0 6y agoYou are correct in the analysis. But you missed the point that "it's a feature".
- imtringued 6y agoThat's a pretty poor argument. What would happen in a world where everyone invested actively? People would switch to index funds to beat them. In your world people would switch to active investing to beat the index funds.
- PascLeRasc 6y agoYour argument is exactly what Michael Green talks about [1]. The talk I linked is from January of this year and he basically predicted the exact crash we saw in February. Individual stocks were going up and down tracking the S&P 500 exactly, based on no news or any kind of information, just that they were in the S&P index. The price of the stock did not reflect the company's financials or outlook. We're about to see this when Tesla gets added to the S&P 500 - funds will be required to purchase Tesla stock at any price. The reason that I'm personally an index fund skeptic is that I like to understand what I'm invested in. If you look through the S&P 500 members, there's dozens to hundreds of companies basically no one's ever heard of, and companies that I personally don't see a big future in. If index funds didn't exist, why would I take $100 of Fifth Third Bancorp or TechnipFMC when I could get $100 of Apple or Slack instead? The former is what you get when you invest in the S&P, while the latter are products I use everyday, and I feel that I understand how they make money. If you hang around investing subreddits long enough, it starts to feel like everyone's parroting the same 5 sentences about expense ratios and diversification, with no analysis or critical thought put into what the actual investments are. [1] https://youtu.be/x-rJciYZmi0 https://youtu.be/x-rJciYZmi0
- paulclinger 6y ago> If index funds didn't exist, why would I take $100 of Fifth Third Bancorp or TechnipFMC when I could get $100 of Apple or Slack instead? Because you don't know which one will become the next Apple or Slack and will invest before they are valued as the next Apple or Slack benefiting from all their growth. Some of them will die, but the effect on the overall holdings will be small given their small size.
- mancerayder 6y agoI agree with the (downvoted) guy who said, I'm an index fund skeptic. Something is true with index funds that was less true historically, which is the concentration of a few large companies in the largest indexes - as in, the amount of percentage of capital they have. Fact, FAANG make up 10% of the s&p 500 index, tech makes up 20+ %. It's NOT at all averaged out in the way the Bogleheads might think it is. Is it a "bet on the economy," or is it a bet on the stocks of big tech? Which brings me to something else that appears to have changed: big tech stocks are viewed as a safe haven, increasingly. With the overall economy being in a shambles combined with a virtual work world, this is even more important. Put those two things together, and the S&P 500 index isn't diversified. Edit: we're at the top of the cycle right now, or so it seems. We're all waiting for the other shoe to drop. But it's worse. What happens if you stick everything in there, you need the money in 5 or 10 years and you just hit the bad part of the cycle (look what happened in March). I'm doing the opposite of what the Bogleheads do, even though I'm extremely familiar with this extremely conservative approach. What's the fun in risking my capital with some index fund that's tied to concentrated entities like that, when I can risk a small percentage of my capital on highly volatile stocks, and make a similar return? You can repeatedly swing trade stocks like SPCE and some of the biopharma stocks and make money over and over again with a tiny percentage of your capital. I'm more interested in understanding how the bond market will work now in this strange new reality. Are bonds not a safe haven place to park cash?
- hydroreadsstuff 6y agoThe historic worst case for the inflation-adjusted S&P 500 is not being up from 1929 - 1987 - 58 years. https://www.macrotrends.net/2324/sp-500-historical-chart-data https://www.macrotrends.net/2324/sp-500-historical-chart-dat... Edit: This ignores dividend reinvestment as ummonk noted. https://www.officialdata.org/us/stocks/s-p-500/1900 https://www.officialdata.org/us/stocks/s-p-500/1900 suggests 1929 - 1944 was probably the longest time. We are in unprecedented times. Highest debt, lowest bond yields, crazy P/Es, historic GDP drop (worst since 1929, or since WW2 for some). We don't yet know how inflation/deflation will play out. CPI is useless. A lot "inflation" is going into real estate / land and the stock market. I don't think past wisdom applies anymore. If you put money into most products (including most index funds) on the stock market today you are in fact stock-picking / gambling. Also tech companies are partially up for a good reason. Small caps have lost a lot earnings power. https://twitter.com/NorthmanTrader/status/1283353116973432832 https://twitter.com/NorthmanTrader/status/128335311697343283... Much much more than tech stocks. E.g. tech stocks were almost the only ones doing any buybacks last quarter. Stay-at-home companies, solid/value companies, and cheap stocks is where hedgefunds seem to move to. But yes, some valuations are bonkers. EV stocks, CVNA, W, ... Personally, I've been late to the party, and needed to learn on the fly, BUT: I now own a portion of gold and royalty and streaming companies (mining exposure with less risk of badly run mining companies. They lend money to miners in return for metal. I.e. miners don't need to worry about the price of the metal.) Mind that GLD and SLV are not fully backed by gold and silver. There is significant counter-party risk (E.g. if the bank goes bankrupt you might not receive anything). They also haven't really been audited, and JP Morgan employees have been charged for price manipulation of metals. I reduced my bond exposure, and I will probably soon move into gov bonds exclusively. I don't want to gamble on MBSs, CLOs, corporate bonds being bailed out. (The Fed and ECB's policies skew the bond market. Ratings and yields are (increasingly) not great indicators of company health). There is little room for lower yields. Real yields (bond yield - inflation) will turn negative or are already. When rates eventually will be hiked, both stocks and bonds will fall. (See 2019 / December 2019) I started stock picking. Mainly value, but really random stuff I find on Youtube investment channels and Reddit (Of course I read up on them, listen to financial calls. Balance sheet. Cash flow. Exposure to potential problems.). I sleep better at night with a cheaper stock that has less downside, even if it isn't riding the current trend/bubble. Other than that I'd keep a good amount of cash for potential opportunities. In the current climate, stocks could fall any week, real estate will likely be on sale (depending on how many rich people will try scoop it up at the same time), or perhaps you can buy a share in a local business.
