15 ms·
Why forgiving someone else is about you
- miedpo 6y agoI know this is a difficult subject for many. In any case, I can say this of my own experiences with forgiveness. I find that forgiveness really helps me feel happy.
- orwin 6y agoI think revenge and forgiveness are big words with a lot of different meanings. Someone close to me was raped a few years back. No witnesses (yeah, he was her boss and asked her to stay a bit longer), so the perpetrator could walk of free of worries. It was enraging, but we simply learned not to care. What's done is done. Is this forgiveness? However everyone i talk to in the city where it happened know that the particular restaurant is owned by a rapist, and i've said multiple time, to multiple people, to always ask the nearest formation center to know if they forbid/discourage female cook to apprentice in some restaurants, and if they do, which ones. It's not really revenge, it is just not supporting rapists.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hawk_ 6y agoWhile law doesn't have place for revenge in a civilised society and rightly so, the need for revenge/retribution I suspect is quite innate. It's healthy to try to forgive but it's quite difficult, almost like you can't fool yourselves into thinking you aren't hungry.
- hnarayanan 6y agoDo you honestly believe revenge helps you?
- choonway 6y agowhat about making sure the person who did it to you does not profit from it?
- bschne 6y agoBy itself, that seems like sunk costs to me - preventing someone else from profiting from a disadvantage they put you at does not necessarily remediate said disadvantage. But there's certain ways in which it could be "rational" - e.g. preventing them from doing you harm again in the future by scaring them off with your revenge, evening out some sort of competitive position so that you are on the same level again, or if your revenge actually re-balances some material loss you suffered at their hands.
- waterhouse 6y agoAre you familiar with the game-theoretic definition of a threat? A threat is when I say that, if you do X (which I don't want), then I will do Y, and Y hurts both you and me. (If Y benefited me, then we'd expect me to do Y anyway, so the threat would make no difference.) Carrying out a threat is, therefore, always irrational. However, if I could make you believe that I would carry out the threat, then I could get you to not do X, which would be good for me. If I can modify my own mind so that, if you do X, then I am obsessively driven to carry out Y—"revenge"—and I make this obvious to you, then modifying my mind in that way is rational for me to do. (Of course, the only key part is making you believe that my mind works like this. But as a species, I think humans are not especially good liars—probably for good reasons, so that threats and promises are possible—and the most reliable approach to making you think I'm like that is to be like that.) I think this is why there is a built-in drive for revenge. Now, the drive for revenge doesn't always win. In the ancestral environment, carrying out revenge against the wrong enemy may simply get you killed. It's possible that "knowing when to back off" has been selected for. (Perhaps the neural circuitry sometimes perceived natural forces like rain, or stronger creatures like tigers (possibly the relevant evolving happened before we got good at hunting), as the "enemy".) Which then opens the door to trying to intimidate the other party even further so they don't try for revenge, or to bluffing that you're not intimidated, or to guessing (perhaps incorrectly) that the other side is bluffing, and so on. Anyway, that is the mess we are left with.
- billfruit 6y agoI do think it is something which is greatly variables among individuals. I have felt that I have a dampened sense of anger, that people find it weird/strange that I did not become angry in such and such situations. This could be problematic in some situations including at work, sometimes if you don't have or show anger then your motives can be viewed with suspicion.
- njacobs5074 6y agoIt does seem to be an innate part of our behavior. It's interesting because the interviewee strongly suggests that we forgive others when it no longer makes sense to hold a grudge. On the other hand, she also recommends that we cultivate that feeling because it often gives no benefit to not move on from the wrong that was visited upon us.
- mc32 6y agoCouldn’t it have a function of regulating social behavior such that by holding a grudge society is helped if this causes the perp to at least be aware of impropriety of their transgression?
- brightball 6y agoAnecdotal I know, but I tried for 2 years to forgive someone who had deeply wronged my family, but I simply couldn’t get past feeling like we needed to go to court to make it right and it was eating me up inside. My wife suggested I ask God to help, which I hadn’t tried and didn’t think it would make a difference but I tried it. And it worked. The next day the anger was just...gone and remains so to this day. I realize it’s anecdotal and I don’t expect most people to take it seriously but it changed my life.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chaoticmass 6y agoReminds me of something my Dad sent me when I was dealing with grief over someone who wronged me. It's from the Alcoholics Anonymous book, but I found the advice worked anyway. Here's the scan from the book: https://imgur.com/a/XlkPGLp https://imgur.com/a/XlkPGLp
- brightball 6y agoThank you for sharing that. The line at the beginning of the last paragraph jumps out at me. "This great experience that released me from the bondage of hatred and replaced it with love is really just another affirmation of the truth I know..." Having really experienced hatred first-hand, the nearly obsessive state of ongoing anger... It bothers me every time I see people toss around the word "hate" with every disagreement or bias that they believe other people have. Without realizing it, these people are minimizing one of the most dangerous internal emotional experiences that we experience as humans by turning it into hyperbole that nobody takes seriously.
