13 ms·
The frustration of trying to invest in my hometown
- thinkloop 6y agoIf a building has tenants it's straightforward to value it, no need for comps or sqft calculations.
- dillonmckay 6y agoHow long are those tenants planning to stay?
- thinkloop 6y agoCheck their leases, apply a vacancy rate of 5%-15% depending on history or estimation.
- MattGaiser 6y agoAssuming no major repairs required.
- thinkloop 6y agoRepairs are estimate'able and often increase the value of a building by allowing for the increase of rent making the current leases a floor of value. The roi is relatively straightforward. Buildings are some of the simplest assets.
- mjevans 6y agoTech isn't really a solution to this problem, but maybe some outside of the box thinking could setup a newer framework that would help. If private lending doesn't want to back this project, even if there isn't 'strong competition' (at least 5 lenders willing to accept the land within a city as collateral), then the government (whichever layer values the land the highest) should be willing to be a buyer at that value and that should be the collateral for a loan at median market rate. Automating that process and making it easier for consumers to check that data is a natural fit for tech.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wjnc 6y agoProper valuation of real estate takes into account the future: usually 15+ years of rental income, maintenance cost, interest on loans, vacancies and churn, the development of surrounding areas in that period and then as a clincher: the future value that the building can be sold for. The underlying principle of any valuation is that there is "At Least One" potential buyer. That makes valuation of real estate an art. Say in a downturn when nobody is buying, the value is suddenly non existent. Valuers have solved that by the "At Least One" criterium: you just value in the fiction that there is always a buyer. I've been involved in several dozen valuations from a risk management perspective and that is the one thing that stuck by me. The downside risk of no liquidity is not in the valuation. What does this lead to? A value of zero in case of tenants is highly unlikely unless there are some large cost are modelled. If there are a lot of vacant properties with zero current value, that might lead to all values being depressed. If in the set are buildings with high future maintenance cost modelled, the value of the set could become zero. Perhaps the bank didn't want the risk of all eight properties at the same time and he should have moved step by step: first buy and redevelop the buildings with tenants, only then to expand and get leverage while building on an existing portfolio. That is the way real estate fortunes are made where I live. Get a building, make condos, fill them, show a positive cashflow and add leverage. Rinse and repeat. With rental income in 5%+ and interest moving to 1% it has been a few lucky decades for those involved. The statistics mentioned between loaning in white and black communities are quite stark. However, to give some more perspective from the lender. A low interest rate signals even smaller risk appetite for the lender. If there ever was room for defaults in portfolios, there is none at interest rates < 1%. It just kills your business to have any one customer fail on payments or worse needing auctioning off. I guess he could easily get crowdsourcing or private investment at 25% of needed capital with his story if he did 75% downpayment at 4%. But that would kill his part of the business case. I would agree that this risk management view could blow up inherent biases in the way valuation work.
- giorgioz 6y agoI'm deeply sorry to hear that he's great endeavor to do well by doing good is being blocked. This is not an apology to the systematic racism that prevents the entreprenur Brian Rice to get a loan. He's right to make his personal struggle known and try to improve the system. This said and given I'm a single founder of a boostrapped startup: is there anyway he could bootstrap his project and do that in a smaller scale without funding? As I said before it's terrible to force him to do so, but at least if he does bootstrap and succeed and many do the same one day some of them will be banks/VC and will remember the inequality they suffered and they will not push it further to others.