- dpweb 6y agoStock indexes over the long term are a function of Corporate profits of the large companies and the inflationary nature of the economy, especially over the last 30 years, the willingness of the Federal reserve to print money (create debt). Without restraint nowadays. For instance, in 2020, the massive stimulus by the Fed almost certainly will create a rising stock market. It deviates of course in the short term 6-18 months, few years etc.. In short, if you go that route, buy on the 1-2 year dips. Invest would certainly be the way to go, although if you have a certain talent.. For instance, house flipping or starting a business. You can get better than the 5% or whatever you get after inflation in stocks. If you're really good at what you do, your odds of getting a better return go up.
- throw0101a 6y ago> the willingness of the Federal reserve to print money (create debt). Without restraint nowadays. Ben Felix, a portfolio manager at PWL Capital in Canada, just released a video explaining why this is completely wrong: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K3lP3BhvnSo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K3lP3BhvnSo > Quantitative easing is a monetary policy whereby a central bank buys government bonds or other financial assets in order to inject money into the economy to expand economic activity. But what exactly does that mean? In today’s episode, Benjamin and Cameron are going to address this topic, avoiding highly politicized aspects, like whether or not central banks should be involved in the economy in the first place, and focusing purely on the operational perspective of quantitative easing – what is it, how it works, and what the intended transmission mechanisms are. * https://rationalreminder.ca/podcast/109 https://rationalreminder.ca/podcast/109 > For instance, house flipping or starting a business. You can get better than the 5% or whatever you get after inflation in stocks. If you're really good at what you do, your odds of getting a better return go up. That's nice if you want a different/second career or something. But there are those of us who are happy with our careers/jobs, and simply want something to do with our retirement savings… ain't nobody got time for that. Of course the half-life on any new business is quite abysmal, so I'm not crazy/ambitious enough to take on that kind of risk.
- hydroreadsstuff 6y ago
- polote 6y ago> Even if you only invested in the peaks, you'd still do quite well over the decades: This is not true for a 10 years period though https://www.vizlit.com/finance/2020/07/01/sp-performance.html https://www.vizlit.com/finance/2020/07/01/sp-performance.htm... You might to add that even though in the past economic growth has always been the case, it doesn't mean it will always be the case, especially now that the energy consumption more or less reached a peak
- throw0101a 6y ago> This is not true for a 10 years period though That's for the S&P 500. How would have a portfolio using (say) the Russell 3000 have done? How about adding some international/EM component? What about a portfolio wish some bonds to control for volatility and allow for rebalancing? That is to say: does diversification help?
- throw0101a 6y ago> This is not true for a 10 years period though It was true in this ten-year period (2000-2009) if you rebalanced between VFINX (S&P) and VBMFX (bonds): * https://www.forbes.com/sites/investor/2010/12/17/the-lost-decade-was-a-golden-age-if-you-rebalanced/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/investor/2010/12/17/the-lost-de...
- baby 6y agoI hear this again and again, but something that went up throughout history is not a proof that it will continue to go up in our time. It's definitely highly likely, but it's not a certainty. A lot of people spread their investment in more than just the market to account for that.
- arcticbull 6y agoThere is one way you can beat dollar-cost averaging when you're investing large lump sums like this. Selling cash-covered put options until you get assigned. This is the only strategy that has proven to outperform buying and holding. The reason is obvious: you're buying at a discount if you get assigned, and you get to keep the premium if you don’t. Selling a put is basically being paid to put in a limit order.
- wocram 6y agoWhy do you think this is true? $PUTW is an ETF that implements the strategy and it has not done well in recent years.
- arcticbull 6y agoTo clarify, using put sells to enter into a position that you would otherwise have opened, today, to hold long-term with a is generally better than a market or limit order. As an income-generation strategy, selling put options is, on average, a moneymaker so long as realized volatility remains lower than implied volatility. That is typically the case, but of course, March flipped that on its head, and there's no "one" strategy. If you would have otherwise bought 100 shares of SPY on Friday, it would cost you $326.52 (x100, so $32650). If you sell 1 put option expiring 8/31 "at the money" (i.e. a $326P) you will receive a net credit of $7.20 per share today ($720). That money is yours at the moment you sell the put option, so if SPY closes at or above $326 on 8/31 (excluding early expiry), you've made $720 on $32600, or a one-month gain of 2.2%. That is an annualized return on your staked capital of 29%. You can then keep making an annualized 29% return every month until you get assigned (assuming IV rank remains stable). Alternatively, if SPY closes below $326, you've actually bought it for a $7.72 per share discount ($7.20 + $0.56), or $318.80 over what it's trading at right now. As you plan to buy and hold for the long run, you got a much better entry price than you would have with a market order. If you're planning to buy and hold today, it's hard to lose with selling a put to open. You either collect a nice premium, or you buy the shares at a discount. If your goal is to own the shares long term, you're feeling good either way. Make sense? What you could theoretically miss out on is a big run up from the moment you bought the shares in excess of the premium. You can get more aggressive too, and sell puts you don't think you'll get assigned on, at the highest price you'd be willing to pay for SPY and play the long game. Sell $300 8/31 puts for $2. There's a 80% chance you'll keep that premium, and it's an annualized 8.2% return on staked capital. Then if you get assigned it's actually a $28/share discount -- 8.5% -- below today's price.
- mattalbie 6y agoRelevant: Remembering John Bogle, patron saint of the amateur investor - https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2019/01/21/remembering-john-bogle-patron-saint-of-the-amateur-investor https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2019/01/21/r...