- qwerty456127 6y ago> the need for revenge/retribution I suspect is quite innate. Why? I can't imagine feeling this way for longer than some minutes.
- hawk_ 6y agoperhaps you haven't been wronged in a significant way, and i hope it stays that way.
- qwerty456127 6y agoThat probably is a "personality type" thing or something. Some people seem to value "justice" (and this way may want to punish somebody) instinctively. I value comfort, security, freedom and avoid wasting energy on anything which is not a big investment in these. If somebody would wrong me I would only invest myself in punishing him if I had a good reason to believe that's really going to scare whoever might be planning to wrong me or somebody else in future. And I would not write about this if I wasn't curious about how does this work. Why do some people are the first kind and the other the second? Isn't energy conservation and danger avoidance a fundamental program of every living brain? Why would somebody really want to hurt somebody who isn't a threat any more? That feels so alien to me I become extremely curious.
- snarf21 6y agoI had a realization about hate quite a long time ago. When you hate someone, 99.999% of the time they don't know or they don't care. So the only one that ends up feeling bad 24/7 is you. You have to find a way to let it go and move on, forgiveness or not..
- zo1 6y agoThat's why it's important to "verbally" punish them on some level (if you hate them because they've done you wrong). They need to know, or if they've done wrong in a work/shared social context, then others need to know as well. Otherwise, it's as you said, only you feel bad and they have no idea or don't care. Too much of the ills happening in the world today is (I would argue) due to us responding to bad things by appeasing, forgiving, or simply "letting it go" without confrontation/conflict.
- jakear 6y ago> you can't fool yourselves into thinking you aren't hungry Interesting take. Friends of mine who grew up in poverty would tend to disagree - from what I’ve heard it becomes very natural to ignore hunger to the point of it going away entirely. This is more or less the only way to have a semi-pleasant life, given you won’t be at a healthy nutrition level regardless.
- mattigames 6y agoLong time ago I went by without eating a few days, your body stops nagging you for food so much, peak hunger is about 24 hours later and then slowly but steadily you feel it less strongly, it never truly goes away, just less powerful.
- jakear 6y ago> a few days For some friends, this was more like 10+ years in the core development phase of early childhood. I think the two experiences are more or less incomparable.
- mattigames 6y agoI was telling everyone else how it works at small scale, not about the experiences being comparable or not.
- hawk_ 6y agoYes absolutely. But this is subjective as well is part of my premise. Like some people may be genetically predisposed to not saying no to food etc... in my experience the desire to get revenge is hard to overcome for a fairly large part of the population. So teaching forgiveness is equivalent of asking people to diet or exercise... it's really difficult.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 6y agoInterestingly, forgiveness plays a part of some systems of law (particularly in the Middle East). If, for example, you accidentally kill a person while driving drunk, you have the opportunity to publicly apologize, and the family of the deceased are offered an opportunity to publicly forgive (though from my understanding, they're under no obligation or pressure to do this, and I believe in an instance this egregious, it would be quite rare). If you're forgiven, the sentencing is less harsh than it would be otherwise.
- hawk_ 6y agoeven in this woke era those legal systems can hardly be called civilised though. i mean the punishment for rape is being wed to the victim. also the "forgiveness" there is bought using wealth, kind of like out of court settlement but even for criminal matters not just civil.
- paulsutter 6y agoIn which we learn that forgiveness is a suitcase word (prone to useless debate as each party uses a different definition) https://alexvermeer.com/unpacking-suitcase-words/ https://alexvermeer.com/unpacking-suitcase-words/
- Lammy 6y agoI've unfortunately run into this concept many times firsthand, but thank you for finally giving me a term for it! Hopefully naming it will make it easier to talk about. As long as we can keep "suitcase word" to a single definition, of course.
- coldtea 6y agoAren't those the only words that matter? Anything else, that everybody is clear and agrees on, might as well not be discussed at all...
- dicytea 6y agoThe category doesn't necessarily imply any value judgement by itself, at least as discussed in that article.
- munchbunny 6y agoThe activity of unpacking those words is important, because in the process you get to an actual debate and not just people talking past each other. Once you do it everyone involved realizes that they mostly agree anyway, that they actually disagree on something fundamental, or that some people are intentionally clouding the argument to try to make a dishonest point.
- waterhouse 6y agoIf definitions are clear and everyone agrees on them, then discussion can be about whether those definitions apply. Discussion is then about the real world. The definition of murder is pretty clear and widely agreed on; there is plenty of room for discussion about whether it was Smith or Jones who committed it. If definitions are unclear or people disagree on them, then discussion may either be about the definitions and not about the real world, or be incoherent.
- mamon 6y agoWe can have cookie and eat it to: stop being angry at those who wronged you, just start plotting your revenge :) Treat revenge as just another item on your todo list, just like shopping or dentist visit. Or maybe even outsource your revenge by hiring a lawyer/PI/hitman to enact it.
- ogurechny 6y agoPeople considering a two thousand year old idea an original fresh take show how self-delusional the concept of “progress” and believing in being smarter than than brutes of the past are.
