19 ms·
A College Degree Is No Guarantee of a Good Life
- melvinroest 6y agoI agree with this. In retrospect, a better path for me would've been (in The Netherlands): - Don't do pre-university in high school but prepare for "higher job education" in high school. Graduate at 17. - Do a "higher job education", speed it up (instead of 4 years do 3 years) and graduate at 20. Do some web dev/UX-based degree (they exist and speedups are possible, provided you're pro-active). - Get a job grind away for 3 to 5 years, learn about investing and invest most of the money. - If you want to go deeper in computer science, because the craft is beautiful then follow a master degree in security. I'd have missed out on a lot of spiritual/some social development that I wouldn't have gotten at "higher job education" but did get at uni (as I did that for 6 months, a different degree though). However, compared to that, I now have a career setback of 7 years.
- markus92 6y agoAssuming you're Dutch, but in the context of this article, HBO is college as well (the very clear distinction between applied universities and research universities doesn't exist in the Americas).
- melvinroest 6y agoAh, I didn't know! Thanks. And community college is MBO then I guess?
- markus92 6y agoYeah, pretty much.
- 082349872349872 6y agoA short (and hence inaccurate) overview of the apprenticeship system for the trades in my country: Apprentices start working one day a week and going to school four. They end up working four days a week and going to school one. Apprentices can switch to a more academic track, at a technical school or university, if they get the desire. When they finish with their apprenticeship, not only do they already have horizontal ties with their classmates, but they also have vertical ties with their business, its clients, and the master tradesmen who conducted the classroom component and oversaw the theoretical and practical exams.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>Apprentices start working one day a week and going to school four. They end up working four days a week and going to school one. It's brilliant. And is there any profession that can't be done this way?
- hocuspocus 6y agoWell you can't become a surgeon or a lawyer unless you switch a university track at some point. But you can definitely work in the medical or legal field by doing an apprenticeship first and moving on to a 2-3 year professional degree (for instance nurse school isn't college here).
- itsoktocry 6y ago>Well you can't become a surgeon or a lawyer unless you switch a university track at some point. "Can't" because those are the rules we've established. But both of those professions seem like they be perfect for apprenticeships (they were at one point in history). It's not like studying the literature isn't or can't be a part of apprenticeship curriculum.
- hocuspocus 6y agoYou could argue that med and law schools are pretty much trade schools, just long ones :) Unlike in the US where you first do 4 year of pre-med/pre-law, in continental Europe med and law students start learning on the job early.
- analog31 6y agoAny skilled trade that's highly dependent on outdoor work and physical labor, in the absence of free health care, economic safety net, and strong labor laws. I've dealt with a lot of trades people, and the ones who are my age (mid 50s) tend to be hobbling and broken. On the other hand I could see it work for things like the "lesser" health care trades such as dental hygienist.
- 6y ago
- hectorr1 6y agoMost successful people have X. Government: “Let’s give everyone X!” Over time the value of X is diluted, loses its status signaling, and overall quality degrades. Successful people move to Y.
- mac01021 6y agoThe big question is "what is Y in this case"?
- quietbritishjim 6y agoPerhaps a degree from one of the "best" colleges/universities in the country.
- nix23 6y agoMore like having the best connection's from the university/family/friends ;)
- quietbritishjim 6y agoI never said the degree was a benefit itself! Just that it might satisfy "Most successful people have X" (Although, here in the UK at least, the quality of degrees genuinely does vary by university in a way that roughly corresponds to their rankings. I know that's an unfashionable observable but I have seen enough degree programs at different universities to know it's likely true unless I happen to have seen an atonishingly unrepresentative sample. Partly this is self fulfilling because lower ranked universities are forced to take less good students and the level of the programme has to be adjusted accordingly, but part of it really is to do with quality of teaching.)
- C1sc0cat 6y agoIt does vary when I worked at BT, one of our students doing a year out had lectures from one of the people who built the Manchester Baby. On our team we had a guy from ENA and he was the son of a French diplomat and a British mother - we quickly learnt he did not need any hand holding.
- itsoktocry 6y agoColleges have become massive businesses whose purpose is to jam kids through to graduation (thus maximize tuition fees). Most kids don't really want to be there. Both parties are incentivized to "get through it". When a large number of young people have degrees obtained this way, is it any wonder the value is diminished? It's a shame, because I loved (and continue to love) higher education.
- atomflunder 6y agoIs it really true that, in the US, many college students don't want to be there but go nonetheless, despite having to pay absurd amounts of money? Where I study, uni is basically free, and I've met very few people in my degree who don't want to be there. This seems absurd to me.
