7 ms·
Can you provide some evidence for this? Your argument, by extension, would mean that anything that increases a person's income is effectively pointless. Incre
by alistairSH 6y ago
Can you provide some evidence for this? Your argument, by extension, would mean that anything that increases a person's income is effectively pointless. Increased minimum wage? Prices increase and eat the income increase. Collective bargaining? Prices increase and eat the income increase. Taken to the extreme, any action to improve the lot of the poor/low-income is wasted effort, because rent seekers will always collect the maximum rent.
I'm willing to concede UBI (or other unrestricted cash grants) could impact specific segments of a market. But, I can't find good evidence one way or the other that those negative pricing impacts offset increases in productivity, wellness, etc.
- austincheney 6y agoInflation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation
- thebean11 6y agoAnd time and time again, things that by conventional wisdom would increase inflation somehow don't. Macroeconomics isn't that simple, and posting a wikipedia article isn't an argument.
- phone8675309 6y agoYou'd think that employers would be all over UBI then because it means that they can instantly cut the wages of their workers by the amount of the UBI and that more people will have money to purchase their goods and services.
- tspike 6y agoCompanies that depend on underpaid workers will fight this tooth and nail.
- phone8675309 6y agoWhy? It means that they can pay less than they do now and still retain workers. How is it not a positive benefit for them? It potentially means that people working for them actually want to work and aren’t doing it just to survive.
- tspike 6y agoBecause the jobs they're offering are shitty, demeaning and menial, and most people who take them are doing so because they need to survive. Absent the survival need, the companies will have to dramatically improve working conditions to maintain the sheer quantity of labor they require.
- phone8675309 6y agoPerhaps, but the reduced wages (since total income is now UBI + wage instead of 0 + wages) sounds like it will more than make up for whatever increased costs they may have to make the working environment less shitty.
- skrtskrt 6y agoDirt poor people being slightly less dirt poor and not having to worry about where their next meal is going to come from will not inflate basic goods that much. We've seen this with higher minimum wages. The amount of inflation is much lower than than the wage increase, and poor people end up with more buying power.
- austincheney 6y agoA serious distinction is that increased minimum wages incur a burden on employers which they pass around to their customers and business partners. The increase of burden is directly proportional to the amount of work of an hourly employee. UBI does not come from an employer and is not tied to an effort. There is no direct market burden, but yet an increase of cash is available none the less. It should also be noted that inflation is not immediately present following a cash stimulus. It takes time for inflation to set in as a response to market conditions and as such inflation is measured as an adjustable change over a given period of time. That said specific single time examples of UBI not adjusting inflation only demonstrates a faulty understanding of economics. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation#Issues_in_measuring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation#Issues_in_measuring
- mamon 6y ago>> UBI does not come from an employer and is not tied to an effort Where do you think government's money come from? Financing UBI will require raising taxes.
- austincheney 6y agoFor my thoughts on taxes please see my comment further down: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24005134 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24005134
- fragmede 6y agoMoney at the government level is not a zero-sum game, so thinking it's as simple as raising taxes is an oversimplification, and while unchecked printing of money is problematic leading to inflation, how the monetary base grows would need to be part of a well-considered implementation plan.
- ryanwaggoner 6y agoJust saying “inflation” is both condescending and lazy. Billions of people have been lifted out of abject poverty over the past few decades while also dealing with inflation. We know it’s a concept and it has relevance to the discussion, so merely saying the word brings literally nothing to the table.
- austincheney 6y agoDiscarding the term merely for its presense is by argument equally lazy. I didn't provide only a word, but also provided qualifying source material. What the other replies have failed to consider is that UBI is just injection of cash. It isn't a voucher for a specific class of goods, such as rent. It is just cash that can be used for absolutely anything. If that means burning cash on a $5000 handbag then so be it. Inflation is literaly the injection of cash into a market. The problem with inflation is lost value. Cash is an abstraction of value to conduct an exchange. The real world worth of that abstraction is variable. When the availability of that abstraction increases disproportionately to a real world value it will be able to purchase less. The most common reason is that prices increase to follow the increased availibility of cash, but there are other reasons as well. When everybody equally has uniformly increased purchasing power the natural counter-reaction is to reduce availability of goods and services. That can mean raising prices. It can also mean removing goods from market to make them more exclusive. Any means of restoring value to the prior state will happen to lower disruption to the transfer of goods. Had you read the wikipedia article it would have addressed everything I just said.