- ben_w 6y agoProgress is a different thing to having an accurate model of what long-dead people thought. I mean, it can even be hard to accurately model someone who you’re having a conversation with.
- aszantu 6y agoEmily fletcher has a great meditation on forgiveness, it's about 10 minutes long :)
- scottious 6y agoAs somebody who's struggling to forgive somebody who's wronged me, I find this article to be a bit wishy-washy, like this: > Reexamine your perceptions of life events that have trapped you in the role of victim. well, what if somebody really truly was a victim? What if one's parents have condescended and belittled them for decades? What if one's mother is abusive and drinks too much? What if somebody spent their entire childhood planning their escape from their parents (successfully!) That kind of stuff doesn't just go away. Is it even possible to forgive somebody who honestly doesn't think they've done anything wrong?
- watwut 6y agoI call this stuff self-gasslighting. You convince yourself that you was at fault for own abuse.
- fladrif 6y agoI think the part you're missing is this passage > soul-level letting-go of our pain, our sorrow, our suffering," Holub says. "And we do that because we want to be free. I'm not saying that it's easy or something you may want to do, but it will end up improving your life. Personally I'm in a similar situation to the one you presented, with the overbearing insensitive parent. It's difficult to say that I've forgiven them, but it's a slow process of trying to rid my life of their influence and shedding that negativity and their nagging voice in the back of my head. The forgiveness isn't seeking reconciliation with them, but resolving the blame and anger you have within yourself directed towards the person in order to free yourself to heal. Of course the person will continue with their actions which will cause it difficult to heal, but I've found the strategy of divorcing emotion to the person helpful. Therefore you can heal yourself of the wounds caused by that person on your own even if the person is still ever present. I can't say this works out all the time, but I do feel myself getting closure without reconciliation.
- unionpivo 6y agoBecause its about you not them. It doesn't matter what they think or do. You should do it for yourself to set yourself free of emotional baggage. Just because you forgive someone does not mean you suddenly think he is a great person, or should forget that he is abusive. Its saying I am done with all this shit. "you" (whomever wronged you) are not worth my time hating you. At least that worked for me.
- watwut 6y agoI really have issue with the whole often repeated "If something was done to you that actually makes you victim of x, there is something wrong with you. You must not be victim, even when you was victim" thing. Its consequences is "I did not wanted to complain because that would make me victim" which is no good result. I don't like the part where you have to make yourself responsible for it either.
- GavinMcG 6y agoYou've got to make yourself responsible for your emotional reality, because you're the only one who can consistently influence it. Or at least, it's up to you whether you allow others to influence it. No one denies that people really are victimized. But whether they let that victim vs. perpetrator mindset play out in their other relationships and lived experiences is (with time and practice) up to them.
- watwut 6y agoI do not know what "victim mindset" is supposed to be. Victim is descriptor - something negative was done to you. You don't become victim by looking at things certain way. Nor you do stop being one. If you was robbed, you are robbery victim regardless of what your mindset is. Most of this is about denying that you might be victim of something either to yourself or to others. Plus, people actually really do deny that. If you read this article in full, majority of examples are about trying to figure out whether you don't misremember or misrepresent what happened.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoIn many scenarios you do become a victim by looking at things a certain way. Suppose I get in a nasty fight with a close friend, where she yells at me and calls me all sorts of nasty names and shoves me a bit before running away. There are two different ways I could process that: * That conversation really spiraled out of control. We should get together, understand what went wrong, and make up. * I'm an abuse victim! She emotionally abused me and then lightly physically abused me. She'd better apologize for the trauma she put me through. The first attitude is especially important when I might be misremembering how things went or forgetting about what I was yelling back. But even if I'm 100% confident that my summary is fair and accurate, I don't think the second strategy is healthy, and I'd call the idea that I should embrace it "victim mindset".
- dkarl 6y agoForgiveness as discussed here is an internal emotional matter and easy to make a case for. Forgiveness becomes a public and contentious issue when the injured party is under pressure to once more trust the offender, to do business with them, to "let them back into their lives," etc. That's what the arguments are about, and that's when this idea of forgiveness gets perverted into "gee, you must be suffering spiritually under all that hatred and resentment towards Bob, why don't you let it go and let Bob borrow your car for his bachelor party road trip."
- jerkstate 6y agoOne of the most important aspects of forgiveness is a credible apology. We all know people who can't or won't apologize for their transgressions, or heard apologies that don't address the core issues of the transgression. When you hear a small child apologize, it's reflexive, like they hope to use it as a shield for any retribution or punishment. The true purpose of an apology is to convey contrition and growth from the aggrieving party to the aggrieved, which are both important to the ability to forgive any given transgression. A large part of this forgiveness article is about expressing yourself - perhaps to the aggrieving party - perhaps in order to achieve a satisfactory apology. In that way, an apology is like a confession of sin prayer. If you don't mean it, the person upstairs can tell and you won't be forgiven. Maybe this is one function of religion - helping us develop the important life skills of apology and forgiveness.