- throwanem 6y agoMy relevant experience is twenty years stale, but I'd say yes, absolutely, there are a lot of people who go to college in the US despite not actually wanting to. I saw it in many of my high-school cohort, even as they expressed their grave concern to me about my evident disinterest in doing likewise. (It was an interesting kind of place, the high school where I graduated. Early in my time there, the first person who took me aside to ask why, despite evident intelligence, I seemed not to apply myself in class, was the head of the cheerleading squad.) If anything, I'd say the rate of people attending college despite not wanting to can only have increased since then. The assumption that college is an absolute necessity for a comfortable middle-class life has only in the last few years come into serious question, and still has yet to face anything like the inquisition it deserves.
- violetgarden 6y agoMaybe it’s half true. I wanted to be in college, and everyone I met was happy to be there. However, there is some anger at the feeling that you HAVE to be there. There is a lot of cultural pressure to get a higher education. I also remember feeling like I had to decide the rest of my life by choosing a degree, and that really stressed me out. However, I still really wanted to go to college. Yes, we tend to pay a lot to go to college, and yes, a lot of us feel like we must do it. A lot of choices factor into how much you pay - community college can reduce this, going to a lesser known school, etc. However, it’s an investment in yourself. For some of us, that investment works out really well. Others may struggle to get that awesome job after college.
- kamaal 6y agoLife is a long haul ride, requires a lot of things to get through it well. College education is obviously one part of it. It would help people to realize any thing one does has an expiry date to it. This is why you need to have a system to remain consistent at some broad goals. Things like good eating, exercise, personal finance, relationships, reading and learning have to be done consistently, and have to be done throughout your life. You won't be good at life, if you don't do some of things regardless of the age, and place you are in. The loss is in assuming College Degree as an aristocratic right. If you think this way you will soon realize there is nothing special about reading a few books between ages 18 - 22 and doing no learning after that for decades. To me primary purpose of education is initiation. College degree should be treated as a good head start as an initiation. Nothing more, Nothing less.
- mac01021 6y agoDoes it follow that you see basically no value in community colleges and other "low-prestige" public institutions whose participants are predominantly from outside of any aspirationally-aristocratic subculture?
- kamaal 6y agoOf course if you are rich you are always going to have means and mechanisms to connect with the peer rich. I'm guessing once you move out of Ivy leagues, you will always the board rooms and golf courses to continue your networking. I'm talking more on the lines of normal people, from normal families. For people like us, education means some thing very different. Its like initial exposure to an experience we must maintain all life.
- nicoburns 6y ago> Life is a long haul ride, requires a lot of things to get through it well. College education is obviously one part of it. I would disagree. College education is absolutely not required to get through life. And it should be required even less than it is. There are some professions for which degrees are super useful. But most people doing degrees are going into professions that just require any degree and could easily be done without one.
- technothrasher 6y agoThe four years I spent at my university were four of the best years of my life. I grew academically, socially, and career-wise in ways I just never would have without going to school. However, I have plenty of friends that never went to any higher education than high school, or who dropped out of college early on, and it's not like they're unsuccessful or maladjusted. It seems pretty clear that different paths work for different people.
- non-entity 6y agoYeah, as much as I hate the university as an institution, they're still necessary for a large amount of people (in practice) These threads tend to be filled with comments that assume everyone is a developer and / or should be. Unfortunately many, if not most high paying jobs will still require higher education, particularly the stereotypically well paying ones. You aren't going to become a doctor, engineer (non software), lawyer, etc. without that degree unfortunately.
- technothrasher 6y agoWhat you say is true, but there are plenty of smart people who start in the trades and then leverage their way up to making millions in business for themselves. When I said I had plenty of friends who were successful without a college degree, I was specifically thinking of auto mechanics. While I'm the typical "developer" type you reference, my main hobby is classic sports cars (which started during my time at college, coincidentally). From that hobby I know quite a few "high school only" folks who are now independently wealthy and fully satisfied with their lives, from building up automotive businesses.
- randomdata 6y ago> Unfortunately many, if not most high paying jobs will still require higher education, particularly the stereotypically well paying ones. Not just any higher education, though, but specific professional degrees that grant access to supply managed markets. That part seems to be often missed when this topic comes up. I recall a Gallup study into the top 1% finding that something like 70% of the top 1% have a professional degrees (doctors, lawyers, etc.). The remaining portion was comprised of more people with high school or less than those with only a bachelor degree, suggesting that a bachelor degree alone does nothing to improve your prospects. Which goes against the common thinking. But is also echoed in the general economy. With the rise of post-secondary attainment, incomes have held stagnant. If there was a financial advantage gained though higher education itself, not through supply management, incomes would be rising.