- ryanwaggoner 6y agoCome on, man. Linking to Wikipedia and expecting people to read a 12,000 word article to magically construct the ~200 word argument you've laid out here is almost a textbook definition of laziness. I stand by what I said.
- ntSean 6y agoIf you had a more well versed economics background, you might be more privy to how narrow of a view you have regarding inflation. Australia currently has a program where anyone impacted from the effects of the pandemic, receives $1,500 a fortnight- and yet is experiencing deflation. The very fact of this debunks your argument, as it is a significant portion of the population who is now receiving a cash injection. This money is not exclusively for rent, nor is it tied to food stamps; it is $1,500 to spend as you wish. Further, The Reserve Bank Of Australia is in favour of these payments. And it's also worth noting, many economies have an inflation target of about 3%, which indicates that inflation is healthy and to so staunchly avoid anything that may affect inflation is a fools errand. Regardless, please read more than a wikipedia article before holding such a strong opinion. The other commenter called you out for being lazy, and I wholeheartedly agree with them.
- alistairSH 6y agoSure, if UBI is implemented without a matching increase in government revenue, or reallocation of existing government revenue. Every serious proposal for UBI does one, the other, or both of those. There is plenty of literature that contradicts your assertion. Here are a few links... https://medium.com/basic-income/wouldnt-unconditional-basic-income-just-cause-massive-inflation-fe71d69f15e7 https://medium.com/basic-income/wouldnt-unconditional-basic-... https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2020/03/18/understanding-claims-about-basic-income-and-inflation/ https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2020/03/18/understandin... https://ubi.earth/basic-income-doesnt-cause-inflation https://ubi.earth/basic-income-doesnt-cause-inflation
- joyeuse6701 6y agoI think if the increase in income is concentrated enough, you may find concentrated rent increase, i.e. silicon valley incomes and housing.
- alistairSH 6y agoSure, and I conceded that in my initial post. What I'm looking for is published work that indicates that changes in consumer prices equals the increase in income due to unrestricted cash grants/UBI. I've looked, but all I see is conjecture. Nothing academic. The academic articles I do find tend to assert the opposite - that any changes in consumer prices are smaller than increases in income, granting the recipient more buying power.
- ellis-bell 6y agothey won't be equal because not all ubi income will be spent on consumption. it will stimulate consumption, however, which was the primary reasoning behind the op and that will lead to some form of inflation edit: inflation because based on the assumptions of the op, the supply side has stagnated and so there is less downward pressure on aggregate prices. the degree of that inflation is unclear and i'm not familiar with any empirical studies. either way inflation won't match one to one with the increase in income. fwiw i noticed above you mentioned that there will be an increase in productivity, wellness etc. although i tend to agree with the wellness aspect (esp. compared to our current circumstances) the degree to which wellness would increase is also unclear. for some colinear studies, i'm thinking of finkelstein's work on medicaid expansion in oregon where they found exposure to medicaid increased reported well being of recipients. and i don't think productivity increases under a ubi holds water on theoretical grounds. you seem to be assuming large increases in productivity and wellness and other benefits and then asking if inflation will erode that, when we also need to consider that the possible benefits will themselves be attenuated, particularly for those already at lower incomes or those who will earn a ubi.
- kbenson 6y agoHousing is supply and demand. More demand for housing without an increase in supply will increase cost. That said, a guaranteed income may allow many people to safely choose to move out of an area that was hard to accomplish previously. If you're living paycheck to paycheck, how do you move far enough away from a high-cost area to actually reduce your housing cost while still allowing you to reach your job, since you can't quit it and still afford to pay rent? All you can usually do is trade commute time for rent cost, and then you pay in time and vehicle wear and gas. UBI would allow an unprecedented level of freedom for people to relocate with little risk, and that would itself have a massive influence on city make-up and the housing market. If a lot of the unskilled labor in the bay area actually chose to move somewhere else, wages for those people would either have to increase greatly to meet demand, or the area would finally have to allow much more cheap housing. I imagine other shifts like that would play out large in small in almost all aspects of the economy. UBI entirely changes everything.