- ogurechny 6y agoThis is a complete misunderstanding, in my opinion. It is not an accounting of receipts and expenditures, not some “game theory” example, not an investment onto “the betterment of a society”, etc. You don't need anything to forgive, to do the right thing, it is always in your power. It might be hard, but it has always been like that.
- jerkstate 6y agoWell like elsewhere in the thread, people have mentioned that forgiveness is a complicated word. You should definitely learn to "let it go" regardless of whether you've received any apology, in terms of not letting it affect your psyche negatively, but in terms of future interactions with someone who wronged you and can't show contrition or growth, you have no obligation to put yourself into a position where they can do the same thing to you again. Hence, not a full forgiveness because your interactions with them are altered.
- ogurechny 6y ago“Letting it go to feel better”, in my opinion, is also an accounting, some self-objectifying robot maintenance. It is strange that people find it hard to imagine how to forgive without receiving anything back. For one thing, I seriously doubt I'm in position to judge “growth” of other people.
- trabant00 6y ago> Without forgiveness, accumulated resentments extract a toll, says forgiveness coach Kym Kennedy. Without snake oil your accumulated borxins extract a toll on your health, says snake oil salesman. We get angry to have an emotional STOP sign attached to certain experiences, people, things, etc. You should always forgive like you should always forget that fire burns. Go ahead, put your hand back in, get it out of your system.
- stupidcar 6y agoFalse dichotomy. Taking steps to heal yourself from damage, such as a physical burn or a psychological wound, doesn't necessarily mean not taking the threat seriously in future. Pain is a signal that teaches us a lesson. Once the lesson is learned, holding onto the pain can just be needless suffering.
- trabant00 6y agoYou would be right if people would be rational, which they are not. They are emotional. If you forgive the abusive partner, the loan shark, the casino, etc, you return to them no matter what lessons you learned rationally. And this happens in real life a lot, it isn't just a theory.
- GavinMcG 6y ago> If you forgive the abusive partner, the loan shark, the casino, etc, you return to them No? Forgiveness is the letting go of the past. It doesn't mean going back to or repeating the situation. When you heal your broken leg, you don't necessarily go back to skydiving.
- trabant00 6y agoDoes what I said and you quoted happen or not? Because we can argue theory all you want, but reality is what actually happens.
- 6y ago
- keiferski 6y agoFor a serious academic take on the topic, I recommend the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy's articles on Forgiveness and Reconciliation. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/forgiveness/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/forgiveness/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/reconciliation/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/reconciliation/
- tombert 6y agoAs a rule if I feel someone makes an honest apology, I will almost always forgive them, at least if they did something to me (and I try really hard to apply the reverse and apologize sincerely if I think there's even a chance of something being my fault). What I've found is that I'm far less-willing or able to forgive people for doing things to hurt people that aren't me. For example, I haven't talked to my grandmother in almost 4 years because she said some really racist stuff that would get this post flagged if I repeated it. Do these comments hurt me, a yuppie white dude who's biggest problem is being bored from working at home? No, not really, but it's not just about me, and I feel like "forgiveness" would be insulting to the people who it does hurt. I'll admit this might be a character flaw on my end, but I also don't see myself changing on that.
- known 6y ago"Live well. It is the greatest revenge" --Talmud
- wenc 6y agoForgiveness is a tough topic for many who have been hurt, so I expect we'll see many comments along the lines of "what about this?" or "this is unrealistic/too simplistic". I hope we can be compassionate toward the skeptics in our replies.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI'm really glad to see this posted. I think that "Forgiveness" and "Acceptance" are often confused. I feel that the important part, for ourselves, is "Acceptance." I won't go into details, but Forgiveness and Acceptance have been a significant part of my life for about 40 years. I have been on both sides of the coin. There are people who have had to Forgive me (or not), and have had to Accept wrongs that I did them, and I have had to Accept, and, in some cases, Forgive, trauma inflicted upon me. A big part of my life has been dedicated to making sure that no one needs to forgive me, or accept unacceptable behavior, on my part, and in making sure that I don't set myself up for needless trauma. In order to move past trauma, we need to "defuse the time bomb." We need to Accept it. We may never be able to Forgive it, though. I'm thinking about genocide survivors (I've known a few, including from events other than The Holocaust), soldiers (including child soldiers), families of murder victims, and rape/sexual assault/assault victims (I have known many; including a number of males). It's unreasonable to expect trauma victims to Forgive their trauma-inflictors, but they must get to a point of Acceptance, if they ever want to live a life that's halfway normal. In some cases, it's because many cultures on Earth (including family/clan/tribal cultures) consider Forgiveness to be weakness, or trauma victims to be "at fault" (I won't get into the specifics, there, but it happens -a lot). Even in those cultures, if we can separate Acceptance from Forgiveness, there's a chance that people can heal. Despite all that, I have seen some that have truly Forgiven what I consider to be unforgivable acts. Before they can Forgive, though, they have always first reached a point of Acceptance. Those people are my heroes. Acceptance means coming to terms with trauma. It happened. It sucked. It was deeply unfair. It was wrong. It may even have been downright evil. It left scars (sometimes, literally). It may even have been self-inflicted, or exacerbated by our own complicity. The perpetrators "got away with it," and are still walking around, unconcerned, unrepentant, and unpunished. It's not happening anymore. Despite all that, it still needs to be put into a place behind us, and no one is going to be able to do that, except ourselves. Time won't heal this. It needs some elbow grease. A very valuable part of Acceptance, is that it frees us to help others that have gone through (or are going through) the same trauma. If we can't Accept, we can't help others. Another aspect of non-acceptance, is that unhealed trauma can actually make trauma victims dangerous. Hurt people hurt people. I know many folks that have never learned to live in Acceptance, and their lives are a vale of tears. When the external trauma stopped, it was replaced by internal trauma. There's a story I was told (completely made-up): A man walks into a building, is immediately beaten badly by another man, and thrown out into the street. They get up, dust themselves off, put up their fists, and walk back in. Same thing happens. This is repeated a number of times. Then, one time, they walk into the building, and the other man is no longer there. So they go looking for them.