- mac01021 6y agoThe article spends a little time, in the middle on the headline assertion "College does not guarantee Happiness" But spends more time on an anecdote about the author's son to demonstrate that "Happiness is possible without College", which is a different matter entirely. And one would hope the latter is true, since 2/3 of the US population does not attend college.
- throwanem 6y agoHard to blame a third-generation academic for being surprised that happiness is possible without college.
- astura 6y agoI agree. This article is very light on content and I'm kinda surprised something this banal and content-less even made it to an actual publication. Also, the guy's son graduated high school two years ago, he's 20-21 years old, practically everyone is happy at that age, let's hear about his life satisfaction at 40. That's ignoring the fact that two years is hardly enough time to evaluate the long term outcome of a major life decision. To be clear, I don't think the author's son will grow up to be miserable, like the parent pointed out, most people don't have a college degree and most people aren't miserable. But this should be obvious.
- mac01021 6y agoBut then "It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied; better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied. And if the fool, or the pig, is of a different opinion, it is only because they only know their own side of the question." -- J S Mill
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- projektfu 6y agoI think as time goes on, I am learning that humans are dissatisfied because they no longer know how to live the life of a human, where (wild) pigs are fully capable of living the life of a pig. The big eye-opener for me was "The Story of B", by Daniel Quinn. Say what you want about the completeness or quality of its anthropology, it has touched on an ineffable fact that we are constantly trying to use more of what is bad for us to try to make it good.
- Pete-Codes 6y agoIf you are facing minimum of £27k tuition debt in England which AFAIK gathers interest from day one I would probably skip it. And it's even worse in the US. As far as webdev goes, you could do a bootcamp and be earning money within 6 months to a year. That's money that's hopefully going into your pension fund and earning interest while your peers are still in class. Or you could learn to code using cheap and/or free resources. College isn't the only place to learn things nowadays and I think a lot of people haven't caught up with that yet. I used to think nothing could beat the college experience for bonding but I think the formula of lots of people doing the same thing every day in a niche environment they want to be in is easily repeatable. I'm still in contact with digital nomads I hung out with in Bansko two years ago and I was only there for a month. But it was an intense month of seeing each other every day, just like college. Oh and don't worry about not finding a dev job if you don't go to college. Employers are coming around slowly and there are lots of success stories out there: www.nocsdegree.com
- Pete-Codes 6y agoOh and this article could have been written 15 years ago.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agothink of the money they could have made writing the article 15 years ago, and then selling it with a few word changes and a new title every year. Is a College Degree Worth It? College Degrees are no longer worth it! College Degrees - not worth the paper they're printed on. A College Degree - what does it really get you? And so on and so forth.
- wun0ne 6y ago100% this. If bootcamps were a valid pathway into the profession at the time after I left high school I definitely would have foregone my Computer Science degree and gone down that route. I'm glad attitudes towards them have shifted in the last few years - most of my friends in the profession work in companies that actively seek out applicants from bootcamps.
- 6y ago
- s1t5 6y agoI mean of course it isn't - no single aspect of your life will guarantee happiness or a good life.
- naveen_ 6y agoYes.. But it's definitely far better than not having a college degree!!!
- omginternets 6y agoI barely skimmed the article, but I don't find this surprising for a few reasons (some of which have been mentioned elsewhere in the comments): - "University degree" is a heterogeneous thing. While there is such thing as non-economic value, the strictly economic value of a college education tends to cluster around a small subset of degrees. - Many countries have enacted policies to increase proportion of people who get degrees. Far from fixing inequality, this has instead diluted the value of university degrees. - All universities are not created equal. While it is possible (and even common) for employers to pay too much attention to the reputation of the school, it is also quite common for students to over-estimate the value of a no-name institution. I've found this to be moreso the case in the two European countries I've lived in for an extended period of time (France & England). - The exorbitant debt incurred by university tuition in some countries (which need not be named, I think) means the ROI on the university degree has to also be exorbitant. Have I missed anything?
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> Far from fixing inequality Was this the purpose? I thought it was to raise living standards by improving productivity. By and large, broader education has been successful at that. (It went off the deep end, in recent years, with the proliferation of bullshit degrees.)