- bbarnett 6y agoThis could be a chicken and egg problem, too. Banks lend on statistics, just as insurance companies have rates based upon the same. And insurance companies, for the most part, can assign rates based upon average accident rates, for identifiable traits. Like one's sex. Or where they live (a common way to get statistics without 'race/colour'). So what do I mean by the chicken and the egg, here? Well, imagine that black landowners go bankrupt more often. And sadly, this could be because black landowners go bankrupt more often! If a specific statistical classification indicates more bankruptcy, then it becomes true. For example, bank $a is bold enough to lend to someone whom they view as, statistically, more likely to fail. Then.. a few years later? That person needs a fiscal injection. Were that person not black, it would be easier to get funding at a time of need. However, since that person is? Well, then they get more denials, go bankrupt, and add to the proof that "statistically, more black people go bankrupt". Or as the banks are likely doing it, "the area where people live in". In other words, unless you can make EVERYONE, 100% not deny based upon an statistical models? Race/gender/sexual orientation/sex/where they live, etc, etc? Anyone, like bank $a lending outside of those models, will be lending to people less able to find additional assistance when/if the time comes. Chicken and egg. It's not right, but I view this a little bit like certain regulations, where corporations can't compete against other corporations which 'cut corners', so we have to mandate all corps behave in a certain manner to level the playing field.
- macspoofing 6y agoThere is no 'chicken and egg' problem. Banks don't use race as criteria for loans, just as auto insurance companies don't use race as criteria for setting rates. I also find perspectives like yours very perplexing. Debt is not charity. It is not charitable to provide debt to someone who cannot afford it. Not for the debtor, nor the lender. I've seen people suffer for years drowning in debt they could not afford. I've seen people with mortgages (variable rates in foreign currency) that went underwater when the rates and currency exchange shifted the wrong way. Bankruptcy is an incredibly painful process to go through as well. Debt is not charity. Banks also do not just give out big loans (no matter what your credit score is) unless there is collateral. It is clear as day, that the bank valued the collateral to be low or inconsequential (i.e. judged one property at land-value at $1/sqft and $0 for the building). So there was no collateral for those loans, because redevelopment of those properties was expensive, with lots of risk. Why do you think it hasn't happened yet? Why do you think these properties were standing there rotting away? Why didn't anybody take a flyer on those, given how inexpensive these properties probably are? Because there are major risks associated with redevelopment. In our city, a property, seemingly in a prime location, stood abandoned for years .. turns out, the property was cheap, the land was cheap, the environmental cleanup necessary for redevelopment, was not. >Were that person not black, it would be easier to get funding at a time of need Says who!? Have you actually tried? Our company was only extended a line of credit years after we were in business, and it was collateralized against purchase orders and revenue (and we had to provide lots of documentation to prove those). Banks do not want to give out loans with even a little bit of risk associated. They are not like venture capital firms and haven't been for a long time.
- projektfu 6y agoIt’s especially frustrating when you see how banks will fund SBA projects for fad businesses like cupcake bakeries that are unlikely to be in business in 5 years. By then, the bank has made its profit and can dump the loan on the government.
- lazyjones 6y agoWhy is this frustrating? The banks make a profit this way, just like you described. They are not public services. Banks that operate with alleged "systemic racism" are bound to lose out on profits to banks that don't, therefore the case for it isn't very strong in this situation.
- papaf 6y agoThey are not public services. And yet the public does bail them out which suggests a symbiotic relationship with the economy and that banks have some responsibility to the greater whole.
- lazyjones 6y ago> yet the public does bail them out Involuntarily, due to corruption of public officials. Don't read too much into it. There have been some attempts to run banks in an "altruistic" manner. I don't know of a successful one, just failures.
- hannasanarion 6y agoCorruption has nothing to do with it. Giving extra aid to the people on top while ignoring the people who are struggling is ideology, not corruption.
- Apocryphon 6y agoThey are all around you. They are called credit unions and community banks.
- dlkf 6y ago
- yardie 6y agoThe way the US property market works just completely blows my mind. Even with federal regulation there is a lot of racism inherently built into the system. Cities drain money from predominantly black neighborhoods by not repairing or updating infrastructure. Banks drain money from those neighborhoods by denying loans and undervaluing property. No surprise the buyer got an appraisal of $0.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoIt's not racism unless you subscribe to highly inclusive definitions of racism. It's just that government is mostly made up of people who are upper middle class or higher and government reflects their values so development they consider "nice" is facilitated and regulatory roadblocks are added to development they are suspect of. If you told HN that some random dude buying a bunch of dilapidated buildings and make them into apartments and commercial real estate people would basically assume you're dealing with a slum lord. These are the kinds of assumptions that government codifies. They don't care that you're black or brown or white. You're just a name on a form to them. What they care about is that your proposed development meets X, Y and Z which triggers scrutiny A B and C (which was all originally passed to curtail slum lords back when the municipality got rich on a boom of local industry 0-70yr ago and could afford to drive them out). And of course the bank knows all this and they figure that into their calculations when they're deciding whether or not to lend to you and what interest rate you'll get.