- jwieczorek 6y agoIt's interesting to see modern-day “certified forgiveness coachers” transmit the millenia-old Christian teaching on sin, resentment and forgiveness.
- Barrin92 6y agowas about to remark the same thing. Seeing an article like this in what is allegedly a Christian culture is a little bit funny. Do we really need to teach people that forgiveness, properly understood, is an act of virtue rather than some sort of bargain?
- betenoire 6y agoPlot twist: it's ALL about us, if you keep digging
- 627467 6y agoI have a hard time thinking that anything one does isn't about oneself first and foremost. Even when that action is self-destructive. But this is probably just my view of existence.
- steve76 6y agoOther things exist with great power. Not just humanistic things, like stronger nations or armies. Natural things. Electrical and chemical potentials. Mechanical structures. Cosmic effects of gravity. Biological pathogens and ecosystems. Without forgiveness their work would be much easier. Existence is not created from a past mistake or a trivial act of chance. Forgiveness comes first. Not provoking. Overlooking as much as possible. Choosing something is not worth the effort or focus. Forgiveness is the only reason something exists. The article mentions "You have to get it out of your system". No. Don't do that. Forget about it as fast as you can. You don't run out a blister. It's mostly just bad habits.
- RomanPushkin 6y agoIn Orthodox Christianity they have "Forgiving Sunday" every year. Many people (in Russia, for example) ask for forgiveness once a year, and everyone forgives. Like for real, it's happening to folks of all ages, including progressive folks of 20-30 age.
- NumberCruncher 6y ago"To forgive and forget means to throw away dearly bought experience.” - Schopenhauer
- skinkestek 6y agoI used to believe that those two were the same but since a few years ago I have come down closer to this. That said I really do forgive even if I don't always forget: - the person will get cake/discounts/etc and I won't seek revenge - I might not however hire them / defend them / etc I've struggled a bit with this and a number of similar problems since according to my religion there's no forgiveness for me unless I forgive others and I actually have a past so I better not void the deal ;-)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jonstaab 6y agoThere's some truth to this, but this therapeutic reduction does a disservice to the traditional (and fuller) practice of forgiveness: > In the new therapeutic dispensation, however, forgiveness is all about the forgiver, and his or her power and well-being. We have come a long way from Shakespeare’s Portia, who spoke so memorably in The Merchant of Venice about the unstrained “quality of mercy,” which “droppeth as the gentle rain from heaven” and blesses both “him that gives and him that takes.” And an even longer way from Christ’s anguished cry from the cross, “Forgive them, for they know not what they do.” And perhaps even further yet from the most basic sense of forgiveness, the canceling of a monetary debt or the pardoning of a criminal offense, in either case a very conscious suspension of the entirely rightful demands of justice. From: https://hedgehogreview.com/issues/the-post-modern-self/articles/the-strange-persistence-of-guilt https://hedgehogreview.com/issues/the-post-modern-self/artic..., which I highly recommend reading, as it's super relevant not only to our personal lives, but to the cultural moment we find ourselves in.
- jkingsbery 6y agoI agree. From a high-minded perspective, "Forgiveness has a PR problem" only if one is talking about a group that ignores the canon of religious teachers and what they've said about the importance of forgiveness and mercy, and what that actually means. From a more basic approach, I don't know what playground Holub was on as a kid leading her to say "we're taught what we'll call "traditional" forgiveness when we're 4 or 5 years old," but I was taught based on Mr. Rogers (and my daughters were taught based on Daniel Tiger), that forgiveness still requires consequences. (See: "Saying sorry is the first step, then how can I help": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oICZVpmtL4c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oICZVpmtL4c).