- csharptwdec19 6y agoI think you covered part of the problem in the second half of your statement. In the US, part of the problem is that by making education debts non-dischargable in bankruptcy, and by the aforementioned proliferation of degrees that may qualify as 'nice to have' rather than 'increase earning potential'. The end result is a lot of people who got a college degree that doesn't really pay for itself, and instead leads to 20+ years of debt, or 10 years of indentured servitude to a non-profit.
- bhupy 6y agoMaking education debts dischargeable in bankruptcy sounds good in theory, but against what collateral do you take out a college loan? Most bankruptcy includes collateral liquidation. What's to stop someone from obtaining a useless degree that doesn't contribute to the nation's economy, and then discharges the debt in bankruptcy? I think a big part of the problem is that debt is so readily issued for degrees that overwhelmingly leave the recipient incapable of providing for society in gainful ways.
- cafard 6y agoCollege was a lot less expensive when I went many years ago. However, I suppose that if I had sunk what I and my family spent on it into local real estate, I could have made more money over the years. I have regrets about college--I wish I had taken more math, I wish I had studied more foreign languages--but none of the regrets are financial.
- shahbaby 6y agoIn the CS field, the low hanging fruit is often worth more than the harder stuff. It's all about show and very little about substance. Building a flashy web app and studying for interviews will get you further than anything you learn in school.
- onetimemanytime 6y agoIn summary: many people go to expensive colleges and don't live a good life. On other hand, many people don't go to colleges but live a good life. That's all.
- imgabe 6y agoNothing is a guarantee of a good life. It seems like people think you should be able to just check a few boxes, then slot into a 9-5 and have everything taken care of for you for the rest of your life. Well, it doesn't work like that. Even after college you're still going to have to plan and think and take action to make things happen for you. It's not just all going to fall into your lap because you took a few classes in your early 20s.
- francisofascii 6y agoTo be fair, it used to work like that in America. Graduate high school, get a decent paying union job in your hometown with an okay house to raise a family. Drink beer and watch sports on the weekends with neighborhood buddies. Work 30-40 years and retire.
- foobiekr 6y agoEven on the relatively short timeline of the history of the US, the period you’re referring to was quite short.
- sokoloff 6y agoWhich was launched and substantially overlapped with a period where the US was the largest export manufacturing base left standing and where massive rebuilding was needed on more than one continent. I hope to not experience a repeat of those initial conditions.
- francisofascii 6y agoWith the huge increases in productivity since the 1950's, people should be working less hours than in 1950. I don't have a good reason why this should be an anomaly in history.
- geodel 6y agoSure, if one is willing to stay at 50's living standard. Trouble is what used to be luxury then is now basic necessity and "everyone" must have it.
- ptero 6y agoThe article seemed underwhelming to me. TLDR: college doesn't guarantee future happiness (uhm, what does guarantee it?) some kids would be happier just going to work. That's fair, but while some kids would thrive going to work after college many more would be hampered by a lack of a college education for the rest of their lives. Probably US specific but, in most schools, education sucks and all good colleges (not just super expensive; state schools, too) offer a solid STEM background to fix the damage after lousy schools. College should not be necessary, but in the US it kind of is. So to make college optional, fix schools: reduce hours and drudgery, focus on consistent STEM background, give extra support to kids that excel in a subjext. My 2c.
- batt4good 6y agoYeah, no sh*t. Assuming you went to college for a marketable and "valuable" degree - by this, I mean a degree with a clear path to a somewhat stable career. Usually, if you don't have internships you've already shot yourself in the foot. Plenty of people with family money and college still find ways to go bankrupt from addiction, real-estate woes or bad investments. Some just don't care enough or have enough drive to be "successful". Some who find success get involved with the wrong people, or think their source of money is an endless fountain and go broke or worse end up on the street. Goodness do journalists write for simpletons these days...
- vladletter 6y agoWell, this article may target white people. You can do a bootc amp and be paid. When you're part of a minority, you need a college degree to live.
- culopatin 6y agoCan you expand on this? I'm a minority with no degree and I'm curious about your perspective.
- dgb23 6y agoI think it is conventional knowledge that if you are a minority you are often forced to overcome discrimination and are being judged more harshly. I mostly second-hand experienced this because half of my family are immigrants from a country that had "low-status" when they got here. Just to be sure: if you are young/new please don't take this as discouragement. The less it applies to you the better. And if you face discrimination then take pride in your accomplishments in spite of adversity. But I find OP's assessment overly specific...