- enumjorge 6y agoSome people think the price of going to college has gone up because so much money has been made available to students through financial aid. I don’t know if that’s been proven but it sounds plausible.
- alistairSH 6y agoI'm actually in the higher education world (on the periphery, as a software developer). It's more complicated than that. Over the same time period that loans have become easily obtainable (via US government backing), massive amounts of regulation has also been imposed on colleges/universities. While people love to talk about football stadiums, luxury dorms, and other amenities, one of the largest increases in the cost of running a college is administrators to keep up with regulatory demands. I'm not claiming administrators are solely responsible, only that it's not as simple as "Uncle Sam gives students money and college spend every penny". Additionally, public funding of colleges has dropped over the same time period. As of 2018, state funding of public colleges was down ~$7 billion since 2008. It was slashed during the down economy, but never brought back up again.
- seanlinehan 6y agoTo add a small bit of context for the last point about funding. A $7B reduction in funding sounds like a lot, but during that same period student loan debt increased by $760B.[0] On the balance, the reduction in state funding seems like an insignificant piece of the puzzle. [0] https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/state-of-student-loan-debt/ https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/state-of-student...
- DangitBobby 6y agoIn what ways have regulations increased costs?
- malandrew 6y agoA good example is the parallel legal and law enforcement systems on college campuses. In the past, you'd call the regular police and you'd take issues to the courts used by all other citizens outside the university. Now universities maintain their own law enforcement and farcical "justice" system. This stuff is not cheap to operate and comes with tons of overhead.
- captainbland 6y agoThe good news is that, to take one of your examples, while the minimum wage does have a small effect on prices, the inflationary effect seems to be vanishingly tiny compared to the actual wage rise offered. (PDF link) https://mitsloan.mit.edu/shared/ods/documents/?PublicationDocumentID=5548 https://mitsloan.mit.edu/shared/ods/documents/?PublicationDo...
- jokethrowaway 6y agonot if you count the rise in unemployment because you're killing jobs
- xwdv 6y agoYou have come to the correct conclusion. The logical leap that you are missing is that prices don’t always rise quickly enough as a response to increase in wages. What a person is willing to pay is only part of the pricing equation. You also have to consider what competitors are charging and how much potential margin there is to play with. Inevitably though, all prices consolidate and all players in the market will charge more to meet the increase in wages, it’s just a slow process. The only time it happens quickly is if each business conspires to raise prices simultaneously, which isn’t going to happen or may be illegal. So yes, increase in wages or handing out UBI inevitably raises prices after a period of time, necessitating the need for even more increase in wages and more UBI. It’s not a one and done thing.
- Supermancho 6y ago> Inevitably though, all prices consolidate and all players in the market will charge more to meet the increase in wages, it’s just a slow process. All prices? No. Clothing is now effectively free, for example. Prices of necessities are the only things you want to watch. Basic food products, healthcare, etc. Those prices have risen around the same as the rate of inflation or spiraled out beyond. Food prices cannot outstrip the inflation ever, because of food subsidy and/or ebt which is tied to it.
- xwdv 6y agoHow is clothing free? Last time I checked I paid 50 bucks for a shirt. Food is cheap and no one cares if you waste it.
- jacobr1 6y agoYou could buy a shirt for $5 at walmart. And there is even a reasonable chance the material quality would be good. It almost certainly won't be fashionable. Purchasing quality second-hand clothing in North America is even cheaper. For food, some people buy bulk staples and some buy high-end food at Wholefoods. The degree of substitutes and variety available on the market is staggering for consumer items.
- 6y ago
- SiliconMageDev 6y agoCan I use my UBI to buy Crack? And then live on the street because i blew my UBI on Crack?
- Alex63 6y agoIf we assume that income reflects society's demand for an individual's labor/skills/knowledge, and we arbitrarily increase income with no concomitant increase in demand then we have to assume something else is going to shift. A couple of outcomes seem likely to me: * employer wages for low-demand workers will drop, as competition for low-demand workers will not increase, and those workers will accept a lower wage reasoning that the UBI 'makes up the difference' * if employer wages are not allowed to drop below a certain point (the minimum wage), then more disposable income will create increased demand for scarce resources (e.g., housing that is a bit better than currently occupied) thereby causing prices to rise. I'm no Econ major, so happy to hear how my reasoning may be in error.