- yardie 6y ago> government is mostly made up of people who are upper middle class or higher Go to your city hall or their website and see if they have an organizational chart. For some of us one thing will overwhelmingly stick out. For others it's just business as usual. > the municipality got rich on a boom of local industry 0-70yr ago and could afford to drive them out This did not happen. Local industry collapsed and ushered in slumlords. City living has only started trending up within the last 2 decades. Banks still rely on an outdated, and I would say racist, method of property valuation called "comps". The value of the property around you determines the value of the property you are buying. If you are trying to rehabilitate a distressed neighborhood you can't use that method. You'll end up with situations like this. Needing hundreds of thousands of dollars in loans meanwhile the buildings around you are valued at $0. Of course you don't have to take my word for it. HUD has a whole enforcement arm targeting racial discrimination in banking [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining#Court_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining#Court_system
- MattGaiser 6y agoHow much did he pay to buy those buildings in cash? That seems like key information to allow readers to draw conclusions. What was the market value for them?
- e1g 6y agoI was curious too, so quickly checked on Zillow. In this neighborhood, the land is up for sale at ~$1/sqft[0] which is what the bank estimated. Many homes in the range of $30-50k, but the article says his properties are 100 years old and half are not inhabited, so the cost might be near the lower bound. [0] https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/2121-Avenue-I-0-Birmingham-AL-35218/2103491102_zpid/ https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/2121-Avenue-I-0-Birmingha...
- MattGaiser 6y agoA landmark "historic" building in downtown Ensley is an abandoned hazard. https://bhamnow.com/2020/04/23/ensleys-ramsay-mccormack-building-to-be-demolished-and-redeveloped/ https://bhamnow.com/2020/04/23/ensleys-ramsay-mccormack-buil... And it turns out that his properties are close to this large abandoned one. https://www.al.com/news/birmingham/2020/04/johnson-with-ramsay-mccormack-20-finally-happening-will-businesses-come-to-west-birmingham.html https://www.al.com/news/birmingham/2020/04/johnson-with-rams... I found another article where at least one building is described as held together by decay. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-05-13/why-it-s-so-hard-to-invest-in-black-neighborhoods https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-05-13/why-it-s-...
- sct202 6y agoSomeone down thread posted addresses and this one on Zillow kind of matches the background pictures in the article. It may be for more than one address, since he could own contiguous buildings that got tagged to one transaction. https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/610-19th-St-Ensley-AL-35218/174609109_zpid/ https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/610-19th-St-Ensley-AL-352...
- MattGaiser 6y ago
- zo1 6y agoWould be great if all that "funding" that the banks send to the activist BLM organization be rather sent/loaned to individuals such as this one to actually develop and promote neighborhoods that needs some personal love and actually foster the change that we all want to see.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aliante 6y agoWhen he says “historic”, the bank thinks “decrepit.” Unless they building is the Empire State Building, age hurts value. Seriously, the fact that he had the cash to buy the buildings but needs a line of credit against them to develop them tells me that the value of the buildings was quite low to begin with.
- joshgel 6y agoDoesn’t this represent a huge potential financial opportunity to whoever can figure out how to properly recognize the value in these places/owners? What’s stopping some forward looking bank from doing so?
- catmanjan 6y agoWhat if the banks have properly recognised the value?
- blargmaster33 6y agoThanks BLM!
- trabant00 6y agoThe title is misleading at best. He wants the banks to invest in his buildings. Which they don't want to because they don't see it as profitable. "You don't want to give me money? RACISM!" - USA 2020
- tantalor 6y agoWhat point are you trying to make? The article makes it pretty clear: It didn't happen and Mr Rice believes the fact that Ensley is a black neighbourhood was the main factor, especially after being asked questions about the "demographics of Ensley".