- frockington1 6y agoBased on my experience its the opposite. If you are a female minority, large companies will pay you to attend a bootcamp and join them. There are so many great opportunities out there for people from all sorts of backgrounds
- game_the0ry 6y agoNo one really goes to college and grad school to learn. Higher ed is commoditized as a: * insurance policy, where students use it to avoid limiting themselves to low-status and low-paying careers * lottery ticket, the gateway to a "prestige" career track [1] * status signaling mechanism, where young people flex their educational elitism [2] And higher ed is arguably bad at what its supposed be good at - a delivery mechanism of relevant knowledge. If you have ever interviewed a fresh grad who didn't study "Cracking the Coding Interview" or did not have a few "side projects" under their belt, then you know what I am talking about.[3] The internet is the most effective information distribution delivery and it's much cheaper, no wonder the value of college is in question. [1] Consulting, finance, corporate middle management, grad school [2] How many times have you been on a date and you tell or ask the other person where they wen to college, what they majored in, etc [3] Arguably, the standard that hiring managers set for new grads is too high. Perhaps it's the employer that should be training fresh grads, but that is not how the current job market works. I think about this a lot because it causes problems for both young people and employers.
- throwawaygh 6y ago> If you have ever interviewed a fresh grad who didn't study "Cracking the Coding Interview" Goodhart's Law. > or did not have a few "side projects" under their belt IME: end-of-course projects at places like MIT and Carneige Mellon are often much more impressive than the CRUD web app or copy-pasta Jupyter notebooks I tend to see from e.g. coding bootcamps or especially self-taught applicants. And students usually have a half dozen or more of those, in addition to internship projects. Sometimes a self-taught person comes along with a genuinely impressive project, and I push hard to hire those folks. But for the most part it's silly little single-person-project web apps and such. > The internet is the most effective information distribution delivery and it's much cheaper, no wonder the value of college is in question. The questioning only really has a loud voice in places like the USA with horrendously expensive higher ed systems. I don't really hear a lot of griping about the cost of education or opining on internet alternatives when I'm in Munich or Vienna.
- flyingfences 6y ago
- rayiner 6y agoIt shouldn’t be!
- unixhero 6y agoKnowing what you're worth. Charging accordingly. Don't work for middle men, get direct clients. Make friends Help people Oh and study
- minicoz 6y agoHow to get direct clients? Id love to go C2C but finding clients seems really hard.
- qzx_pierri 6y agoIt is if you major in STEM (and you apply yourself and get internships, etc) - Majoring in "Eastern Gender Studies" will likely waste 4 years of your life.
- organicfigs 6y agoAs someone with a STEM degree who enjoyed taking online classes at a CC during their 20s in Art History, I wouldn't call it a waste of time; it's brought me more joy, balance, and a feeling of well-roundedness than I had contributing to os projects.
- qzx_pierri 6y agoWhat about a stable salary? In all seriousness, I agree with you. However, I think some degrees are borderline "hobby-tier" - They're cool, but not very useful outside of personal enjoyment.
- minicoz 6y agoTrue, I believe it does lead to a well rounded individual to study the arts and humanities, but with the cost of a college degree, the ROI on those courses ($900 per course) is not worth the investment. applied STEM will pay off for the investment. I still take college courses online after my Masters in CS. I really enjoy learning about humanities and arts at a cheaper CC during my free time.
- biophysboy 6y agoI've always wondered - is there a way that we can decouple liberal education from technical skill building in the US university system? Because I absolutely agree that people crave and need the joy and balance that you describe, but currently its being held hostage to the price of at least 10k a year! Its so sad, I would kill for affordable, offline liberal education. The instructor doesn't even need to be elite (in fact I would prefer that she/he were not!), they just need to have a cool format.
- non-entity 6y agoEven only a subset of STEM is "useful" from what I've seen. Particularly in the science part there's just so few jobs and such high education requirements.
- atlgator 6y agoThis would have been a hot take if they published it 10 years ago. Now it's old news.
- Upvoter33 6y agoNothing is a guarantee of a good life. A good life requires so many different elements, but mostly comes down to one thing: what you put into it, esp. in regards to improving the lives and welfare of others around you. Do this, and you will find that your own life gets better and better. Be kind, do work to help others, care about people and their lives (and not just your own) and you'll find that life will turn out pretty darn fine.
- kleer001 6y agoExactly: https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/233578 https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/233578 "The only major personality trait that consistently leads to success is conscientiousness."
- chosenbreed37 6y agoI don't think contentiousness is the same thing described in that post. But I agree that it is an excellent trait to have.