- isoskeles 6y ago> Contrary to popular opinion, the practice of forgiveness is not about condoning or making excuses for unfair treatment and other hurtful behaviors. It's not about getting an apology or a show of remorse from the offending party. I'm not sure it's popular opinion to receive some sort of apology or show of remorse. What are other perspectives on this? My view has been that forgiveness is independent of an apology. An apology might lead to forgiveness for some, but shouldn't be expected nor is it a requirement. As an aside, it also seems forgiveness has fallen out of favor as a public virtue, if not in popular opinion, then in practice. When someone makes a public mistake, many people want to make it as difficult as possible to move on, a vindictiveness that is the polar opposite of forgiveness. Or I'm mistaken, and the change is that everything is more public now. Also, hope everyone had a laugh at "certified forgiveness coach."
- kayodelycaon 6y agoFor an example: It’s very common for victims of rape to be told to forgive the family member who raped them and not “cause drama” in the family.
- jka 6y agoIn this and many other conversations nowadays I find myself wondering how the narrative applies through the lens of three different groups: - Those who are generally in good health (mental and physical) and who may have experienced difficulties in the past but do not dwell on them - People who are victims and who encounter regular struggles as a result -- likely the intended audience of articles like this - Sociopaths who at best do not understand the emotional pain of others, and at worst enjoy inflicting it I hope the advice in the article is genuinely intended to help people in the second group. Sometimes I fear that content is authored or perpetuated by people from the third group who would prefer to place the responsibility for repair on the victims. And frequently I find that the audience who reads and discusses it is the first group, without really understanding the others and in particular how charming, reasonable and attractive the third group can appear. In short and in my experience: it is probably good advice but it should not detract focus from the harm that some people willingly cause.
- Osiris 6y agoMy therapist has recently recommend "The Grief Recovery Handbook"[1] to me to deal with a breech of trust in my life. I never thought of that as "grief" but as we went through it, it's really put a new perspective on things. The book also talks about the importance of forgiveness and explains it this way: "Since you cannot go back in time to change the past, forgiveness is about giving up the hope of a different or better yesterday. It relates to forgiving actions that were taken, that gave you the feelings of loss of control over your happiness. It’s about acknowledging those things that another did or said that caused pain and making the decision that you are not going to let that hurt or control you anymore. Forgiveness can be very empowering. It can give you the chance to be free of another person’s emotional control. It has nothing to do with the other person. As was said before, it is something that is for you and you alone." [1] https://www.amazon.com/Grief-Recovery-Handbook-Anniversary-Expanded/dp/0061686077 https://www.amazon.com/Grief-Recovery-Handbook-Anniversary-E...
- barrkel 6y agoI personally frame it as taking responsibility for your feelings - recognizing that you have in large measure conscious choice over the way you feel and can will it differently - and I think of it in opposition to what I perceive as a modern vogue for playing the victim, or worse, stacking up victimhood cards like they are spell multipliers and using them in a social competition to prove how much bigger of a victim you are than other people. But victimhood, as I see it, surrenders your well-being to forces external to you. That all sounds pretty political, but everything social turns political above a certain scale. Forgiveness is underrated, for sure. Take control over your self.
- throwanem 6y agoThis sounds like a recipe for redirecting the grudge toward some other external target, instead of letting it go. Not to say you shouldn't do what works for you, as long as you don't hurt anyone else in the doing of it - but to find it as you've put it here gives it the sense of general advice and recommendation, and in that sense it seems very much wanting.
- throwaway_234 6y agoMy former best friend of 30 years turned into a greedy, vengeful, ego-driven criminal and after 15 years of keeping me away from his gambling (addiction) world (friends) he got me involved. I am not an innocent party as I agreed to do something that I knew was wrong and stupid. Even kept saying such to him and everyone while we did such. When the stuff hit the fan he threw me under the bus to save himself from the cops. We tried to patch things up a few months later by continuing to run our outdoor recreation business, but the only day we were in business that season he stole portions of the profit. When this all happened I was harsh and judged him.. saying i didnt even know him anymore and he's turned into a criminal. Thus, he won't ever speak with me again as I judged him (lol). The guy started doing some illegal scary stuff and as a friend I was pointing out he's going in the wrong and a very bad direction. Doesn't matter we will never speak again and I know the only way we will is for me to forgive him and reach out. But no he's become a criminal and ego/being revengeful/greed/being right yet he's so wrong is more important then 3 decades of friendship. People change... him changing and the loss of our friendship hasnt been easy.
- inostia 6y agoExcuse the cultural reference, but the outdoor recreation thing makes me think of a plot line from The Sopranos where an addicted gambler gets "busted out" by the mafia and ends up being force to do illegal things because of his debts. Maybe it was the gambling addiction that lead your friend to doing illegal activities? Addictions like that can cause people to go out of control, it's a compulsion and a very sad one.