- jaclaz 6y agoYep. The point is - as I see it - a little different, the valuation is lower (or in this specific case next to nothing) because the bank does not want to invest in a black neighborhood (racism) or because the bank has historical data saying that black neighborhoods (in general or that particular one) have lower value (pragmatism)?
- JshWright 6y agoYou see how both of those are actually "racism", right?
- DoofusOfDeath 6y ago> You see how both of those are actually "racism", right? I suspect you and GP are using subtly different definitions of "racism".
- jaclaz 6y agoThe point is who exactly is racist. The bank that reads the data or the environment that over the years created the conditions for the data (values) to be so low? Or maybe the unknown people that compiled (or even forged) the data? Let's for the sake of discussion bring it to a different form of discrimination (ageism). Here (EU) in most countries you can have your driving license at 18 years. When you go to an insurance company and you are younger than 21 or in some cases 25 years you will pay a much higher insurance rate for your car then if you are (say) 40. Same goes for renting a car, you simply cannot rent one if below 21 or in some cases 25 years. Now, the bad, bad, insurance and rent a car companies may be populated by bastards, or maybe for some reasons drivers below 21 or 25 years actually have an increased risk of accidents.
- osmay88 6y agoWell guys I did some work in a insurance company a few years ago. From my experience, the issue here is not that the guy is black, the issue is the location where the business are to be open. The banks and insurance companies will evaluate the risk of lending money more than twice for business in those high crime areas. Just take a look at the news in the Minneapolis protests and the amount of black owned business burn to the ground on those areas. After events like this most banks will be reluctant to invest money there, is not so complicated. https://www.neighborhoodscout.com/al/birmingham/crime https://www.neighborhoodscout.com/al/birmingham/crime
- Aeolun 6y agoHe bought eight buildings, then didn’t have enough left to redevelop any of them? While it sucks if you can’t get a loan, maybe you should have tried this with one property before trying to do it with 8 at the same time...
- MattGaiser 6y agoIn fairness to him, all the buildings are part of a complex, so buying the entire set for redevelopment would normally make sense. https://www.google.com/maps/@33.5124301,-86.8954494,58m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/@33.5124301,-86.8954494,58m/data...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kiplkipl 6y agoMaybe YCombinator companies should have tried bootstrapping.
- macspoofing 6y agoI hate these kinds of articles. There are thousands of reasons why this gentleman was denied a loan for redevelopment of these properties, and it is just taken as a truism that it must be racism. The article doesn't even attempt to justify this view, and simply expects the reader to take it at face-value. This is serious stuff. If there is institutional racism, then we need to stamp it out. You cannot be frivolous with these accusations. And the problem with this case, there's nothing you can do. You can't even inundate the bank with calls to stop their racism, because they didn't even bother doing any investigative reporting to see if the bank is following some sort of stated or unstated racist policy - so you have no facts to stand on. The article doesn't say it, but it is clear as day that there is a lot of risk in redevelopment of these properties. For one thing, nobody has done it yet. There is a reason why these properties are abandoned and nobody took a flyer on their redevelopment. Maybe it is oversight by existing real estate developers, but maybe they know something you don't. Locally, there is a building, in a prime location, that has stood abandoned for years - turns out though the building and land is cheaper, redevelopment would mean doing an environmental cleanup that was ostensibly cost-prohibitive. The city didn't even want to reposes it even though they could (the property owned lots of bank taxes). It's irresponsible journalism to do this. >Properties in black areas are priced 23% lower than in white areas, says Andre Perry As always, whenever a line like this is presented, the reader is invited to assume that the reason for that is racism. Is that true though? I have no doubt that this fact is true as stated, but no effort has been done to explain 'why' this fact is. It could be the case that banks are racist (and even in that case, there are multitude of modalities for racism so you still need to do the legwork), but it could be a thousand other reasons. And it is important to know. >They compared my eight historic properties to farmland 14 or so miles away, and they compared my buildings to an abandoned car wash. I mean, yes, I believe it. Banks are weird like this. They are banks. They don't understand the nuances of the business you're in. My farmer friend got denied a loan (and even used farm collateral) for replacement of a machine to aide in drainage tiling because it wasn't deemed a farm-centric operation by the Farm Credit bank (or something like that). To be fair, he did use the tile machine to contract out the service as a side-gig but that's a distinction without meaning. Farmers always have side-hussles that fund farm operations. >JP Morgan Chase, the largest bank in the US, launched its Advancing Black Pathways programme just over a year ago. I don't know anything about the program, but if it is debt-based (as opposed to investment for equity), then I have mixed feelings, because debt is the fastest way for a new business to go underwater. Starting a business is hard enough, and when you have debt hanging over you, it makes it so much harder to survive because business is cyclic - you have bad quarters and good quarters, and debt will inflate a bad quarter and put a damper on the good quarters.