- kleer001 6y agoIt's not. Conscientious is a very specific set of behaviours. I was offering an easy answer to the confused wondering of the Atlantic article. The path to success is known. Apparently not as well known as I would have thought. No need to point to the fact that the heterogeneous mess of a "College Degree" as being not a factor. Yes, there's lots of ways to not succeed. Why not do a very little bit of shallow research and shout out to the roof tops what actually does work?!
- rbanffy 6y agoA good ZIP code is a great start. https://talkpoverty.org/2015/12/17/american-dream-zip-codes-affordable-housing/ https://talkpoverty.org/2015/12/17/american-dream-zip-codes-...
- DiffEq 6y ago
- Proven 6y agoMy guesstimate is more than 50% become socialists. There's nothing worse than can happen to a student. Those individuals are practically doomed and guaranteed to have a worse life than those who didn't go.
- nu_throwaway 6y agothis sort of reads as self re-assurement for his son's path; the author is a Harvard professor and I assume daily interaction in academia all revolves around how great and virtuous higher ed is yet he's bucked the trend. perhaps if he truly feels that way he could leave academia and cease perpetuating the myth? imo calling it an "investment" is part of the problem. its a pure sunk cost and not an asset.
- oneplane 6y agoPeople call it an investment because they think: I put something in it with the goal of getting more out of it in total. They don't see it as finance terminology and the concept of the word investment in the context of others like 'sunk cost' and 'asset' holds very little specific meaning in that case. Ironically that is a 'problem' you can 'fix' by putting people in college and teaching them basic accounting.
- nu_throwaway 6y agoid argue that with an investment you can compare like to like alternatives and can use a greater degree of objectivity. there are far more variables to consider in higher ed (student loan debt, opportunity cost of time, unemployment, alternative education experiences, etc) so looking at it as an outflow of cash with a predictable return is misleading at best. no college has a monopoly on information and there is no proprietary info gained (other than network from elite schools). in a sense the knowledge component of a degree can only approach a value of zero as time goes on. the experience aspect is of course subjective and very important to some.
- oneplane 6y agoAnd that's why people use the word 'investment' without knowing the meaning of the word.
- bananaface 6y agoYou'd fix it by banning non-dischargeable loans (and potentially making Universities guarantee the loans so they're actually responsible for the candidates they shit out without prospects). It's incredibly predatory to lure people who by definition don't know that much about the world yet (let alone finance) to take on six figures of debt for something that the investors know in a lot of cases won't pay for itself. It's usury. As an outsider, the fact the US allows it reeks of political corruption.
- pfarnsworth 6y agoConsidering how expensive college is in the US, I'm actively considering alternate options for my kids. It doesn't make sense to turn them into debt slaves and get into hundreds of thousands in debt just to get a job.
- DeonPenny 6y agoIt shouldn't be. I never understood this idea. Because no one really says this, and you especially don't have an excuse to believe this now. Why would you subsidize a path in life making people in some cases worse.
- tenderfault 6y agoand No college degree is a guarantee for a Bad life. nothing hurts us more than the lack of (higher) education. kids, stay in school.
- cinntaile 6y agoThere are plenty of people without a college degree that have a good life. This disproves that it's a guarantee for a bad life.
- gamechangr 6y agoThat's exactly the kind of thinking that makes this discussion interesting. Why do you hold that view?
- ldad 6y ago...Breaking News
- annoyingnoob 6y agoIf you turn that statement around the same is true. You can have a 'Good Life' without a college degree too. From my perspective, its more about what you can produce on an on-going basis than any certificates that you hang on the wall.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoI had a mate who did this in the UK joined the army but he said he enjoyed his time in the "Mob" but eventually you have to get a job that pays a real wage. It is one way of getting training - and if you say went into the right MOS cyber etc get to Master Sargent E8 you could then get a good job outside.
- taobility 6y agoThere is no degree can guarantee a good life. But college degree can increase dramatically for that possibility.