- throwaway_234 6y agoYes and so am I supposed to give him a pass? He's going to keep going in the wrong direction until his addiction and it's action lands him in jail or something bad to teach him a lesson. Not sure I can teach him that lesson myself minus cutting him out of my life and all my family's life (he grew up around my family). Also, when you put out he's doing wrong and going in a horrible direction he says i am horrible for judging him. He already almost got thrown in jail once, yet didnt get time. Maybe time in jail is what he needs to wake himself up from his addiction. Unfortunately, both his parents died early due to drug addiction. Hard to forgive and reach out when all i can see is he will do the same until he works on quitting his addiction. What would others do? *im here in the mid-Atlantic area of the US. Didnt watch the Sopranos that much, but on a different note running that business with him was the best job I ever had. Customers loved what we offered and not only paid us but would write reviews on Facebook without asking. As well I was selling a service I loved and working with friends outside. It could definitely could have become a 100k summer business and more, but he ran the business like a Soprano and I ran it like Walt Disney. The latter is still blossoming decades later ... mob bosses not so much.
- viburnum 6y agoThe forgiveness instructions in the article are very detailed and tie together many current popular ideas. Some people really like complicated systems, so maybe having so much to do helps them by crowding out the bad feelings that cause suffering. Another approach is to decide that being the judge is no longer your job, and to simply stop caring. It can be hard because caring about the injustice to done to you often reflects your best values: kindness, fairness, compassion. To turn off the judge in your brain can feel like you’re abandoning your values. But forgiveness is actually work, and you have to ask yourself if it’s one of those jobs that don’t really need to be done. So the trick is separate your values from the work of being the judge, and choosing to keep your values but let other people be the judge. This approach has helped me.
- slothtrop 6y agoIt's an old virtue that's thought to be good for society, which I imagine is why it's proselytized. But refraining from offering forgiveness need not be a burden. There are people I will never forgive, nor bother to think about. It's not a matter of carrying hatred, it's just a judgment. Forgiveness is an absolution that returns people into good graces: I don't see why, in a blanket sense, everyone who's done exceptional harm should return to everyone's good graces. Petty slights can be more easily forgiven, as everyone will eventually cause offense and consider it a mistake.
- ta1234567890 6y ago"Hating someone is like drinking poison and expecting the other person to die" Recently I realized I was poisoning myself with intense negative thoughts and feelings about someone. Then I also noticed those thoughts feelings were only impacting me, not the other person at all. Finally I decided to forgive that person for what they had done to me, and when I started that process it became evident that in order to accomplish it, I actually needed to forgive myself. I had to forgive myself for judging, for holding a grudge and for hating. Then I wrote down a list of all the people that I felt even a little bit negative about. At first I thought it was going to be a short list, but it ended up including over a hundred people. So I discovered that hiding subtly in my mind and within my feelings, I was secretly holding anger/hate/negativity for a lot of people. After putting together the list, I started wishing love and wellbeing to everyone in it, individually, one by one. Kind of like going through my body and taking care of every little wound or cut I could find. I tried going through the list and having positive feelings about those people every day for a few weeks. It did wonders for me.
- jasonv 6y agoI like your post in that it takes "forgiving" and makes it a practice. I often think I'm aligned with something only to realize I'm telling myself I'm aligned (that I "know"), but I haven't done anything with that alignment. You have to do it too, even if it's working through the thought process. I guess "transformation" is taking the "knowing" and making it "doing".
- yarrel 6y ago"Forgiving someone who hasn't changed is like encouraging a poisoner."
- ta1234567890 6y agoLike the article says, it's about you, not about them. In that sense, forgiveness is about an internal change of your feelings so that you can lead a better life without hate. It is not about condoning what others did. And it's very helpful to differentiate between them.
- 6y ago
- TedDoesntTalk 6y ago> a forgiveness author and peace educator What is a peace educator?
- yarrel 6y agoSomeone who doesn't want people to speak up.
- tunesmith 6y agoCorollary: Never tell anyone else you forgive them unless they ask for it. Otherwise it's just some sort of passive-aggressive way of telling someone they've wronged you and that you're the better person. If forgiving someone is for you and they're not asking for it, you can keep it to yourself.
- ta1234567890 6y agoA bit off topic but related, saying sorry means different things and it's used differently in different cultures[1]. In the US in particular, apologizing usually implies taking the guilt or responsibility (and sometimes even liability) for what happened. Unfortunately, this creates a huge incentive to not apologize, which then easily turns into bad feelings, grudges, anger and sometimes even lawsuits. Interestingly, in the case of malpractice, apologizing reduces the chances a patient will file a lawsuit[2]. I wonder how many fewer lawsuits we would have, and how much healthier of a society we would be if we all apologized more. [1] https://www.businessnewsdaily.com/12004-apologies-around-the-world.html https://www.businessnewsdaily.com/12004-apologies-around-the... [2] https://www.natlawreview.com/article/you-had-me-i-m-sorry-impact-physicians-apologies-medical-malpractice-litigation https://www.natlawreview.com/article/you-had-me-i-m-sorry-im...
- raincom 6y agoJust forgiving without erasing it from memory wouldn't help, since you relive through that act.