- aliante 6y agoCheck out the buildings he owns and the neighbourhood he is in on Google Earth and Google Streetview. One address is 608 19th street Ensley. He is surrounded by buildings which are abandoned and the roofs have caved in. Half the windows in the area are smashed. Saw a few crumbling walls. Those building aren’t worth anything.
- tomcam 6y agoSadly, these buildings just aren’t good investments, and he’s not a good investor. Buildings that old are subject to all kinds of safety regulations, and Birmingham is not an easy town to work through that kind of thing. No one in the city is going to stick their neck out to cut through decades of regulations only to lose their job when there’s a fire or collapse. Any new owner will be tied up in red tape and rehab requirements that would dwarf the value of the buildings themselves. It’s likely that feasibility studies, inspections (and reinspections), and permits alone would cost more than the buildings. They also tend to take months and even years to get through. I’m a successful real estate investor and while I absolutely love old downtown areas like that, and would love to revitalize them myself, I couldn’t even talk my wife into one of those properties, much less eight for which I had no budget. The numbers just don’t pencil out. Racism has nothing to do with it. In fact, banks love to make loans to women and minority business owners. But there are some risks that would be irresponsible, and this is a textbook example of a loan that’s likely to default, leaving the banks with costs they couldn’t possibly recover. Just to make sure this post gets flagged to extinction, I’d like to suggest to anyone sure that this is a case of racism and not pragmatism put together an investment group and help out.
- raziel2p 6y agoHow are you able to tell the state of the buildings in such details from the article alone? Unless I'm missing something, Rice pretty much addresses your comment in the article: "It's one thing to do this with one building," he says, "if it is small and falling apart. It's another thing to do it with eight buildings with sitting tenants."
- tomcam 6y agoYou’re right, I can’t be certain, other than being reasonably familiar with this business. That’s a lot of real estate. He doesn’t specify how many are paying. If he had enough tenants to move the needle and the buildings were up to code he would have little trouble getting a loan. I’m also willing to bet some serious money that either the buildings aren’t properly permitted for tenants, or that the previous owners were grandfathered in so they didn’t have to observe the same regulations the new owner will. If you haven’t gone through this process it ranges from difficult to imagine to nearly unbelievable what it’s like to bring buildings into compliance. You spend hundreds of dollars to apply for a permit, wait to get it, spend thousands of dollars for an inspection, get incomprehensible paperwork a month later, call someone to find out it means some aspect of your building didn’t pass, hire a lawyer to find out what compliance means, try to find a contractor to fix the things the previous contractor didn’t understand, pay for another inspection, get referred to a different department for something else you didn’t know about... it’s enervating, brutal, and expensive. Think you should have known what to do when you started? No municipalities have clear documentation on what to do when. You are just supposed to know it all ahead of time. No lawyer will coach you through it. Maybe, just maybe, you can find a local GC who can help. Or not. All municipalities have different rules. If you’re super lucky you can charm someone in the planning office to coach you a little, but they aren’t responsible if they forgot to help you with something. This just isn’t a business for the undercapitalized.