- zuhayeer 6y ago"Some kids think they know what they want to do after college, but others don’t, so for them college is like buying an expensive insurance policy" Expensive is an understatement. At the same time, being unsure of what you want to do before college is what makes it a great place to sow the seeds for what you do in life. Funnily enough that happens mostly outside of class through people you meet and projects you work on. Since the physical aspect of college is in question this upcoming year, I feel that it isn't worth it. You can probably do a lot of school without actually paying tuition, and find new ways to meet people and work on projects.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI passed up a National Merit Scholarship that would have let me go away to school and attend one of the big two colleges in my home state. Instead, I attended a local college for two years, living at my parents, taking whatever federal grant money was available and my parents covered the rest, in part because going to the local college kept tuition and other expenses reasonable. (I'm 55. Tuition has changed in the decades since and this approach might no longer work. It did at the time.) I then dropped out without a degree and did the military wife thing for a lot of years. I returned to school when I knew what I wanted to do, career-wise. I made that decision in part because I was personally acquainted with two people who each had a bachelor's degree (and more schooling beyond that -- one was two quarters short of a master's and the other was working on his second bachelor's) and were financially dependent on someone else while they delivered newspapers (one also spent some time selling shoes and he eventually killed himself). One was in his thirties and living with his mother. The other was mooching off a wife at the time who eventually left him. So I was never fooled into believing that a college degree guarantees you a successful professional career. I felt I could deliver newspapers for a living without a college degree and I would be better off if I had such a job without being saddled with college debts like at least one of these two men was. I don't regret my decision. Given the details of my life, I think I made the right choice. We need to do a better job of educating young people about when it makes sense to go to school. Far too many people seem to think a degree is a magic wand and don't understand what else needs to happen to establish a career, especially one that pays well enough to justify taking on student debt.
- supernova87a 6y agoWait, if you're 55 now, you grew up in basically the golden age of US growth and the easy value of a college degree at relatively cheap tuition. And you had friends back then who were saddled with college debt that led to dead end jobs? The situation, is way, way worse now. Orders of magnitude worse.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoYes, I know. That's why I added the qualifier I did: I'm aware that not stating I did this decades ago could be misconstrued as saying "You fools just need to live at home and go to the local college. Problem solved!" I'm not interested in being thusly misconstrued.
- mindvirus 6y agoThere's so much potential in a better university/college. Imagine that in society we pooled our resources to make the best video/online courses for a variety of subjects. The best CS courses. The best history courses. The best biology courses. We could focus on making the courses accessible and translated. We could make the best assignments and projects, iterated and experimented on with a population of millions. Heck, we could even hire professional actors that would both help with engagement and with representation problems in various fields. Then in addition to being places of research, universities become the places we go to facilitate taking those courses and applying the knowledge. Watch the interactive videos, and expert tutors help you understand challenging topics, guide you where to look next, and facilitate labs. At least for undergraduate, this seems much better than what we have now. And then, why not open it up to everyone? We could all take various courses throughout our lives. I'd love to be continuously taking classes in new fields, but the world isn't set up that way.
- rajlego 6y agoBeautiful idea. Courses that improve over time iterated on research would be amazing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- robotresearcher 6y agoImagine we collected the best material in written, bound volumes. And nearly every city had a large collection you could borrow from for free. We did. The professors of history, psychology, art, biology, math, - everything - at the world's greatest universities very often write down what they know in books. We achieved this already. You can read Feynman's course on physics tonight. Your city library probably has it.
- mindvirus 6y agoAbsolutely, and that's something I'm very grateful for! One of the things I love the most about where I live is the excellent library system, and I have taken a ton of advantage of it. That said, it's not always the best for serious self study, since often books lack answer keys or worked solutions. I'm not proposing distance ed. I'm proposing that we shape education around automating the rote things, in particular delivering lectures. I don't think the main benefit of being on campus is the lectures or coming up with assignments, instead (as another comment noted) it's the peers and the people you interact with and how they help you learn. And so by automating away the rote part of it and focusing on the creative (research, TAing, peer interaction), it seems like we should be able to create better outcomes.
- peter303 6y agoI couldnt wait to escape the pre-internet dreariness of suburbia and attend college (MIT).
- mcguire 6y ago"Higher education is often described as an investment. But it’s still unclear if it pays off in happiness." Nothing, nothing will guarantee happiness. Or a good life. Make the best decisions you can, by which I mean try to make decisions that you will not regret later. (Have I made a crap-ton of mistakes in my life? Sure 'nuff. Would I make different decisions if I could, even knowing what I know now? Probably not.) And for the love of Pete, stop denigrating those who have made different choices. Sure, it may make you feel better about your situation temporarily, but it is very, very unappealing.
- d4mi3n 6y ago> Make the best decisions you can, by which I mean try to make decisions that you will not regret later. (Have I made a crap-ton of mistakes in my life? Sure 'nuff. Would I make different decisions if I could, even knowing what I know now? Probably not.) I can't agree with this enough, and it's a very powerful mindset. As a personal example, there was some point in my mid/late 20s where how I made decisions changed. Less of "will I regret doing this" and more "will I regret NOT doing this". It's amazing how much happier and content with my life I was when I removed speculative regret (what if..?) in favor of actual regret. Turned out I regretted a lot less and enjoyed much more when I actually got out and did.