- talentedcoin 6y agoDo not let the sun go down while you are still angry, and do not give the devil a foothold. -- Ephesians 4:26-27 This is something that Christians have proclaimed for a long time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 6y agoThis is helped with practice. Our family’s cultural/religious background instills this process from a young age. Every evening, starting with the youngest child, everyone has a chance to say what they are thankful for that day and they are also given space to say ‘I’m sorry if they feel they have wronged anyone.’ We teach the other children not to respond “that’s okay” but “I forgive you” to properly acknowledge the wrongdoing. It’s amazing how joyful children get with these simple rituals.
- globular-toast 6y agoMy ex and first love cheated on me in the worst possible way. I'm certain I've been through a kind of grief that few people will ever experience as a result. But I just got over it. I forgave her in the sense that I understand what women are like now. She can't affect me any more. I've become so much stronger. I'm Stoic now. Time is the great healer as always. Therapy and all the rest of it are a massive swindle for the instant gratification age.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- blueyes 6y agoThis podcast feels like Freud warmed over. It doesn't provide much insight into what goes on in people, or what they should do.
- jarbus 6y agoShameless plus, I wrote a few paragraphs on this very topic a while back: http://jarbus.net/Forgiveness http://jarbus.net/Forgiveness A core thing I want to mention is that Forgiveness doesn’t excuse actions, nor does it mean you need to associate with people. Forgiving is purely about letting go of anger.
- mcguire 6y agoI was recently introduced to the best article on forgiveness (and some politics) here the other day: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/GLMFmFvXGyAcG25ni/i-can-tole. https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/GLMFmFvXGyAcG25ni/i-can-tole.... I Can Tolerate Anything Except The Outgroup by Scott Alexander
- higeorge13 6y agoThere are so many articles on forgiving, letting go and so on, but so little on encouraging people to retrospect their lives and wrongs and give sincere apologies. World would be a little bit better if people were encouraged to talk their differences or mistakes, to give closure, or give an apology, even if it took months or years for them to understand. Moving on is the easy part; reaching out the one you did wrong and asking forgiveness needs tons of courage and mental strength.
- tarkin2 6y agoThe phrase “to forgive someone“ confuses me. If you want to accept, no longer demand anything be said or done and move on wiser—and this is your definition of forgiveness—then I can understand that. But forgiving someone implies you do, say or treat someone a certain way. Most of the posts imply the opposite. I generally accept someone’s destructive past actions without demanding an apology and then move on with newfound caution and anger-dissolved-into-disappointment regarding that person, but would you say that is “forgiving someone”?
- White_Wolf 6y agoPast is to be learned from, no to live in and no ammount of revenge will bring you peace.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoIt makes some decent points, especially with regards to "forgiveness isn't necessarily about reconciling" and addresses other general misinformation about the idea. What I always say is "Forgiveness is a gift. Trust is earned." I think people hang onto a lot of negativity precisely because we so often hear garbage like "Forgive and forget" and "let bygones by bygones" which are phrases explicitly used by abusive people to indicate you are the asshole if you use their track record of bad behavior to be skeptical of their latest empty promises. Such ideas get used to facilitate abusive behavior and tell you that the only way you can be a good and decent person is to set aside common sense and actively cooperate with their plans to victimize you again. "Forgiveness is a gift. Trust is earned." helps make the distinction between the two things. It can say "I may no longer be mad and projecting a lot of negativity at you, but you haven't fixed anything at all from your end, so, no. Don't assume that means I will be a chump and fall for your garbage." AKA: Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. It's okay to say "I was burned by this person. There is zero evidence that they have changed and I will not trust them again." while also saying to yourself "I am sick to death of wallowing in my misery. I would like to leave this emotional pain behind and focus on other things. I would like to stop and smell the roses and be present in the here and now and enjoy today, regardless of what shitty things some asshole did to me in the past." TLDR: Sometimes, clinging to old pain is a means to shield yourself from new harm. Realizing that can help empower you to protect yourself without wallowing in misery.
- ggm 6y agoThe take-away about forgiveness I carry is that doing wrong things has a life-long burden. No amount of self-forgiveness can rid you of the burden of remembering you did a thing you have strong negative emotions about. If you did a stupid thing to yourself its a 'virtuous circle' but when you do it to somebody else (and, I did) then you carry a burden of your impact into another autonomous entitie's life. I really regret what I did to them, and I regret what it did to me too. No amount of forgiveness on their part will end this burden.
- Waterfall 6y agoI think the letting go part they mention is important but letting go can be done in a different way. When you reframe the story, add a new chapter, one where the last battle you lost, but the new one you win. Holding onto toxic feelings is painful, you can either turn it into a good one (revenge), forgive (reframe), or forget (drug use and/or time). Most people forget unless it was really bad.
- harveywalters 6y agoMy advice for the future is simple. You need to choose proven online casinos https://reddogcasino.com/en/try-game/fruit-frenzy/ https://reddogcasino.com/en/try-game/fruit-frenzy/, love playing Fruit Frenzy Slot . Good luck, big bets and wins.