- etchalon 6y agoReading these threads, it’s always frustrating to see people insist that it can’t be because of race. “There must be a logical, mathematical reason for this!” As a graduate of the Goldman Sachs 10KSB program, one of the most shocking things I found amongst my cohort was how many of the black small business owners were struggling with credit and financing. It didn’t make any sense when we discussed their business. Often times, their companies were in better financial situations than my own, yet, whereas I was fairly easily able to secure low-interest LOCs and credit lines, they were stuck with high-interest consumer cards, or worse. This made their businesses inherently more fragile than mine, as the interest payments alone were eating into what would have been otherwise healthy margins. There is often no logical, mathematical reason. There is just new racism justified by the lasting impact of old racism, and sometimes it’s not even that: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/15/business/paycheck-protection-program-bias.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/15/business/paycheck-protect...
- aliante 6y agoCheck out the area where he wants the bank to “invest.” 608 19th street Ensley. Look on Google Streetview and Google Earth. Roofs have collapsed. Half the windows around there are smashed. A few large holes in walls. What would you value buildings in that area at?
- etchalon 6y agoSet that aside. Imagine instead that he has found undervalued property in an area with low-labor costs and high potential demand. It’s exactly the type of investment opportunity banks and financiers should be looking for. It’s literally how our housing system gentrifies. He didn’t ask the banks to buy the properties. He was seeking an LOC with a personal guarantee and the buildings as collateral.
- aliante 6y ago> high potential demand. That would require growth. Birmingham is not growing. > the buildings as collateral. Except the buildings are not worth much of anything. I may as well offer my shoe as collateral.
- DFHippie 6y agoSome context: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining
- ethagknight 6y agoI recently led an $80mm mixed use investment in a 10 derelict properties in an offbeat part of Memphis next to a few large government housing projects. Some takeaways reading the article. Banks are not the problem; banks are just doing their jobs by trying to make securable loans. Appraisals aren’t the problem; appraisers are hired and paid to be non-creative and non-biased they assign a value to property. If a group of properties were acquired for next-to-nothing because they’ve been vacant for a decade, it’s tough to assign more than a pittance because there is simply no value comps. The market agrees with the banks and the appraisers, hence not enough people have attempted to concurrently try to develop in Ensley, thus there’s not enough value. What succeeded for us in Memphis is threefold: 1) proximity to jobs, 2) group buy-in of participation into the vision, and 3) some very wealthy investors who believe in the vision. I’ve toured Ensley, I looked at buying that mid rise in the back of the article’s picture, and it’s a neat place. It has the fabric of old small towns that used to thrive. However, I don’t think Ensley has any proximity for high quality jobs or prospects for job growth, so that’s probably square one for Ensley. Historically, this has been “the creatives” who need cheap space but also like to buy expensive lattes And generate a micro economy, but in our case in Memphis, a bank wanted to move its headquarters into the neighborhood, alongside several smaller businesses. Modern day construction is extremely expensive and complicated, to the point that acquisition price in cheap parts of town are a rounding error on the project budget. You need to find a way to guarantee that rents will be sufficient for the long haul, and if you believe banks and appraisals are being short sighted (and they always are..) then you have to provide that guaranty yourself by setting aside a pile of cash or stock to secure the debt. I could write for days on this topic, more than happy to continue discussion offline or elsewhere
- nicoburns 6y agoYou say banks are just doing their job. But you also admit that they're short sighted. Doesn't that suggeat that they're not fulfilling the role that we need them to fulfil in society. I don't want to live in a society where you can only take on a project like this if you are wealthy or have a wealthy backer. Do you?
- ethagknight 6y ago
- aaron695 6y agoIf you want a happy version of this try - Apple TV's "Home" S01E02, Chicago The show is more about artistically showing peoples Home's physically and spiritually for lack of a better word, not figures, but you can see the money it would take in Theaster Gates's project. If you can't see the money it would take, jump to something generic with $ like Grand Designs.