- mcguire 6y agoWhen you are young, you have a lot of options that you will almost certainly regret later, when you realize that they have closed off other options.
- arcticbull 6y agoI find the idea of a "guarantee of a good life" very strange, and super myopic. There are no guarantees in life, everything is probabilistic. Based on other people's outcomes you can do your best to infer which decisions increase the likelihood of your desired outcome. Want to be rich? I can't guarantee that -- though I would say give what other self-made rich people did a go: move somewhere where you're in the path of money, with other like-minded people.
- 6y ago
- darepublic 6y agoThanks for telling me something I discovered half way through my university studies.
- bena 6y agoThere are things that can increase the chances of "a good life". There is nothing that can guarantee it. Pocket aces increase your chance of winning a hand, but it doesn't guarantee you win. So while a college degree is not a guarantee, the question is whether or not it increases your chances. Because if it does, you can combine it with other things that also increase your chances to give yourself the best shot. I mean, it is possible to sit infinite monkeys at infinite typewriters and get Shakespeare. Doesn't mean it's a good strategy. Now, if college is unavailable to someone for whatever reason, it is good to know that a good life isn't dependent on getting a college degree. You can focus harder on other positive indicators. But if we're going to dismiss everything that isn't a sure thing, we're going to be just dismissing everything.
- vaidhy 6y agoI have been reading through the comments and I am very curious about a few things - 1. What "bullshit" degrees people are talking about? Are they the liberal arts studies? If so, as a society do we not see value in the fine arts? Expertise in music, language, anthropology, history, etc do not necessarily lead to a well-paying job.. but they give intellectually satisfaction in and of itself. 2. IMHO, the pay you are likely to earn should never be a judge of value of a degree. A degree gives you an opportunity to learn something in depth. As long as you are able to reach that, the degree is valuable. The sad part of being in US (and other places) is that the depth is not valued. Trying college fees to ability to earn is an incorrect optimization. 3. If I were a poet, an author or a painter, do you think I should expect that I will be able to pursue my passion on a nominal pay (maybe as a teacher/tutor, basic income from government etc)? Most of the "golden age of civilizations" had this property. When everyone needs to fight for survival, that reflects poorly on the state of things and it is more of a dog eat dog world.
- AnimalMuppet 6y ago"This knowledge is valuable in itself. It will make you a better, more well-rounded person, who has a richer life." That's a completely reasonable statement. "This degree is valuable economically. It will lead to you having a well-paying job that will lead to you being economically successful". For many degrees, that statement is false. The problem is that, when we talk about the value of a college education, much of the time we're talking about the second statement. But that statement is true only of some degrees, not of all of them. Is the first statement still true? Sure. But is it true enough to be worth going deeply into debt for, without an economic payback for the degree? That's much harder to claim. And many people think that they're getting the second benefit from a degree when they're getting a degree that only provides the first, and they feel like they didn't get what was promised.
- michaelchisari 6y agoA degree used to show someone was capable of learning more advanced topics. Companies hired broadly regardless of major and trained for the tasks needed. Degrees as having economic "worth" comes from the shift away from career training and apprenticeship and towards an expectation of readily available career skills (and unpaid internships, a related issue).
- Lammy 6y agoCollege degrees only became a so-called "requirement" for a good life in America around 1970 as a way to maintain racial segregation as a response to all the civil rights legislation in the '60s :/
- stosto88 6y agoIt is close if you get a CS, Engineering or business degree.
- prewett 6y agoI'm not sure where this goes in the threads and discussion, but this historian has a really nice article on the importance of the humanities. Unlike science and technology, the humanities don't have an obvious ROI, especially when you have to pay large sums of money, and I think he does a good job of illustrating the value the humanities bring and possible consequences we are seeing in our own society of not valuing them. https://acoup.blog/2020/07/03/collections-the-practical-case-on-why-we-need-the-humanities/ https://acoup.blog/2020/07/03/collections-the-practical-case... (And thank-you to whoever first posted a link to this guy's blog to HN, it's really good, and I'm not even all that into history of warfare.)
- throw7 6y agoIf you want a _good_ life, DO something you are GOOD at. That really is all there is to it. People recognize value and, guess what, they'll gladly _pay_ you for your skill. Happiness is up to you. The only thing I'd send your way to think about: "In order to get love, you have to give love."
- makz 6y agoTo be fair, nothing ever is a guarantee of anything.
- zalkota 6y agoThe only degrees worth going to school for are STEM.