- johnyzee 6y ago> Financial reparations to African American communities are key, argues Prof Baradaran This seems obvious and fair. Blacks have never been given a fair chance in America. > In 1863, when President Lincoln signed the Emancipation Proclamation, black Americans owned less than 1% of US total wealth. Nearly 160 years later, this number has barely budged. Just setting slaves free did not, in any way, put them on equal footing with the rest of the population, and they are still mostly in the hole today that they were then, through mostly no fault of their own. Yet it is my impression that most white Americans, across the political spectrum, are repelled by this idea. There seems to be a widespread, though usually not so bluntly stated, sentiment, that blacks are to blame for their own problems. And not much recognition of how utterly disenfranchised, and frankly destroyed, this people were during slavery, and that this has effects generations later.
- ghufran_syed 6y agoyou might be interested by what a particular black professor has to say on the subject: https://www.creators.com/read/thomas-sowell/11/14/a-legacy-of-liberalism https://www.creators.com/read/thomas-sowell/11/14/a-legacy-o...
- ShamelessC 6y agoYou might be right about the "most" qualifier (although I hope you're not) but have you been paying attention to the protests and media/editorial coverage of the black lives matter movement? It seems many white people are finally starting to grasp the idea that black people have always been severely disadvantaged in this country. A good example is the popularity of the "white fragility" concept and a broader effort to call out racism when it happens instead of worrying about the egos and shame of those accused. Of course, there's also a lot of white people (conservatives, mostly) offended by this notion who are pushing back heavily. There's also obviously the issue that the majority of police in certain areas are particularly fragile and defensive when accused of being racists. Two sides to the issue n all that.
- johnyzee 6y agoI partly base the 'most' part on seeing how widespread the idea is here on HN, which I generally consider to consist of reasonable, and mostly liberal leaning, white people. Honestly, though the BLM movement is a nice gesture, it seems mostly prompted by the string of high-profile police brutality cases, and limited to that. I haven't seen a real agenda of change beyond that, like, for example, the suggestion of reparations, or other significant economic initiatives.
- esalman 6y agoIt is just depressing to read these comments. Most of these are arguing that it is not a good investment for the banks to invest in a high crime rate area. Well if it is not the banks, who else? If it is nobody, are these areas condemned to be in this state forever? It just shows how broken the American society and psyche has become. I am sure even if the local, state or federal government try to make the same "bad" investment, the same people will come out demanding that tax dollars be spent elsewhere.
- Apocryphon 6y agoIt’s also been said that zero-interest rates has led to an economy awash in dumb money looking for a place to invest: https://themargins.substack.com/p/zirp-explains-the-world https://themargins.substack.com/p/zirp-explains-the-world > Treasury investors shift to corporate debt. Public equity hedge funds shift to late-stage private equity. Late-stage private equity shifts to mid-stage, mid-stage to early stage. Seed rounds become bigger. Angel investors become a thing. Unicorns, unicorns, and more unicorns. Ashton Kutcher. > And that's how we end up where we are. In the past, if somewhat risky corporate debt got you 10%. It now gets you 7% (I'm making up numbers here) so you start taking meetings with late-stage growth companies. The Saudi SWF wants to modernize their economy, but they are also looking to achieve returns once found in public equities, so they have to get creative. Blackrock gets jealous of KKR who gets jealous of a16z who gets jealous of YC. There is just so much money looking to do so many new, riskier things. > And again, that's exactly how it's supposed to work. Cutting interest rates spurs demand and risk-taking. > When that much money finds its way into places not used to that much money, weird things happen. It's how we got to Community-Adjusted EBITDA and sleep economies. You don't create a ridesharing service, but a service that oddly loses money on every ride with a promise to figure out some future business [Tough, but fair -Can]. The distortions live at the valuation level, but also the communications and expectations level. Things just get weird. In which case, why opt for risky profit-less startups, and not attempts to revitalize local communities? It’s almost as if these cost-benefit analyses are skewed with built-in cultural biases and expectations.
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoThe government should do its job of preventing crime first and foremost.